Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

1st August 1889

Mines Act Prosecution At Moor Row

At the Whitehaven police court, on Thursday, before J. R. Bain, Esq. (In the chair), and other magistrates, Miles Postlethwaite, the Hollins, Whitehaven, gentleman, and John Dixon Kendall, mining and civil engineer, the former the owner and the latter the agent of a metalliferous mine known as Postlethwaite's Moor Row Mine, were charged with contravening one of the general rules to be observed in the mine by neglecting to produce in such mine an adequate amount of ventilation to such an extent that the shafts, winges, sumps, levels, and working places of such mine, and the travelling roads to and from such working places should be in a fit state for working and passing therein; and John Dixon Kendall was further charged, as the agent, with having unlawfully caused an abstract of the Metalliferous Mines Regulation Act, 1872, to be posted up at such mine, such abstract not having appended thereto the name and address of the Inspector of the district. — Mr. Atter prosecuted, and Mr. T. Brown defended. — Mr. Atter said he appeared for the Treasury, and said there were three information's against the defendants, and the first he would take was that of not having sufficient ventilation in the mines. On the day in question Mr. Oswald visited the mines at Moor Row between eleven and twelve o'clock, and the result of his examination would clearly prove that there was inadequate ventilation in the mines. At the time of the visit there were twenty-three workmen in the mines. Mr. Oswald reported to Mr. Willis and Mr. Bell, who was inspector for the Durham district, and they would be able to state what the effect might be on the workmen. He would also call Mr. Woolcock, who would speak as to the defects of the ventilation. This case was a serious one, and if it was proved he hoped the Bench would impose a substantial penalty. He did not think the owner of the mines should leave the work to the agent, but he ought to go himself and visit the mines. — Mr. Oswald, assistant inspector of mines, said on the 9th of May he visited Postlethwaite's mines at Moor Row. He descended the pit between eleven and twelve o'clock in company with William James, the pit overman. When he got to the bottom he observed that his candle burned very dim, there was no current of air passing, and the atmosphere was in a stagnant condition. The depth of the pit was fifty fathoms. There was brattice down for forty—three fathoms. He then proceeded into the workings. Witness's candle burnt very badly. He noticed an air tube pipe running from the shaft, but there was no current of air passing through it. He tested it by putting his candle at the end of the pipe, the light of the candle not being affected at all. The tube did not produce ventilation at all. The diameter of the pipe was sixteen inches. The length of the shaft was about 160 yards; one hundred and five yards being level, and about fifty—five feet rise. The rise was about eight inches to the yard. He went into No. 12 Company's working place, where he found the candles of the workmen, instead of standing upright were burning in a horizontal position. Even when they were placed horizontally they gave a very bad light. There was no current of air whatever. He then proceeded into No. 4 Company's working, where he also found the candles of the workmen burning in a horizontal position. He put his candle upright, and it died out. He then held another candle straight up, and it went out in five minutes. He inspected No. 3 Company's working, where the men were working with the candles in a horizontal position. He tried his candle in an upright position about eighteen inches from the floor, which burned, but it gave a very dim light. He also inspected No. 9 Company's working, where the men were working with the candles in a horizontal position. One candle on being placed upright went out. There was no current of air at all. He inspected No. 5 Company's working, which was very bad indeed. He saw all the workmen working with the candles in the usual position. He tried two or three experiments in the place with candles. The first candle which he tried died out in two minutes. He also tried another candle in an upright position which died out in one and a quarter minute. He then tried a candle on the brake post, and that died out in a very short time. He tried another candle on the metal about 18 inches from the ground, which died out in about four minutes. The working was very bad, there not being the slightest ventilation. He also found the men working with their candles in a horizontal position in No. 10 working, and only gave a very bad light at that. He ascended the pit about two o'clock. The ventilation in the pit had a very bad effect upon him physically, he being ill for several days after. The number of workmen in the pit at the time of examination was 23. They were engaged in places where there was no ventilation whatever, and it was quite a stagnant atmosphere. The levels and workings were not in a fit state for the workmen in passing. He thought that the Act had been seriously infringed. It was generally calculated that a man should have 100 cubic feet of air supplied to him per minute and 80 cubic feet for each light, making a total of 180 cubic feet per minute; but this should be doubled in order to carry away any gases and powder smoke. The minimum amount of fresh air should be 10,000 cubic feet, which was sufficient for the thirty workmen usually employed in the pit. Witness went to the mine some time afterwards, when he found they had made a connection through into the top eye from No. 5 working. They could have made a similar connection long ago if they had liked. Cross—examined by Mr. Brown: I laid my information on the 7th of June. — Will you tell us why you were so long in laying your information after you had visited the pit? I had to go by the instructions of Mr. Willis. — Do you think it is reasonable to lay information a month after the circumstances, and not give the mineowner an opportunity of bringing other officials who saw the condition of the pit at the time you visited it? I did not think he would be proceeded against. — Were you not told when you were at the pit, on the 9th of May, by the overman, that they were driving to a particular point for the purpose of making ventilation? I was told that. — Then this connection is not made because of your visit to the pit, but was contemplated before the occasion of your visit. Do you think the condition of the mine was injurious to health? I think it was in a beastly condition. — Re—examined by Mr. Atter: I had a written complaint about the condition of this pit. — Mr. Atter then read the following letter:—

