|
20th December 1888 The Mining Disaster At CleatorThe inquiry held by Mr. J. Webster, coroner, into the circumstances attending the deaths of James Phillips, John McAvoy, and John Mills, was resumed at the Magistrates Court—room, Cleator Moor, yesterday (Wednesday). — Mr. Atter appeared on behalf of the relatives of the deceased man Phillips, and Mr. J. R. Thompson represented the Cleator Iron Ore Company; and Mr. Oswald, Assistant Inspector of Mines, was also present. — In reply to the Coroner, Mr. Thompson said he did not wish to call any additional witnesses. — Mr. Atter also said he did not wish to call any additional witnesses, but suggested that the medical witnesses should be examined as to the gas which would be generated by using the hand grenades. — The Coroner said he did not think it mattered, because the Company were bound both by their own special rules and the Act itself to provide a constant and adequate amount of ventilation to assure the working places, travelling roads, &c., to be kept in a safe and efficient state at all times. He (the coroner) did not think it was material what was in the hand grenades, as it was met by the Act and special rules. Mr. Atter, however, should have the opportunity of questioning the medical witnesses upon the point if he chose to do so. — The depositions having been read over to the witnesses and signed, the Coroner called Dr. Welby I'Anson, who, in answer to him, said that if the carbonic acid gas was pure when inhaled, the person who inhaled it would become unconscious at once. If a man had been in and out of the gas for two or three hours he would have all manner of unpleasant sensations, such as noises in the head, depression of breathing, and probably vomiting, and he might have pains in various parts of the body. It would make a man's intellect more or less confused. — In answer to Mr. Atter, witness said he could not say whether a man suffering from poisoning by carbonic acid gas would be relieved by vomiting. A man might walk home a distance of 600 yards, talk rashly, and yet he might suffer from the effect of the gas afterwards. — The Coroner, in summing up, said the most important person in this unfortunate occurrence was to his (the Coroner's) mind, the overman, Crawford. The rule, with regard to overmen, was a very good rule, and one which, if observed, would — not only in this pit but throughout the whole of the pits in this district — have a very good effect, he believed, from saving men from being injured, and saving men from losing their lives. It was one which he had frequently said ought to be observed in its integrity, and he believed Mr. Willis, chief inspector of mines for this district, and Mr. Oswald, assistant—inspector, were also of the same opinion. The manager, deputy — manager, and overman, appear to have been desirous of discharging their duties on the night of the 29th November. The deputy-manager and overman were on the spot as soon as they were warned, and there could not be a doubt but that they did all in their power to save their master's property. The manager, Mr. Addison, also appeared to have come without the slightest hesitation and did all he could. Unfortunately, the order that no men were to ride the pit was not given to the engineman or banksman of No. 9 Pit. There could not be a doubt but that it was the duty of some one to have been at No. 9 Pit before it begun to work on the Friday morning. He (the Coroner) would observe upon a point in the evidence which at one time made him think it was the cause of the accident, which was with regard to the key of the No. 9 engine-house. A person of the name of Taylor was the engineman of No. 9 Pit, and when he went on duty he had a key which was kept under the step door of No. 9 engine-house, but formerly — he could not say why — it was thought desirable that the key should be kept at No. 6. Had it been that the key was kept at No. 6, there could not be a doubt but that the engineman, Taylor, in going for the key in the morning, he would have been warned by the engineman of No. 6 that there was a fire in No. 6 pit, and probably it might, but not necessarily have prevented those men riding the pit. Either the overman or the deputy manager should have endeavoured to give warning to the men at No. 9 before six o'clock in the morning that No. 6 pit was on fire. There had been neglect there was no doubt on that point. The Coroner referred to the gallantry shown by several volunteers and the deceased men. — The Jury retired to consider their verdict, and after an hour's absence returned into court. — The Jury returned the following verdict: "That the cause of death was poisoning by carbonic acid gas. There had been a great, but not criminal, amount of neglect on the part of the three officials, Messrs. Addison, Leck, and Crawford, in not taking necessary and special precautions of preventing the men going down No. 9 pit." — Mr. Atter then thanked the Coroner and the jury for the impartial manner in which the inquest had been conducted, and also for Messrs. Ainsworth for offering every facility in their power, and the evidence which had been produced for his assistance.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||