Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

13th December 1888

The Mining Disaster At Cleator

The Inquest

The inquiry into the circumstances attending the deaths of John McAvoy, James Philips, and John Mills, who were suffocated at the Cleator Iron Ore Company's No. 6 Pit, on the 30th November last, was resumed before Mr. J. Webster, coroner, and a jury over whom Mr. W. Dixon presided, at the Magistrates' Court, Cleator Moor, on Monday. Mr. J. R. Thompson appeared for the Cleator Iron Ore Company, and Mr. E. Atter appeared on behalf of the relatives of Philips. There were also present :— Mr. Willis (inspector of mines) and Mr. Oswald (deputy-inspector of mines), Mr. J. S. Ainsworth (of the firm of the Cleator Iron Ore Company), and Mr. P. L. Addison (manager for Messrs. Ainsworth). — Terrence McAvoy was the first witness called, and deposed: I live at 35, Wyndham—street, Cleator Moor, and I am a miner in the employ of Messrs. Ainsworth. I was employed as a miner in No. 9 Pit. I went down the pit a week last Thursday, about two o'clock in the afternoon, in company with Richard Johnston and John Gaffany. We worked in No. 4 working until about half-past nine o'clock, when we proceeded along the main drift way to shaft of No. 6 Pit. We got to the top of the second ladder leading towards the shaft of No. 6 Pit, when I observed a smell, and we came to the conclusion that some wood was burning. We had another ladder to go down, and we went down to the bottom, when we found a main drift was full of smoke. The draught was meeting us at this time. We proceeded on, the smoke getting thicker as we proceeded. I then said to my companions "We will go on now and see what it is." We proceeded until we turned out of No. 9 Pit into No. 5 road. I left Johnston and Gaffany behind. I then proceeded about 30 fathoms, and I observed a fire in the main drift. There were no working places about there. Johnston, Gaffney, and I were the only men who were working in No. 9 Pit from two o'clock until half-past nine in the evening. I can't say whether there was anyone working in No. 6 Pit. When I found the pit on fire I returned to my companions, and we proceeded to No. 9 Pit shaft, and knocked for about a quarter, when a voice came to the top and said that No. 6 Pit was on fire. We were then lifted, and we told a number of persons at the top about the fire. About ten minutes to eleven o'clock I saw William Crawford, who is overman of No's 6 and 9 Pits, when I told him that No. 6 drift was on fire. I said this in the presence of several men, and Crawford must have heard it. John Taylor is the engineman, and Edward Cranny is the banksman of No. 9 Pit. Neither of these men were present when I said the pit was on fire. The height of the drift where the fire took place was 6ft, and the breadth 8ft. The fire was blazing, but I could not tell the extent of it. There was no system of sending an overman down the pit each morning before the men went down. — By Mr. Atter: Crawford was the only official I saw when we were lifted. — By Mr. Thompson: I was in the habit of going down No. 9 and coming up No. 6, and only for the fire I would not have thought of coming up No. 9, because there would be no engineman at No. 9. — By Mr. Oswald: I sometimes worked in the morning shift. I never see any other officials except Mr. Leck and Mr. Crawford. I have sometimes seen Mr. Addison. I see Crawford in my working place each day, but I did not see any official in my working place on Thursday, 29th November. — Dr. Speirs said he had made a post-mortem examination on December 2nd, along with Dr. Welby I'Anson, on the body of James Philips, and the result of his examination was that he was of opinion that deceased died from blood poisoning, causing by exhaling into the lungs poisonous gas, and he had all the appearances connected with those found after death by breathing carbonic acid gas, which caused death in this case. He was also of opinion that the deaths of McAvoy and Mills were due to the same cause. — Dr. Welby I'Anson said he assisted Dr. Speirs in making a post-mortem examination, and he was of the same opinion as Dr. Speirs as to the cause of death of the deceased men. — William Lyons deposed: I live at Wyndham—street, Cleator Moor. On Thursday week I was returning from my work at No. 21 Pit, Cleator. Whilst passing No. 9 pit I heard a hammer knocking, and I went to the No. 6 engineman, named Holden. I told him the men were knocking at No. 9, and that there was no engineman there. He said he could not lift them, and that I was to go for a man named Cunningham, who lived at Cleator. I then came on to the road again to the men who were my companions, and one of them named John Rogan returned with me to Holden, who again requested me to go to Cleator for Cunningham; and I went for him, and brought him to No. 9 Pit. — By Mr. Atter: I cannot say why Holden did not go for Cunningham. I saw Mr. Leck when I returned with Cunningham, which would be about twenty—five minutes to eleven. I also saw Mr. Crawford about the same time. I do not remember seeing Mr. Addison. — By Mr. Thompson: Holden did not tell me why he could not lift the men up. — John Cunningham deposed: I live at 49, Main—street, Cleator, and am an engineman. I work at No. 6 Pit. Our hours of working are from seven to five on the day shift, and from five in the evening to seven in the morning. On the 29th November I was on the day shift. I left No. 6 Pit at five o'clock in the evening, leaving the engine in charge of William Holden. Before I left I had drawn the men who were on the day shift up No. 6 shaft. Mr. Crawford was the overman on duty during the day shift. I can generally observe from where I sit the men who come up the pit. I don't know at what hour the overman, Mr. Crawford, came up that day. Thomas Graham was the banksman on duty that day at No. 6 Pit top. I saw Graham on duty when the last man came up. At five minutes past ten o'clock William Lyons came to my house, and told me there was a fire, as far as he knew, at No. 6, and that there were some men knocking at No. 9. I came right away to No. 9 Pit, and found Mr. Leck and several strangers. William