|
1st December 1887 The Accident At Ellenborough CollieryResult Of The InquiryOn Tuesday afternoon, at Netherton, Mr. W. W. Lumb, and a jury, of which Mr. J. B. Rollinshaw was foreman, resumed their inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of Joseph Highmore Nixon, who died recently from an accident he met with at Ellenborough more than twelve months ago. Mr. Oswald, Government inspector, was in attendance, and Mr. E. Atter (Whitehaven) watched the proceedings on behalf of the Colliery Company, and William Clark, a deputy, whose name had been freely mentioned at the previous inquiries. — Mr. W. Hobson, clerk to the magistrates, was the first witness called. He stated that on the 6th of December last he, accompanied by Dr. Pearson, J.P., proceeded to the house of the deceased's father, and took the former's deposition as follows: — I am satisfied that I am dangerously ill, and shall not recover from the injuries from which I am suffering, and that my death may take place at any time. I have been employed for some time at Grasslot Colliery, and acted as driver in the pit on Friday, the 26th November last, in the fourth brow in the metal band. The accident occurred in Isaac Thompson's turn. When I was going up the bye the tub got off the way, and I could not put it on myself. I shouted to Isaac Thompson to come and give me a lift. He did not come, but he sent his mate, David Cooper. I was at the fore-end of the tub, and David was at the hinder and had the fore end up, and he had his back at the hinder end and his hand against the roof to slew. When he slewed he either slewed the tub against the drop or shoved it away with his hand. The roof came down with a rush, and we were both covered up. The horse that drew the tub killed. The roof had not sufficient wood in it to hold it up. I had told William Clark, the deputy; several times that he had got to fettle it up. It was not safe, and Clark promised to get it done. I also told William Young about it. Clark told me he had taken the overman and let him see the place. It was the overman's duty to do what was necessary to make the place safe. I have only been at work for five weeks from a lame foot which I had got on the main way from a falling stone from the roof into the tub. That was also in the same pit. If I had been in two minutes longer on that occasion I should have been killed. I am twenty-one years of age. — Mr. F. Atkinson, manager of the colliery, produced a plan of the working. It had never been suggested to him that the place where the accident occurred was unsafe. Clark, the deputy who had been referred to, always paid great attention to his duties. He did his work regularly and steadily, and he had the greatest confidence in him. Clark, of course, had to run the same risk as the other men, as he had to pass under the place where the roof fell in. David Cooper stated that on the day of the accident (November 26th, last year) he found the deceased taking a stone out of one of the wheels of a tub. Witness helped him. The tub gave a cant, and went into the low side against a prop. The roof then came down with a rush, burying the deceased and witness. Up to that time the roof had appeared as safe as a house. There were as many props there as it was possible to get in. He may have told some one that he pushed the prop away; but it must have been very loose if it did. — In reply to Mr. Atter, witness said the wood used for props was perfectly sound, and the place seemed as safe as possible. Clark was very attentive to his duties. — By Mr. Phillips (a juryman): The accident laid him up for six weeks. He got nothing for that, although he believed the Company had insured him. — John Cunningham, the night-deputy, spoke to examining the place and finding it quite safe early on the morning of the accident. There were plenty of props, and they were well set. The roof appeared to be good, and he did not suppose deceased would have stayed there had he considered it unsafe. — Thomas Woodward, day overman; employed at the colliery, said he examined the roof where the accident took place, on the 24th. He found it in good condition, and there was no fault to find with the props. He thought the fall was caused by the tub striking the prop. It would have been impossible for a man to push the prop out. The deceased, after the accident, told him that he had told Clark, the deputy, that the place was unsafe. So far as witness knew no one was to blame. — By Mr. Atter: The place was sufficiently propped, and he never saw any indications of danger. The complaint deceased said he had made to Clark had reference to a sweep plate, which was wanted on the road at the curve, and had nothing whatever to do with the roof. Witness thought that the accident was caused by the loaded truck going against the prop. — By a juryman: Witness never told deceased that if he refused to work in that spot he would get some one to work in his place. — By the Inspector: Witness did not think deceased had sufficient experience to enable him to state whether the place was safe or not. — Captain Brown (a juror): When you went to see the deceased in bed did he shake hands with you, and say, "Tom, I forgive you; but you might have mended this?" — Witness: No. — Captain Brown: I believe there is a witness to that effect. — Witness: Those words never came out of his mouth. — Henry Sheppard, formerly employed at Ellenborough Colliery, said that when the accident occurred he was about 35 yards from the deceased. He thought the wood was not set properly, or the accident would not have occurred. There were