Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

28th November 1889

The Late Mining Accident At Cleator

The adjourned inquest upon the body of William Currie, aged 28, late of Prospect Row, Cleator, who died from injuries received in a mine accident about a fortnight ago, was held in the Three Tuns Public-house, Cleator, on Friday afternoon last. Mr. J. Webster, as coroner, was present. Mr. John Briggs was chosen as foreman of the jury. — The first witness called was John Currie (brother of deceased), living at 32, Prospect Row, Cleator, who stated: I am a miner in the employment of Messers. Ainsworth & Co. On Wednesday night, the 6th inst., I went to work at ten o'clock in the evening along with my brother William, at No. 16 pit, Jack-trees-road, and into No. 7 working. I and my brother had worked there before. There were three shifts working in that place. The first shift went on at six in the morning; the second at two in the afternoon; and the shift I was on at ten at night. My brother and I left home at about 9.45 p.m., and proceeded to the pit. Before we went down we met one of the men on the afternoon shift. We stopped at the bait spot for about quarter of an hour and then went up to the working. There was nobody in the pit at the time but ourselves. We were not told by anyone that the working place had been examined before we went into it. When we went into the working we thought it safe enough. We examined it and saw that the wood was all right. We examined it by looking over the top to see what weight it was gathering. We concluded that another head-tree should be put in. My brother cut a hitch on one side of the working in a stone side. I bored another hitch on the other side. I then went to the bait spot for a charge to put into the hole I had bored. I came back and charged the hole, lighted it, and we then returned to the bait spot. We had our food then, about two o'clock. We sat between thirty and forty minutes before going back to the working. During the time we were away the charge exploded. We got back to the working about fifteen or twenty minutes to three. My brother got a slate to take a measure of the breadth of the working. It would be about ten or eleven feet. My brother then cut the head-tree with a saw to that length, after which we carried it into the working and lifted one side of it into the hitch, and we were in the act of lifting the other side when the fall came. The fall came from the roof right through the spiles. This fall fastened us in. My brother's legs were fastened, his arms and head being free. I was completely covered. We could speak to each other. The weight began to get too heavy on my head until I could not speak. I was only suffering from the weight on my body, and was not cut or bruised. I think my brother was inured, because he cried out about his breast first thing, saying there was a terrible weight on his breast. He kept his senses the whole of the time. I was found about six o'clock when the first shift came. These shiftmen got me out about eight o'clock. My brother was further in than me. His head laid on my thigh. I could not see what steps were taken to get me out as I could not see, but could hear them working. My brother spoke to them, and told them where I was situated. There are two men employed to go round examining the working places. Their names are William Crawford and James Gleives. I know of no particular time at which they are directed to make examinations. William Crawford generally comes in two or three times a week to examine. I have seen Gleives there. There are eight men ad four labourers working in this pit. In two of the shifts there are three, and in our shift two employed. The labourers are just in on shift which is the first shift. The other shifts were to get the metal. I never saw my brother after he was taken out. — By Mr. Bell: The distance between the head-trees is three or four feet. On the top of the head-trees there were spikes, of about 2in, in thickness, and about 6in. or 7in. in breadth. They were put so close together that one could not see through them. On the top of this was piled stones and other materials. The stuff broke right through the spikes. I do not know whether it broke through the head-trees. Examined by Mr. Oswald: When we went to work we commenced to cut the hitches until we got our bait. After we got our bait the fall occurred. I have seen Crawford in the pit two or three times when on the first shift, but when working on the second and third I never saw him. — Walter Place stated: I am a miner in the employment of Messers. Ainsworth. I went to work at six o'clock. Was the first man down, and there was nobody there to examine the place. It is a common occurrence in our pit to go to work without it being examined. He has never been there before I went to work. James Gleives and William Crawford are the men who examine. When we went in that morning we were going to No. 7. When we got to the bait place we heard a shout, and went forward and found John and William Currie fast. The first two sets of head-trees would be about 5ft. distance. These were three sets of head-trees, and they were putting the fourth in. Between the second and third there would be about 3ft. John was lying beside the third set, and William a little further in. John was in a stooping position, with a wood slab holding his head down. We got John out without much difficulty. We got William out a little after twelve. He had his senses. — By Mr. Bell: I did not consider it too wide. I thought such sets were amply sufficient. — Edward Crellin stated: I work on the first shift, No. 7 working. It would be about ten minutes past six when we first ascertained there had been an accident. I did not meet any officials of the pit that morning. It is William Crawford's and James Gleives duty to inspect the pits. I don't know that there is any fixed rule when they should inspect. They came to inspect this working about two or three times a week, as far as I have seen. — The Coroner, having read over a rule stating the Deputies ought to satisfy themselves all was safe prior to the miners starting work, witness asked by the Coroner said: That rule very likely then is transgressed. — Ann Roney stated: I live at Cleator Hall. I laid the body of the deceased man out. There was a little scratch on his left leg and the skin was off. There did not seem to be any damage to the chest. The