Holden was also there, and had got steam up. I drew out of the pit Terrence McAvoy, John Gaffany, and Richard Johnston. Mr. Leck, Mr. Crawford, Holden, Cullen, and myself then proceeded to No. 6 Pit shaft. Mr. Leck, and Mr. Crawford, and Thomas Finn, and Patrick Curran went down. They came up, and said there was a swinging fire. We then got water—boxes on to the cage to draw to the middle high, and extinguish the fire. Mr. Crawford and Mr. Leck went down, but the smoke was so strong in the pit that they could not remain to empty the boxes. It was then suggested that a hose should be obtained, and this was got from Messrs. Ainsworth's mill. Mr. Leck and Mr. Crawford, Curran, and Finn took this down the pit, and remained down about a quarter of an hour. After coming up again I observed that Crawford was not fit to go down again, so Mr. Leck and Curran went down to see how the hose was acting. They would be down about five minutes, and when they came up they said the hose was not acting so freely as it should do, and they thought there might be a kink in the pipe. Mr. Leck, and Curran, and Finn therefore went down again to find out where the kink was. They remained down about four or five minutes when they returned to the top, and Mr. Leck was taken off the cage insensible. The extinction of the fire then ceased. Before the hose—pipe was put down nine fire extinguishers were sent down the pit. — By Mr. Atter: About eleven o'clock I saw Mr. Addison, the manager, at the pit top. I saw him go away about two o'clock on Friday morning. It would be about half—past ten on Thursday night when Mr. Leck and the others came and said there was a swinging fire. I left the pit at half—past three o'clock on Friday morning. I don't know whether the fire was then extinguished. Orders were given by Mr. Leck about one o'clock that word should be sent to Mr. Mackenzie's pit that no men should ride until they were satisfied there was no danger. George Kirkpatrick took the message. — What precautions were taken for the safety of Mr. Ainsworth's men? I don't know. — The Coroner: Did you hear any orders given that notice should be given to No. 9 engineman, and that no men should be allowed to go down? I can't say. — By Mr. Atter: Mackenzie's Pit is about 300 yards away, and No. 6 Pit 200 yards away from No. 9 Pit. When I left the pit I knew there was danger. I am certain that Mr. Crawford was down the No. 6 Pit during the morning's shift on Thursday, the 29th November. No one came up with him. I know of no other official who went down or came up No. 6 Pit. — By Mr. Thompson: Crawford complained of being ill, when he went home. I heard Crawford say in the presence of Holden and myself that there was no work at No. 6 Pit. Next day orders were given by Crawford to stop the pumps, so as to allow the water to rise in the "high." I returned to duty in No. 6 Pit, about five minutes past seven o'clock on Friday morning. I first heard that men had gone down No. 9 at about ten minutes past seven o'clock, and they could not help themselves up the pit. — By the Foreman: When I left No. 6 Pit, on the 30th November, I left Holden there in charge of the engine. There was no work for the engine at that time, as the pumps had been stopped. — By Mr. Willis: John Taylor and not Holden would let the men down No. 9 on Friday morning. — William Holden deposed: I live at Cleator Moor, and am an engineman in the employ of the Cleator Iron Ore Company. I had charge of the engine at No. 6 Pit. On the 29th November I went on duty at five o'clock, relieving John Cunningham. There would be no men working in No. 6 Pit when I went on duty. I did not draw any men up from the time I went on duty to the time I left. At ten o'clock I let two men down. There was no banker at the time. The men were going down to work, because they told me so. The two men whom I let down were Thomas Finn and Patrick Curran. About fourteen minutes after I brought them up again. They told me the pit was on fire. I then sent Curran for Mr. Crawford and John Cunningham. They then came and lifted the men who had been knocking at No. 9 Pit. I got the steam up at No. 9. I returned to my engine about half—past ten o'clock. Mr. Addison was there about eleven o'clock. Mr. Leck gave me orders to stop the pumps. I brought Mr. Crawford, Mr. Leck, Curran, and Finn down the pit several times before I was ordered to stop the pumps. I was ordered to stop the pumps about three o'clock in the morning. I did not let any men down the pit, or bring any up after I had stopped the pumps. I think Mr. Addison would leave about two in the morning as near as I can tell. I let Mr. Leck and Mr. Crawford down the pit twice after Mr. Addison left. Mr. Leck and Mr. Crawford told me before they left that the miners were not to ride that day. — Have you any charge over No. 9 engine house? No, sir. — How did you get into No. 9 engine — house? With keys, sir. — How did you happen to have the key? The key was hanging in No. 6 engine—house. — Why is the key kept in No. 6 engine—house? I cannot exactly say why it is kept there. About ten o'clock a boy named Lyons came and told me that some men were knocking at No. 9. I sent Lyons to Cunningham, and a man whom I believe is called Curran for Crawford. Formerly the engineman of No. 9 used to come to the engine—house of No. 6 to get the key, but about three months ago Taylor got a duplicate key. I don't know whether Mr. Addison, Mr. Leck, or Mr. Crawford knew that Taylor had a duplicate key. — By Mr. Atter: I have worked for the Cleator Iron Ore Company the last ten years. I have been an engineman all my life. No. 6 engine is a different class of engine than No. 9. I did not care to work No. 9 engine, because I knew nothing about it. I first saw Mr. Crawford and Mr. Leck soon after ten o'clock in the evening at No. 9 pit. I last saw them soon after three o'clock. When they left they seemed to be rather put about from fatigue, but were well able to walk home. Mr. Leck would have to go about a quarter of a mile, and Crawford about half a mile. No orders were given to me that the men were not to ride in No. 9 pit. I was left in charge of No. 6 