Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

31st October 1889

The Dean Moor Colliery Accident

The Inquest

On Tuesday, at the Star Inn, Branthwaite, Mr. J. Simpson, deputy-coroner for Cockermouth, and a jury, of whom the Rev. Canon Sherwen was foreman, held an inquiry into the circumstances of the death of William Thompson, coalminer, Bannock Row, who was employed at Dean Moor Colliery. Mr. John Wilson, Whitehaven (from the office of Mr. T. Brown), appeared for the Colliery Company, and Mr. Oswald, Hensingham, the local inspector of mines, also attended the inquiry. The inquest was interesting from the fact that there was a doubt about the cause of Thompson's death, for after meeting with an accident at the colliery on the 10th October he appeared to be progressing satisfactorily towards recovery, and his death on Sunday, 20th October, took his medical attendant by surprise, and the unexpected dissolution probably caused the rumour that Thompson had committed suicide by taking some poisonous substance. The post-mortem, however, did not support the hypothesis of self-slaughter. If, on the other hand, the death was directly traceable to the injuries received in the mine, then a fellow workman named Joseph Dobinson stood in danger of being committed for trial on a charge of manslaughter. Abraham Dixon, coalminer, Branthwaite, identified the body as that of William Thompson, who was 48 years of age, and left a widow and five children. Witness had worked at the Dean Moor Colliery since it was sunk about 15 years ago, and for the last two years he had acted as deputy. On the 10th October, Thompson came to his work at six o'clock, and from that time till ten o'clock he was occupied in getting coal. Witness last saw Thompson alive about ten o'clock, when the deceased was running his coal out. He had a tub, which is on four wheels, and into this he put an iron lock and started off, a candle, which was lighted standing on the tub end. About five minutes after Thompson started someone called witness by name, and on going down the brow he found Thompson lying on his left side between two full tubs, which were about four feet apart. Thompson told him to examine the second tub (Dobinson's), and witness did, finding the front lock in. Thompson also said witness was to get him away as quickly as possible as he was hurt. Thompson's tub, which stood at the beginning of the level, had no locks in. A lighted candle at the level is visible from the place where they put the second lock, which is about six yards from the top of the brow. On the 10th all the men were taking tubs out. Each man takes his own coal out. One of the tubs belonged to Joseph Dobinson, who lives at Branthwaite. It was he who shouted of witness, and witness heard him crying bitterly all the time. He called to Dobinson and told him to go for help. When help came Dobinson came back very near to where Thompson was. By Mr. Oswald: What do you mean by very near? He was about a dozen yards away. — Did he not come to see if Thompson was injured? He was the sairer put out of the way the two. Dobinson said his wagon had run into Thompson. When there were two men at the brow top, one man had to wait till the other shouted that all was clear. He had told Thompson and Dobinson of this, and both knew it well enough. — By the Foreman: One of the scotches was lying in front of the wheel. — By Mr. Oswald: He did not think it was a dangerous practice brings tubs down this incline, and he was quite agreeable to work at it. He thought Dobinson must have tumbled. Joseph Hellon, coalminer, Branthwaite, also gave evidence. Joseph Dobinson, coalminer, Branthwaite, after being formally warned by the Coroner, said he wished to give evidence. Being then sworn he deposed: I have been working at the colliery a fortnight, and previous to going there I was at farm service, though before that I was employed at pits. I had not to hew coal, but to trail coal for Hellon, who employed me, though I asked the foreman's consent to the arrangement. I had to take the coal from Hellon's working to a siding, where other men took them up the shaft. Hellon went with me two days — one day we had eight tubs and the other nine — to show me the way, and every time we went down this brow. We each took a tub. He told me to go first the first day to put one scorch in at the brow top, and another about six yards down. He also went with me to the bottom and showed me how to take the scotches out.