Cumberland Miners' Association, John Street, Maryport, May 7th 1889

Dear Sir, — I am in receipt of a letter from a person this morning who is working in Mr. Postlethwaite's iron ore mine, called Fletcher Pit, in the parish of Egremont. The party says that the workmen are nearly suffocated for want of ventilation, and several men are laid up poorly by the foul air in the pit. He requests me to send for you at once to go and inspect the mine. He says every day in the week, except Monday, the mine is in a fearful state for want of ventilation, and he recommended that you should visit the mine about the middle or latter part of the week. I have not written to Mr. James Willis, because I thought you might attend to this case yourself. —

Yours truly, A SHARP, SECRETARY.

Mr. R. P. Oswald, Hensingham.

The Court then adjourned for half an hour for luncheon. On re—assembling, Mr. James Willis was examined by Mr. Atter. He said he thought it was a proper state of affairs for Mr. Oswald to report upon. There had been no undue delay in taking these proceedings. The state, which the mine was in he, did not think workmen should have been allowed to work in it. The report of Mr. Oswald conveyed to his mind that there was no ventilation whatever. He considered that what had since been done was only a makeshift, and that it was no part of any comprehensive scheme of ventilation. The mine ought to have a scheme of ventilation of some sort. — Cross—examined by Mr. Brown: I think the mine was in a shocking condition, and if I had been a workman I would have refused to work in it. — Mr. Thomas Bell said he was Government Inspector of Mines for Durham, and quite concurred with the evidence given by the inspectors. He thought that what had been done was only a make—shift. — Mr. Henry Woolcock also gave evidence. — Mr. Brown, for the defence, submitted that the opening and closing words of the Act were guarded to show that if all reasonable means were taken the defendants would not be liable to be penalised. The mine was only commenced in May 1888. The royalty had been worked before, and the shaft had been sunk before, but they were working a portion of the royalty, which had never been worked before, and therefore they had to make their ventilation as they went on. The question of ventilation was not only considered, but decided upon. On the Wednesday that Mr. Oswald was down the pit they had as perfect a ventilation, as good a ventilation, as any pit in the district, and much better than many. What he wanted to draw their attention to was that this was a scheme that was settled as a means of ventilation before ever the lower level was worked at all, and he thought that when they had that evidence put before them that their worships would be satisfied that they certainly had given ventilation their serious consideration, and that they had acted up to the best of their judgment in making such a ventilation as would ventilate a large area. Mr. Oswald saw the mine on perhaps one of the most unfavourable days in the year he could have visited it. He visited the pit at a time when men were firing more shots than they would at any time in the day, except when they were going off the labouring shift. With regard to No. 5 working he was instructed that when Mr. Oswald went in all the men who worked in the place were standing a little distance out of the working. One of the men told Mr. Oswald and the overman that he had just fired three shots, and he thought they ought not to go into it then. Mr. Oswald took no notice but went in, when the place was absolutely full of smoke from a recent blast. Mr. Oswald had no right to let them go on working without giving them notice, and he knew there was three months in which information could be laid — he did complain about him not telling them that information was going to be laid, for this reason, that they had no means of bringing outside evidence to show what was the condition of the pit at the time of his visit. — Mr. Kendall, one of the defendants, said he was a mining engineer and had about 26 years experience. The shaft of this pit was a strong downcast one. As soon as a plan of ventilation was decided upon it was carried straightforward till it was completed. He was prepared