|
24th May 1888 The St. Helens Colliery DisasterThe Inquest Before Mr. LumbOn Thursday morning, at the Green Dragon Hotel, Workington, the adjourned inquest on the bodies of 15 of the men killed in the explosion at St. Helens Colliery on Thursday, April 19th, and whose names follow below, was resumed by Mr. W. W. Lumb, of Whitehaven, coroner for West Cumberland. The following are the names of the eleven who were brought to the pit bank on the night of the explosion :–
The names of the two that were recovered from the pit on the 30th April are :–
Those recovered on Tuesday last were :–
The following were sworn on the jury :– John Henry Howe, draper (foreman); Thomas Bates, innkeeper; James McAleese, draper; David Clark, tea dealer; Robert Adair, draper; William Carruthers, chemist; William Lowes, boot dealer; John Towerson Cuthbertson, innkeeper; Henry Graham, butcher; John Bouch, tailor and draper; Henry McAleer, boot and shoe dealer; William Irving, corn merchant; John Wilkinson, draper; Robert Metcalfe, grocer; James Spedding, baker; John Milfield Dunn, draper; Christopher Robinson, clogger; William Steel, grocer; James Newton, coachman; John Lawson Yeowart, draper; James Ellwood, saddler; John Twentyman, caretaker, Workington. The Government officials present were Mr. Willis, Chief Inspector of Mines, Newcastle; Mr. J. B. Atkinson, Government Sub-Inspector of Mines, Newcastle; and Mr. R. P. W. Oswald, Government Inspector of Mines for the Cumberland district. The leading officials and colliery managers present were : Mr. J. C. Croudace, Hollywell, North Wales, agent for the colliery company; Mr. G. H. Liddell, resident viewer for Lord Lonsdale's collieries, Whitehaven, and temporary viewer and consulting engineer for the St. Helens Colliery; Mr. John Holliday Johnston, manager of the St. Helens Colliery; Mr. Atkinson, manager of the Ellenborough Colliery; Mr. J. Sempill, manager of the Gilcrux and Crosby Colliery; Mr. T. Dacres, manager of the Dearham Colliery; Mr. William Mulcaster, colliery manager, Maryport; Mr. William Johnston, manager of the Aspatria Colliery; Mr. Joseph Mulcaster, Mr. Harker, Mr. W. W. Mulcaster, Mr. R. W. Moore, and Mr. B. Cowie, Whitehaven; Mr. James Mulcaster, secretary; and Dr. W. H. Spurgin, medical officer to the St. Helens Colliery Company. The following solicitors were present :– Mr. Woodfall (barrister) appeared for the Crown, and was instructed by Mr. Willis; Mr. T. Rigg, Wigton, appeared for Mr. Johnston, the manager; Mr. L. T. Helder, Whitehaven, appeared for the St. Helens Colliery Company; Mr. T. Milburn, Workington, appeared for the West Cumberland Miners' Association and the relatives of the deceased, and was instructed by Mr. A. Sharp, Maryport, miners' agent; and Mr. W. Paisley, Workington, appeared for the Employers' Liability Assurance Company. The directors of the company present were :– Mr. A. Helder, Whitehaven; Mr. W. McGowan, Whitehaven; Mr. P. Wedgwood, Flimby; Mr. H. P. Senhouse, The Fitz; and Mr. T. Carey, Maryport. The first witness called was John Holliday Johnson, Church-street, Workington, who deposed: I have been for seven years manager of the St. Helens Colliery. I was there on the morning of the 19th of April last. I produce the plans of the colliery. Between nine and half-past nine that morning there were 160 men at work in the main band seam. About that time a message came to say that a shot had been fired and lit a feeder of gas. I did not see the gas blower myself. I could not get through to where the fire was for smoke. The particular working where the shot was fired had been examined that morning, I believe, by a deputy inspector. The place where the shot was fired was about 1,200 yards from the bottom of the shaft. An attempt was made to put out the fire by means of stoppings at various points. We continued putting in the stoppings. All those stoppings were completed except the third one. When the third one was being completed we turned the air. The temporary stoppings were of wood and canvas. A message came to me that Mr. Liddell, of Whitehaven, had arrived at the pit top. I went up the shaft to see him, and while I was there the explosion occurred. As near as I can tell, it would then be about nine o'clock. I had perhaps been up the pit about a quarter of an hour. When the explosion occurred there were 35 men in the pit. I first went to see if the cage was all right, and we drew it up. We found Joseph Robinson in it. He was taken to the Workington Infirmary, and died there. About half-an-hour after the explosion Mr. Liddell, Mr. Oswald, myself, and others went down the pit. At the bottom of the shaft I found Morrison, who was alive, and was sent up to the top. Witness described where several of the dead were found. He stated that he afterwards went down the main dip, nearer the bottom, which was about 800 yards from the shaft. There he saw several dead bodies. He was then "gassed," and became insensible. Mr. John Davidson was the under manager under me. Mr. Morrison was the overman. Davidson is dead, but Morrison is alive. — W. J. Beattie was the man who fired the shot in the morning. Beattie was authorised to fire the shot. Beattie tried to put out the fire before he sent me a message about the fire. The place where the shot was fired is called Hogg's Brow. The report book