engine, and remained in charge of the engine until next morning, when my mate relieved me. I had nothing to do after Mr. Leck and Crawford left. It was my duty to stay until next morning, when my mate relieved me. Mr. Leck and Mr. Crawford told me the last time they came up that the pit was still on fire. I knew there was danger. I saw Gaffany, Johnston, and McAvoy taken from No. 9. — Were not all those men more dead than alive? I did not take any notice of the men. They were well able to walk away. — Did they not appear to be in a worse condition than Leck and Crawford were? I cannot say they were in any worse condition than Crawford or Leck. I did not hear nor see Mr. Addison do anything in my presence. I saw Mr. Leck vomit when he came up the last time, and Crawford was suffering from fatigue. — By Mr. Thompson: When Mr. Leck came up the last time he was exhausted and sick. He was recovering from faintness when I saw him. There is a slate kept in No. 6 pit in a small hut, and it is usual for the banksman of No. 9 to come to No. 6 to get the slate. He usually came before the morning shift. I do not know whether he came on Friday morning. If he had come I might not have seen him. It never occurred to me that the men would go down the pit next morning. Soon after seven o'clock I heard that the men had gone down No. 9. I was much surprised on hearing that the men had gone down the pit. When the No. 6 men came in the morning I told them the pit was on fire. — By Mr. Atter: I don't know that any warning had been given to these men who lost their lives. — John Taylor deposed: I am an engineman, and live at Greystone—terrace, Wath Brow, Cleator Moor, and I am in the employ of the Cleator Iron Ore Company. I have charge of the engine at No. 9 pit. I went off duty between two and three o'clock on Thursday afternoon. I damped the fires down before leaving. I locked the engine—house, and went home. I left home again on the 30th ult., a little before six o'clock in the morning, and arrived at the engine—house between six and half—past. No communication was made to me between ten o'clock on the evening of the 29th November, and the next morning when I arrived at the pit. I found the banksman, Edward Curran. He did not make any communication to me about the fire. I let several cages full of men down No. 9 Pit. There was no overman present before I let the men down, nor any shiftmen present, besides the bankers, to my knowledge. I got notice from a man named Hugh McMullen, who came up the pit and appeared to be exhausted, and said help was to be sent for, because the men in the pit appeared to be in a bad state. I then returned to the engine—house. — Did you hear him say anything about a fire? He might have said so, but I cannot say positively. — By Mr. Atter: I was at home at ten o'clock on the evening of the 29th November. My house is about twenty or twenty—five minutes' walk from Mr. Leck's house, and it would be two or three minutes more to Mr. Crawford's house. — If you had known there had been a fire at No. 9 Pit would you on your own responsibility have refused to allow these men to go down? Yes, sir, I would. When I got to my work I found the engine door locked. — By the Coroner: I got the key at home. A key was not given to me by an official of the Company. — Was Mr. Addison or Mr. Leck aware that you had that key? Mr. Crawford was aware that I had that key. Cunningham and Holden also knew that I had the key. I have had the key about four months. When I first went to work at No. 9 Pit I used to hide the key under the engine—house step. Previous to getting a duplicate key, I got into the engine—house at No. 9 Pit by means of a key kept at No. 6. The key was kept at No. 6 so that the ambulance stretcher, which was kept at No. 9, could be got when wanted. — Holden re-called and in answer to the Coroner said: The key was kept at No. 9 for about six months. — Taylor, re—called and examined by Mr. Atter: Crawford led witness to understand that he knew I had a duplicate key before the accident. Crawford came to the pit on the 30th later than usual. The usual time for Crawford coming to the pit is between six and seven o'clock. — By Mr. Thompson: Crawford has other pits to attend to besides No. 9. I spoke to one of the deceased men, named John McAvoy, on the morning of the 30th. He said there had been a fire at No. 6 pit, but he did not know much about it. He said that as his mate had gone down, he would go down, as he could work if they could. I had let his partners down. I let a man named Curran down the pit also. He generally went down No. 6, but he went down No. 9 at times. — Edward Crellin deposed: I live at No.80, Ennerdale—road, Cleator Moor, and am a banker at No. 9 pit. On the 30th ult., I went to my work about ten minutes to six. I sent twenty-four men and two cages of wood down the pit. Previous to sending the men down the pit, no communication was made to me that No. 6 was on fire. I had a few words with McAvoy before he descended about the fire. He said the pit was on fire and the men who were in No. 6 pit could not get down. McAvoy belonged to No. 18 company, which consisted of Miles Burns, John Mills, John Fitzpatrick, and Hugh McMullen. Mills and McAvoy are two of the men who are now dead. I did not hear Mills say anything about the pit being on fire. When McAvoy told me about the fire, all the men had gone down except himself, and a man named Currie, who went down afterwards. — By Mr. Atter: Philips was in the cage that went down the pit. Richard Glanville, John Glanville, and John Fitzpatrick accompanied him. About a quarter to seven o'clock a number of labourers came across and said there was a fire at No. 6 pit, and they could not get down. All the men went away except McAvoy, who went down the pit, as well as a man named Currie. About half—an — hour afterwards Hugh McMullen came up and staggered off the cage. He told me that No. 6 pit was on fire and that the men were choking. Shortly after two knocks were heard and then three knocks, after which Richard Glanville came up. He was in a similar state as McMullen. Glanville told us that the men were suffocating in the pit bottom, and he would go for help. Four men came up the pit shortly afterwards, and they were all affected in the same way as Glanville and McMullen. About nine o'clock James Gardener, an overman over a gang of men employed about the pit top, got into the cage and went down the pit, and stayed down about a quarter of an hour. There were volunteers down the pit before Mr. Leck or Mr. Addison came. — By Mr. Thompson: John McAvoy should have gone down No. 6 pit. He said he would go down and see what his mates were doing, and if he could not get work he would come back again. None of the men who knew about the fire said they would warn the men who were in the pit. — The Coroner then said he would adjourn the inquiry till Tuesday morning.

