|
15th September 1887 The Recent Fatal Accident At Lowca PitMr. A. Sharp And The CoronerOn Tuesday the inquiry relative to the death of Joseph Holliday (40), of Lowca Cottages, who was killed, on Wednesday last, at Messers Bain & Co.'s No. 7 pit, Lowca, Parton, was resumed at the Ship Inn, Lowca Cottages, Parton, before Mr. Webster, coroner from the lordship of Egremont, and jury over whom Mr. I. Wilson was the foreman. Mr. Oswald, the Government Inspector of mines for the district, was present at the inquiry, and also Mr. A. Sharp, miners' agent, Maryport; and Mr. W. Cameron, the manager of the pit where the accident occurred. — Mr. Sharp said he claimed under Lord Cross's Act of the previous year to be present at the inquiry and put questions to the witnesses as representing the relatives of the deceased. — The Coroner declined to allow Mr. Sharp to question the witnesses, and Mr. Sharp said he would make a protest against the coroner's decision when the representatives of the press had arrived. Walter Gribbin deposed: I am an overman in the employment of Messrs Bain & Company, and live at Parton. At five o'clock on Wednesday, the 7th inst., I went on duty at No. 7 pit, Lowca, with the intention of going down the shaft on the rise side. Two doors have to be opened before the men go down the pit shaft. When the deceased man came to the outer door he was told to stop and not open the door because we were not ready for him. When we got ready for descending the shaft I said, "Come on, Joe," and thereupon he opened the door and came into the shed. Deceased said he had two props to fetch. John Greener answered, "Well, Joe, you can't get them on this time." We had two dozen of sleepers, which took up the room. It is usual to carry wood when men are riding down in the cage. The deceased man handed me his saw and went out of the outer door. At the same time I said to him, "Well, Joe, you had better come next cage," or words to that effect. Just with that I closed the inside door, and said to John Hayes, "Give the signal to descend," and the cage moved away. We would be about 16 or 20 fathoms down the shaft when something came down on the top of the cage. It was a prop and a man. When the man fell on to the cage he rolled off the top on to the side of the shaft and into the bottom of the cage. The Coroner: — Whose duty is it to see that these doors leading to the shaft are closed? — It is mine. — Can you swear that you closed that door yourself? — Yes, I can, and I have plenty of evidence, too. — By the Inspector: When I was speaking to the deceased, before we descended, both the inner and the outer doors were open. — Witness said they could not get their wood in when it was long without both doors being open. — The Inspector: What about your ventilation? You ought not to have both doors open at once. Mr. Sharp said he claimed as a legal right to be present and question the witness, and he protested against the coroner refusing to allow him to do so. — The Coroner: All right, sir. — Mr. Sharp: I produce Lord Cross's Act giving me that right. If you don't understand it, I can't help it. — The Coroner: If you don't behave yourself, sir, I shall.-.-.-. John Hayes, a deputy at Messrs Bains No. 7 pit, Lowca, gave corrobative evidence. The Coroner said he thought it would be desirable, before proceeding further, that the Jury should view the pit shaft, so that they could the better understand the evidence. — This course was agreed to. Mr. Sharp, as the jurymen were leaving the room, handed a copy of Lord Cross's Act to the foreman of the jury, and said that gave him the right to be present at the inquiry and question the witnesses. — The Coroner: Don't look at that, Mr. Foreman. — The foreman returned the document to Mr. Sharp. The jury then proceeded to view the shaft of the pit. On their return the examination of Hayes was continued. John Greener, a deputy employed at the pit, also gave evidence. The Coroner, at this stage, directed that the widow of the deceased should be sent for, and on her arrival he informed her that if she wished to put any questions to the witnesses he would do so for her. — Mrs. Holliday: I requested Mr. Sharp to come here for me. — The Coroner: I have objected to Mr. Sharp. He cannot ask questions, but if you wish him to put questions through me I will allow him to do so. — Mrs. Holliday: That is my wish. — The Coroner: Tell Mr. Sharp to come in. The Coroner (to Mr. Sharp): If you have any questions to suggest on behalf of this woman and put them to me I will ask the witness them. — Mr. Sharp: No, you would not allow me at the commencement. I gave you a fair understanding before you commenced, and you objected. — The Coroner: I still object to you putting questions to the witnesses direct, but you may put them through me. — Mr. Sharp: You did not give me that chance. — The Coroner: You please yourself whether you ask the questions in this way. — Mr. Sharp: We will fight this question with you. — The Coroner: Do you wish to put questions? — I wished to put questions, but you said I had no right to be here. — The Coroner: You have a perfect right to be here, it is an open court. — Mr. Sharp: You said I had no right to take part, and I left the room. — The Coroner: I understand the widow of the deceased is desirous that you should advise her in this matter, and I am quite prepared to put any questions which you may suggest and illicit the answers. I can't say more. — Mr. Sharp: I told you in the morning that I wished to put questions. — The Coroner: I cannot say any more. I have given you every opportunity. — Mr. Sharp: No, you have not. You said that Lord Cross's Act was not legal. — The Coroner: I did not say anything of the kind. — Mr. Sharp: Not say it! I will ask Mr. Oswald what you said. — Mr. Oswald: He said it was not in force. — Mr. Sharp: I say it is in force. — The Coroner: I did not say anything of the kind. — Mr. Sharp: You did. You will have to recall the whole of them. You will have to go over the whole evidence. — The Coroner: You shall hear the whole of the evidence of every witness. — Mr. Sharp: Then why did you dispute the matter at first? — The Coroner: Now, don't let us go into that. I do dispute your right to examine witnesses, but I have said you can put them questions through me. He has got a grievance, and he wants to ventilate it. — Mr. Sharp said he had a right to be there, and he wished the coroner would look at the Act. — The Corner: That has no interest for me. I don't wish you to go away, however, without having every information. Now I will read Beck's evidence. Have you any question to ask him? — Mr. Sharp: Can