was produced, and the Coroner read the entry, signed by W. J. Beattie, which stated that the ventilation was good and the working place safe at four a.m. Mr. Woodfall: That was four hours before the shot was fired? — Witness: Yes. — Would you say that the regulations had been complied with if the place was examined four hours before the shot was fired? Yes, I know it was the regular custom for the shot firer to examine any place before a shot was fired. To my knowledge Beattie had been shot firer for over seven years. — I want to know what authority you have for saying that an inspection was made before the shot was fired? I can only say that it was the general custom of the mine, and according to the general rules. — What sort of place was this working? It was a wet place. Its sectional area would be eight feet by six feet. The coal was damp, more or less. We had about 150 gallons of water to take out of the place in the 24 hours. All the coal dust in that particular working was in a wet condition. So far as I know, we have had no previous fires from the firing of shots. I don't know that the working had been subject to blowers. I know there were feeders of gas. I should call the one that caused the fire a blower. A blower is a more voluminous feeder. They are both of the same character. There had been small feeders in that working. The explosive used in the mine was compressed blasting powder. The storekeeper (Skelton Holliday) would be the man who gave out the powder. It would be kept in a canister in the pit. The men are only supposed to take 5lbs. of gunpowder at once. Mr. Woodfall: What was the effect of the explosion in other parts of the mine? It was not very severe. Some of the doors were blown to pieces. — What, in your opinion, was the seat of the explosion? I could not say. I believe the force of the explosion came from, the return drift. — Therefore, it would almost follow that the explosion came from Hogg's Brow? — Yes. There have been feeders of gas in Hogg's Brow. — Would you consider that a dangerous part to fire a shot? It would depend upon the extent of the feeder. I did not consider it so dangerous that I should withdraw the men before firing a shot. After the fire occurred there were 35 men employed in work connected with its extinction. — How were these 35 men distributed? They were working very hard, and could not stand long near the fire. They worked in "spells," and changed with one another. — What I want to get is, why were 35 men kept down? We wanted to get the fire out as quickly as possible. The men had to "spell" one another. The stopping at "B" was brick and mortar. I have heard of no explosion that took place while the stoppings were being made during the day. — What, in your opinion, was the cause of the accident? I cannot tell that. —You know by the Act you are required to give information of an explosion, when one occurs, to the inspector of the district. Although that is now authorised to be done in an informal way, the manager used to be required to specify the character of the accident. I ask you, as manager of the mine, what, to the best of your judgment, was the character of the explosion? Witness (after a pause): It was an explosion of fire-damp. In reply to Mr. Helder, witness said: I have no reason to suppose that Beattie would not go through the ordinary course of examining the working before the shot was fired. I have always found him an experienced shot firer. Compressed blasting powder is the only blasting powder used in the pits in this district. Examined by Mr. Milburn, witness said: On the 18th of April I had a report of the presence of gas in the workings of John Ditchburn and John Hinde. In consequence of that report I withdrew the men. Davidson and I consulted, and concluded that the best thing was to wall the fire off. — Mr. Millburn: Would that effect of that not be to wall in any gas that might be accumulating or standing? Witness: Yes; and the gas would rise to the fire. — When gas got to the fire what would happen? There would be an explosion. We did not succeed in walling up the point "D". I know that this district of the pit has made gas ever since it was opened out. — Is it not a fact that you have paid men extra for taking away the "juds" in the district? Not to my knowledge. The shot firer had written authority. He had orders not to fire any shots where there was the presence of gas. Were any other shots fired in any other part of the district during the day? Yes. Some of them were fired before and some after the men went out of the pit. This happened in cases where they were working the double shift. At the consultation with Mr. Wedgewood I told him the pit was on fire and pointed out the position on the plans. I told him that it had been caused by a shot and a feeder of gas. I did not tell him anything else. When I came up to the surface at half-past eleven, I gave notice in the office of what had happened, and Mr. Croudace was telegraphed for to come at once. I returned down the pit and went back to the fire, where I remained till about two o'clock, and then came up again to the surface and had the interview with Mr. Wedgwood. It lasted about a quarter of an hour and the decision was to divert the air and try to get a stopping into the return dip. We were preparing to put in