The inquiry was resumed on Tuesday morning. — Terrence McAvoy, recalled said he went about 100 fathoms from the lowest ladder, when he left his companions, and he was about three fathoms from the fire. — Hugh McMullen deposed: I live in Jacktrees—road, Cleator Moor. I am a miner in the employ of the Cleator Iron Ore Company. I work in No. 6 Pit. On the morning of the 30th November I left home to go to my work, about 5.30 am. I went direct to No. 9. I worked in company with John Mills, Myles Burns, and John Fitzpatrick. Fitzpatrick is better known as "John Fitz." I descended No. 9 Pit about 6.20 a.m., along with Myles Burns. All the No. 9 men having preceded us, Myles Burns and I remained at the top to send some wood down. After this Burns and I went down, and we found Mills and Fitzpatrick there, and each of us took a load of wood and threw it down where the first ladder was. The depth of the lower part of this ladder would be about two fathoms. Each of us returned to the shaft for another load, which we threw down at the same place. At that time I had not observed any offensive smell. The four of us then went down the first ladder, and John Fitzpatrick and John Mills proceeded down the second ladder. I went to the top of the ladder and Myles Burns handed the wood to me, and I handed it over the second ladder to John Mills and John Fitzpatrick. When the last of the wood was sent down I went down the second ladder. I passed Fitzpatrick and went up to John Mills, who said to me, "Do you find that smell?" I replied, "Yes," and I thought it was from the fresh slabs of wood we had brought down the pit that morning. Mills and I proceeded down the drift to the top of the third ladder, and I was standing waiting for him to go a bit further. He went down the ladder to the bottom of the drift, and stood on the top of the fourth ladder. He then turned into the fourth ladder to go down and I was waiting for him to go a bit further in order that I should turn into it. He said "There is some wood on fire or something in the pit which is wrong," and with that I turned to come up the drift again. I don't remember going up the ladder, but when I regained consciousness I found a lad named Welsh leading me to the pit shaft. He put me into the cage, and I went up to the pit top, and the banker helped me off the cage. I then laid on the engine—house and gave a report to the banker to the effect that he was to tell the manager that the men in the pit would be lost. I did not see either John McAvoy or James Philips after they went down the pit that morning. I was ill all the day after I came up the pit, my head being quite light. — Were you told by anyone on the 29th or 30th of November before you went down the pit that it was on fire? — No, sir. — By Mr. Atter: I have worked for the Cleator Iron Ore Company for 29 years. A fire took place in No. 9 pit, about five or six years ago. There was no one killed. A man named John Telford was a bit bad, and that was only until he came out of the pit. — The Coroner said that he did not think the questions by Mr. Atter had any material bearing upon the present accident. Mr. Atter was quite right in asking the questions, but how a fire which took place five years ago affected the present question he could not tell. — Mr. Atter contended that there might have been other fires, and it ought to have warned the officials. It was no use of him attending the inquiry if the questions were not allowed to be put. — The Coroner: Have you any more questions to put? If you have not I will ask Mr. Thompson to go on with his examination. — Mr. Atter: I refuse to put any more questions because of your ruling. — By Mr. Thompson: It was after seven o'clock in the morning when I was brought up the pit. — By the Foreman: When I regained consciousness I walked home without assistance. — By a Juryman: I did not ask John Mills to come home when I was in the pit. — Myles Burns was the next witness. — By Mr. Thompson: John McAvoy was a trailer in my company, and he generally went down No. 6. When McAvoy went down No. 9 he was going round about to his work. I and my mates are contract men, and the trailers are paid by us, and not by the Cleator Iron Ore Company. I cannot say that I saw John McAvoy, but I heard his voice. — By a Juryman: The only way that I knew there was a fire in the pit was by reason of the effects on myself. — By Mr. Oswald: Either John Currie or John McAvoy told me they had been ordered not to go down No. 9. — John Fitzpatrick gave evidence. — By a Juryman: John McAvoy was engaged by Mr. Leck. — By Mr. Oswald: I was not aware that on the 30th John McAvoy had orders to go down No. 9 pit. — John Glanville deposed: I live at No. 6, Trumpet—terrace, Cleator, and am a miner in the employ of the Cleator Iron Ore Company. I descended the pit with James Philips, Richard Glanville, and John Fitzpatrick. About 6.15 I went to the boxes, which were about 100 yards from the shaft. We stayed there a short time and then each man went towards their workings, and I went to mine, No. 38. I had just got down into my own place when I heard a shout, and I said to my brother William, who was working with me, "Run and see what is that shout." He returned and said there were two men buried. I then ran onto the main road where I met James Philips and Richard Glanville. They said, "Come on," and I followed them to where there was a ladder. John Fitzpatrick and Myles Burns