|
30th May 1889 St. Helens Colliery DisasterResumption Of The InquestExamination Of Beatty, The All Important WitnessOn Tuesday morning Mr. Webster, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, opened the adjourned inquest at the Workington Magistrate's Court on the victims of the St. Helens Colliery disaster, who were found dead in his district. The inquiry was adjourned from the 6th of June, 1889, for the purpose mainly of ascertaining if the man W. J. Beatty would recover his reason, his evidence being most material to the inquiry. The men on the view of whose bodies Mr. Webster's first inquest was held were Joseph Robinson, of Seaton, and Robert Hodgson, of Flimby, who died on the 21st of April. The foreman of the jury was Mr. William Wilson, a member of the Workington Corporation. The names of the jurymen were: Messers Buchanan, J. Cahill, J. Head, R. Thompson, H. Madine, C. Fothergill, J. McKay, Bewley, J. Lorraine, J. Pinguey, T. Lucock, J. Yeowart, W. Bailiff, F. Braithwaite. One of the jurymen, Joseph Allison, had died since the last inquest. The St. Helens Colliery Company was represented by Mr. L. T. Helder, Whitehaven. There were also present: Mr. J. Johnstone, manager; Mr. J. W. Muncaster, secretary; Mr. Oswald, assistant-inspector of mines for the Cumberland district; Mr. Tom Milburn, Workington, represented the Miner's Association; Mr. T. Rigg represented Mr. Johnstone, the manager. — The Foreman said he would like to know how it was that himself and his fellow jurymen had not been allowed an opportunity of visiting the working of the pit since the adjournment of the inquest. Since that time the discharged jurymen had been allowed that opportunity. He did not know whether they were asking for more than their rights, but some of them pretended to know something about a pit, and they had expressed a wish more than once or twice to go down this pit. The manager had informed him that if he left his name they would have been allowed the opportunity. He desired to know if it were a privilege they had asked for, or was it their duty to go down and view the place where the men met their deaths? Further, was it within the discretion of the colliery company to say whether they should go down the pit or not. If they were entitled to go down the pit then he protested against the action of the Company in inviting the discharged jury to inspect it, and not the present jury. To-day was the fourth time he had attempted to get down the pit, and he had always been treated with contempt. — The Coroner said he fully anticipated that the proprietors of the colliery would have given Mr. Wilson and his colleagues every facility. It was desirable that they should have been able to judge for themselves the condition of the pit. He quite coincided with Mr. Wilson's remarks, if he had been prevented from visiting the pit. — Mr. Wilson: I applied to you. — The Coroner: If you want to go down now — Mr. Wilson: What is the good of going down now when everything has been put right. Why I wanted to go down was to prevent such things again occurring. — Mr. Helder said after the water was got out no one but experts were allowed to enter the pit. It was not considered at that time expedient for practical men to go down. If Mr. Wilson had applied to go down, facilities would have been granted him, as in the case of Mr. Howe, the foreman of the other jury, and his colleagues on November 27th, 1888. Mr. Wilson said a clerk of Lord Lonsdale's had been allowed down the pit — Mr. Muncaster. — Mr. Helder said Mr. Muncaster had been employed in Lord Lonsdale's colliery for some years. — Mr. Wilson replied so also had he. — Mr. Milburn: I wish to say something as to the impression that prevails upon the mind of the jury. It is certain that the impression was when we adjourned the inquiry that the whole were to have an inspection of the pit as early as they possibly could have. In the face of that understanding it was incumbent upon the colliery proprietors to have intimated to me at the earliest possible time when this jury might have gone down the pit. I think that the colliery proprietors have been lax in not affording the jury that opportunity, as they cannot form the same judgement now that they might have done then. — Mr. Braithwaite said it was distinctly understood that the inspector of police, Mr. Lancaster, was to let the jury know when they were to go down the pit, and he did not think therefore it was necessary for any of them to write to the mineowners. (Hear, hear.) — The subject then dropped. William John Beattie, No. 10, Botany-street, Workington, the important witness referred to, was then called. He said he was a coalminer. He was formerly in the employment of the St. Helens Colliery Company as a deputy. He did not work anywhere now. He couldn't say whether the Company kept special rules defining the duties of a deputy or other men. He could not remember that he was in St. Helens pit when an explosion took place, though he knew he was engaged as a deputy. The duties of a deputy were to examine working places in the pit. — What else? Witness failed to answer the question. — Do you know whether he has to look after the brattices? I think so. He has not anything else to do that I know of. — Supposing he finds that the working places are not safe, what duties would he have to perform? He would have to see that they were put in order. — Was all the coal hagged out of the pit? Sometimes by means of shots. — Then what sort of explosive material was used — was it dynamite, or what? Powder, I think. — Have you any doubt? My head is that bad, I can't say. — Have you any doubt? I can't say. I only think so. — Was there any official in the pit whose duty it was to use the powder? No answer. — Whose duty was it to fire the shot? I think his name was Tunsty [Tunstall]. I remember Tunstall. — What was Tunstall? What they call a shot firer. — What were you? No answer. — Question repeated. I believe I was a shot firer too. — Was it the duty of deputies