left side was rather bruised. — Percy Leonard Addison stated: I am the responsible manager of the Cleator Iron-ore Company. It is provided for in the special rules of the Company there should be overmen and deputy-overmen. We have several pits, and we have those officials specified. The deputies are not confined to one pit, and work under the overman. It is provided that prior to the men commencing work an inspection should be made by the deputies to see all is right. That is not intended to apply before every shift. I have heard the evidence that no inspection was made on that occasion. — By Mr. Oswald: The principal overman who had to look after No. 16 was Crawford. He had power to send Gleives. I never gave the overman personal instruction. Mr. Leck does so. — By the Coroner: I prepared the plan from instructions given me by Mr. Leck. — Mr. Oswald: I have seen the place, and think I should have timbered it the same way myself — up to the third set. — Mr. William Leck stated: I am the underground manager of these mines and have been for five or six years. I saw this place on Monday previous to the accident. They had two head-trees in when I saw it. I have given data to Mr. Addison to prepare a plan. It is principally form my knowledge. Fitzsimmons told me it would be about three or four feet between the third head-tree and the forehead, that would mean taking the size of the head-tree from it, about two feet between the third and fourth sets. I define the duties of the overmen. Their duties are to go round and examine. Our rules define that examination should be made before commencing work in the morning. It would not surprise me to hear of men going to work in this particular pit without the working being examined. It is probable the rules may have been disobeyed in that particular pit. — James Fitzsimmons stated: I have been in the employment of Messers. Ainsworth for about five years. I was on the second shift on the day when the accident occurred. I did not see Crawford down the pit that day. Sometimes I never see Crawford at all in the working. I am on the first shift now. I did not see Crawford this morning, but saw Gleives. He was on the pit top, and had been down. He said all was right. When I left the night before at ten o'clock we had driven about three or four feet from the third set. It might be necessary to put in a set then. It was almost necessary when we left to put in a new set. It would be about two feet between the other sets. There has been greater care in examining since this accident. — Mr. William Crawford, examined by Mr. Oswald: I am under the orders of Mr. Leck. I had instructions to examine this pit on the morning shift. — The Coroner, in summing up, spoke strongly against not having examinations regularly every morning before the first shift, and hoped the day would come when enforced examinations would had to be made before every shift. Referring to the accident, he said the men had no one to tell them whether the mine was in good, bad, or indifferent order prior to their commencing work. The two men had seen it was absolutely necessary they should put up what was called a head-tree before starting to blast out the ore. Thus the men must have been of the opinion the place was in a dangerous condition. There was a bed of shale intervening between the gravel and where they were working. They set to work not very far distant from where this shale was, and bored a hole up each side. It appeared to him that it was exceedingly probable the thin roof of stone, shale, or sill must have been shaken to some extent by the explosion which the men caused. They were in the very act of putting in a piece of wood as a support when the ground came down upon them. Many witnesses had said the place was safe, but the question was had these men the ability to know it was safe. Plans had been submitted, which he regretted to say were not correct. If the plans as presented had been strictly accurate, the managers were not to blame for the distance of the head-trees. They were left in some degree of un-certainty as to what was really the space between the props. It was manifestly the interest of the management to say it was as narrow as possible, and therefore they had tried to induce him to believe the distance was only two feet, whereas one of the witnesses had said it was five. He did not say the working was not carefully examined by the overman who were deputed to go every day; but they had not made the examination every day. He regretted to say that the discipline at this working had been such as to make one think in other mining companies similar laxity might be going on. He did not say that the disobeying of that rule of making examination each morning had been the cause of the accident. If the inspection had been before the men commenced work in the morning the inspector going down would have found the injured men sooner than they were found. The overmen, in his opinion, ought to put in props, because the men would naturally neglect doing so to the last moment, and if possible leave the work for the next shift men in order that they themselves might put out a large quantity of metal. — Mr. Oswald said Messers. Ainsworth had always been ready to make any improvements suggested by himself, which could not be said of some other mining companies in the district. — The jury requested that they might be left alone to consider their verdict, and all except jurymen retired. — After a quarter of an hour's consideration the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death," and recommended that the managers should see in future that the workings were properly examined every morning before the commencement of the first shift.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Addison, Percy Leonard    Manager  
Ainsworth, —    Mine Owner  
Briggs, John    Jury Foreman  
Crawford, William      
Crellin, Edward    Miner  
Currie, John    Miner  
Currie, William   30 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Fitzsimmons, James    Miner  
Gleives, James      
Leck, William    Underground Manager  Whos Who Page
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Deputy Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Place, Walter    Miner  
Roney, Ann      
Webster, John    Coroner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Cleator (Iron Ore)  Cleator (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print