to prove that both Mr. Willis and Mr. Oswald knew of a mine which was twenty times worse than this particular mine. As soon as they got holed through the ventilation in the mine was as good as in any other pit in the district. — By Mr. Atter: He would say that when Mr. Oswald visited the pit the air was quite fit for the men to work in. It was not true, so far as he knew, that men had been dismissed within the past ten days. — John Gunson Selkirk, mining engineer under Mr. Kendall, said he was down the pit at least twice a week and never suffered from the ventilation. He considered the ventilation was as good as the average mines in the district. About a month before Mr. Oswald's visit the air—pipe was broken down, and there was a complaint from the men. The air was then bad, and the pipe was put up again. The air was then all right. — William James, who said he had been employed in mines 25 years, said he was with Mr. Oswald when he made the inspection of the mine. He heard Mr. Oswald say the air was light, but he did not give any idea that he was going to proceed to a prosecution. On that day a charge of dynamite mis—fired, and its burning away would foul the air to the extent of five or six shots. — Edward Carlton, miner, said he had worked for twelve months in Postlethwaite's mines, and he remembered the day Mr. Oswald was down. Just before that witness had been firing shots. It was a dark, heavy day. He never knew anyone who had to keep their lights sideways instead of upright in that pit. He had never suffered in health through working there, and he was working in the worst place. — John Woodburn said he had been an iron ore miner about 40 years, and had been employed at Postlethwaite's mine for some months. The condition of the air was in no way bad, and it did not affect his health in any way. He never lost his light in the pit through want of air. He heard Mr. Oswald say to William James that the air was very bad. Mr. Oswald had a candle lighted, and it went out. Witness said the candle was dirty. It was cleaned and lighted again, and then it kept lighted. He did not think there was better ventilation in the country than there was in the pit now. — John Nolan, miner, said he had been a miner for many years, and gave similar evidence to the last witness. — Mr. Brown said he had several other witnesses, but their evidence was similar in effect to that already given. — The Bench retired, and on their return the Chairman said they had decided to dismiss both cases.

The charge against Mr. Kendall was then taken. — Mr. Oswald, Inspector, stated that when he inspected the mine he found the notice up, and there was no writing upon it of the name of the owner of the mine or the Government Inspector of the district. — Mr. Brown said he admitted the name was not on the notice at the time the inspector went, but this notice had been up twelve months. When it was put up Mr. Kendall wrote the name of the owner and inspector on the notice, but as it had been exposed to the weather the writing had become obliterated. — Defendant corroborated Mr. Brown's statement. William Elliott, joiner at Postlethwaite's mines, stated that he put the notice up on the board. There was writing on it at that time, but he could not say what the writing was. He did not notice the writing afterwards. The Bench fined the defendant 20s.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, —    Solicitor  
Bain, J. R.    Magistrate  
Bell, Thomas    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Brown, T.    Solicitor  
Carlton, Edward    Miner  
Elliott, William    Joiner  
James, William    Overman  
Kendall, John Dixon    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page
Nolan, John    Miner  
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Deputy Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Postlethwaite, Miles    Mine Owner  
Selkirk, John Gunson    Mining Engineer  
Sharp, Andrew    Miners' Agent  
Willis, James    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Woodburn, John    Miner  
Woolcock, —    Mining Engineer  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Postlethwaite's Moor Row (Iron Ore)  Postlethwaite's Moor Row (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print