to fire shots? Yes, I think so. — Mr. Millburn asked for Beatty to place on record his appointment as deputy. — In reply to Mr. Webster, witness gave no satisfactory answer to this question. — The counterfoil was then produced of the appointment. — The Coroner: Were you in the habit of firing shots? Yes. — And do you remember 1888, about the 10th April, firing a shot in the pit? No. — Have you no recollection of a fire taking place in the pit, and an attempt being made to put it out? No. — Can you remember what took place before that date? No. — Have you lived for two years in Botany-street? I don't know. — Where did you live before that? In Elizabeth-street. — Do you know what age you are? No, I don't. — How are you maintained at the present time — who supports you? The Sick and Benefit Club and the St. Helens Relief Fund. — Do you get anything else? No. — Have you any allowance made by the colliery? No. Cross-examined by Mr. Millburn: Were you living in Workington when you first went to work at St. Helens. At Clifton, I walked to my work. I can't say how long I was at St. Helens before I was appointed a shot-firer. Shot firing is done by touch and straw. — What has the straw in it? Powder. — Are they supplied to you? No. — Where do you get them? The men make the straws themselves, and I as shot firer fire them. That was I think part of my work. I can't remember what took place when I fired the shots. — I am not speaking of this particular day. The shot fetched the coal out. — Did you ever see a blower lit with the shot? Yes, feeders. Feeders consist of gas out of coal. — I can't say that I have seen them lighted. — Do you know Hogg's Brow in St. Helens Pit? No, don't know whether I know it now. — But you did know it? Yes. — Was that part of the district you looked after? Well, I couldn't say. You have been in there, of course? Yes, most likely I have been in. — Did you know any men who worked there — any of the Ditchburns? No. — Do you know Tom Sanderson? — No answer. Question repeated. I did know him. — Did you know Hogg? Yes. — Do you know if Hogg worked at that part of the pit? I can't say in which part he wrought in. — Did you go to all the three pits? We generally used to change districts with the other deputies every morning. One of them was Peile. I can't remember anyone else. You have mentioned Tunstall. Was he another? I cannot say for a certainty. — I think he was a deputy. — What time in the morning did you last go to work in this pit? I cannot say what time, unless it was between two and three o'clock. — In the afternoon or morning? Morning. — Who would you find there? No one that I know of. My first duty at the pit would be to examine the places to see if they were all right from any danger. — What was the expected danger? There are all sorts of dangers in a pit — stone or wood, roof, and gas. — You can write, and you know your own handwriting? Yes, I think so. — Look at this entry dated April 19th. Is that your handwriting? — He was shown the book, and replied: I think it is in my handwriting. The entries dated April 16th, 18th and 19th are in my handwriting. — What does the entry of the 16th April say? It says that Wilson and Fletcher were withdrawn from the working on account of danger. — Danger from what? I don't know. — Do you mean to swear you don't know? Yes. I don't know where they were working. I know William Fletcher, of Seaton. I don't known where he was working at. He was a hagger. — What wages had you? 4s 3d. Paid by the day? — Yes. I have not been paid since. — Any deductions? The doctor's. — Anything else? I don't know. — Now, to come to the explosion; you remember going to the pit. You have told us that between three and four o'clock? I can't say what time. — Did you see Davidson on that morning? I don't know. — You know Davidson? Yes. — What was he? He was under-ground manager. — Very attentive man; was he not? Yes. — Do you remember being taken to the infirmary. What do you remember after the explosion? I don't remember anything. — I know nothing. Hasn't your memory improved? No. — The Coroner: You don't remember anything what — as to the explosion? Yes. — Mr. Milburn: Is the jury to understand that you limit your want of recollection that day to the explosion? I recollect nothing at all. If there was a shot in Hogg's Brow on that morning I should have had to fire it. — What time in the morning? When I examined the place. What time would that be in the ordinary course of things? I don't know whether it was half-past two or three o'clock that morning when I went down the pit. — If you found a strong blower or feeder, or gas accumulating, what would you do? If there was standing gas in a working, I should have had to rail it off? — How is that done? Put it planks across the full width of the place. — What else? Withdraw the men working in the place. — Like what you did on the 16th? What else would you have had to do? To see that the gas was cleared away; — Would you have anything to do with this book? Yes; make an entry in the report-book of gas and of men withdrawn. — Does your entry of the 19th April, 1888, say anything about gas? There is no entry here about gas on the 19th April, 1888. — A plan of the place was handed to Beatty for inspection, but he said he could make nothing of it. He could not tell where Hogg worked. — Have you been promised anything besides what you have received from the Colliery Fund and the Benefit Society? No. I haven't. — When you left the Infirmary where did you go to? To Millom for a change of air. — Who paid your expenses? No one. — Was there any promise? No. — By Mr. Helder: He had been a coalminer all his life. He did not know how long he had been a deputy or a shot firer. He remembered nothing about the accident. He was "clean by it." He was still under a doctor. — By the Foreman: He couldn't say whether he had seen gas in the working before the explosion. He couldn't say whether he had seen a feeder hit by a shot being fired. He knew what a hanging shot was. — The