Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

13th January 1887

The Recent Fatal Accident At Knockmurton

Adjourned Inquest, Yesterday

The Right Of Pit Managers To Attend Inquests

Yesterday (Wednesday) forenoon the adjourned inquest on the body of Francis Cross, a lad of 15, living in James Street, Frizington, who was killed on Saturday week in No. 2 pit of the Knockmurton Mining Co., was resumed at Yeathouse Hotel by Mr. J. Webster (Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont) and a jury, over which Mr. Hodgson was chosen foreman.

Mr. James Willis (the Government Inspector of Mines, from Newcastle) and Mr. R. P. W. Oswald (the Deputy Inspector from Brigham) were present. Mr. E. Atter represented the father of the deceased, and Mr. Rankin the Mining Co.

Mr. Richards (as a witness was about to give evidence): Mr. Coroner, would it not be advisable, before this witness gives evidence, to ask Mr. Rankin to withdraw, because his presence might influence the witnesses?

The Coroner: who is Mr. Rankin?

Mr. Rankin: I represent the Knockmurton Company, and I claim the right to be here. The Coroner said Mr. Rankin was entitled to be present; it was only fair that he should be.

Mr. Atter: I ask the right to represent the father of the deceased.

The Coroner: Oh, certainly. (To Mr. Richards, who again made an observation relative to the presence of Mr. Rankin): I don't know anything about the matter; but if the company are to blame — I don't know whether they are or not, but they may be — it is right that they should have an opportunity of being here to defend themselves. But I must again warn you gentlemen, that anything you have heard outside, you must not allow to influence you in any way. You must take the evidence as it comes before you in this court, and on that evidence you will give your verdict.

Mr. Hetherington: Mr. Coroner, this is very unfair, I think.

The Coroner: What is very unfair? This about Mr. Rankin.

The Coroner: Now, listen: A question may arise as to whether the Company is to blame. Then the Company must be represented. How can they defend themselves if they are not?

Mr. Hetherington: Well, I think they should have sent a solicitor instead of one of their managers.

The Coroner: I don't know whether they have sent a solicitor or not; but I shall have a full enquiry, and I shall not allow anyone to interfere with the witnesses whilst they are giving their evidence. I cannot permit this discussion. Now, Mr. Rankin, you must not interfere at any time, except at such times as you and representatives of the deceased shall have full opportunity of putting such questions as you think desirable in this matter. Do you raise any objection, Mr. Atter?

Mr. Atter: I certainly must say, sir, that I think the remarks of the jury are very proper. I think there is intimidation, or may be intimidation, by the presence of Mr. Rankin.

The Coroner: I certainly cannot see it.

Mr. Richards: I certainly---.

The Coroner: I have decided the matter.

Mr. Richards: Well, I don't see that the Coroner should have the power to decide such a matter.

The Coroner: Well, I intend to do. Now don't let us have any more discussion on the matter.

Robert Jopson, 8, Chapel-Row, Rowrah, said the deceased, who worked in No. 2 Pit, the property of Messrs. Baird & Co., with himself, was a hanger-on at the incline foot. About nine o'clock witness was walking up and down near to the deceased boy, waiting for a bogey to come up, so that he could fill it with metal. The boy was engaged uncoupling two full bogies, which were standing on a siding.

Mr. Thom, jun., an engineer in the employ of the Company, here put in a plan of the workings, prepared on a scale of half an inch to the foot. Witness went on to say that he did not know whether it was the duty of the deceased to uncouple the bogies or not. He did not know whether the deceased was in his proper place or not; but he had seen him there before — it was the place where he was usually stationed. How far was he from the incline foot at this time? I don't know.

Mr. Rankin here leaned over to the coroner as though about to speak.

The Coroner: Now, Mr. Rankin, will you please not interfere — or whatever your name is, I don't know?

Witness went on to say that the deceased had just arrived at the place mentioned when a stone fell from the roof, hit him on the left temple, and killed him.

The drift had five sets of wood from the commencement of it towards where the deceased was standing. There was no wood supporting the roof above where the boy was standing. Archie Thom was the overman in that place where the deceased was killed. Witness had not seen the overman in the drift on the morning of the 31st of December. Besides Thom there was also a deputy-overman, Alfred Litt.