this stopping when the explosion took place, and so work was actually done there. The intention was to cut the fire off from the other sections and the stopping was built more than 800 yards away from the rest of the fire. I was going to remove the men to the other section if the explosion had not taken place. In consultation we talked about flooding the pit after we had put in the stopping which was never completed. — Do you mean to say that the stoppings put into this part of the pit were sufficient to withstand the flooding? — We were not wanting them to withstand the flooding. — You were going to put water in? The water would never have gone near them at all. At this point Dr. Dudgeon, Workington, entered the room, and the Coroner proposed to take his evidence. The doctor said he had attended William John Beaty, who was at present in Workington Infirmary, suffering from the injuries received in St. Helen's Colliery explosion. He was not fit to give any evidence in this Court, nor was he in a condition to have his evidence taken. It was quite impossible to say when he would be able to give evidence. He was suffering both mentally and physically. He had been burned about the head, gassed, and since he had recovered consciousness he had lost his memory entirely. Mr. Woodfall: Can you name any time when he will be fit to appear, mentally? No, I could not. It would be impossible to say. — The Coroner said that being so, he would have great hesitation in taking his deposition. — In answer to Mr. Milburn, Dr. Dudgeon said be had seen the patient yesterday, and he was mentally in much the same condition. Physically, of course, he was a great deal better. After the explosion he was unconscious for many days, and recovered consciousness within the first ten days. If anything, Beattie was mentally a little better. His mind, however, was still affected.
Mr. Milburn then proceeded with his cross-examination of Mr. J. S. Smith, one of the jurymen, said he did not think it was right that the shareholders and others interested in the colliery, and who were represented, should sit amongst them whilst the evidence of workmen was being given. They ought to have no intimidation while workmen were giving evidence as to this inquiry. — Mr. Helder: I must say that observation has been very uncalled for. I have not seen any interference with the witnesses so far. — Mr. Smith: Possibly so. You appear on behalf of the Company. There may not be any actual interference as far as the subject is concerned, but still we know, when we have employers sitting by our side, that we cannot, when we have got our bread to win, say many a thing that we would say. — The Coroner: I think it is a fair request, and I must ask those gentlemen who are in any way connected with the colliery, as shareholders, managers, or otherwise, with the exception of Mr. Johnston, to leave the room. — Mr. Helder: I must be instructed by some one, and the gentlemen are enabled by the Act of Parliament to be present. Under section 48 of the Mines Regulation Act, it is provided that any relative of any person whose death may have been caused by an explosion, the owner, agent, or manager, can be present either in person or by counsel. — The Coroner: Yes, but after that I must say the other persons must go out of the room. — Mr. Senhouse, The Fitz, said if the Coroner decided that he as an owner had no right to be there he would retire. — Mr. Helder: The Act of Parliament says you are entitled to be present. — Mr. said that he as another of the owners would be glad to withdraw if it was the wish of the Coroner. — After some further discussion, at the request of the Coroner several of the owners of the colliery and witnesses retired from the room. Joseph Morrison, Flimby, back overman, said: I have worked at St. Helen's Colliery for 7½ years. I went to the colliery at six o'clock on the morning of the 19th April. I was in the pit when the shot was fired in James Hogg's working. It was fired by William James Beaty. The working was examined previous to the shot being fired. The air courses were in very good condition. The mine in that particular district is well laid out. I heard Hodgson tell Davidson, about ten o'clock, that a shot had been fired and could not be put out. Davidson went to the fire, and I was told to get some water, which I did. Afterwards I saw Davidson holding two lamps, while a couple of men were cutting a place to stop the fire. He told me to hold the lamps for these men, which I did. Davidson went away, and shortly afterwards came back and told me to get all the men out of the districts. There would be about 100 men altogether. After these districts were cleared of men, I was sent to close four regulators, which I did. While at Gilmour's Brow I met some one running down, and they said that there had been a slight explosion. That might be about half-past one o'clock. William Tunstall told me that it was not an explosion, it was a fall. Shortly after eight o'clock at night there was another explosion. I was on the south level at the time. — Can you say what was the cause of the explosion? I cannot tell that; firedamp likely. John Davidson told me the men were to remain where they were, and I was told to go and open the regulators which had been closed in the afternoon. I altered one of