we not start with the first? — The Coroner: This witness is before the Court. — Mr. Sharp said he would not ask questions unless through the proper routine. — The Coroner: We will go through the proper routine. — Mr. Sharp: I will question the first witness when he comes in. — The Coroner: Have you any questions to ask this witness? I will take the others after. — Mr. Sharp: You had proper knowledge at the commencement, and you objected then. — The Coroner: You don't answer the question. Call the next witness. — Mr. Sharp: You will understand, Mr. Reporters, that I simply object to commence any questioning with a middle witness. Peter Woodburn, a miner, gave evidence. — The Coroner asked Mr. Sharp if he had any questions to ask the witness. — Mr. Sharp said he would not put questions unless he commenced with the first witness. — The Coroner: I have already told you that every witness shall be recalled. — Mr. Sharp: You had Gribbin in, why not call him? — The Coroner: You are not going to dictate in this court. — Mr. Sharp: And I am not going to be caught in a net. P.C. Fisher said there were no other witnesses. The Coroner said he would now take the witnesses over again, and Mr. Sharp might put any questions he wished through him if he desired to do so. — Mr. Sharp said he wished to do so. James Morgan (who gave evidence of identification) was re-called, and in answer to Mr. Sharp said he had lodged with the deceased man. The deceased was deputy overman. Mr. Sharp then proceeded to examine the witness on the duties of a deputy overman, when it was ascertained that the rules handed to the coroner and those in the possession of Mr. Sharp did not agree. Mr. Sharp: What is the date of those rules? — The Coroner: 1874. — Mr. Sharp: I have later that those. — The Coroner said the rules had been handed to him that morning by the manager, and the manager had better go and get the special rules relating to the colliery. Upon the rules being produced and examined in reference to the banksman's duty, the Coroner said they were precisely the same as the copy he had received. — Mr. Sharp: They are not. — The Coroner: If you don't behave yourself I shall be obliged to take strong measures. — Mr. Sharp: Let us have justice. — The Coroner: I have read the rules, and they agree. William Cameron deposed that the copy he had produced had been certified by the Government Inspector, and that the copy he had handed to the coroner was exactly the same. — Mr. Sharp: Well, I dispute the pair of them. — The Coroner: I can't permit you to go on any further in this way. — Mr. Sharp said the rules he had were certified by the name of the manager, and he wanted to put questions on the rules in force, and not on anything that was made to be covered up. — The coroner could see the copy he had. — The Coroner said he did not want to see it. Walter Gribbin was re-called, and a series of questions were out to him by Mr. Sharp. He did not hear Allan Boyd say, "We'll have the props and Holliday upon us before we get to the bottom of the pit." — The Coroner directed that Boyd, Carruthers, and Veitch should be sent for. John Hayes, re-called, in answer to Mr. Sharp, said he thought Holliday handed his saw to Greener. He did not expect Holliday to go down with them, as he was told to go down in the next cage. Two cages went down before the banksmen went on duty. There were seven officials who usually went down before the men arrived. The cage would take eight men at a time. Other questions were put and answered. — The Coroner: We have had every one of these questions before. — Mr. Sharp: You are to blame for it, Mr. Coroner. — The Coroner: It's pitiable, isn't it? — Other questions followed. — The Coroner: You are trying the patience of the jurymen, I think. — Mr. Sharp said he ought to be treated with respect. The law gave him a right to be present. — The Coroner: The law does not. It is a special favour I give you. — Mr. Sharp: The law gives me the power. — The Coroner: Don't let us discuss it. You think so, doubtless. Proceed with your questions. — Mr. Sharp: How can I when you go on with a lot of insinuating nonsense all the time? You don't give time to collect my thoughts. — The Coroner: Put your questions. John Greener, recalled, stated in answer to Mr. Sharp that Holliday handed him the saw, and he handed it to Gribbin. Allan Boyd, examined by Mr. Sharp at the request of Mrs. Holliday, said the deceased handed his saw to Greener and said he had two props. He went for the props. He could not say whether Holliday had any knowledge that the cage had been knocked away. Witness made a remark to the effect that Holliday would be coming after them. — The Coroner: What do you mean by that? — I thought that as the cage was there when he went away that the deceased might have tumble down the shaft. I thought he might have opened the door. — The Coroner: But supposing he had come to the door would he have been able to see the cage? — Well, I think so. — By the Inspector: I did not hear Gribbin tell Holiday that he could come down by the next cage, nor anyone else. I was next to John Gribbin. I did not hear Greener say so either. Thomas Corbet, a deputy, said he heard Gribbin tell Holliday to come down by the next cage. He never heard the remark that Holliday would be coming after them. William Carruthers, miner, said he had heard since the accident that Boyd had said that Holliday would be coming after them, but didn't hear it said in the cage. William Veitch, deputy overman, gave similar evidence, and said that he heard Gribbin say there were plenty in the cage already. John Hayes was re-called a second time, and retracted his statement that he heard some one in the cage say that Holliday and the wood would be coming after them. He meant that the wood and Holliday would follow by the next cage. The Coroner then summed up, and pointed out that the evidence did not clearly show how the accident had happened. The jury returned the following verdict: "That the deceased, Joseph Holliday, came by his death through falling down the shaft, but there is now evidence to show the cause. The jury recommended that men and wood should not ride together on the same cage." — A juryman: Some of the jury have a strong opinion that the loading of the cage with wood was the cause of the man's death. — The Coroner: It only shows the value of your suggestion that in some collieries there are special rules preventing men and wood riding down together. — Mr. Oswald: That is so. Several of the jury said it ought not to be allowed. — The inquiry lasted over five hours.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||