|
14th June 1888 The St. Helen's Colliery DisasterThe Adjourned Inquest: Scenes Between The Coroner And ForemanOn Thursday last, at the Police Court, Workington, Mr. J. Webster, coroner for the lordship of Egremont, and the following jury, held an inquiry touching the deaths of Robert Hodgson, Flimby, and Joseph Robinson, Seaton, who died at the Workington Infirmary in consequence of injuries received by the explosion at St. Helen's Colliery on the 19th April last :– Messrs. William Wilson (foreman), J. McKay, Coates Fothergill, John Head, Robert Adams, Hugh Madine, William Bewley, Robert Thompson, James Lorane, Jonathan Buchanan, Joseph Pinguey, J. Cahill, Thomas Lucock, Joseph Yeowart, Matthew Morgan, William Bayliff, and Fletcher Branthwaite. Joseph Allison, who was sworn as a juror, has died since the opening of the inquiry. There were also present Mr. T. Rigg, Wigton, who appeared for the colliery manager; Mr. L. T. Helder, for the colliery company; Mr. T. Milburn, for Margaret Tilley and Margaret Hodgson, representatives of the deceased, and the West Cumberland Miners Association; Mr. A. Sharp, agent for the Miners' Association; Mr. Oswald, Brigham, inspector of mines for the Cumberland district; Mr. J. H. Johnston, manager of the colliery; Mr. J. E. Mulcaster, secretary; Mr. P. Wedgwood and Mr. T. Carey, directors; Mr. H. Liddell, Whitehaven; Mr. W. Johnston, Aspatria; and Mr. F. Atkinson, Ellenborough. Before the proceedings commenced, the Foreman asked that witnesses, while they were not giving their evidence, should not be allowed to remain in the Court. The Coroner: If you will allow me to conduct the inquiry I should be very glad to do so. The Foreman: You will allow me to-make a request for all that. Mr. James E. Mulcaster, secretary to the St. Helen's Colliery Company, produced the plan of No. 3 William Pit, the daily report book, and reports of Davidson and Morrison, the overmen, as to the condition of the mine during the month of April last, also the book for authorising persons to fire shots in the mine, and a copy of the special rules for the regulation of the mine. The Coroner : If you have any questions to ask, ask them. The Foreman: I put them to you first, and I claim the right as an Englishman. I did not come here to be nipped by the Coroner. I came here to do my duty to the relatives of the deceased. The Coroner: I hope I have said nothing that has offended you. The Foreman : You have offended me. The Coroner asked the Foreman if he had any question to put. The Foreman said he thought the Coroner was a little bit sharp with him, and he was not going to put up with it. The Coroner, of course, was conducting the inquiry, but if he did not pay any respect to the jury it was no use their being there. He wished to protest against the kind of treatment he had received from the Coroner. In answer to the Foreman, witness said he could not tell why the members of the jury were not allowed to go down the pit. It would have been as safe, he thought, for the jury to go down the pit as the doctor. They would have been glad if the jury had gone down the pit, but it was full of standing gas, and dangerous. The men who went down the mine were selected by Mr. Liddle, the consulting engineer. The court had to wait some time for Dr. Dudgeon, which caused the foreman to remark: We shall have to pay extra for this; it is killing time with a vengeance. The time was killed by the Foreman again returning to the question of having the witnesses in court, observing that it was not right for the official's to be present. The Coroner; I cannot see there is any objection. The Foreman specified Mr. Liddell, and it was said he was only a scientific witness. The Foreman: Was he not-down putting the pit right? I think it is absolutely necessary he should be away. I think it is just intimidating the witness. The Coroner: Oh, dear. The Foreman: But allow me to tell you from experience. Can we not take another witness? The Coroner? No. I don't think you will be long I here to-day. Dr. Dudgeon stated that Beatty was not in such a conditions to attend the court, and he could form no opinion as to-the time when Beatty would be able to give evidence. Clark was injured in the explosion, but he was of opinion that Clark could give evidence with out injury to himself. — By Mr. Milburn: Beatty was no better mentally, though physically there was improvement. He would not say that the condition of mental obscenity was permanent. — He remembered one case where a person only recovered his reason after a period of five years. It would be impossible for Beatty to be ready in two months or four months, though it was possible he might be ready in