14th June 1888
The Mining Interests Of Cumberland
Prospective New Industries For The County
By W. Wilson Barnes, M.E., Mealsgate, Carlisle.
Mention was made in an article entitled "Proposed Mid — Cumberland Railway," which appeared in the Colliery Guardian in 1882, of the possible hematite iron ore deposits in the Bolton, Caldbeck, and Ireby parishes, but owing to that
greatest of bugbears — heavy dead rents and tonnage dues — no attempt could be made to prove their existence. But for these, ample capital would have been forthcoming to try for hematite iron ores in the carboniferous limestone, as also for
other oxides in the older rocks eastward. It is not proposed here to discuss the principles of mining dead rents and royalty dues, but undoubtedly they are to no slight extent responsible for the depression which has prevailed for several years past.
Outcry has again and again been raised, and recently Mr. O. M. Percy has ably exposed these irregularities. There cannot surely be much question that the present system is altogether indefensible.
From personal observations, and after trying at considerable trouble to get some fairly correct information as to the present working mines of Cleator, Egremont, Frizington, Lamplugh, Millom, and the Barrow in Furness districts, conclusions are that
there is at the present rate of demand sufficient ore to keep going for several years to come. The costs of raising are, however, greater on account of the ore nearer the surface being exhausted, or comparatively so, and the heavier watering, owing to
extraction and the tonnage brought to bank, and represents, in many instances, a gathering up of fragments, or "robbery ore," as it is termed. There does not seem to be anything to indicate that should a materially increased tonnage be
demanded it would be supplied at other than a considerably higher price. The older and more celebrated mines have been deepened, some until the slate has been reached, and new bodies of ore have been obtained — sparingly, however, in many cases.
As the older mines about Cleator are working out, the comparatively new field of Egremont is developing most promisingly. Some thirty years or so ago a borehole was put down near the village of Egremont — to the north—east — and ore
touched, but owing to dispute as to ownership of minerals the work was given up, and for many years no other attempt was made. Later a royalty was bored unsuccessfully, and the district came to be regarded as not likely to yield ores. The contrary is,
however, the case, and the very royalty that was hawked about the county, and refused repeatedly, is now turning out some 400 tons per day of the richest ore, and is capable of maintaining the output for years to come. Near Beckermont, about three miles
to the south, holes have been put down and the relative positions of the slates, limestone, and coal measures are favourable to possible depositions. In the Millom district the well known Hodbarrow mines have turned out an immense tonnage and the
company are "in sight," by borehole and drivings in new ground along the foreshore, of some 5,000,000 tons. An original £100 share of the Company was sold a few months ago for £8,500. The Company now find it necessary to pursue
their workings under the sea in the estuary of the river Duddon, a very rapid tidal river. To do this it is necessary to build, at an expense of £175,000, a sea wall to reclaim the foreshore. To the west and north of Hodbarrow several royalties
have, a little time ago, been secured. Some portions near the north foreshore have been bored, but with no result. Other holes are now being started; the Whicham Mining Company — the most northerly working in the Millom neighbourhood — are
finding their pits more costly to work on account of being heavily watered. The deposits are large. Similar accounts have been received from Barrow in Furness, Dalton in Furness, Stank, and Urswick, situated to the north east of Barrow.
Ennerdale, Eskdale, Borrowdale, Dunnerdale in the slate and other older formations have not yielded, excepting in one instance (Knockmurton Mines), ores workable for any length of time.
It must be admitted that boreholes in recognised fields have, on the whole, been disappointing. The question then arises, is there in Cumberland or North Lancashire any new untried field presenting reasonable hope of hematite iron ore? An object of
this paper is to draw attention to such a line of country, not only for deposits of hematite iron ores but also for ferromanganese, umber, ochres, sulphur, barytes, china clay, granites, etc.
While working a sulphur—barytes mining set in the parish of Ireby frequent explorations have been made through Bolton, Ireby, Uldale, Caldbeck, and the neighbouring parishes, and the conclusion arrived at is that, given fair and reasonable terms,
rents, and tonnage dues, and facility of transit by means of a railway, there is in all probability a new and very valuable field of hematite iron and other ores. Taking Curthwaite (north), along the plain of the "Chalk Beck," by Waverhead,
skirting Thistlebottom, by Catlands Hill, Newbiggin Grange, and some distance east of Bothel, turn and run the eye by Threapland, Bothel Cragge, High Ireby, Ruthwaite, directly cross the River Ehen, to Uldale, by Longlands, about Intack, through
Caldbeck, Hesket, Newmarket, and for some considerable distance south east there is the mountain limestone of an area much greater than the Cleator district. The limestone is of fine quality, free and open, exhibiting in numerous instances hematite iron
ore. In crevices in the old quarries are washers and "strings" of ore which have also turned up when cutting foundations in the stone. Although no mining trial has been made, considering the geological position, the existence of a new field
of hematite iron ore seems more than possible.
Of the unwrought coal, taking a rough estimate, there will not be less than some 2,500,000, a considerable proportion of which could be drained and wrought by levels. Hitherto, dead rents and tonnage dues and arbitrary terms have stood in the way of
developing the district, especially in the direction of new railway enterprise. It remains to be seen whether the lords of the manors will still block the way.
