|
31st May 1888 St. Helens Colliery DisasterVerdict Of The JuryOn Saturday morning the seventh sitting of the jury on the St. Helens Colliery disaster was held. When the jury were called four of them did not answer to their names. Mr. G. H. Liddell, Moresby Hall, was called. He said he had been viewer of the Whitehaven Collieries for eleven years. In 1873 he was assistant-inspector of mines in this district. He heard of the pit being on fire from Mr. McGowan, of Whitehaven, whom he accidentally met. It was nearly eight o'clock when he arrived at the colliery. They were discussing the plans in the office when they heard a loud report. Subsequently they examined the fan, which was in good condition, but the return air was foul. He then related his experiences on descending the pit, and the nature of the explorations undertaken by himself and others — facts with which the public are all familiar. After the explosion occurred it would not have been wise to have attempted to restore the ventilation. With regard to the number of men employed, he gave no opinion, excepting to say that it was advisable the work should be done as speedily as possible. By Mr. Woodfall: The object of the stoppings was to convert the return drift into an intake. He would not under the circumstances have abandoned the mines. Speed in carrying on the work was the essence of success. Would the gas accumulate in such quantities to explode when the air was restored? That is a problematical question, and not easy to answer. — What do you suggest caused the explosion? I should say the fire extended to such an extent as to come in contact with the fire damp and thus cause the explosion. By Mr. Milburn: The curious thing was that the men were so much injured and the pit so little damaged. No doubt this was due to the newness of the pit. There was danger in the afternoon, but not great danger. The men might had run away for a trifling thing. He should not have expected danger at that time. — Suppose you had known that the pit was on fire on Saturday and that a shot firer was exhausted in trying to put out the fire, what would you have said then about it? The shot firer would have to be guided by the condition of the place at the time he fired the shot. — Was it a proper thing to fire a shot in the same place afterwards? As I said before, it all depended on the condition of the working at the time the shot was fired. — Were all the bodies in the shaft side of the stoppings? Yes. — Would it in your opinion have been dangerous to the property to have ventilated so far? Yes, it would, and to life also. Mr. Woodfall: What was the extent of the explosion? It had gone right to the shaft. A piece of electric wire near there had become twisted from being blown down round one of the men. By Mr. Helder: The reports showed on that morning that the place was safe for shot firing. I should not have expected an explosion, from what I have heard, at any time during that day. Morrison, re-called, was asked by Mr. Helder, whether it was the duty of Tunstall to give him notice of the supposed fire of coal on the Saturday. He replied that Tunstall should have entered the report in his report book. — Did he do so? No, and he never reported to me. Mr. Milburn: Were you in Hogg's Brow on that Saturday? Yes. — And examined the place? Yes. — Very well, that is enough for me. Thomas Dacres, manager to the Dearham Collieries, was next called, and said he had been a manager for thirty years. He had had experience of three "standing fires" in the district of Durham. From the evidence given, he thought Mr. Johnson had adopted the proper course to isolate the fire. Mr. Sempill, Maryport, manager of the Crosby Collieries, was of opinion that everything possible was done after the explosion occurred. He agreed with Mr. Liddell as to the course the air would take. Mr. Oswald, sub-inspector of mines, was interrogated by the Coroner as to whether he should give evidence. — In reply, Mr. Willis said they seemed to be in the position. They had to report upon this disaster, and that appeared to him to be the proper time when they should give their opinion. That report of course became a public document. In an inquiry of this sort it behoved them to be cautious and careful, and if the jury were satisfied that there was sufficient evidence to come to a conclusion, so far as he was concerned he would rather say that they would like to be excused. At the request of the Coroner, the room was cleared for a quarter of an hour in order to allow a consultative to take place between himself and the jury, after which the Coroner stated that sufficient scientific evidence had been given. Another short adjournment having taken place, the Coroner proceeded to sum up at twelve o'clock. — After three hours' deliberation the court resumed at ten minutes to four o'clock. — In answer to the Coroner, the Foreman said they had agreed upon their verdict. — The Coroner said perhaps it would be convenient to answer the questions as they had been put. — The questions were therefore put and answered as follows: — What were the respective cause of deaths of James Smith and others employed at the St. Helens Colliery on the 19th April? Were their deaths attributable directly to the explosion that took place there on that day? We find that the deaths were caused directly through the explosion. — In what part of the mine did the explosion occur? In Hogg's Brow, No. 3 district, William Pit No. 3, St. Helens Colliery. — Was it an explosion of fire-damp or marsh gas? — It was an explosion of fire-damp or marsh gas. — Were the means adopted for dealing with the fire suitable and proper under the circumstances? We find so. — Was the number of men kept in the pit for dealing with the fire excessive? On this question we cannot agree. — Was the explosion accidental or not? It was accidental. — Was the presence of standing gas or excess of coal dust known prior to the explosion to any of the managers of the colliery? No, not according to the evidence. — Was any blame attributable to any one in the management? And if so, to who? and was such blame culpable or negligent? We think not. — The Coroner: Gentleman, that is a verdict of "Accidental death." Is that the verdict of all of you? — The Foreman: It is. — The jury verified their verdict, and the court room at 3.55.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||