Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th May 1888

The Charge Against A Colliery Official

Yesterday (Wednesday) morning, the hearing of the charge was resumed. Mr. Howson prosecuting and Mr. Chapman defending. The magistrates present were C. A. Parker and H. Fox, Esq.

Henry Benson, aged 16, employed in the wasteman's department, said he had put down the time for one man who was not working in the pit, and that was John Graham. He had put down Graham's name by order of the prisoner.

John Kirkbride, in the cashier's department at the Whitehaven Colliery Office, gave evidence as to the payment of the various sums charged in the wasteman's book for wages for the fictitious workmen.

John Thompson, 29, Senhouse-street, Whitehaven, master weighman at William Pit, stated that he had been employed at the pit about eight years, and was engaged on the day shifts. On pay days he assisted the last witness to pay the men. Robert Graham used to present his own ticket, also for Robert Little and John Graham. Previous to that Steele used to have Graham's ticket. For three years he had noticed that Robert Graham had drawn wages on these tickets. He began to suspect that something was wrong, and thought it strange of Graham having these tickets every fortnight. On the 1st of April witness gave Mr. Liddell certain information at Moresby Hall, and mentioned his suspicions. At the 5th of April inquiry witness challenged prisoner to produce Little, and prisoner said that it was a mistake and that the name should be Joseph Little, and that he had left the town. John Little and Robert Graham said the same. Cunnion at first also corroborated, but he acknowledged he had made a mistake. — Mr. Howson: Then you were pretty much in a minority of one? — Witness: Yes, they sat on me proper. (Laughter.) — Mr. Howson: And you got your notice? — Witness: Yes, from Mr. Harker.

Mr. Chapman: When did you first suspect that the names were false? Three years ago when Graham presented the tickets. — Did you ever question anyone about it? No. — Why did you not give information before? Because I was not sure about it, and when I did give information I was put down. What made you give information when you did? Because I thought conscientiously it was right towards my master. — Which side did Mr. Harker take, for you or against you, at the inquiry? Against me. — And Mr. Harker gave you your notice? Yes. — What did he say when he gave you your notice? He said I had to take 14 days notice. — Did he give you any reason? Yes, he said that they were going to reduce their hands. — Was that the only reason? That was the reason given, but I did not think it was the real reason.

Thomas Burney, Charles-street, stated that he was Whingill banksman, and sent the men up and down the pit. Never knew Robert Little, John Graham, Joseph Little, nor John Steel as wastemen.

Robert Sewell, stonemason, working in the Whingill Colliery, stated that he had worked there about 30 years. In December last witness had one shift in prisoner's sheet, and received 4s. — Mr. Howson: Would you be surprised to know you got £3 11s 4d for that pay? No, I didn't. (Laughter.) — If anybody drew since that time in the wasteman's department in the name of Robert Sewell £27 4s you did not get it? No, I did not.

Mr. Kirkbride, re-called, and examined by Mr. Chapman: Robert Little and John Steele have been included in my pay-sheets since July, 1885, up to the present time.

James Rooney and John Parkinson also gave evidence as to some of the men alleged to be improperly on the pay-sheet.

John Thompson, recalled, was examined by Mr. Chapman: What relation is there between you and Mr. Harker? — I am his nephew. — Being a near relative you would be surprised at getting your notice? — Yes. — And following upon that you would naturally ask the reason? — No, I did not, sir. I was surprised, but I considered the notice was for bringing this case forward. — Why should he be angry at that? — I cannot say.

Thomas Studholme, Henry Cunnion, William Black, Tom Anderson, and Patrick McGuiness also gave evidence as to not knowing respectively men already referred to in the employ.

Robert Graham, wasteman, said he had been employed in Whingill Colliery between six and seven years. The writing in the wasteman's pay-book from the 21st of December was in witness's handwriting, and the six more pays following. The last entry he made in the book was 7th April, 1888. He did the book produced for Joseph Wilkinson by his direction. — Mr. Howson: How is that there are more names in the pay-book than there is in the time-book? By Joseph Wilkinson's orders, sir. Those names have been occurring in the pay-book before I had anything to do with it. — Did it not occur to you as strange? Yes, I know they were fictitious names. — In further cross-examination, witness said it was to be understood those three names had always to be continued, and they were to have full pay. The wages were continued fortnight after fortnight as a standing order. In regard to Robert Sewell, the sums varied. Witness gave further evidence as to the manipulation of the book. — Mr. Howson: Anything else? Yes, the money. — Do you know what Wilkinson did with it? — Witness: I wish to say that for a considerable time after I began to receive the money for Wilkinson, I used to give him the whole amount of the money, but on one occasion Wilkinson pointed out the coppers, and gave them to me, and he said that in the future I was to keep them. — Mr. Howson: Do you know who got the money? Not of my knowledge, but Wilkinson has told me. He told me on the 17th of April that he took the money to Harker, and they divided it. — Mr. Chapman: It is long since you first heard about where the money went? — Witness: Well, about eighteen months ago Wilkinson told me. It was one pay Saturday. Wilkinson came in the evening at dark and said that when he took the money to Harker they found there was 10s wrong. I have heard him say that he could not do these things by himself. In my own mind I took it to mean Harker he referred to. — By Mr. Chapman: It would often be £10 and more that I would hand over in the fortnight. — Mr. Chapman: I suppose you look upon yourself as an honest man in this business? — Witness: I knew I was doing wrong, but I did not think I was culpable. I did it according to orders. — Mr. Chapman: What part of the money did you receive yourself? — Witness: Just the part I told you — the coppers. — Mr. Chapman: Do you mean me to believe that? You know you were committing a fraud. You are a man of average intellect or ability. — Witness: Very ordinary, I should say. (Laughter.) — By Mr. Howson: I always got full time, but I did not always work full time. — Mr. Howson: Wilkinson instructed Benson to mark him full time always.

Sergeant Hope said he apprehended the prisoner on a warrant on the Tuesday, a littler after twelve at noon. He read the warrant over to him, and, having heard the contents of it, prisoner replied, "It was Graham, you know, who got the money; I did not get it."

Mr. Chapman submitted that the false pretence had not been made out. It might be said there is the confession. That required corroborative evidence, and he contended that there was no evidence which came to false pretences except that of Graham. He was an accomplice, and his evidence should not be accepted without corroboration — Mr. Howson submitted there was sufficient corroboration by the boy Benson. — The Clerk said if the question was raised he should say there was corroborative evidence.

The magistrates decided to commit the prisoner for trial. — It was agreed to admit the prisoner to bail, himself in £200, and two sureties in £100 each. — Mr. McKenzie and Mr. Glaister, innkeepers, became the sureties.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Benson, Henry   16 Miner  
Black, William    Miner  
Burney, Thomas    Banksman  
Chapman, —    Solicitor  
Cunnion, Henry    Miner  
Fox, H.    Magistrate  
Glaister, —    Innkeeper  
Graham, John    Miner  
Graham, Robert    Miner  
Harker, —      
Hope, —    Police Sergeant  
Howson, —    Solicitor  
Kirkbride, John    Cashier  
Liddell, G. H.    Viewer  
Little, Joseph    Miner  
Little, Robert    Miner  
McGuiness, Patrick    Miner  
McKenzie, —    Innkeeper  
Parker, C. A.    Magistrate  
Parkinson, John    Miner  
Rooney, James    Miner  
Sewell, Robert    Stonemason  
Studholme, Thomas    Miner  
Thompson, John    Master Weighman  
Wilkinson, Joseph      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whingill Colliery  Whingill Colliery
Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print