|
12th September 1889 Ventilation Of MinesImportant Prosecution At WhitehavenAt the Whitehaven Petty Sessions, on Thursday — (before Joseph Dickinson, Esq., H. Fox, Esq., and J. G. Dees, Esq.,) — Sir James Bain, Mr. J. D. Bain, Mr. J. R. Bain, Mr. J. S. Simpson, and Mr. Isaac Pattinson, the first four as the owners, and Mr. Pattinson as the agent, were charged with neglecting on the 18th and 19th July, to provide adequate ventilation in No. 11 pit of the Woodend Mines. — Mr. M. W. Mattinson, M.P. (instructed by the solicitor for the Treasury, through Mr. Atter) prosecuted, and Messers Bain and Company were defended by Mr. T. Brown. Mr. Mattinson: I am instructed, sir, by the Solicitor of the Treasury to appear before you to-day in support of certain summonses, which the authorities have determined to take out against Messers James Bain & Co. and their manager, Mr. Isaac Pattinson, for alleged offences against the Metalliferous Mines Act, 1872. These proceedings are instituted under the Act of 1872, and I think it will be convenient, in the first instance, if I draw your attention to the material sections. First of all, the 23rd section of the Act of 1872 provides that "the following general rules shall, so far as may be reasonable and practicable, be observed in every mine to which this Act applies." That is every iron ore mine. "(1) An adequate amount of ventilation shall be constantly produced in every mine to such an extent that the shafts, winzes, sumps, levels, underground stables, and working places of such mine, and the travelling roads to and from such places shall be in a fit state for working and passing therein." That is the offence, taken in conjunction with the last clause of the 19th sub-section, which provides that every person who contravenes or does not comply with any of the general rules in this section shall be guilty of an offence against this Act. The 31st section of the Act provides the penalty: "Every person who is guilty of an offence against this Act shall be liable to a penalty not exceeding, if he is an owner or agent £20;" and then there are provisions with regard to other persons which are not material to this case. Now, these are the sections with which you have to deal to-day; and the observations I desire to make upon section 23, sub-section 1, which creates the offence, is this. This enactment imposes, in our view, an absolute duty upon every mineowner, to have in his mine, at his peril, an adequate amount of ventilation. It contemplates that if necessary ventilation shall be produced by artificial means. If ventilation can be obtained by the action of natural causes, so much the better for the mineowner; but if the ordinary operations of nature will not produce that adequate ventilation which is necessary, then this section clearly contemplates that the mineowner, shall by artificial means produce the ventilation; because it says "an adequate amount of ventilation shall be constantly produced. The second observation I wish to make is this. The section contemplates not only the necessity of producing ventilation if ventilation is not there of itself, but in addition to that the section contemplates the necessity of having ventilation always there. It does not satisfy the requirements of this section that there shall generally be ventilation or that there shall be ventilation from time to time. The Act requires that "an adequate amount of ventilation shall be constantly produced." That being, as I take it, the clear meaning of this section of the Act of Parliament, it is sufficient for me to make out that at the time we allege, there was not in point of fact, in these particular mines, an adequate amount of ventilation. And if in point of fact at the times we allege there was not an adequate amount of ventilation, it is no answer for these gentlemen to say there were difficulties in the way of procuring it. It is no answer to say that under general conditions there was enough ventilation, but that at that time there was not sufficient. The Act requires, for the benefit of these men, subject to the risk of working in these mines, that mineowners shall have in their mines an adequate amount of ventilation. Mr. Mattinson then proceeded to state the facts upon which the prosecution relied. On the 18th of last July, in consequence of information which Mr. Oswald, the sub-inspector of mines of this district, received, he thought it his duty to make an official visit to this mine. Going down the pit he got off the cage in the first instance on the top eye of the pit, upon the north side; and then he proceeded up a break-road, for a distance of about 100 yards. Now at that time he was holding in his hand a lamp; and you will hear from him that walking up this break-road, at least upon one occasion that lamp went out itself — a suspicious and significant circumstance as pointing to the want of ventilation in the mine. But I allow that that fact when taken by itself is in no way conclusive. Of course one can imagine reasons why possibly a lamp being carried with as much care as possible, but still somewhat unsteadily, might have gone out. But when Mr. Oswald, accompanied by Mr. Pattinson, the manager, had got to the top of the break-road, all doubt as to the state of the