them, and was on my way to the second when the explosion took place. I was one that escaped uninjured from the explosion. I had not the least idea that any explosion was likely to take place. The 35 men who were put into the pit were experienced men. — Was the pit of a dangerous or fiery character? Not particularly. I ran to the shaft as quickly as I could, and while I was talking to Wright, John Pearson, who evidently was becoming unconscious, began shouting to me. I shouted to him to remain where he was until I came back, but he got to the shaft as soon as I. I went to signal for the cage to go up. Examined by Mr. Helder: I have known Davidson for a long time, and he is an experienced man. I have never been in an explosion before. There was no compulsion for these 35 men to say in the pit. There was not one of them but was necessarily employed. Examined by Mr. Woodfall: Beattie said to me that he thought the shot he had fired had not thrown down the coal. — So that the gas must have been going out at the time that the shot was fired? Well, I could not say that. — Did you know of a previous explosion in Gilmour's working? No. I did not know that Beattie was going to fire a shot. — Would it not be his duty to report that he was going to fire it? No, sir. At the time of the explosion my impression was that there had been a fall. — Have you any idea that the explosion took place in Hogg's Brow. I have no idea whatever. William John Beattie, who fired the shot, was the man who made the Inspection of that part of the mine before the shot was fired. Mr. Oswald found Beattie after the explosion down the back drift. Examined by Mr. Milburn: I cannot say who it was that told me there had been an explosion while I was going up Gilmour's Brow. I had previously met some men, the only one that is alive now being James Southern. I did not ask any of the men to turn back and go with me. — Was the pit cleared of the men and boys for any particular purpose? I was told to clear the districts by John Davidson, so I went. He gave me no reason for this, and I did not ask him. It is not usual to do this in this pit. — Perhaps you knew why? I understood it was in consequence of the fire. That was my own opinion. — Do you think at that time that it was right to clear out the place? Yes, if he thought there was any danger of the fire. — You have said that that is your own opinion? But I was obeying orders. I did not go through any of the workings in the neighbourhood of Gilmour's Brow, but kept to the main road. I found no symptoms of gas beyond that already burning. I know Ditchburn's end was stopped on account of strong feeders in it. It was getting too far advanced for those above it. Ditchburn had left his working nearly a fortnight before the 18th April. — Is there to your knowledge any place in the neighbourhood of the stoppings containing standing gas? No, I am not aware of it. — Gas is pretty often seen in that neighbourhood? No, it is not. — Mr. Milburn read several quotations from one of the colliery books, showing that on several occasions from March 19th up to the 18th April gas had been seen in different workings, and the men withdrawn. — Witness explained that they were only withdrawn for a short time in the morning when gas was seen, and the men were kept out of the place until it was made right by bratticing. With regard to the question of the flooding of the mine, no preparations were made beyond the stopping for flooding the mine. — Have you heard of a fire from shots in this district before. No, never. Dr. Spurgin, Maryport, doctor for the Flimby side of the St. Helen's Colliery Company, was then called, and the Coroner asked the jury whether they had any questions to ask the doctor. — Mr. Smith: Was the body of William Peile, that was not scorched, examined by you? Yes, I examined it superficially, but made no post-mortem examination. — What do you suppose was the cause of death? He was killed by the explosion. — How would you account for the body being in such a perfect state, then, when every other one came up literally charred? Became the fire missed him. — He would choke? Yes, suffocation or asphyxia. — Yes; but what I thought you meant was that he was in the current of the explosion? I think most probably he was in the force of the explosion. — But it is so curious that his body should have been in such a perfect state? He was injured on the head and the body was in a very decomposed state. He must have been dead for some very considerable time. — The Court then adjourned at 6.20 to meet again on Friday morning at 10.30. The inquiry was resumed on Friday morning, at the Green Dragon Hotel, before Mr. W. W. Lumb. The legal gentlemen present on the previous day were again in attendance. Mr. Lightfoot, Maryport, solicitor, appeared on behalf, of the relatives of Gaskin and Martin, two of the men killed. Mr. Woodfall asked that the manager should be recalled, and Mr. Johnston, in reply to questions, stated the shot was fired about eight, and the place was examined about four o'clock. He would not think the examination at four o'clock a proper examination for a shot to be fired at eight. An examination was made before any shot was fired, immediately before it; but it was not necessary to report these examinations in the book. He could not say