Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th May 1888

The Whitehaven Colliery Embezzlement Case

At the Whitehaven Petty Sessions, on Monday (before Dr. Parker (in the chair) and H. Fox, Esq.), Robert Graham (42), wasteman, and Joseph Wilkinson (61), master wasteman, were charged on remand with obtaining money by false pretences. Mr. T. Howson appeared for the prosecution, the proprietary of the Whitehaven Colliery. — He said: Before I go into the case at all I wish, with the approval of the Bench, of course, to withdraw the charge against Robert Graham. From circumstances that were communicated to me on Saturday and some more this morning, I have reason to believe that Graham has been more a tool than anything else. Moreover, I may have a difficulty in proving handwriting and so on; and with the approval of the Bench I propose to withdraw the case, with a view of calling him as a witness at or near the end of the case. — Mr. Atter (who appeared for Graham): I don't object. If Graham is called he has promised to tell all that he knows; and I am willing to give Mr. Howson particulars of the instructions that he gives me as regards his evidence. — The Chairman: Very well. — Graham was then liberated from the dock, and took a seat beside Mr. Atter. — Mr. Chapman again appeared for the prisoner Wilkinson. — Mr. Howson again stated the case. The prisoner was charged with obtaining by false pretences, on the 18th February, two sums of £2 18s 4d, by means of false entry in a pay-sheet, under the names of Robert Little and John Graham. At the following fortnightly pay, on the 3rd March, two similar sums in the same names; at the next fortnightly pay, on the 17th March, two similar sums in the same names; at the next fortnightly pay, which was held three days short of the fortnight end, on account of Easter — held on the day before Good Friday, 29th March — with obtaining the sum of £2 18s 4d in the name of Joseph Little; these men being supposed at the pay-table to have been working, whereas no such men were employed in the colliery at all. Since the information was laid, other circumstances had come out, and it had been discovered that not only these sums were obtained by the prisoner or somebody for him, but further sums and larger sums in the name of Robert Sewell; and finding that, he (Mr. Howson) served notice upon the prisoner that today these additional charges would be gone into. Many more might have been selected from the books; but he confined himself to a number that he could cover with the evidence and within a recent period. He had selected seven of the charges of obtaining money in the name of Robert Sewell. Robert Sewell was a stonemason; the other men were what are called "wastemen" in the air courses of Henry and William Pit coalmines. The prisoner was charged with having on the 7th January in this year obtained in the name of Robert Sewell a sum of £5 1s 4d for alleged earnings up to the fortnight end successive fortnight ended 31st December last; and at the following successive fortnightly pays he obtained in the same name £4 11s 4d, £4 5s 10d, £3 18s 2d, £4 11s 8d, £2 4s 10d, and £2 1s 10d. Part of the prisoner's duty was to keep the time of the waste-men, over whom he was master; and from his time-book a pay-sheet was made out. Prisoner was an illiterate man, and he was allowed to have another person to do this for him. That person was the man Graham, who had been discharged. Tickets for their wages were distributed to the wastemen by Wilkinson, and wages were paid at the pay-office on presentation of these tickets. Robert Graham received regularly at the pay-table wages in the names of the men he had mentioned — Robert Little, John Graham (sometimes instead of John Graham, John Steele), and Robert Sewell. He would trace the money from Graham into the hands of Wilkinson himself, partly by his own admission, and having done that, and having proved the circumstances under which this book appeared to have been made up fraudulently, he would ask the magistrates to commit the prisoner for trial for obtaining this money under false pretences.