were lying shouting. Then I heard that there were two more further down. I had my candle with me and it was burning first class. James Philips said, "Come on I will show you." We followed down another ladder, and came to the top of a third ladder where I saw John McAvoy with Mills in his arms standing on a ladder. Philips got hold of Mills on one side of the shoulders and I got hold of the other, and we tried to draw him from the ladder, but could not. Philips said "Hold on," and then went down the ladder and shoved Mills up to me, and Walker, who had come up, got hold of Mills, and we then drew him up and laid him on some spiles. As we lifted Mills, McAvoy fell. When he fell Philips stopped to pick him up and kept on shouting, "Come on Jack." I ran back, and when I got to the top of the ladder I saw Philips in a stooping position, and I saw him fall forward. I then became unconscious. When I regained consciousness I found myself on the pit top. I did not know that the pit was on fire before I descended that morning. — By Mr. Atter: I have worked for the Company about two months. It is not the practice for the overman to examine the working places before the men go to work. We see the overman once a day. Mr. Crawford is the overman we generally see. Had I known there was a fire in No. 6 I would not have gone down the pit. I trust to the overman to warn me if there is any danger. When I was assisting Philips I saw no smoke nor fire, and there was nothing to show what the men were suffering from. — By Mr. Oswald: Philips light was burning when I saw him stooping for McAvoy. You could not count more than five between the time of my seeing Philips stooping for McAvoy, and the lights going out. — Frederick McConnell was called and deposed: I live at Cleator Gate, Cleator, and am manager of the Cleator Mills. On the 30th November I went to No. 9 pit, because I heard there had been an accident there. After I had obtained certain information I decided to descend the shaft. Before doing that I sent some one to telephone for Mr. Addison. After I got to the bottom of the shaft of No. 9 pit, I had formed my opinion at that time that it would be simple death for any man to go forwards, and I made the remark that if there was the least chance of life being left I would go forwards, to which all the men added that they would do the same. At this time I found several men who had preceded me, and we all went to the top of the first ladder. I saw what appeared to be a slight haze down below. I saw from the way the two candles were burning that gas was there. While moving towards the pit shaft one of the party suddenly fell down, and we had to carry him out. Before going it appeared to me that the gas was arising rapidly. I met Mr. Addison and I reported to him that I had been down and considered it impossible to recover the bodies then. I had previously been informed there were two men lying in the pit. We immediately considered how the ventilation was to be restored, and we decided that a fan which we had at the Cleator Mills would be of service. We then went together to see an engine which Mr. Addison considered would do to drive the fan. The engine was conveyed to the pit, and the fan was erected about half-past ten o'clock. When we saw that all practical purposes were ready — I mean all but packing up some holes and getting up steam — I went to get some refreshment, and to the office to despatch a telegram. When I returned about two o'clock, I found the fan running. I then went to No. 6 shaft and found a slight smell coming up, which made me feel satisfied that the fan was beginning to alter the ventilation. I then returned to No. 9, and met Mr. Addison with Mr. Main. I asked Mr. Addison to telephone to the mills to let me know as soon as the relief party were ready to descend. I got the message about four o'clock, and I came at once to No. 9 pit, and found Mr. Addison, Mr. Leck, and a party of miners preparing to descend. I found that there was a vacancy in the cage going down, and in order to save time I got on to it, and Mr. Leck followed me. When we got to the bottom we began to move forward. I noticed one or two candles, the light of which appeared to indicate that the current of air was coming against me. Mr. Leck and I had a short conversation and decided that the wind from the fan must be escaping up the shaft by which we descended. We therefore sent a man up to Mr. Addison, as we knew he was about to follow us, requesting him to get the shaft sealed up again. We then went forward and at the top of the first ladder we had a short consultation. It was decided that the longer we waited the weaker we might get, and we had better go forward at once. It was pointed out that the flame of one of the lamps was blowing tolerably powerful, in the direction in which we were going, and therefore we considered that the flame of the candle was due merely to a small eddy, and that we might go forward. When we got to the top of the third ladder we could see the bodies of the two men lying below. A man named Kennedy was leading, and we tied a rope under his arms, and he got down. The company consisted of a man named Watson, a miner, and myself. Watson drew my attention to a pricker that was threw past one of the men's clothing. I told him to draw it as it would have added to our difficulties in raising him. We then lifted him out. We then lifted the second man out ourselves as quickly as possible. I felt it close, but I did not smell the gas until we removed the bodies. — By Mr. Atter: The object in putting up the fan was to drive the bad air towards No. 6 pit shaft. When I first went down the shaft about fifteen minutes past nine in the morning Mr. Crawford was on the pit top. He appeared to be ill at the time. I have no special knowledge of pits. My impression is that Mr. Leck was at the top of the third ladder when the first body was removed. I met the body of John Mills as it was being removed from the pit on the main road, about ten minutes past nine o'clock. — James Welsh, 38, Jacktrees—road, Cleator Moor, and David Bryan having given evidence, the inquiry was adjourned until Wednesday morning.