without reference to the book which deputy was on duty at the place at the time the shot was fired. — Who was on duty at nine o'clock on the night of 18th April? Joseph Stephenson. The ventilation was reported good by him in the book. — How long has the mine been opened? About eight or ten years. — Are both shafts fitted for ingress and egress? — The main shaft has sliding cages to the bottom; the upcast shaft has cages as far as the upper seam. — What is the depth of the main shaft? — 119 fathoms. The remaining portion of the upcast shaft has a wire rope and kibble for lifting the men from the bottom in case of emergency. — What are the diameters of the shafts? — Downcast, 10ft. 8in; upcast, 11ft. 8in. — Were both those shafts in full working order on the 19th April? — Yes. — Witness then detailed from the plan the method of ventilating the mine. — In reply to further questions bearing on the ventilation of the mine, witness said a change was made on the 28th March, but that would not affect the ventilation of the district in which the fire originated. It was done to keep the "robbery" separate from the solid coal. The air was about 7,000 feet more in March than in previous months. On the whole there was an increase quantity of air taken in March, and it was adequate to dilute noxious gas. The air drifts were also used as engine roads and travelling roads. Only one was used as an engine road. Were the mine ways generally free from coal dust? We had dust, but not a great quantity. — It is a more desirable way of working to ventilate by separate splits. Our ventilation is partly by separate splits. If it was worked by separate splits it would entail such expense that the colliery could not be worked? Yes, directly from each shaft. The object of diverting the air was to enable them to put up stoppings.to wall in the fire. The walling of the fire they hoped would cause the fire to die out. — It would also have the result of causing a concentration of gas? Yes. — So that whereas it might have been non-explosive if the air current continued to pass through, the gas would become explosive when concentrated? If the air continued. — If there was no air passing through to dilute the gas, then the gas which would otherwise be harmless, might be explosive? Oh, no. If there was no air on the gas it would not be explosive. — What you did before the explosion did affect the air in No. 3? — Yes. Although the air might have been lessened, yet there was still passing through what was sufficient to dilute the gas. Still the accident must have been caused by gas? Yes. You don't suggest there was an explosion of coal dust? I am of opinion that the coal dust assisted the explosion to a considerable extent. I did not say that the whole of No. 3 was damp; only Hogg's and Gilmour's Brows. The water in the mine now will have altered the whole aspect of things. — The mine was so ventilated that all the working places were safe? Yes. — That you say of your own knowledge and of your own inspection? I did not examine the whole of the workings. By Mr. Smith: The fire was not walled off. I tried to wall off the fire, but it beat us at that point. By the Foreman: I was up the pit when the fall took place at half-past one; it was not an explosion. I was in Gilmour's Brow, close to it. Mr. Milburn: What was the object of diverting the air? To send it in a particular direction to get a stopping put in. If there was gas it would be obliged to go with the air towards the fire. By Mr. Helder: Mr. Oswald had been down the mine several times, and he would be able to see the kind of ventilation. By Mr. Woodfall: The total area of the mine was about 120 acres. Pillar and stall was the mode of working. By Mr. Smith: The water had risen since it was poured in the mine. Gas might account for this. Thomas Wright, a shiftman at St. Helens Colliery, said: I remember the day of the explosion, I went down the pit at six o'clock, and into an end in the same brow that the shot was fired in. I did not know that a shot had been fired till half-an-hour afterwards. Some muck came down. Beattie said a sad job had happened, and he wanted help. I told Wright and Allen, and they went to the place. I was in the pit at two o'clock, and remained till six. We put up a brick stopping at Gilmour's end to turn the fire, I suppose. I was bearing mortar, bricks, and things. The deputy was giving me orders. At six o'clock some of the men were sent up to get something to eat, and the whole of the 35 men went up in relays. Afterwards there was an explosion. — Can you tell us what was the cause of the explosion? No, sir, I could not tell you that. I have been in the employ of the colliery for 35 years. — Had you any reason to think there would be an explosion? No, and I didn't think any of them had; they were all as lively as could be. "If ah hed thowt about it," added the witness, ah wad hev been oot o' theer." — Were the men all experienced? Not all of them; half were. — Do you think the experienced men would have stopped in the pit if they had thought there would have been an explosion? No. A fellow wad hev bin rang in his heed. (Much laughter.) — Seeing you have been a miner for 35 years, cannot you tell us the cause of the accident? Ah hev nowt in me heed, ye know. A deal gah's to sarve theer time, an' they can't