Witness could not say whose duty it was to examine the working. It would be the duty of Thom or Litt. Witness saw Litt in the crosscut that morning; he was keeping the men in order. There was now five pieces of wood put in to support the roof from which fell the stone that killed the deceased. He did not know when the wood was put in.

Mr. Lowden: Did you consider the roof where the boy was standing was safe?

Witness: Yes, I had been under it myself five minutes before. I never had any fear of it. What sort of a roof was it? Hard stone. — Are there any breaks or cracks in the roof? I don't know; I don't examine them.

The Coroner: No, no; Mr. Lowden asks you a very proper question — Were there any cracks in the roof? No, not that I have seen.

Mr. Lowden: How high is the roof? About 5ft. 6in. — Where this piece fell was it from a back or from between two cracks? It came off by a back. — What size might the stone be that fell? — About two stones or two stones and a half. I never lifted it.

Mr. Hetherington: What position was the boy in when the stone fell? He was in a leaning position.

Mr. Richards: Were there any other stones fell? Yes there were others; this was the only one that hit the boy. What was the width of the road? About four feet. How long had this place stood unwooded? A long time. — Have there been any men working in the crosscut making the road wider as of late? Yes.

By another juryman: It was my duty when I had a full bogie to trail it on to the siding.

By Mr. Hetherington: There had been no dressing down at this cutting since the boy was killed.

By another juryman: It was the trailers' duty to take the bogies when they were filled at the hopper to the crosscut.

Mr. Atter: Has any one connected with the pit spoken to you about your evidence? No, no one. — No one at all? No. — How long have you been in the pit? I have been there about three years and four months. — And during that time you have never seen any wooding nor sounding done in this drift? No; but it has been put in. — Is there anyone present affecting you in the way in which you give your evidence? No, no one. I am afraid of no one. I am not coming here with a lot of lies in my mouth. — Are you aware that a stone fell about five minutes before the deceased was killed, and struck a man named Styles? No. — Have these alterations in the way of widening been done since the accident? No.

Mr. Willis: Was this known to be a bad roof or a good roof? I never examined it.

By Mr. Rankin: He could not tell how many times he had seen the deceased in the crosscut. He had seen him often at the incline foot. — You consider the working perfectly safe. — Yes. — And you would pass through it tomorrow? Yes. — With as much assurance as ever? Yes.

Mr. Atter. You see the way in which the questions are put sir.

The Coroner: Yes; I am not taking it down, and I will not comment upon it in addressing the jury.

Isaac Holmes, Kirkland, who was working in No. 2 Pit at the time of the accident, said that he was standing a few yards away from the deceased when he was struck. The duties of the deceased, who was a hanger-on, were to hook the empty bogies on to a chain at the bottom of the incline, and take the full ones off when they came down. The fall would be about eight or nine cwt. There was a slape back where the fall came from.

John Skimming, Kirkland, said he worked in the same pit as the deceased. He was engaged in December last in widening the crosscut in which the deceased was killed. He had an opportunity of examining the roof, and he thought the place was very safe. All the stone that was taken away in the course of these widening operations had to be blasted. The cause of the recent fall was that there had been a joint in the rock, from which a part of the roof had fallen. He examined the place carefully, and he was of opinion that it would not have shown any indication of a parting before the fall. — It was the hardest stone in the place. Even had it been sounded he did not think that it would have been found to be loose. The quantity of stone, which fell, was about half a bogey. The deceased had no duties to perform at the crosscut. His business was to hang-on at the incline. There were five sets of timber in the cross-cut. Witness put them in under the direction of Mr. Thom. There were only five put in because no more were required. If it had been wooded up to where the boy was standing he supposed the accident would have been prevented; but it would have taken a lot of work to do that.

Here, (at one o'clock) the Coroner adjourned the Court for half an hour.

After the adjournment Skimming's evidence was again taken.

By Mr. Atter: No directions were ever given to examine to me by anyone connected with the pit to sound and examine the roof, and I was never asked about its condition. If the place had been wooded the accident would not have happened.

By Mr. Willis: I did the widening and wooding at so much a fathom. I made no examination of the roof after the 23rd of December last. The stone could not have fallen between the setts if the place had been wooded, as there is no cross covering in the setts.