G. H. Liddell deposed: I live at Moresby Hall, and am the resident viewer for the trustees of the Earl of Lonsdale for the Whitehaven Colliery, including the Whinghyll Colliery. William Harker is the certificated manager of the Whinghyll Colliery, under me. Joseph Wilkinson is the master wasteman, under Harker. On the average he has about 30 wastemen under his charge. Their duties are anything in the nature of maintaining the air-courses, which are very extensive in William and Henry Pits. They attend daily, and some of them on Sundays. There is certain work which cannot be done any other day. There are firemen connected with the gang, to attend to the furnaces. They commence duty practically together, at from half-past four to five, and they come up the mine again between one and two. A place is provided for them in the mine, where they assemble in the mornings to receive orders — a place called the old engine, with a lock-up door. This place is for the wastemen only. It should be the duty of the master wasteman to keep the time of these men. I have been here since the year 1877. During all that time, it has been the practice to pay these wastemen fortnightly, the wages being made up to every alternate Saturday and paid the following Saturday. There is a time-book made up every morning to enter the time of the men every day. This is done at the cabin where they meet. That is the system; I don't see it done. Wilkinson was master wasteman before I came, and he has been ever since. I understand he cannot write. Shortly after I came I ascertained he could not write and I inquired how it was he had been appointed, and was told by Mr. Harker that my predecessor, Mr. Martin, thought he was a good man, and allowed him to be appointed on the understanding that his son would make up his book for him. I don't know, but I have an impression that he can read. The master wasteman's pay-book now produced does not go down the pit. It is made up once a fortnight by the master wasteman, and handed in to the pay-office. The pay for the fortnight ended 31st December, 1887, is in the handwriting of Robert Graham, I believe. I have not seen Graham write. The book has been referred to by me in the presence of Graham and in the presence of Wilkinson, separately. Beginning at the 31st down to the fortnight ending 24th March it is all in the same handwriting. Going back to the fortnight ended 31st December last, £5 1s 4d is on the 9th January paid in the name of Robert Sewell. That is understood to be paid to Robert Sewell and a partner, but it is put in the name of Robert Sewell. The following fortnight, 14th Jan., paid 21st Jan., £4 11s 4d is entered in the name of Robert Sewell. For the fortnight ended 28th Jan., paid 4th Feb., £4 5s 10d is entered in the name of Robert Sewell. For the fortnight ended 11th Feb., £3 17s 2d is entered to Robert Sewell. For the fortnight ended 25th Feb., £4 11s 8d is entered to Robert Sewell. For the fortnight ended 10th March, £2 14s 10d is entered to Robert Sewell. For the fortnight ended 24th March, £2 1s 10d is entered to Robert Sewell. Turning again to the fortnight ended 11th February, 1888, I find there an entry Robert Little, 14 days, £2 18s 4d; same date, John Graham, £2 18s 4d. In the pay for the fortnight ending 25th February there are the same two names and the same amounts. For the next fortnight ending 10th March, there are precisely the same entries, in the same names; and for the fortnight ended 24th March, there is the name of Joseph Little, £2 18s 4d. The number against Joseph Little's name was the same as was previously against Robert Little, viz., 1,420. In the pay sheet ending 24th March, the names Robert Little and John Graham have disappeared. The usual course of business when the wasteman's pay book is made up is to deliver it on the Monday following the end of the fortnight to the clerk's office, and the money payments and shifts are calculated by the clerks and checked. The book is then handed to Mr. Harker for re-examination and signature. The seven pays to which I have referred are all signed by William Harker. The rule is for the book to be brought to me by Mr. Harker on the Thursday afternoon, when in the presence of Mr. Harker and the prisoner Wilkinson (the officials being called in one by one) I countersign them. That has been the practice ever since I came to Whitehaven. I cannot speak to any