put owt intull them, an' ah think I'se yan o' them. (More laughter.) By Mr. Milburn: I went with Morrison to open slides at twenty minutes to eight. I had never been with him before, and I don't know why I had to go. — Mr. Milburn: Was he frightened? No. John Davidson told me to go, and I went. No gas stood in the workings, and the only place that was baddish was Ditchburn's end. That was stopped off, and a danger notice was placed there. This was the only time the feeders had kindled in Hogg's Brow. They were strong feeders. I was in a day or two before, and I heard the gas singing. — Was it a blower? Well, it was making a noise. — Did you tell anybody? Not that I know of. — By the Coroner: Milburn had heard there was a bit of gas, and he went out because he was flay't. He wanted Nicholson to go out, and he would not. — By Mr. Rigg: Whenever men stop working at an end it is usual to rail it off and have it marked "Danger." — By Mr. Milburn: It was always marked off whether dangerous or not. — You said something about a slight explosion. What time was that? It would be about eleven o'clock. — And were was it? Up in Gilmour's Brow. — Did you hear it yourself? Yes. — What did you do then? Well, we hid a bit, and we hed to go down to the dib then. — By Mr. Helder: It was a fire rather than an explosion. — By Mr. Woodfall: The fire in Gilmour's Brow went out again. It wasn't anything hardly — just a flash. Beattie knew there had been this flash. John Pearson, Flimby, mason at the St. Helen's Colliery, said: I was at the colliery on the day of the explosion, and went to work at the brick stopping close to the fire. Robert Clark and Mr. Johnston, the manager, went with me. John Davidson gave directions as to what was to be done, and we commenced the work immediately. We put up the stopping. — Did anything out of the ordinary course take place before eight o'clock? Yes. — What was the first thing? An explosion. — What of? I don't know; gas, I expect. — When? Perhaps between three and four. It was after we put in the brick stopping. — Did you feel any effects from it? No. — Did anything go wrong after that? No. The men with me in the pit did not say anything at the time. The next explosion occurred shortly after eight. — Can you tell us what was the cause? An explosion of gas, I believe. I had no fear of an explosion myself. As far as I know the pit was safe. — By Mr. Woodfall: I am not a miner, and don't know much about these things. I know it was an explosion, because I heard the report. The noise of a fall could not be mistaken for the noise of an explosion. After eight o'clock, when the explosion occurred, I was struck by something. — By Mr. Milburn: I could not distinguish any smell of gas when putting up the stopping. I did not broach any stoppings. When the larger explosion took place I was working under the engine not far from the shaft. — By the Foreman: I was really doing nothing from the time the brick stopping was made until the larger explosion — from two till eight o'clock. — Mr. Milburn: Was Clark engaged in the same occupation? Yes. — Doing nothing? Yes. — By Mr. Woodfall: It would take some time to prepare the place; it was not ready for us. Thomas Bradshaw, Seaton, said: I have been a coalminer for 16 or 17 years, and have been about eight years at the St. Helen's Colliery. I would call William Pit, No. 3, a very safe pit. It was not extra fiery, though it might be called rather fiery. I know the place where the shot was fired — Hogg's Brow — and was there the day before. In the portion where I wrought it was safe enough; there was plenty of fresh air and no gas. It was about 100 yards from the place where the explosion occurred. I came out of the pit about two o'clock the day before the explosion. There were no signs of an approaching explosion where I was, or in any other part of the pit. I was amongst the first that went down after the explosion. Mr. Johnston, Patrick Howdigan, and John Hewetson went down with me in the first cage. The first thing I saw was Morrison, who told me where there was a man lying. Mr. Johnston and I went to him, gave him some brandy, and came up with him. We went down again. I assisted to get three men to the bank. On going down again I relieved Morrison bringing a man up the dip, and came up with that man. I was not enabled after that to make any examination. It might have been possible, but I was not thinking about that. I was thinking of getting the men out. — Can you tell us what was the cause of the explosion? No, I know nothing about the explosion. I left my working because the smoke was too strong to work in. John Milburn, Thomas Sanderson, and David Whitehead came out also. Two shiftmen — George Wright and Thomas Hannah — were repairing the roof, and I asked if they knew what had happened. They said "No," and I told them to go into that end, and tell the men to come out. There were two, and they came out. By Mr. Woodfall: I never saw a naked light used in any part of the mine. — Safety lamps were always used all over the pit. By Mr. Willis: My place was dry, and there was not much dust in it. The deputy always examined the place before the shot was fired, and if it was not safe he would go and leave it. By Mr. Milburn: I can't remember that Milburn said anything except "I'm off," — Sanderson