|
18th April 1889 The Fatal Accident At Croft PitThe adjourned inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of William Nulty, 25 years of age, who was killed in Croft Pit on the 10th inst., was resumed yesterday (Wednesday) afternoon, at the Whitehaven Infirmary, before Mr. W. W. Lumb, coroner, and a jury, of whom Mr. G. Dobson was foreman. — Mr. T. H. Brockbank appeared for the Whitehaven Colliery Company, and Mr. R. W. P. Oswald, assistant inspector of mines, and Mr. J. Ramsey were also present. — John Cooke said he was a sett rider, and was in charge of the sett on the afternoon of the 10th inst. There were 29 tubs, which contained about 60 men. The tubs were drawn by an engine at the top. The tubs started from a place called "Crassent," and were going to the deputy's cabin, a distance of about two miles. Witness should have been in the second wagon, in order to keep men from getting into the first. The deceased and another man were in the first wagon, and there were also two men in the second. When about 400 yards from the landing place the first tub left the rails, followed by several others. They would be going six or seven miles an hour. Witness jumped out of his tub, and signalled the engineman to stop. The tubs were stopped after going about 200 yards. Witness then went to the fore end, where he saw the deceased, who was hurt. Witness should have been in the second wagon, but both the first and second were full, and therefore he did not trouble the men to get out. Some men would rather stop the work for half an hour than get out when asked. — George Hooper, surveyor to the Whitehaven Colliery Company, produced a plan showing he place where the accident occurred. Witness, continuing, said the road was a straight one. He thought that a roller had been canted up by the tubs when going, and on them coming back the first tub struck the roller and left the rails. It was not usual to have so many men riding in the set. They rode in tubs in order to save the walk. At one time the men used to ride both out and in. The men said they would strike if they were not allowed to ride. — Mr. Oswald: Do the managers force the men to ride in the sett? No, sir. — Mr. Brockbank: They would prefer walking, but the men won't. — Witness did not consider it safe for men to ride in the sett. — John Beck said he was an engineman employed at Croft Pit. He had been for seventeen years in that occupation. Witness was at the engine on the afternoon in question. A short distance from the landing place witness got a knock to stop, which he did instantly. Witness could not say how the accident happened. He considered it safe to ride in the setts. — John Smith said he was a hanger on of setts at the Brow Bottom. Witness and another youth named James Trainor were in the second tub, and the deceased and another man were in the first tub. No one was allowed to ride in the first tub. Witness did not know the cause of the accident. When the accident happened nearly all their lamps went out. They were new lamps, but were not so good as the old ones. He could not say anyone was to blame. All the men knew they were not to ride in the first wagon. If Cooke had been in the second tub he could not have prevented the tubs leaving the rails. — Cooke, re-called, said if he had been in the second wagon he would have had less power over the signal. — George Batty, shiftman, also gave evidence, saying that the men were very careless. — William Henderson also gave evidence. — Mr. James Ramsey, manager of the Whitehaven Colliery, said he had made every inquiry regarding the cause of the accident, but could not find out how it happened. If a roller had been out of its place it would have knocked the tubs off the rails, but there was nothing to show that such was the case. He supposed all the men tried to get into the first tubs in order to get up as quickly as possible. So far as he knew he thought the engine was carefully driven at the time of the accident. They were required by an Act of Parliament to have the new lamps spoken of by a witness. The signalling system in the pit had been much improved. — Andrew Brough, a nurse at the infirmary, said the deceased had died about two hours after being admitted. The Coroner, in summing up, said Mr. Ramsey told them (the jury) that he could not find any blame attributable to anyone. The blame was no doubt attributable to the man himself by riding in the first truck. The rule to allow no one to ride in the first wagon was a good one, because it had been strongly borne out. It was a wonder that more lives were not lost. If the jury had any recommendations to make he had no doubt the owners of the Colliery would consider them. — The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||