|
21st July 1887 Fatal Mining Accident At SalterThe Coroners Views On The Examination Of Ore MinesYesterday (Wednesday) an inquest was held at the offices of the Salter Hall Mining Company on the body of Robert Courtney, who met his death in the mines at Salter on Monday, through a fall of roof. Mr. Webster, coroner for the lordship of Egremont, conducted the inquiry, and the foreman of the jury was Mr. Anthony Spedding. The deputy-inspector of mines for the district (Mr. Oswald) was also present. — The first witness called was the father of the deceased, Thomas Courtney, of Caldbeck, near Wigton, who said that he was a miner. He identified the body of the deceased, who died on Monday, the 18th of July. Deceased was 32 years of age, and he was married, having four children. — Alfred Armfield, a fellow workman of the deceased, said that on the 18 inst., witness was working in the Ann Pit, and between nine and ten a.m. he heard that an accident had happened. He then ran to where a fall had taken place. Robert Courtney was buried in metal and cill. John Garvey was with witness, and set to work to dig out the deceased. He was alive, and witness spoke to him. A quantity of metal had hid deceased from them at first. This they removed, and found that deceased was fast with metal and cill upon his back. They had to put two head trees in the working in order to get him out, a precaution used as much for their own protection as anything else. Before they could get these things in the man was dead. Before that deceased spoke to witness telling them to "be sharp" and get him out. About two hours elapsed before altogether in getting him out. Witness could not say where the fall came from. Witness could not say what sort of a working the one in question was. He had never worked in it. The man was beneath a weight which witness roughly estimated at three or four tons. The place was "a rise" working. There was timber in the rise working. He considered it was sufficiently wooded. One headtree was lying down. The crosspiece was lying alongside of him. Deceased had been working beyond where his body was found, two or three months ago. Deceased had been working a week in the same spot, so he had a chance to see if it was properly wooded. Larry Borland had to come round to see that the place was properly wooded. Witness could not say if Borland had been in the working places of the deceased and or his (witness's). — John Garvey, another workman at the Salter Mines, who was in the same pit as deceased, said that at 9.30 a.m. he heard of the accident, and helped to take the man out. Witness saw Larry Borland, the overman, at the time they took deceased out. Witness know they working, which he should describe as a "rise" working. It went up, perhaps a couple of fathoms. The man was about 7 ft. up it. The working was well wooded. The timber had not broke; it had evidently slipped. — Thomas Kitchin, a workman at the Ann Pit, said that on the 18th he was working with the deceased man in No. 4 Company. Before going into the working he did not see the man Borland. It was Borland's duty to examine the working, and either he or Jackson Casson generally came through the working to see if they were safe. He was not there, however, before the accident happened. Before commencing work he and deceased, who worked together, examined the rise drift. They found it had gone into an old working, and they did not consider it safe, and intended to put in some more wood. When the accident occurred both of them were sitting, and he was about to take up a pick to make a footing under a crosshead when the fall took place. It knocked deceased into the side of the working and witness down the rise. When witness "gathered himself up" he could hear deceased shouting, "Come, and help me out." Witness was badly hurt, and was twenty minutes before he recovered. They did not touch the wood supports. The accident was the result of some earth having fallen away. The place where they were about to put supports was not in their working, but it was only about a yard off, and a very small bit. If they had remained in their own place they would have been injured, as the cill and metal fell upon it. — The Coroner: Was it not necessary that your working should be examined? — Witness: We examined it, and found it safe. — How could it be safe if you were obliged to wood it? How long is it since any of the foremen inspected it? Friday afternoon. I don't know about Saturday. It was Jackson Casson, and he said it was safe. — Did he look at this place? We had not "holed it" in to another working. There was nobody there on Monday. — In reply to Mr. Oswald, the witness said that the place was only holed in Friday night. They had plenty of timber. — Jackson Casson, overman, said that it was his duty to examine the working places. He went on duty on the 18th at one a.m. on the surface. He went down the pit about 9.30, because of the accident. — The Coroner: What time do the men go to work? — Witness: About six o'clock. — The Coroner: If it is your duty to examine these working places don't you think it would be much better if you examined them before the men went to work? — Well, I could not examine them all. — Well, you see you didn't examine any. Not that morning. — When was the last time you examined them? Saturday afternoon I examined that working, but no one was present. — What condition did you find it in? Oh, all right. I didn't see that it was holed in. I could not see it because they had not quite done it. — Oh, but I think that the contrary is proved. Were you not aware that they "holed through" on Friday night? No, sir, I was not. — If you examined it you would have seen it. How was it you didn't see it? If it was "holed through" I would. — The evidence is that it was. Well, it might have been filled up. Something might have fallen and filled up the hole. — Did it strike you that this place was dangerous? — No. Well, but you see these men found it necessary to "wood" it. — We always do upon broken ground. I did not advise the men to do this. If I had seen that this place was "holed through" it would have made a decided difference in my opinion. — Deceased's father said he desired to ask a question. He said: Would it be any benefit to them to block up the hole? No; not a bit. Sometimes it is done. Not with ore; only when it is fixed. It could not have been any benefit to them upon this occasion. — In reply to Mr. Oswald, witness said that he saw no cause to give the deceased any special orders when he visited the working on Saturday. He always examined the workings either at ten o'clock, one o'clock, or two o'clock. — The Coroner: That is a very bad arrangement. You should see that these places are safe for men to go there. — Witness: The place was safe when I examined it. — The Coroner: It was not safe though. — Witness: In the opinion of a working man it was safe. — The Coroner: There are certain men who have to examine these workings, and if they don't do their duty men's lives have to be sacrificed. I have a very strong opinion on this point. — The Inspector having briefly examined the witness, the Coroner summed up. In doing so, he said: As I said to the last witness, I have a very strong opinion with regard to the way in which mine owners in this district should see to the examination of the places where men work in the iron-ore mines. By a certain Act of Parliament in coalmines the working places of the men have to be examined before the men go to work, and there is careful provision made for the protection of life. I think it is much to be regretted that some such provision is not made for the safety of the miners in iron-ore pits. I have held the office of coroner for some considerable time, and I don't remember that I have sat on an inquest on any man who was killed in a coalmine in this district from a fall of the side, or the roof of a working place. I regret to say I have held a very great many inquests where men have been killed by falls from the roofs or sides of working places in ore mines, and therefore I consider that it is very desirable, indeed, that before the men go to work these places should be carefully examined by some person in authority on behalf of the owners of the pits. I am generally told that men are set apart for this duty, and as has been stated by Jackson Casson they sometimes do it in the course of the day, without any specified time being set apart for it, but just when it is most convenient to themselves. Were they compelled, as in the coalmines, to examine the workings at a specified time, probably we should have fewer of these accidents. I sincerely hope that the iron-ore proprietors and owners of mines in the district will endeavour to compel these men whom they employ and pay to do it, and see that they discharge their duties in such a manner as will ensure the safety of the others whom they employ. All of you are engaged in iron-ore mining, and you are therefore peculiarly interested in this question. The fact that it is another man's duty to examine the workings does not, however, relieve you from examining them yourselves, and making yourselves safe, as far as possible. In the course of further remarks, the Coroner pointed out that in the case before them there was no criminal neglect. — The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||