began "yooling," and to twist his face a bit. I did not see anybody running. Have you known gas feeders take fire before? No. This is the first time. Mr. Smith (a juror): Was there any interference by the colliery officials as to going down the pit after the explosion, in any way, so as to get the bodies out? No. — Mr. Smith: The reason why I ask is to contradict, if possible, the statement made in a letter by Milburn to the newspapers, who said that the whole of the bodies could have been got out if it had not been for the interference of the colliery officials. The Coroner: Were you or anybody prevented from getting the bodies out? No. — was it possible to have got them out? Was all done that could be done? It was not possible for human man to have done more than what was done. Mr. Smith: I think that letter of Milburn's was most scurrilous, and a libel on the whole of the people who were assisting to get the bodies out. The Coroner: I think he has given a capital answer to the question. Joseph Labouren, Seaton, said: I am a coalminer, and have been a miner for 30 years. I have worked at St. Helen's colliery for about eight years. I went to work on the morning of the explosion at about half past five. I was working about half-way down the engine dip. Nothing happened that I knew of till the fire broke out from the shot. I did not stay, nor was I sent home. I asked John Nicholson to come home with me; but I had no reason for doing so. I did not know whether the pit was safe or not. Nobody came to clear me out before my time. The reason why I went home was because I was not asked to stay, and my shift was over. John Sowerby, Wyndham-row, coalminer, was examined. He said: I have been a coalminer for 20 years. I worked at St. Helens for eleven days previous to the explosion. I should have gone to work at one o'clock, but I was turned by men coming from the pit who said that the pit had fired. I went back again about half-past nine, and went down in the second cage after the explosion. I found a man dead, and helped to bring him up. The second time I assisted in bringing up Robert Hodgson, of Flimby. Eleven bodies were got up that night. Everything was done to get the remaining bodies up that could be done. I do not know of the explosion, as I was not there. The manager was gassed in recovering the bodies. We were stopping at two bodies down the dip when they fetched us away. I felt no gas, but I am not used to it. We certainly all tried to get out any that were living. Mr. Smith: Would you have been ready to venture down again to fetch up these bodies? Yes. The Coroner: Do you think it would have been safe to have gone? I don't know, sir, but I would have gone down. Mr. Helder: But you knew that men had been gassed in recovering the bodies? Yes. By Mr. McAleese: Were the two bodies you saw dead? I think so. Robert Jackson, Flimby, was next examined. He said: I have been a coalminer for 40 years, and had worked at William Pit No. 3 for about eighteen months altogether. I went into the pit early on the morning of the explosion and came out between twelve and one I was ordered out, because a man said there was fire in the dip. The man was Thompson Moore. I heard nothing unusual myself that morning. I saw no flash nor any fall. I did not know that anything had taken place. I was not one of the persons to go down immediately after the explosion. I went down about half-past ten. Everything was done to get the bodies up which could be done. It would not have been prudent to have attempted anything more because the after damp was getting so strong. I can give no cause for the explosion. I know nothing about it. Mr. Woodfall: Do you know anything about Gilmore's Brow or Hogg's Brow? No, I never was there. Then you went out of the pit because you were ordered out? Yes. The Coroner: Now, Mr. Liddell. Mr. Milburn said that before calling the scientific evidence at that stage of the inquiry it would be as well if they had a little more evidence as to facts. He was of opinion that it was desirable, in the interests of those he was there to represent, that the scientific evidence should not be called at the present stage of the inquiry. If there was any other evidence as to the facts and circumstances to put before the Court, he submitted that it would be as well to defer taking that of the scientific witnesses till after that. Mr. Lightfoot concurred in Mr. Millburn's view. The evidence of facts was rather scanty. The Coroner said it was a question as to what was scientific evidence. Mr. Liddell was a scientific witness; but he would give evidence as to facts as well. The room was then cleared, and on the Court reassembling, the Coroner said the jury had decided to hear Mr. Liddell's evidence to-day. Mr. Woodfall did not see the slightest necessity for that course. If there had been any need for it in the interests of the public he would have been quite willing. He thought the Court had sat long enough already, and was of opinion that the original decision of the Coroner to sit to half-past four should be adhered to. The Court was in the hands of the Coroner, not the jury. Mr. Milburn said the evidence as to fact was not large, and other witnesses should be called. It was understood that the evidence as to fact would occupy the whole of the day's inquiry, and