ventilation of this mine was removed by what he then saw and by the experiments that were then made. At the top of the break-road he came to a man of the name John Martin. He found Martin was working at the top of this break-road by means of a candle placed horizontally, which was giving a faint, feeble, flickering light. Mr. Oswald proceeded to make his tests, and applied that test which I am told is the ordinary working test applied in cases of this description. He tested the condition of the ventilation by regard to the possibility or otherwise of a candle remaining alight. I need not point out to the members of the Bench who I understand are very familiar with these matters that if the ventilation was deficient in its due proportion of oxygen, it was impossible that a lamp or candle should remain alight; and a fortiori, it is impossible to say that is a fit and proper place for a human being to continue his occupation. Well, now, what took place? At this point the top of the break-road, at which point we are dealing with one of the travelling-ways, where there would be from the nature of the case a fair amount of ventilation if there was any ventilation at all, when the test of a candle lighted and placed upright was applied, Mr. Oswald found that the candle went out of itself in three quarters of a minute. Then the candle was lighted and placed horizontally. As you will see, a candle placed horizontally remains alight longer. More fat gets into the wick, and in that way I suppose — or at any rate it so happens — it remains alight longer when horizontal than when upright. Placed horizontally it remained alight for something like a minute and a half. It is perfectly obvious, if the matter had stopped there, that at that point there was a defective condition of the ventilation. Mr. Mattinson related a number of other experiments made by Mr. Oswald in other working places, all with the same result, that no lighted candle could live. When all these experiments had been made, and every experiment had resulted in the same thing, that the candle had gone out, then Mr. Pattinson took the course which I am glad to think he did take, much to his credit, he telling the men engaged in that section that they were to get out of the pit and not come back until the air was better; and the men went. After this, Mr. Oswald, accompanied by Mr. Pattinson, returned to the surface and Mr. Pattinson then in the presence of Mr. Oswald, told the next shift of men, many of whom had come to the top with a view of going down to their work, that they were not to go down at present until the air was better. That is substantially the case; and if these facts turn out in the evidence as I have stated them, I submit with much confidence that these proceedings, so for as Messrs Bain are concerned, and Mr. Pattinson is concerned, are absolutely undefended proceedings. Moreover, if you accept the evidence of Mr. Oswald, that Mr. Pattinson himself directed the men to leave these sections of the works, until the air was put into better condition, that is about as strong an admission of guilt as it is possible to have in a case of this description. — Mr. Mattinson then described the result of Mr. Oswald's visit to the mine on the following day, when he inspected and tested the low bottom of the pit, with substantially the same results as on the following day. I gather from Mr. Oswald's evidence that the only excuse which Mr. Pattison suggested was a continual complaint to Mr. Oswald that he (Mr. Oswald) had come and taken them unawares. Apparently Mr. Pattinson seemed to labour under the delusion that it was the duty of the inspector to appraise a mineowner or his manager, before he came to the mine, that he was coming, so I suppose that everything might be made tight and taut for his inspection. Of course, I need not tell the Bench that a more idle, a more foolish suggestion, than that could not be conceived. The whole object of having a hierarchy of inspectors and sub-inspectors is that there may be a watchful eye upon persons who are carrying on these operations, that they may know they are subject to constant inspection, and that their mines may be kept in such a condition that whenever an inspector appears they may be able to stand inspection. I understand another suggestion is that on the 18th the day was a hot day, and that it was again a hot day on the 19th. Probably that is true. The month of July is usually a hot month. But will the Bench consider for a moment what a farce such a suggestion as that is? When this Act of Parliament was passed, the seasons were as the seasons are now — summer followed winter, and winter followed summer; and Parliament contemplated that provision should be made for adequate ventilation under the heats of summer as well as under the more favourable conditions of winter. If the excuse were to be accepted by this Bench that it was an answer to say that the weather was hot and there are difficulties because the weather is hot — if that excuse were for one moment to be maintained, the result would be that so far as regards several months in the year, which are the most important as regards ventilation, this Act of Parliament would be practically useless. Only one other remark. This prosecution is