|
7th June 1888 CorrespondenceThe Workington Disaster(To the Editor of the Cumberland Pacquet) Sir, — A scribe, evidently having an animus against the St. Helens Colliery Company, falls foul, in the last issue of your Cockermouth contemporary, of the article bearing upon the Workington disaster which appeared in last weeks Pacquet. As you may not notice the remarks of an anonymous writer, and I think they should be noticed, perhaps you will kindly allow me to reply to them. "Z" for .so he styles himself, is desirous of a repetition of the farce which was enacted in the Green Dragon Assembly Room last month. The inquest upon, the unfortunate men who lost their lives in the terrible disaster at St. Helens on the 19th of April last took no fewer than six days to complete. Everybody (except, of course, people like "Z" and those jurymen who wish to shine), is of opinion that the proceedings could, with advantage to all parties, have been greatly curtailed. Yet "Z" wishes Mr. Webster and his jury to begin de noro to-morrow (Thursday), and to have another six days inquiry. At may be that "Z" is a juror, and wants an opportunity of displaying his forensic knowledge and eloquence. But most people cannot see what will he gained by a second coroner's inquest. "Z" would like people to believe that if Mr. Webster and his Court do not hold an investigation, similar in character, and, length to that held by Mr. Lumb, the whole facts relating to the sad affair will not be brought to light. I may be wrong, but I entertain the opinion that a coroner's jury is not competent to make a proper inquiry into the cause of a colliery accident or explosion, or to pronounce whether the colliery manager has done his duty or not. We all know that a coroner's jury at a colliery case is composed — for I only take the trades as an illustration — of butcher, tailors, shoemakers, &c. — of everybody and anybody except coal miners; and it is absurd to suppose that in the course of a few days a jury so composted can acquire sufficient knowledge to enable it to form a proper judgment as to the conduct of men who have had a life-long experience of coal mining. Besides, the Legislature has provided a more efficient means of inquiry into mining accidents of all kinds. First of all, there are Government inspectors of mines; and those appointed for this district have inspected the St. Helens Colliery, and have been assisted at the recent inquest by counsel sent down by the Home Office. Mr. Willis, the chief inspector for this district, will in due course have to make a report to the Home Secretary; and there is not the slightest doubt, if he has discovered any evidence of negligence, that he will report accordingly. Thereupon, a proper investigation will he instituted by the Government, who will appoint a competent person, assisted by professional assessors, to conduct it. Therefore, I agree with you, considering there is proper provision made for further inquiry, if necessary, after the coroners inquest, that it is needless to repeat all the evidence adduced before Mr. Lumb over again before Mr. Webster. Clark and Beaty might be examined.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||