Coroner: Does any one of the jury wish to put any more questions to the witness? — Mr. Fothergill (a juryman): I think his memory is too convenient to make it necessary. (Laughter.) — Robert Clarke's evidence was read over to him, after which the Court adjourned for lunch. On resuming, Robert Clarke was re-called, but Mr. Millburn did not desire to further cross-examine him. Joseph Morrison, Flimby, who was employed by the Company at the time of the disaster as bank overman, again gave evidence. It was between nine and ten o'clock on the morning of the 19th April, 1888, when Robert Hodgson told him that a shot had been fired in Hogg's Brow, which had lighted some gas, and that they could not put it out. Mr. Davidson told him to get some water barrels filled, and take them to the scene of the fire in Hogg's Brow. He did so. When got them to the bottom of the dip they were not needed. Witness then went up Gilmour's Brow, and came to a place where two men were cutting a place for a stopping. Davidson was holding a light for the men. Subsequently he told witness to get the men out of the pit. The rest of the evidence was given under considerable hesitation, the witness apparently experiencing great difficulty in remembering what occurred on that memorable day. — Cross-examined by Mr. Millburn, witness stated that the putting in of the props was a preparation for flooding the pit. Davidson had said to him that the pit would have to be flooded at last. The props were put in about 50 or 60 yards from the foot of Hogg's Brow on the main dip. Mr. Johnston was not present when they commenced the work, nor did he come to them. The stopping next put in was completer before he went to reinstate the regulators. When he closed the ventilators, between two and three o'clock, the effect would be to put more air on the No. 3 district throughout, and lessen the air in No. 1 and No. 2 district, which had then been cleared of the workmen. — What was the effect of the alteration back again? It would have the effect of slightly reducing the current of air in No. 3 district at ten minutes to eight o'clock. The object in changing the regulators at that time was to prevent the smoke descending upon the men working at stopping S three. The fire was then expected to be proceeding in Hogg's Brow. There was occasionally gas emitted in Hogg's Brow. It was a common occurrence. He had heard of feeders occasionally in Hogg's Brow. Hodgson had told him of one having occurred that day. It was in Ditchburn's working. — What condition was No. 3 stopping when you re-opened the pit? It had disappeared, having been blown away. Witness had since the disaster been appointed under-manager in the room of Mr. Davidson, deceased. When they re-opened the mine there were appearances of fire to be seen in Hogg's Brow in the form of cinders. There was not much fire in the forehead of Hogg's Brow, and none in Gilmour's Brow. There was no appearance of fire in Ditchburn's working. The brattice and fence were standing intact about 20 feet from the face. He saw no signs of fire in the other workings. — Taking it altogether are there signs of a great fire having occurred? There must have been a great fire on the thirl mouth, nearest to the top of Hogg's Brow. — What depth had it gone into the coal? It might be a couple of inches in. Thirty two men were kept down the pit on the night when the disaster occurred for the purpose of labouring in the assistance of two masons who were to put in a brick stopping. On his oath, he thought that was a proper number of men to keep down to perform the work. The men were only uneasy because their time was up, and they wanted to catch their train. The work of putting in the brick stopping hadn't been begun, yet it was necessary to have the men waiting there. As soon as one stopping was finished, they went to work at another. How long were they waiting? I can't tell you. — Were they waiting there all afternoon? I cannot tell you how long they were waiting. — Don't you think it would have been better to have flooded the mine right off? Now, that we know the consequences of the fire, we know it would have been better to have it flooded in the morning. — It could have been done? Yes. — By Mr. Rigg: It took more than a week to flood the mine. The brick stoppings were put in for the purpose of walling up the fire, but it was found that it couldn't be done. The other stoppings were erected with the intention of flooding the dip. It would not at that time have been so extensive an operation as was afterwards the case. — By Mr. Helder: Witness was of opinion that everything was done on the 19th of April, 1888, that could reasonably have been done to take the air off the fire; and when that could not be done, to make preparations for the flooding of the pit. All the men were out of the pit excepting the 35 engaged in the work in hand. — By Mr. Millburn: Was anybody working at the stoppings B, C, D after five o'clock? No. — So you had no material to carry up there after five o'clock.. — By the Foreman: Witness did not really see the fire, but he saw it shining through the thirl. — What was the cause of the men running away? I don't know, but I met William Tunstall and he told me he thought it was going to a fall. — Didn't it strike you there was great danger when No. 3 district had to be flooded? No. — When you opened these regulators did Davidson say what was going to be the result? No. — The result was that it drove more air into the intake? Yes. — Further questioned, witness said he supposed he had obtained his certificate for service. — If a fire occurred again tomorrow, which I hope it won't, would you with your experience of the fire do the same as Davidson did — what would you do? I would have an empty pit. I would not get the same chance. He meant by this expression that the men would leave the place. — Mr. Wilson: A good job, too. — The inquest was then adjourned until Friday, at nine o'clock.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||