Alfred Litt, deputy-overman, said it was his duty to see the workings were safe, and he and Mr. Thom were the responsible parties. He admitted that, in some instances, he had, in places in the pit, noticed stone that was a little sprung. He did not consider it necessary to wood the working. He accounted for the fall through the stone having been shaken by shots, and it must have been overlooked. Possibly, if it had been sounded it might have sounded sprung.

By a juror: Outside where the fall took place the roof adjoining is a little sprung. I did not know of this till after the accident.

By Mr. Atter: If this place had been wooded the accident would not have occurred. There were probably 40 men using the cross-cut daily. I cannot say that I ever examined the stone which fell.

By Mr. Willis: I am not accustomed to examine the workings before the men go to work.

Archibald Thom, the manager of the mines, stated that the deceased had no right to be in the cross-cut. His duties were solely at the incline foot. He had both before and after the accident examined the roof. The workings were perfectly safe. The roof is in good condition. It is not now sprung that I can check. If the roof had been sounded on the morning of the accident most probably it would have been detected as being loose.

By Mr. Atter: I am in the pit daily. I never saw the deceased in the cross-cut. If I had seen him there I probably should not have found fault with him beyond asking why he was there. I never had any complaint made to me of the deceased being in the cross-cut. There were no written or printed rules for the guidance of the deceased, nor anyone to work with him. I have been connected with mining works for the last 20 years.

By Mr. Willis: The witness did not know much of the Metalliferous Mines Act.

James Styles, a trailer in the mines, said that on the day of the accident, whilst he was engaged in the cross-cut he heard a shout, and got out of the way, when a fall of stone fell close to where he was. The deceased came and assisted him to get the stone away. About twenty-five minutes afterwards another fall of stone took place, and the deceased was hit and killed. Witness never mentioned the fall from which he had escaped to anyone.

The Coroner then had the evidence read over and summed up to the jury.

He congratulated them that amongst them they had several practical and experienced miners. Also, that there were present the two Government inspectors. He desired it to be universally known, not only for that case, but for all others, that where any person undertook any special duty they were bound to execute it in an efficient manner, and if they neglected it they were to be held fully responsible for the consequences. He hoped that shortly the same regulations as applied to coal mines would be adopted in the case of iron-ore mines, and that the workings would have daily to be examined and reported upon.

After the Coroner had concluded his address, the jury asked that the inspector who had examined the workings should favour them as an independent person with his evidence, and this was assented to.

Ralph Patterson William Oswald, said he lived at Brigham. He was the deputy-inspector of mines, acting as assistant to Mr. Willis, the inspector. On the 4th inst. he examined the cross-cut in No. 2, Knockmurton Mine, at the place where the deceased was killed. He saw the stone, which was pointed out to him as the one which had fallen and killed him. The roof immediately above the place from where the stone fell was quite sound. He considered, from appearances, that if the piece of stone had been examined by a hammer that it could have been told if it was safe or not. He also examined the adjoining stone, and did not consider it very sound. He noticed the timbering; it was put in well, and of good quality.

By a juror; If I was a miner I should not have cared to have worked under the roof as I saw it, as a portion of it ought to have been taken down. It does not now need timbering. I am speaking only since the accident.

By Mr. Atter: I consider the widening of the cross-cut the cause of the accident. There was the firing of the shots, and I consider the span of the cutting too wide for the existing condition of the stone.

The jury were then left to consider their verdict at twenty-five minutes to six o'clock, and at six o'clock they found that the deceased was killed by a stone falling upon him, and they also found that there had been great error of judgement committed by Thom and Litt in not having heightened the arch or wooded the cross-cut.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Solicitor  
Baird, —    Mine Owner  
Cross, Francis   16 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hetherington, —      
Hodgson, —    Jury Foreman  
Holmes, Isaac    Miner  
Jopson, Robert    Miner  
Litt, Alfred    Deputy Overman  
Lowden, —      
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Deputy Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Rankin, —    Manager  
Richards, —      
Skimming, John    Miner  
Styles, James    Trailer  
Thom, —    Engineer  
Thom, Archibald    Manager  Whos Who Page
Webster, John    Coroner  
Willis, James    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Knockmurton (Iron Ore)  Knockmurton (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print