one of these particular fortnights. Having been countersigned by me it becomes a certificate for payment on the following Saturday. Another book that I now produce is also made up from up from it. That is called the pay check-book. Then names, numbers, and amounts, and gross deductions are entered in that book, and the balance to the credit of each name on the pay check book is put upon a pay ticket, which is a printed card in the form I now produce and hand in. Certain deductions for gear, fines, doctor, lent money, &c., are if necessary made. In the case of the wastemen as soon as the pay checks are completed they are sent to the master wasteman's house to be distributed amongst his gang. Then the pay checkbook is handed in to the cashier's department, to provide the money. On the following Saturday a cashier attends to pay the money to the persons presenting tickets and he has the assistance of two or three of the weighmen from the pit tops. I remember the 1st of April last, Easter Day, I on that day received certain information which led me to make inquiries. A few days previously to that an anonymous letter was sent to the Colliery office, which was handed to me. On Easter Monday or Tuesday I saw Harker and Wilkinson and asked them some questions. My inquiries were directed to ascertaining whether money had been paid regularly in the names of men who had never worked. I inquired whether two men, Robert Little and John Steele, were working as wastemen. I had found those names stretching a long way back in the wastemen's pay-book as regularly receiving money. I had not observed at that time that a few weeks before I made inquiry the name of John Graham had been dropped out and the name of John Steele substituted. On the 5th April I sent for several other men. There were present: John Thompson, the man who gave me the information at Moresby Hall on the Sunday, John Parkinson, John Little, Henry Cunnion, Robert Graham, the prisoner Joseph Wilkinson, and Mr. Harker. I made inquiry. John Parkinson and John Little declared positively that the men, Robert Little and John Steele, had worked regularly until recently. Wilkinson was present the whole time, but Graham was kept out of the room. Parkinson and Little said that Robert Little should be Joseph Little — that it was a mistake in the name. The prisoner declared most positively that they had worked until within two or three weeks. I did not at that time notice the change of the name. Thompson reiterated what he had said before that he had noticed for some two or three years that John Graham was drawing money in the names of two men who did not exist. That was said in the prisoner's presence. Those men were Robert Little and John Steele. It was customary to pay money to anyone presenting the tickets. Sometimes men sent their wives or children for their money. Wilkinson contradicted Thompson. I couldn't give you his words; but he repeatedly declared most positively that the two men had worked till a short time before. Graham was called into the room, but he was so helplessly drunk that he could neither speak not stand, and I could make nothing of him. Partly from the nature of Thompson's communication I did not believe it was true. Five days later Thompson by my instructions was given notice to quit the employ. Thompson came to me the following day again, the 11th April, and requested me to call some other men, and he could prove his statement. He requested me to call up more of the wastemen. I sent for a number of the wastemen on the 12th. There were present at that interview; Mr. Harker and Wilkinson, John Thompson, the informant; John Little, W. Colvin, T. Burney, J. Roney, and W. Robson. Graham was not present. It was not that day, I think, that Graham was drunk. John Little, in the presence of Harker and Wilkinson, said Joseph was his brother, and that he had worked in the pits until two or three weeks previously, but had left the town, and he did not know where he had gone to. Wilkinson and Thompson heard that statement in my presence. Wilkinson did not contradict it. Thompson contradicted it, and said, "I can bring Roney, who's his neighbour, and he can tell you all about it." Thompson brought Roney before Wilkinson, and he said he had lived next door to the Little family for years, and that for a considerable time Joseph Little had been working for a butcher in the Ginns called