Not only for railway, but for every constructive purpose, steel seems to be taking the place of iron, and in view of the increasing make of spiegel and Bessemer steel manganiferous ores will be in increased demand. In several of the lead and copper
mines of the Lake District ores of manganese in small quantities have been brought to surface. It is not, however, to the small strings or sops of manganese ores found in the old lead workings that we direct notice, but to what may, for the sake of
distinction, be called true manganic ore lodes or veins, veins not associated with lead and copper. More particularly in the chiastolite slates and spotted schists are several distinct lodes, and near the veins the rocks are remarkable for their rich
and varied colouring, due in all probability to the existence of ores of manganese.
It may be mentioned that lead and copper mining in Cumberland has been chiefly in the greenstones and Skiddaw slates, and scarcely anything in the carboniferous formations. During the years 1876-77, 1880-81, permission was given by the late Sir George
Denys, Bart., to do any work desired upon any supposed manganese ore veins that were in his royalties, excepting the sets held by the Caldbeck Fells Mining Company, whose mining was confined to lead and copper only, though all minerals were included in
the lease. The results of many trenchings, shallow sinkings, adit drivings &c., proved that several veins, from 4ft up to 17ft wide — and in one instance 23ft wide from cheek to cheek — exist, and strings and other indications were got
that, if followed up, might lead to material deposits. The majority of such veins are more or less associated with numbers and ochres.
True manganiferous ore veins exist, and are altogether distinct from lead and copper. About 350 to 400 tons were brought to light, but owing to position and other conditions, it was impossible to get the ore on rail. Samplings were, however, pronounced
favourable, and offers were made to take a quantity. Analyses of several samples tested for manganese alone gave from 45 per cent up to (In picked samples) 78.30 per cent. and in one 82.75 per cent. An average sample from each vein was carefully
taken. The test gave 64.20 per cent. manganese, and 2.51 per cent. iron, with phosphoric acid from as low as .04 to 1.70, silica as low as 1.25 to 5.63 per cent. It must, however, be remembered that the ore in nearly every case was from what is
comparatively surface. Ferro—manganese had not before 1876 been known in Cumberland in distinct workable deposits, and the other oxides of manganese gave higher analysis than any before tested. Silver was found in the specimens of pyrolusite.
The quantity was not determined, but according to the report of a firm dealing extensively in all merchantable manganese ores, and makers of the manufactured metal, there was in the picked samples of ore sent them sufficient of both silver and gold to be
well worth the cost of separate treatment for extraction. Umbers and ochres associated with the manganese were upon testing found to be of high metallic base and worth.
Analyses made give evidence of the existence in the ores of lime, magnesia, phosphoric acid, and nickel. Ochres intermixed and indistinct ribs were found, and samplings compare well with Welsh and Cornish ochres. Sulph, barytes is also found freely in
several strong lodes from 45 to 18 feet wide. The colour at the surface in several cases is "off," but even the poorest qualities were sold at 23s 6d to 28s, delivered Newcastle, allowing good profit. There is a quantity of sulphur barytes in
many of the mountain ranges, particularly the Skiddaw slates, but only some three attempts have been made to work the mining, bleaching manufacturing trades generally being unknown in Cumberland.
Cobals and nickel ores were mined for about fifty years ago, but are now closed.
Sulphide of antimony was wrought about 1820, but only to a limited extent, and disputes as to lordship and terms required have prevented a firm consuming largely re—opening a property that is very favourably situated, giving an ore of nearly pure
sulphide of antimony up to 54.10 per cent. "Jamesonite" has been come upon, but prices are low, and coats of separation do not admit of profitable work.
Felspar has been found in situ, and not washed and re—deposited. Analyses were as follows :— From the level nearer surface, somewhat yellowish in colour from past water drainage and umber — silica, 74.20; alumina, 13.31; lime,
magnesia, iron, manganese found, but not determined (the two last named would come from the umber wash). Another sample from a sump in the mass gave — silica, 54.76; alumina, 29.18. Lime, magnesia, iron, manganese found, but not determined; iron
and manganese very slight. Since first exploring — now over twelve years ago — repeated ramblings and examinations have strengthened, first impression, that though the proverb that affirms.
Caldbeck and Caldbeck Fells.
Are worth all England else,
can hardly be supported, yet there is a bright future for the more easterly and southern sections of the county. These views may be thought too sanguine. If, however, it is remembered that not more than three or four of the lead or copper mines over
the area have been thoroughly tested, and that the trials for minerals other than for hematite ores and coal have generally been conducted by men comparatively without chemical, engineering, or geological knowledge, and without proper capital or
machinery for a thorough examination, the prospects ought not to be set aside as visionary. After explaining the position a firm, at the writer's instigation, secured several thousand acres, under which is sulphur—barytes, umbers, ochres,
manganese, felspar, variety of granites, lead, copper. Mills, are at present being put down for treatment of umbers, ochres, barytes, and it is the opinion of experts that such native oxides will at no distant date lead to the construction of a railway
through the district. Mica, schist, which, according to American advices, forms a lining for Bessemer converters far in advance of that commonly used, is abundant, and could be cheaply quarried — varied sandstones and several granite rocks await
cheap transit by railway. No paint or colour works of note are nearer than Newcastle on Tyne (east), Glasgow (north), Liverpool (south). The wet dock and position of Maryport generally offers every facility for shipment, and raw material is at hand.
It does not seem too sanguine, therefore, to believe that ultimately Cumberland will compete in paint, colour, chemical, and possibly pottery and tile manufacturers. — Colliery Guardian.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Barnes, W. Wilson | | Mining Engineer | |
| Denys, George, Sir | | | |
| Percy, O. M. | | | |