The second day sometimes I went first and sometimes he did. — How did you know he was ready at the bottom? He shouted, and told me that that was what had to be done. The light at the bottom was visible from the place six yards from the brow top. I had followed William Thompson out before, but not as near as on the 10th October. He was on the brow top before I got there. We both had tubs, laden with coal, and each had a candle burning. The wagons were not far from each other. Thompson put a scotch in at the top, and went on six yards and put in the other. He then went to the bottom, and I was standing on the top. My tub was not on the brow top then, and was not scotched. After Thompson went down the brow I pushed my tub over a crossing towards the brow top, which is about a yard from the crossing. There was a place for the purpose of putting in the first scorch between the crossing and brow top. There is about seven cwt. of coals in a wagon, and the wagon is about three cwt. Before ever I started my tub I was quite satisfied that Thompson was at the bottom of the brow. I put in the first scotch, and went down six yards, where I stopped, and put in the second scotch, which was places on the forewheel. Then I shoved on to the top of the second incline, meaning to stop there to see if all was clear. Here I tripped myself up, fell, and lost hold of the tub, which left me and went down the incline. By the time I got up again the tub was at the bottom, and therefore I could not stop it. I shouted as soon as I fell, calling to Thompson, who I thought might be in the way, although I knew he had plenty of time to get clear. I heard my tub come in collision with something else, and I ran down as quickly as I could. I found Thompson lying between the tubs, one thigh being fast. I got past my tub, took the scotches out, and shoved it back from him. Then as the tub was on the incline I put in the scotch? I asked Thompson, who was conscious, where I might go for help, and he told me. Thompson's tub was standing three or four yards nearer to the brow top than where I generally stopped. Both my own scotches were in. — By Mr. Wilson: If you had not fallen could you have stopped the tub? Yes, I think I could have slewed it off the road. Some strong men can stop the tubs without slewing. Thompson himself could have stopped it in the middle of the hill. — By Mr. Oswald: Can you stop bogies easily? Not without throwing them of the road. — Hannah Thompson, widow of the deceased, said she remembered her husband being brought home on Thursday, the 10th. He was taken right to bed and he was attended by Dr. Castles. From the time of the accident the deceased was only out of bed twice, and he had to be assisted up. He could not get out of bed himself. They all slept in the same room together; there were five children besides themselves. He was always conscious. The doctor was there on the Saturday. She was away from ten till four that day. There was a stepdaughter of hers who attended to her husband and the children in her absence. When she returned and asked how he was, he said he was the same as the morning. He had his tea when she came home. He had beef and teacakes to it, and he ate the best she ever saw him. At half past eight he had new milk and toast. At one o'clock he awakened her by shouting "Oh dear." She gave him castor oil, which he asked for, and afterwards made him some tea, but he only took a mouthful, and did not eat anything. She went upstairs again to bed at twenty minutes to two. She spoke to him, but as he did not answer she got out of bed, where she had only been a minute, and found that he was dead. Henry Castles, M. D., Distington, said Thompson was a patient of his before the accident. On the 10th, when he examined Thompson, he found nothing of any importance except a semi-circular wound, which was not serious. The skin was torn and the muscle exposed. He treated Thompson for the wound, and for nothing else, and on every visit he found the patient progressing satisfactorily. He did not expect to hear of Thompson's death, and he was then not able to account for it. He made a post-mortem examination jointly with Dr. Joseph Henry Dickson, of Whitehaven. The found a clot of blood in the pulmonary artery and another at the base of the brain, and they came to the conclusion that death arose from these clots of the blood. — Asked if he could give an opinion as to how these clots had been formed he said it was possible that in the case of an injury some of the veins might be injured, and the clots formed and carried to the places where they found them. He expressed the opinion that the proceeded from the wound in the leg.

By Mr. Wilson: This was an opinion, not a surmise. — By the Coroner: He would not say that if it was possible they could be formed in any other way. — By Mr. Oswald: Thompson was a strong healthy man, and might have lived for a hundred years. — Joseph Henry Dickson, M.B. O.M., who practices in Whitehaven with his father, said he corroborated the evidence of Dr. Castles, and agreed with him in his opinion. When the man received the injury it is probable that some vein might be injured, and this formed a sort of dead part in the vein on which the corpuscles of the blood would coagulate and form a stoppage in the vein. That might stay there for some time, and the movement of the man getting in and out of bed might dislodge this, and it would get into the circulation. — John Dakers, colliery manager, West Cornforth, Durham, produced plans and tracings of the underground workings of the Dean Moor Colliery. — The jury, after considering for some time, found that Thompson died from the clots of blood, but there was no evidence to show how they were formed. They also expressed the opinion that the colliery company should have some more efficient system of signalling from the bottom of the brow to the top. — Mr. Oswald said the Company were going to adopt another road for coals, which would not be down a brow, but on a level, and if that alteration were made it would meet the case. The Jury decided to give their fees to the widow.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brown, T.    Solcitor  
Castles, Henry, Dr.    Doctor  
Dakers, Joseph    Colliery Manager  
Dickson, Joseph Henry, Dr.    Doctor  
Dixon, Abraham    Collier  
Dobinson, Joseph    Trailer  
Hellon, —    Collier  
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Deputy Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Sherwen, —, Rev.    Jury Foreman  
Simpson, J.    Deputy Coroner  
Thompson, Hannah      Widow
Thompson, William   50 Deputy  Deceased, Individual Page
Wilson, John    Solicitor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Dean Moor Colliery  Dean Moor Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print