Crisp. He said, "He's not gone away, because I have seen him this dinner time, and if you like I will go and fetch him." He went, and was absent for about 20 minutes, while Wilkinson and I and the other waited. Roney was absent about 20 minutes, and said Little could not come just then, as he was cutting up a beast for Crisp; but he brought a note on one of Crisp's billheads, which I read to Wilkinson: — "Sir, — Joseph Little had been in my employment for the last three years. Signed, Joseph Little and E. B. Crisp." I cannot say that the prisoner Wilkinson said anything. He did not contradict it. I turned to John Little, and asked, "What do you say now?" Little still adhered most positively to his statement, in a very impudent way, I may say. [Mr. Howson: Never mind the impudence.] I told the prisoner he must go with me to Crisp's, and I would see the man myself. We went together to Crisp's, in Preston-street. I had the note with me. I first of all saw Mr. Crisp, and I asked if it was he who had sent this note, and he said "Yes," and that Joseph Little had worked with him continuously for about three years. I then asked if I could see Joseph Little, and the latter was brought in. I saw Little and Crisp together, in the presence of Wilkinson. They both confirmed the contents of the paper I have read, still in Wilkinson's presence and hearing. Joseph Little said he had worked in the pit about seven years before, but not since. That was in Wikinson's hearing, and Wilkinson did not contradict it. I then left in company with Wilkinson. I said to him, "Is that the man you mean?" He said, "No; it must have been a cousin or some other relation, and not a brother." That was the end of the second enquiry. I felt convinced there was something in it, then. On the following day I wrote to Mr. Robinson, Lord Lonsdale's chief agent, and informed him I had strong grounds to suspect that fraud was going on. That was the 13th. On the 14th I made a further inquiry, in the presence of Mr. Harker and Joseph Wilkinson. There were Matthew Powe, John Parkinson, John Bewsher, W. Black, Thomas Studholme, and H. Cunnion present. All the persons present, except Mr. Harker, were wastemen. I made further inquiries about these names. Parkinson and Bewsher still said there had been such men. The other men all said they had never known such men. Parkinson was assistant master wasteman under Wilkinson. Wilkinson heard all this. I have no doubt he said something, but I cannot tell you from memory what he said. On the 18th I sent for Graham. I saw him. Henry McGean, the head clerk, was present. I called him in when Graham came. Graham handed me in a written statement. I do not know whether Wilkinson had by that time left the town. He had been suspended from his employment on or about the 13th, until the thing was cleared up. On Saturday, the 21st, I was informed that the prisoner Wilkinson, having come back to Whitehaven, wanted to make a statement to me. I came into Whitehaven that evening, and sent one of the clerks, John Storey, for him up to his house at James Pit, while I waited at the Grand Hotel. He came to me, accompanied by John Storey, and made a statement to me in Storey's presence, which Storey by my direction took down. He practically said he wished to make a clean breast of the whole thing. I cannot say he used that phrase, but he said he wanted to tell me about it. I had not cautioned him. Previously I had told him that if he was guilty he had better made a clean breast of it; but on that occasion he denied the thing as strongly as ever. I told him I was determined to be at the bottom of it, and probably if he was found out it would be the worse for him. After that he repeatedly denied it. After I had taken his statement on the Saturday, Wilkinson left me at the Grand Hotel. I next say Wilkinson on the following Monday, the 23rd. I saw him at the Castle, in the presence of Mr. T. Howson, Mr. R. A. Robinson, and John Storey. When Wilkinson was called into the room, he was cautioned, as all other witnesses were, that he might speak or not speak, but whatever he might say might be used against him or any other person. He made a statement voluntarily after that, which was taken down by Storey. He said that he knew all about the fraud — that Graham had drawn the money regularly. [Witness read the statement as taken down in longhand by Mr. Howson, as follows]: -