The inquiry was again resumed yesterday (Wednesday) morning, before Mr. J. Webster. — The Coroner said he had received a telegram from Mr. Willis, stating that owing to being ill he could not attend the inquiry yesterday. — John Dobson deposed: I live at 3, Earl—street, Cleator Moor, and am a miner. I was on the morning shift, and worked in a quarry near to No. 6 pit. I heard a little after seven o'clock that some men had been smothered in No. 9 pit. I went to No. 9 pit. I was asked by Richard Glanville to go down, and I did so. When I got down I asked to be shown the way and William Walker volunteered to do so. We both went to where Mills was lying. Walker and Mandale took Mills's coat off, and we brought him to the foot of the second ladder. He was then put on my back and I brought him up the second ladder. I then found Walker lying at the top of the second ladder insensible. I then laid Mills down and helped to get Walker out of the way. We removed him towards the first ladder. I then began to feel the effects, when I had shifted Walker. I did nothing more, and I had to be brought up the pit. — By Mr. Atter: I recovered my senses in about half—an—hour, after I came up the pit. I went home and came out about eleven o'clock. I went down to No. 9, and remained until noon. Mr. Crawford appeared to be getting men down the pit, from half—past eight until half—past nine. — Did you see him go down the pit? No, I did not. — By Mr. Thompson: There was no smoke in the pit. Everything was as clear as day when I went to Mills's body, but there was a strong smell. I did not take particular notice of Mr. Crawford as to his condition. — By Mr. Oswald: I did not get any orders from anyone at the pit bottom. What I did was on my own responsibility. — William Ramsay deposed: I live at Brookside, Cleator. I am a miner in the employ of the Cleator Iron Ore Co., about eight o'clock I heard there had been an accident at No. 9 pit. I went as soon as I could and rendered assistance in getting the men out. — By Mr. Thompson: Holden said we could not get down No. 6. — You were surprised that Crawford was not there when you arrived at the pit? — I was, sir. Because I always found him at the pit when I arrived. — By a juryman: When Holden said Mr. Leck was affected he said nothing about Mr. Crawford. — By Mr. Oswald: When I saw Mr. Crawford I could not say whether he was fit to go down the pit. He appeared to be "put about." — John Currie also gave evidence. — William Walker deposed: I live at 26, Riley Terrace, Cleator Moor, and am a trailer in the employment of the Cleator Iron Ore Company. I was engaged by Mr. Leck to work in No. 28. I saw John McAvoy holding Mills in his arms round the middle. He says, "I am glad you have some men; I have done my best, "or bit." Philips jumped down alongside of Mills and McAvoy, and helped John Glanville and myself to get Mills up to the top of the third ladder. As soon as we got Mills I went for further help, and returned nearly to the top of the first ladder. I saw Philips in a stooping position. McAvoy had fallen at that time. I heard Philips say, "I am done, Jack." That observation was addressed to John Glanville. — By Mr. Atter: I don't know at what time the body of Mills was brought up. No warning was given to me before I went down the pit that anything was wrong. It has been usual for Wm. Crawford to be at No. 9 Pit top before the men go down. — William Leck deposed: I live at Cleator Gate, Cleator, and am deputy manager for the Cleator Iron Ore Co., and have been in that position for three years. I produce a copy of the special rules relating to the pit. — Mr. Thompson: I should prefer Mr. Addison being called if you want the question of the rules cleared up. — Mr. Percy Leonard Addison stated he had been manager for the Cleator Iron Ore Co., for six years. He produced the rules, and gave evidence as to posting them at the pits. — Mr. Leck was re—called, and examined by Mr. Thompson deposed: I first heard of something being wrong in No. 9 pit, as I was returning home from Cleator Moor, a little after ten o'clock on Thursday evening, when I heard the hammer of No. 9 pit knocking. I went to No. 9, and found that there was a fire in No. 6 main drift, and that the three men at No. 9 shaft had been prevented going up to No. 6 shaft, and that they had returned to No. 9. Holden, the engineman of No. 6, was in the engine house of No. 9. One of the men on the surface shouted down the pit shaft and inquired if the men were in any danger. A reply came that they were all right. I then went to the office, changed, and went to No. 6 pit. On reaching the pit again, I learned that the three men had been lifted, and had gone home. Shortly after this I went down No. 6 with Crawford, Thomas Finn, and Patrick Curran. I went to the main drift where the fire was, and found 15 or 20 setts of wood burning. We fixed a water box on the cage intending to lift water from the sump to the high of the level where the fire was, but we found the smoke was too thick to stay in it so as to produce any effects. We threw a few buckets of water on the fire, and then we came up, as we could not stay any longer. I then arranged to get a hose from Cleator Mill, and this I intended to fix to the bottom sett of pumps and run the water that was pumped up to the lodge