his colleague, Mr. Andrew Sharp, had left before it was proposed to call Mr. Liddell, and he had not the advantage of Mr. Sharp's presence to assist him. After further discussion, it was decided to adjourn the inquiry until nine o'clock this (Thursday) morning. The Inquest Before Mr. Webster The adjourned inquest on the bodies of the two men, Robert Hodgson, Flimby, aged 39, hewer, married; and Joseph Robinson, Seaton, onsetter, single, who died at the Workington Infirmary on the 21st of April, was held in the Court-house, Workington, on Friday morning, before Mr. J. Webster, and a jury consisting of Messrs. W. Wilson (foreman), J. McKay, Coates Fothergill, John Head, Robert Adams, Hugh Madine, William Bewley, Robert Thompson, James Lorane, Jonathan Buchannan, Joseph Pinguey, James Cahill, Thomas Lucock, Joseph Yeowart, Matthew Morgan, W. Bayliff, Fletcher Branthwaite, and Joseph Allison. — Mr. L. T. Helder, Whitehaven, asked the coroner if he intended to proceed with this inquiry. He said there were other legal gentlemen who would like to be present, but were unable to do so on account of the inquiry being held by Mr. Lumb at the Green Dragon Hotel. — Mr. Webster said the evidence which he would take would only be of a formal character, but he would give them every opportunity to cross examine any of the witnesses at any time. Dr. Highet was then called, and gave evidence as to the inability of James Allison, one of the jurymen, who was unable to attend the inquest. Philip Wedgwood, farmer, Flimby, was the first witness called. He said he was Chairman of the directors of the St. Helens Colliery Company. The Company was formerly unlimited, but about eight years ago it was formed into a limited Company. The directors at present were himself: W. Mulcaster, Birkby; H. P. Senhouse, The Fitz; A. Helder, Whitehaven; W. McGowan, Whitehaven; Thomas Carey, Maryport. John Holliday Johnson was their manager. The Company has two pits, one working called No. 3, William Pit, and one not working called Old St. Helens. J. E. Mulcaster was the secretary for the Company. The manager, Mr. Johnson, lived at Workington, and held a certificate. J. C. Croudace, Hollywell, was the consulting engineer to the company. John Davidson, of Flimby, was the under manager who was in the pit at the time of the explosion. Davidson held a second class certificate as second manager. At the time of the explosion they were working two seams. The upper seam was called the bannock band, or ten quarter, and the lower was called the cannel and metal band, or main seam. The explosion took place in the lower seam. He was not sufficiently acquainted with the ventilation to tell how the pit was ventilated. The Foreman said he wished to ask Mr. Wedgwood certain questions. — The Coroner said it would be better for the questions to be put at another time when the evidence was completed. — The Foreman said it was respecting some information which he wanted for several of the jury and also the public. — The Coroner said they had not to mind about the public. It was for the jury to consider the evidence given, and return their verdict accordingly. — The Forman said the question he wanted to ask was respecting a privilege which was promised to the jury. At the previous inquiry it was mentioned that the Government Inspector had granted the other jury permission to go down the pit, and it was also understood they should have an opportunity of going down the mine, and Mr. Johnson was asked to see it was done. Well, he (Mr. Wilson) went to the pit one morning and said he would like to go down not as a sightseer, but as a worker. He went to the colliery office, and gave in his name and also that of two other jurymen. On the morning the exploring party went down he was there and he found there was only two ways of getting down the mine; it was either to slide down the rope or jump down the mine. He wanted to know why the privilege was not given to the jury to do down the pit. It had been said the pit was only safe for colliers. Well, he might say he had worked in pits from the time he was seven years of age until he was 21, and surely he was as well qualified to go down as many of the others. — The Coroner said permission was given to the jury to go down the mine, and he was astonished to hear they could not get down. — The Foreman said when he went to the colliery office Mr. Senhouse was there. When he told Mr. Senhouse that he wanted to go down, that gentleman told him that only the managers were going down the mine. — Mr. Wedgwood said any of the jury were quite welcome to go down the mine. — The Foreman: Oh, yes, now we are. But we wanted to go then. Mr. Oswald, Assistant Government Inspector of Mines, at this stage of the proceedings entered the room, and had a consultation with Mr. Webster. The Coroner said Mr. Oswald could not give him any assistance, as he was required at the other inquiry. He would have to have the assistance of either Mr. Willis or Mr. Oswald. The question was — could both inquiries go on at the same time. He thought it would be more desirable to have an adjournment. He had leaned from Mr. Oswald that it would take a week before the other inquiry was finished. It was decided to adjourn the inquiry until Thursday June 7th.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||