|
14th February 1889 The Fatal Accident At Henry PitThe Adjourned InquestThe adjourned inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of Robert Smith, alias Robert Walker, who was killed in Henry Pit, on the 2nd inst., was resumed at the Punch Bowl Inn, Whitehaven, before Mr. W. W. Lumb, coroner, and a jury over whom Mr. G. Dobson was foreman, on Tuesday afternoon last. Mr. T. H. Brockbank appeared on behalf of the owners and managers of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, and Mr. A. Sharpe represented the relatives of the deceased. Mr. Oswald, Inspector of Mines, and Mr. J. Ramsay, manager of the Whitehaven Colliery, were also present. James Thompson deposed: I live at Back Ginns, Whitehaven, and am a joiner employed in Henry Pit. I knew the deceased who went by the name of Walker. On the morning of the accident I visited the working the first thing, when deceased said the roof sounded like a bell, and that there was no necessity for any props, and if I put any in he said he could not work. Richard Harker, the overman, examined the working place that morning before deceased commenced to work. I was proceeding to the place with a prop to put in when the fall of stone occurred and killed deceased, and also partly buried me. I thought the working was perfectly safe. By Mr. Sharpe: I do joiner work for the workings. I set props and run a brake. The deputies in this place were James McKenzie, Isaac Singleton, and Richard Harker. I don't know I am a deputy. I go by the word "joiner." I inspected the workings in the morning. If I had had time to have put the prop in I would. The reason why we did not set cross-heads in this place was because there was not plenty of room to put them in. The stone never gave the least warning. There was plenty of props to timber the working. By the Foreman: When Harker visited the working he told the deceased to leave the coal near the stone, but he disobeyed these orders. Neil Tinnion said he was a miner employed in the Henry Pit. When Harker visited the place in the morning he told the deceased not to touch the coal near the stone. Thompson, the deputy, was very obliging, and would do anything for us. By Mr. Oswald: I sounded this roof myself. I often find these "slips" very treacherous. By Mr. Sharpe: Richard Harker ordered a piece of wood to be left at the right hand side of the loose end. George Hooper, surveyor of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, produced a plan of the working. William Matthews deposed: I am a miner employed in Henry Pit. When Harker visited the place that morning we all thought the working was safe. I don't think there is anyone to blame for the accident. If there had been cross gear erected the stone could not have fell. I think if it could be done that a proper deputy would be better than a joiner. Thompson, the joiner, had too many jobs to attend to, but when he had props to set he always left the other work. By Mr. Sharpe: He got special orders from Harker that morning to leave some coal on the low side, but Smith "hagged" it away. The posts were placed on the soft metal because we could not get a hard bottom. Richard Harker said he examined the place in the morning and sounded the roof with his stick. He thought the accident was due to a slip which was very often unforeseen. Witness told the deceased not to work the coal, but he (witness) was told by the timberman that the deceased did so. There might be slips in a roof when the roof was as smooth as a bowling green. By Mr. Sharpe: When he examined the roof he did not see it. When he found a slip he always timbered it. By Mr. Brockbank: When witness told the deceased to leave the coal on, deceased said it would not make any "odds." Witness spoke to the joiner about putting some props in deceased's place, but deceased said there were plenty. The Coroner summed up, and the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death," with a recommendation in broken workings where the bottom is soft, that sole trees be put at the foot of the props, and planks or cross-heads to extend over the tramways.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||