back again on to the fire. I went up the pit, and made necessary arrangements. When I met Mr. Addison, who had been telephoned for. I explained the position of affairs to him. When I got the hose about half—past twelve o'clock in the morning, Crawford, Finn, Curran, and myself went down, to fix the hose in the lodge. The lodge where we had to fix the hose was full of smoke. Crawford was furthest in the lodge, and he was affected by the smoke. As soon as we had fixed the hose we returned to the surface. We descended the pit again. We found that very little water was coming through the hose. Mr. Addison asked if the Crossfield Company had any working communication with us. I said they had. He then said it would be advisable to send them word — warning them of the smoke. P.C. Kirkpatrick volunteered to go with a message to Mackenzie's pit. The subject of working our own pits (No's 6 and 9) was then referred to. Mr. Addison said the pits would probably not be able to work for a day or two. Crawford said they would not work that week at any rate. It was then agreed that No. 6 and No. 9 should stand for that week. Mr. Addison in doing that did all that could be expected of him. We again descended the pit, and threw nine fire extinguishers on the fire, but they did not appear to have any effect on the fire. We came up the pit again, and shortly after went down and found that the smoke was not so dead as before, and the fire was apparently dying down. We again returned to the surface, and I then said to Mr. Addison there was no necessity for him to stay any longer as the fire was dying out, and that we would get the hinges straightened, and that we would have the fire out in twenty minutes or half — an — hour. Mr. Addison, with that report, then said he would go home, and he repeated again that there would be no more work at No. 6 or No. 9 pit. I said, turning round to Crawford, "No, certainly not." Mr. Addison then went home. After he had gone I went down the pit again and examined the hose at the bottom. We found the hose would not work, and I, on getting dizzy, ordered the cage to be lifted to the pit top, which was done. The next thing I found myself lying on the pumps logs, at the surface. After I came round I decided to let the water rise in the pit and so put out the fire, and I told the engineman not to start the pumps again. I then went home. I felt very ill. I arrived at home between three and four o'clock. I slept very badly and nervously. Between seven and eight o'clock I was startled when I was told by Richard Glanville that there were four men in No. 9 pit and they could not get them out. I went back to dress, but I was so ill that I could not dress myself, and had to be put into bed. I went to the pit a little after ten. I went down the shaft of No. 9 in the afternoon between four and five o'clock and helped to recover the bodies of McAvoy and Philips. I found two lamps burning in No. 9 pit bottom. I do not think there would be any danger from bad gas in No, 33, 38, and 40 workings. I know the overman's duty is to go down No. 6 and No. 9 every day for the purpose of inspecting the workings, and the pit generally. It is one of the special rules that the miners have to see that their own working places are in a safe working condition. I was aware that there was one key, which was kept at No. 6 engine — house. I generally went to the mines about eight o'clock. Crawford had always to be at the mines before six o'clock in the morning. I was engaged from eleven o'clock until three o'clock, with the exception of half-an-hour, whilst we were waiting for the hose, going up and down the shaft, with short rests at the top. — By Mr. Atter: I anticipated that the smoke would fill No. 6 and No. 9, travelling roads. At no time was there much flame visible. After Mr. Addison left, I was the chief person in charge. I told Crawford that no persons were to be allowed down No. 9 Pit. I told Crawford this before any of us were affected by the smoke. I told him before we fixed the hose. I told him at the time Mr. Addison left. Crawford was not so bad then as he had been. I thought it was dangerous for any workmen to go down No. 9 Pit. — By the Coroner: I have ascertained the names of the three men who were in the place where the fire occurred. When they passed they said they did not notice anything wrong. — William Crawford deposed: I live at 3, Croft—terrace, Cleator. I am deputy underground overman. I have been in the employ of the Company eight years and ten months. From No. 9 I went to No. 6 shaft. During the remainder of the night of the 29th November and the early part of the 30th November, I went down the shaft of No. 6 several times, and I got to where the fire was, which was 30 feet from the shaft in the main drift of No. 6. There was a deal of smoke coming up the shaft, and it overcame me when I was putting the hose pipe down between two brattices. I told William Holden, John Cunningham, William Currie, and Charles Lamb that neither No. 6 nor No. 9 pit would work any more that week. William Currie said that I would have to give them work on the top. I went home about four o'clock in the morning. I had a bad pain in my head; having been in the smoke about four hours. When I got home I fell asleep, and did not waken at the time I used to do, and because