twelve. — Have you endeavoured to draw his memory back to these incidents? I have. He is entirely void of any idea at all. — And in reference to other subjects? He is in the same condition. Robert Clarke, at present an inmate of the Workington Infirmary, said he was formerly employed at St. Helens Colliery as a mason. He was working there on the day of the explosion, the 19th April. He commenced work between nine and ten o'clock in the morning from orders received by Mr. Johnston, the manager. Witness was ordered to go down the pit and put in some stoppings. John Pearson, Mr. Johnston, and witness went down the mine to the place where the stoppings had to be put in. As soon as the bricks and lime were brought the stoppings were put in by witness and Pearson. Mr. Johnston and Davidson came several times to see the work as it was proceeding. Witness and Pearson completed the work and came to the down cast shaft for some wood, to enable James Moffat to put in a wood stopping at the engine dip. Moffat and James Smith were engaged at the wood stopping. Witness afterwards came to bank for some refreshments, and then went down the mine again. He saw Joseph Robinson and Henry Nicholson in the mine. Witness did not remember hearing any explosion whilst engaged in the stopping. He had only been occasionally employed down the mine. Mr. Milburn asked the witness if he heard any explosion. The Coroner: Did you hear a noise? Mr. Milburn: Are you examining the witness or am I. The Coroner: Please yourself. I was only asking him whether he heard a noise. By Mr. Milburn: When he left the first stopping there were three or four men there, amongst them being Laybourn and Tunstall. He did not see Mr. Johnston. He heard something about a "thurl" being broached, but he had since forgot about it. He was told by Mr. Johnston that a shot had been fired, and a stopping had to be put in. The stopping would be about 18 or 19 inches in thickness, but he could not tell the height. Whilst working at the stopping he heard a noise of some kind like an explosion. He could not tell what distance the noise came from. He saw some boys running away. He did not see any men running, but he saw some of the men leaving. He saw Stephenson, who said it was an explosion, and he thought that they would stay in the pit until they were all blown up. He heard no conversation between the manager and Davidson as to flooding the pit. By Mr. Rigg: He was rather nervous while in the pit. By Mr. Helder: There was no compulsion for the men to stay down the mine. The noise he heard, like an explosion, might have been caused by the fall of a roof. Mr. Oswald, in reply to the Coroner, said the Chief Inspector had not yet made his final report to the Home Secretary, and he could not say definitely when he would. The Coroner said as that was the case, and as they had not sufficient evidence to enable them to come to a safe and proper conclusion the inquest had better be adjourned. Mr. Milburn: On behalf of the relatives and friends of the deceased I certainly object to this inquiry being adjourned for an indefinite period. I think there is nothing in this case which prevents you fixing the day on which the inquiry should be resumed. The Coroner: I must stop you, I have made up my mind on the subject, and I carefully pointed out that you have your remedy by applying to the Supreme Court to compel me to proceed with the inquiry. I thought it only right that I should call attention to the Act of Parliament which was passed only last session. After further wrangling between the Coroner and Mr. Milburn, the Coroner said the inquest would be adjourned for an indefinite period, and the jury would be bound over. The Foreman asked what would be the consequence if he refused to be bound over. The Coroner: Possibly we may be able to do without you. (Laughter) The Foreman: That's just what I want to be at, and possibly we may be able to do without you; and it would be a good job, for I am satisfied that the jury is no use with you. The Coroner then bound the jury over to appear when called upon by him, and the proceedings terminated. The Foreman and one of the jury (Mr. Fothergill) refused to be bound ever. The Coroner: You put yourselves in opposition to the rest of the jurymen. The Foreman: What have we got to do with them? There is none of them have my business to look after. You can summon us. The Coroner: It will be at your own peril if you refuse to come. I am sorry you are acting in an antagonistic spirit. I shall take a note of it, and I shall summon you. The Foreman: I don't think we are any use where you are. The inquiry terminated.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||