I live at James Pit, Whitehaven, at No.1, and I am master wastemen at William Pit and Henry Pit, in the Whitehaven Colliery. I wish to explain the truth all about what has been going on. I am no scholar, and I got Robert Graham to do my books up. He is one of the wastemen under me. These wastemen are as a rule 30 to 35 in number. This money — that is the wages of the two men Robert Little and John Steele, Robert Graham received at the pay-table every pay day, there being no such men as those two working for me. Graham used to give me most of this money, and I gave most of what I got to Mr. William Harker, the manger of the mine. He never said anything, not till now lately, and I wished to drop. He said, "Never mind." I said, "I must mind, for I am going to get into a trouble over it." "Oh," he says, "there's no fear. No one can hurt you, or do you any harm." I said I would have to fear, as it was going to be a disgrace not to myself alone, but to all my family when I was found out. I do not know if either of the names has been changed lately to John Graham or otherwise. It might be changed to any name without my knowing, as I did not make up the book. Robert Graham has done so for me for some years last past. Before that one of my sons made up the books, but he refused to touch the book as soon as he found out that something was wrong."

I do not know of the existence in the pit of any such men as Robert Little, John Steele, and John Graham.

Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: Prisoner was under Harker, who was immediately responsible for him, although I had a certain amount of responsibility myself. I think it was not a proper arrangement to have that the prisoner should have been allowed to have some one else to make out his books. I would expect Harker to know all the wastemen in that pit, unless it should be a new comer. It is difficult to believe that false names could pass Harker month after month when he examined the book. When I saw Harker and the accused together on Easter Tuesday, Harker said nothing, except that as far as he knew the book was correct. At any rate he accepted Wilkinson's statement. I did not attach much importance to the matter at that time. He practically accepted Wilkinson's statement. I cannot recall exactly what he said. At the second interview I don't think Harker took any part in the inquiry. One day, I don't know when, but after 5th of April, Harker said to me that he had always taken Wilkinson to be an honest man, and he did not take much notice of his bills so long as the amounts did not vary. Harker came to me and consulted me with regard to Thompson. He said, "What's to be done with Thompson for making these statements?" I said something to the effect that it was monstrous thing he should make these charges. Harker then said, "Do you think" or "Don't you think he should have the sack?" He suggested to me that Thompson should be discharged. I said I agreed with him that he ought to be discharged. Thompson thereupon got a fortnight's notice, with my consent I would have given him his notice myself, independent of Harker. I was quite under the belief that he was not speaking the truth, for reasons I could state. I had not made up my mind to do so, but I would have certainly done so, presuming I had not found out what he said was true. At the next inquiry Harker was in this position, that he knew nothing about it. Soon after that, about the 14th April, Harker said he had come to the same conclusion as I had, that Wilkinson was guilty, and he was very much astonished at it. Harker was not catechised in the same way as the other people. This berth of the prisoner's was not one to which Harker had the appointment. His word would of course have some weight, but I don't know whether that was so in this case, as this appointment was made before my time.

Re-examined: I never suspected any false names in the books. I found old and trusted men here as subordinates when I came, and I put confidence in them — perhaps too much confidence in some of them.

William Harker deposed: I live at Catherine-street, Whitehaven, and I am certificated manager of the Whinghyll Colliery. Joseph Wilkinson has been master wasteman in that colliery for into teens of years; and Robert Graham was a wasteman under him. Wilkinson is responsible for the accuracy of the wasteman's pay book. I know that book. It is signed by me on all those fortnightly pays already referred to. Wilkinson got liberty from Mr. Martin to get some one else to keep his books. Robert Graham has made out Wilkinson's books for about two years. I don't know whether Wilkinson can write, but he's not much hand at it. I don't know whether he can read, but he can point a man's name out in the book when he's questioned. Before signing the pay-book I look it over, and if I see anything particular about it I draw Wilkinson's attention to it. I saw nothing particular except extra shifts in the seven pay-sheets referred to. Those were explained. I took the pay-sheets to Mr. Liddell, Wilkinson was present always. I don't think he missed one of the seven pay-sheets. I have about 840 men in the pit to look after, top and bottom, including these 30 wastemen. It is not part of my duty to attend at the old engine cabin when the wastemen muster in the morning; and I don't do it. I go my rounds over one part of the colliery one day and one part another. The air courses are distributed over miles. I could not see all the wastemen on any one day. I know personally most of these wastemen. I never mustered them, had them called over, or anything of that kind. I could not say the date when I first heard of fictitious names being on the list. I think it was a day or two before Good Friday. I first heard whispers. Mr. Liddell first mentioned it to me on Monday, 2nd April. I did not at that time know that there were fictitious names, although I had heard rumours. — Witness corroborated the last witness as to what occurred at the various inquiries held by Mr. Liddell.

Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: I have been 45 years in the employ. I got my certificate in 1872. I expect I am a careful man. I am down William and Henry Pit two or three times a week. Any old hands among the wastemen I would know beyond possibility of mistake. I know the two names said to be fictitious ones. The names Robert Little and John Steele figure in the book produced, in July 15th, 1885, on the first page of the book. Those two names have figured every fortnight from then up to the date of the charge. Every fortnight from that date till now I have examined this book. Any man who has been in the employ so long as three years would be what I call an old hand, and I could not make any mistake about knowing him. — Mr. Chapman: Therefore, if any two false names were upon the book, you must have known it? — The Clerk said the evident object of the question was to incriminate the witness, and he must caution the witness that he was not obliged to answer. — Mr. Chapman said that was not his object in asking the question. [The question was not answered, and was not pressed.] — Cross-examination continued: I never noticed any false names in the book for the past three years. I saw the names of Robert Little and John Steele fortnight by fortnight in the books. I expected those two men were working. There were such men as Robert Little and John Steele, and I knew them when I saw them. They might be working there yet. I don't know when they ceased to be workmen. I saw them when I gave them employment. I knew them by sight, if I was to meet them. I expect they were under Wilkinson this year. I have not seen them in the air courses. I did not ask Wilkinson, and he did not tell me. I did not notice these men were absent, although I saw their names on the book. As to he prisoner's son, who used to keep the prisoner's books, I can only tell you what I have heard him say, and that was that his father was defrauding Lord Lonsdale. I never told prisoner, "You must put some money in that pay-book for me." I have not been spending money lately. I will not answer what my wages are. I have not been fond of driving about the country lately — scarcely once a year at all events. Wilkinson never came to me, and said he could not go on putting these names into the books as he would get into a mess. If I had found Wilkinson wrong, and I had reported it to Mr. Liddell, very likely he would have been dismissed. I did not tell Wilkinson I would dismiss him unless he continued to put the names into the book. Wilkinson never brought me any money except once a year for going through the water levels. I remember Parkinson coming to my house about a month ago. He asked me what I was going to do. I did not say to him, "For God's sake swear the same as before that the men were really there." I heard the prisoner's confession read. I suppose Wilkinson made the allegation against me to save himself. — Mr. Chapman: Nay, that would not save him, because he got some of it. — Witness: Well, I got none of it. — Mr. Chapman: Then why should he say that? — Witness: Oh, I don't know.

John Storey, who lives at No. 1, Hilton-terrace, and is a clerk at the Colliery Office, gave evidence as to the making up of the pay check-book. He produced a transcript of a shorthand note of the statement made by the prisoner before Mr. Liddell, at the Grand Hotel:—

Statement made by Joseph Wilkinson, at the Grand Hotel, Whitehaven, on April 21st, 1888, in the presence of Mr. G. H. Liddell. — You must excuse me I did not tell you the truth at first, but now I mean to tell you it, and proper. Robert Graham has been billing this money, and, if I remember right, a week to-day you told Mr. Harker you thought there was something wrong, and Mr. Harker told me I should take thee and be sure, and question to see what thou knows. Mr. Harker said whatever you do, damn it, stand to it, because if not you will ruin me. My Mrs. could tell you more than me ever since the explosion, and said Graham she hated, and Joe, believe me, I don't like that man to come to you; there's some devilry. I received money from Graham to hand to Mr. Harker. Parkinson went to Mr. Harker's house to ask what he had to say; but Mr. Harker did not report that he told Parkinson to stick to what he said at first. I knew these monies were in the book. Mr. Liddell, before Graham came. I handed the money to Mr. Harker before pay was finished. Mr. Harker got the bulk of it, but Graham and myself each got a small portion. I have no idea how long it has been going on, but remember, I will prove Mr. Harker what he is; and he told me many a time distinctly, which I have said nothing about to my wife nor any one. God dam it, he says, take no thought, but I said it is me that is going to drop into trouble. Well, then, I am up in years, and said to Mr. Harker this is sadly wrong times out of number, and what was going about. — To the devil with what is going about; it's not for me to say. Harker was three-parts drunk when he made it appear that I was receiving all this money. Mr. Liddell, Mr. Harker received the money, and you can have your own opinion of it; but what would he sign that book for? You must understand, Mr. Liddell, I have been in Durham, Northumberland, &c., and it's the first time ever I was charged with ought of the kind. Mr. Harker said Joe, I want so and so, and it was done simply. Of course, understand Mr. Harker suggested it. I deceived you, but it is a lesson to all my boys, and will be for me, on account of my family. If I have done wrong I hope you will not make little of them for it. None of my sons knew anything about the book more than my hat. I am quite sure, Mr. Liddell, my Mrs. told me many a time she imagined things were not right, and she said she did not like Graham, and begged of Joe many a time to be careful. It will send my Mrs. to her grave. Mr. Harker wanted this money, and Graham made his bills out, and we got a small part each, and Harker got the remainder. I know of nothing before Robert Graham started. Graham before making my bills out received this money. Before one of my sons made the book out, but knew nothing wrong. I ordered him. Mr. Liddell, I submit that I knew from the first, but remember it was Mr. Harker's orders, who instructed Tom to put these names in. My son can come to you and explain it, and he knew that these names were not in the working, and for that reason would have nothing to do with the books any longer. He said, father, I won't be fetched up on no consideration, and the boy was working under me, and I won't have anything to do with the books, and then Mr. Harker and I appointed Graham. My son would not have anything to do with it. I have no idea how long since it started, and could not give any idea whatever, but remember I have come to tell the truth. I will tell you if you can make it convenient. Tom is nervous, that made my books up, but refused, and I will fetch him before you. Mr. Harker pressed on me to go on, and I am very sorry, but it is a lesson to all my children, and they can take it as a caution.

