|
15th August 1889 The Fatal Accident At William PitOn Monday afternoon the inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of James Hutchinson, 66 years of age, who was killed at William Pit, Whitehaven, on the 5th inst., was resumed at the Whitehaven Infirmary by Mr. H. J. Whiteside, deputy coroner, and a jury, over whom Mr. W. Brownrigg was foreman. Mr. A. Sharp appeared on behalf of the relatives of the deceased; Mr. T. H. Brockbank appeared on behalf of the Whitehaven Colliery Company; and Mr. Oswald, Government Inspector, was also present. Dr. Pirie, house surgeon at the Whitehaven Infirmary, deposed that deceased when admitted into the Infirmary was suffering from shock. His thigh was injured, and he was injured internally. There was not the slightest chance of his recovery when admitted. Thomas McCartney said the place where the accident occurred was known as Delaval Point. Witness and deceased finished work about half past six o'clock, and on arriving at the Delaval they stood for a short time whilst a set of wagons were running. The wagons (he thought) jumped the points. The first tub struck witness and deceased, and knocked them down senseless. There was a man standing at an electric bell. He considered they were standing in a safe place. These were refuge holes provided for the workmen, but they had not time to cross the rails. Witness could not blame anything else but the points in making the wagons jump. He did not know there was anything wrong with the points. If he had been smashed to pieces he would not have blamed anybody. The Coroner: I don't think you would have been in a position to do so (Laughter.) By Mr. Oswald: He could not say whether or not the wagons jumped the crossings or the points. He did not see them jump. By Mr. Sharp: there were three of them standing at the place, deceased, a man named Rothery, a back-overman, and witness. He did not know the man who was standing at the bell rope. The points used to be worked by a needle. He could not say whether or not they were broken, as well as the switches, at that time. By Mr. Brockbank: They had been ordered several times from the place where they were standing into the refuge holes. He never was ordered out of the refuge holes. John Rothery said he was a deputy-overman in William Pit. On the morning in question he saw deceased and the last witness standing near the points. He was standing talking to Hutchinson when he observed a sett of wagons coming from the shaft. He had been standing four or five minutes when he observed the sett. He was waiting to cross the line as soon as the sett got past. He heard a rattle of the tubs, and on looking he saw that the tubs had come off at the crossing. The rope dragged the wagons for some distance, the first wagon striking deceased and McCartney, witness jumping out of the way. The tubs would be running about four miles an hour. The points were a pair of common loose checks. He examined the points seven or eight minutes before the accident happened, when they were all right. The right hand casting, coming in-bye, was a little worn. That might have caused the accident, but he could not say it did. He saw the points that morning, but they had not been repaired. No tubs had left the rails since the accident that he was aware of. By Mr. Oswald: He was in charge of that district. He did not consider it safe to stand at the place where deceased was standing. He was standing there although he did not consider it safe. He had previously warned men about standing there. There was ample room to accommodate all the men who came out of their workings in the man-holes. By Mr. Brockbank: The men were supposed to go into the refuge holes for safety. By Mr. Sharp: He was talking to Hutchinson about colliery business. It was not usual for the tubs to run at the rate of eight miles an hour. A man should have been at the points but he was not working that morning, and witness had to look after them. A man named John William Fox was at the bell rope. John William Fox was in charge of the bell that morning. After he had signalled to stop the tubs, they would run about fifty-one feet. The coroner summed up, and the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||