I was not there no one would take the responsibility to stop the men. It was clearly understood before I was overcome that the pits would not work. It is my duty to be at No. 6 pit at six o'clock in the morning. I have never missed once before during the eight years and ten months that I have been in the Company's employment. If I had been all right I should have been there at my usual time, before six on the Friday morning. A lad came to my house about a quarter—to—eight, and told me what had happened, and I went to the pit in ten minutes. When I went home on the Friday morning I fully intended to be back at my work at six o'clock. When I arrived at No. 9 on Friday morning, I was asked by some men who were about to stand on the pit top and keep order, and to assist those who were down the pit. — Mr. Percy L. Addison re—called, and examined by Mr. Thompson, deposed: I got to No. 6 pit about midnight, when Mr. Leck reported to me, that three men had been brought up the pit. After Mr. Leck descended the pit and reported that the fire was not a serious one, I suggested that a message be sent to Mackenzie's pit, because Mr. Leck said there was a communication between Mackenzie's pit with No. 7. At about half—past one o'clock on Friday morning I distinctly told both Leck and Crawford that No. 9 and No. 6 were not to work next day. Crawford said they would not be able to work that week. There was no doubt as to my instructions. At that time Mr. Leck was perfectly well. Mr. Crawford had been ill, but was then better. Mr. Leck went down the pit again, and on his return described the state of the pit to me, and said he thought he would be able to extinguish the fire in twenty minutes or half an hour, and that there was no necessity for me to stay any longer. I then went into the engine — house and told him that no one was to be let down the pit in the morning. The following morning I had a telephone message about 9.25, reporting the accident. I superintended the arrangements that went on during the day. I went down No. 6 shaft as soon as I arrived in the morning. When Mr. Leck arrived about half—past ten o'clock I saw him at the pit, when he looked so ill that I would not allow him to go down No. 6 Pit. This is the first fatal accident I have had at the Cleator Iron Ore Company's Pit during my management. — Charles Lamb deposed: I am a fitter in the employment of Messrs. Ainsworth, at Cleator Mills. Hearing something was wrong, I went about ten o'clock and remained until about three o'clock next morning. I was in the engine — house, when I heard Crawford say — I suppose he was speaking to the engineman — "Now, there are no men to go down No. 6 or No. 9 this week, or perhaps on Monday, until I go down and see." There were in the engine—house Cunningham, Holden, Currie, and myself, and there were also some other men present at the time. — Mr. Thompson said they did not wish to call any other witnesses. There were the two men Finn and Curran, but he did not think their evidence was material. — P.C. Kirkpatrick deposed to taking the note to Mackenzie's on Friday morning, which he suggested should be done. — The Court rose about seven o'clock, and the Coroner said he would adjourn the inquiry until Wednesday, the 19th inst.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Addison, Percy L.    Manager  
Ainsworth, J. S.    Mine Owner  
Atter, Edward    Solicitor  
Bryan, David    Miner  
Burns, Miles    Miner  
Cranny, Edward    Banksman  
Crawford, William    Overman  
Crellin, Edward    Banker  
Cunningham, John    Engineman  
Curran, Patrick      
Currie, John    Miner  
Dixon, W.    Jury Foreman  
Dobson, John    Miner  
Finn, Thomas      
Fitzpatrick, John    Miner  
Gaffany, John    Miner  
Gardener, James    Overman  
Glamville, John    Miner  
Glanville, Richard    Miner  
Graham, Thomas    Banksman  
Holden, William    Engineman  
I'Anson, Welby, Dr.    Doctor  
Johnston, Richard    Miner  
Kennedy, —    Miner  
Kirkpatrick, —    Police Constable  
Kirkpatrick, George      
Lamb, Charles    Fitter  
Leck, —      
Leck, —      
Lyons, William    Miner  
Mackenzie, —    Mine Owner  
Main, —      
Mandale, —    Miner  
McAvoy, James   21 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
McAvoy, Terrance    Miner  
McConnell, Frederick    Miner  
McMullen, Hugh    Miner  
Mills, John   43 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Deputy Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Phillips, James   38 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Ramsay, William    Miner  
Rogan, John    Miner  
Speirs, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Taylor, John    Engineman  
Telford, John    Miner  
Thompson, J. R.    Solicitor  
Walker, William    Trailer  
Walker, William    Miner  
Webster, John    Coroner  
Welsh, James    Miner  
Willis, James    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Cleator (Iron Ore)  Cleator (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
06 Dec 1888  Melancholy Mining Disaster At Cleator Moor (Whitehaven News)
13 Dec 1888  The Mining Disaster At Cleator, The Inquest (Whitehaven News)
20 Dec 1888  The Mining Disaster At Cleator (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Cleator, No. 9 Pit (Metalliferous)
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print