Witness also produced a transcript of a shorthand note of the statement made by the prisoner before Mr. Robinson and Mr. Liddell, at the Castle, which was as follows: -

My name is Joseph Wilkinson, and I live at No. 1, James' Pit, and am master wasteman of William and Henry Pits, Whitehaven Colliery. I wish to explain the truth about what has been going on. I am not any scholar, and got Robert Graham to do my books up, who worked under me as a wasteman. There would be from 30 to 35 wastemen under me, but we are rather short at present. Robert Graham received the wages of two men called Robert Little and John Steel, for each pay at the payable, there being no such men working for me of those names. Well, then, Graham used to give me the most of this money, and I handed the most of what I got to Mr. William Harker, manager of the mine. He never said anything until now lately, when I told I was going to get into a trouble over this, and will have to drop it, but he said never mind. Mr. Harker told me there was no fear, as no one could harm me, but I said I won't stand it any longer, because it was going to he a disgrace to myself and family when it is found out. I know nothing about the name having been altered, as they could put any name in my book they thought proper. I did not know the name John Steel was changed to john Graham. I never made up my book. Robert Graham has done so for some years last past. My son used to make the book till he found out that there were wrong names in, and then would have nothing more to do with it. I told Harker, who said never mind. But I said I must mind, and my wife said give it up Joe, or you will get into trouble.

Thomas Atkinson, clerk at the colliery office, gave evidence as to the making up of the books and checks.

William Mulcaster, assistant-surveyor in the Whitehaven Colliery, gave evidence as to the making up of the books and checks.

The Court adjourned at half-past five, to resume again at ten o'clock on Wednesday morning.

[For report of Wednesday's proceedings see page 5]

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, Thomas    Clerk  
Atter, —    Solicitor  
Bewsher, John    Wasteman  
Black, W.    Wasteman  
Burney, T.    Wasteman  
Chapman, —    Solicitor  
Colvin, W.    Wasteman  
Crisp, E. B.    Butcher  
Cunnion, Henry    Miner  
Fox, H.    Magistrate  
Graham, John    Wasteman  
Graham, Robert    Wasteman  
Harker, William    Manager  
Howson, T.    Solicitor  
Howson, T.      
Liddell, G. H.    Viewer  
Little, John    Miner  
Little, Robert    Wasteman  
Lonsdale, Earl of    Mine Owner  
Martin, —    Viewer  
McGean, Henry    Head Clerk  
Mulcaster, William    Surveyor  
Parker, —, Dr.    Magistrate  
Parkinson, John    Miner  
Parkinson, John    Wasteman  
Powe, Matthew    Wasteman  
Robinson, R. A.    Agent  
Robson, W.    Wasteman  
Roney, J.    Wasteman  
Sewell, Robert    Stonemason  
Steele, John    Miner  
Storey, John    Clerk  
Studholme, Thomas    Wasteman  
Thompson, John    Miner  
Wilkinson, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print