instituted by the authorities against Messers Bain and their manager after full deliberation, and with the intention of getting an express decision from this Bench with regard to the administration of this Act. On behalf of the Treasury I in no way wish to press vindictively. I have much pleasure in saying I believe Messers Bain are amongst the best and most public-spirited employers of labour in the district; and it may well be, and probably is, the case so far as the individual members of the firm are concerned, that they are desirous that the law should be conformed to, and that their workmen should get all the benefits Parliament intended they should get. But the authorities of the Treasury feel that this Act is perfectly clear, and imposes a perfectly clear duty upon all mineowners. We feel that it is the duty of those who are charged with the administration of this law to prosecute great employers of labour just the same as small employers — to administer the law with perfect impartiality. Therefore, while I have no desire whatever to press for an extreme penalty, and while I should be content on behalf of the authorities that anything which may be urged by Mr. Brown, arising, it may be from the state of the weather at that time, should be taken into consideration in mitigation of the penalty. I do in the public interest press upon the Bench most earnestly, if the facts come out as I have opened, that it is their bounden duty, as the administrators and not the makers of this law, to inflict such a penalty on these gentlemen as will make it appear that the provisions of this Act of Parliament are not set at naught. — Mr. Mattinson then proceeded to call evidence. — Mr. Oswald, sub-inspector of mines for this district, gave evidence substantially confirming Mr. Mattinson's opening. — Mr. James Willis said he was Government Inspector for the Newcastle district. He received Mr. Oswald's report, and he had heard Mr. Oswald's evidence, and in particular he drew from the fact of the candles going out in so short a time that generally there was little or no ventilation. — Mr. Dickinson said he had heard the evidence given by Mr. Oswald, and he came to the conclusion that there was an entire absence of ventilation, as they understood the term, as it would not support combustion. He considered the condition of the pit was injurious to the men, as it would tend to lower the vitality of the system. Miner's consumption was more common in the North of England among iron-ore miners that among colliers. The want of cleanliness about iron-ore miners' bodies had a tendency to consumption. — Mr. Brown, for the defence, submitted that there was no neglect on the part of the owners of the mine in producing ventilation, and that the condition of the mine was not such as to justify that information being laid. They did not want to screen themselves in any way behind their agent. They were quite willing to take upon themselves the whole responsibility with regard to that matter, because they were satisfied that even if they had committed what might be called a technical offence against the Act, they had not in any way done anything which they need be ashamed of. On the contrary they did everything that was reasonable and practicable to remedy a condition of things which was accidental and abnormal. The mine had been in existence for something like thirteen years, during which there had never been a complaint regarding it. On the 27th June, three weeks before Mr. Oswald made his visit, a large fall happened in the pit, and the fall was right over the air-course, in the low bottom level, and the consequence was that the course was very largely impeded. To show them that they were not unmindful either of their own interests, or the health of the men in that mine, there were inspector who reported on the condition of the mine every day to the manager. On the 4th of July men were set to work to repair the air course, in order to carry the air another way, and from that date until the 20th July men were constantly at work every day. On the 15th July another fall took place, exactly where the first fall had been, and again the ventilation was impeded, and it was immediately after this that Mr. Oswald made his inspection. He made his inspection at the very worst time he could make it, that was just before the men came out of the pit, when all the fumes from the explosives were denser than at any other; and in addition to that he confined his observations almost entirely to the rise portion of the mine, where the ventilation could not possibly be as good as in the other parts, because it was the highest part of the mine, and the air had to travel through the whole pit before it reached that portion. Mr. Oswald had not been down the pit since his inspection, but if he had visited it on the 20th July he would have found the ventilation as good as it was now, and as good as it was before the accident. Isaac Pattinson, manager of Woodend Mine; John Highmore, Joseph Black; William Bowness, workmen in the mine; and Mr. J. D. Kendall, civil and mining engineer, gave evidence for the defence. The Bench agreed to fine Mr. Simpson (representing the firm) £4, and Mr. Pattinson £1.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||