legs where the accident took place where there ought to have been heads; and several heads had been cut out. He did not think the place was well secured and propped. Deceased had not had so much experience as witness; but he must have seen that the place was not properly propped. Two days before the accident he told witness that he had told Mr. Clark, the deputy, many a time that the place was unsafe. Deceased said he reported it on account of its being dangerous. If he reported it, and the deputy took no notice of it, it was his duty to continue working. If the overman had carefully examined the place they could not have considered it safe. He was sure there were not so many heads as shown on the plan, and one of them was broken. — Another plan was produced, and Mr. Atter wished to know where it came from. — Captain Brown said he brought it, but he did not know who made it. — In reply to the Coroner, witness said if he had been in Nixon's place on the morning of the accident he would not have stopped there. The low side prop was not set properly. It was leaning towards the road, and a man could get his hand between the head tree and the top of the prop. — By Mr. Atter: He left the service of the Ellenborough Company in September last. A man named Thomas Harrison was with the witness when deceased said he had complained to Clark about the danger of the place. He was quite sure that deceased did not refer to the roadway when he made his complaint. Witness did not tell Clark that the place was unsafe, because he thought it would do no good as the deceased had told him. If the witness Cunningham said all he knew he would say it was unsafe. If he said it was safe on the morning of the accident he could not have looked at it. No props on the low side were knocked out. — Thomas Harrison, coal hewer, who was working at the colliery on the day of the accident, said the props had been set, but the heads were sawn off — probably to make the place high enough for the horses. The place was not propped as it should have been. Deceased told witness he has complained to Clark. When Cooper was sitting on witness's knee, immediately after the accident, he said, "It never was a safe place from the beginning." — The Coroner: Was there anyone to blame for the accident? — Witness: I consider the men who said the place was safe were to blame if the place was not safe. No man could push a leg away if it was safe. It would take seven men. — The Coroner: And you think the people who inspected it ought to have seen that. — Witness: Certainly. — By Mr. Atter: I consider the props were not safe; but I could not say anything about the roof. It was not my business to see if the roof was safe. — William Clark was the next witness called. He said: I was deputy-overman at the Ellenborough Colliery. I have been employed at a colliery nearly all my life. I knew the deceased. He was under my control. I last examined the place in which he worked at three o'clock on November 25th. I found it all right, except that it was rather dirty on the rails. Deceased never complained to me about the place being unsafe; but he did complain about the groundwork. He never spoke of the roof, or said it was dangerous. — My opinion is that in slewing the tub too much force was used. The prop witnesses have alluded to was as good on the 25th as when I put it up. It was impossible for a man to push it away. — The Coroner: You have heard what Sheppard has said. — Witness: I think very little of it. He seems to have gone walking about condemning the wood; he must have had more time than I ever had. — In reply to further questions, witness emphatically denied that the heads had been cut away as described by previous witnesses. Deceased and Cooper did it all themselves; there was no one else to blame. — By Mr. Atter: He was perfectly certain deceased never complained about the roof. But he certainly did complain about the state of the roadway, and he said unless it was seen to he would not work there any more. — Joseph Gibson, a driver employed at the colliery, said he was close to the last witness when the fall took place. Deceased had never said anything to him about the place being dangerous. — James Bawden said he was at the colliery shortly after deceased had received his injuries. The bogie was lying close to a prop. — John Shimmings gave similar evidence. — Isaac Thompson said he assisted William Clark to put the props in where the accident took place. All the props were sound, and he considered it perfectly safe. — Mr. Oswald, Inspector of Mines, stated that he went to the colliery on the morning following the accident. He came to the conclusion that a tub had come into contact with the low side leg, and let the carrying bar down. — Mr. Atter said some of the jurymen might be under some misapprehension with regard to compensation. It might not be out of place, therefore, if he stated that some time ago an action for compensation was pending; and the Company were perfectly prepared to fight it. He (Mr. Atter) instructed Mr. McConkey, a barrister, of Liverpool, for the defence, and had paid him £13 19s 6d. Mr. McConkey had given an opinion strongly in favour of the Company; but it was afterwards found that the Company had insured the deceased, and that was why compensation had been given to him. — The Coroner having summed up, the jury found that deceased came by his death from his injuries he received from a fall of the roof in the colliery roadway; but they could not determine from what cause the fall took place.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||