|
25th November 1886 Fatal Accident At Pallaflat MinesOn Friday morning last a fatal accident occurred at the Pallaflat iron-ore mines, owned by the Maryport Iron and Steel Company. John Minhennet, a married man, 54 years of age, and living in Queen-street, Cleator Moor, was working along with his son and another man when they were alarmed by the sound of timber cracking. They immediately stopped work and ran off. Unfortunately Minhennet ran in the direction of the fall, and before he had time to retrace his steps he was crushed by the falling timber and metal and earth, being killed instantaneously. It is estimated that there was a fall of 100 tons. The Inquest. On Tuesday afternoon, at the Queens Arms Hotel, Mr. J. Webster, with a jury, of which Mr. H. Ward was chosen foreman, resumed the inquest, which was opened on Friday, and adjourned for the purpose of enabling the Government Inspector to be present. — Mr. Oswald, Brigham (deputy-inspector of mines for the Newcastle district) was in attendance. — Mr. Brown was present on behalf of the Company. — James Minhennet stated that the deceased was his father, and that he came by his death whilst working in the mines of the Pallaflat Company, at a quarter to nine on Friday morning. He was working along with his father at the time, in solid ore, and they were slipping the side of the pillar. On one side of them was an open drift. At the side of the pillar they had worked upwards about two fathoms. And as they went along they wooded it. Neither witness nor his father put any of the wood in. It was wooded by Patrick Porter, John Murray, James Atkinson, and John Atkinson. Witness thought the wood which was put in was sufficient. The ore was not of a loose character, but if a pillar was left pieces would be constantly crumbling away. Witness was not aware that there was any water there, though he had been told that an incline above them was full of water. — By the inspector: The deceased had told witness that he thought the working was a little unsafe; he did not say how. — By the Coroner: He heard Regan and Phillip Waters, and Cavan Burns talking together on Friday morning, and he heard one of them say that the working was unsafe at their side. The ore fell about an hour and a half afterwards. Henry Fisher and Wilson Wright were both in the working that morning, before the accident happened, to examine the working. Witness did not say anything to them about having heard that it was unsafe; he did not think anything about it. — By the inspector: No shots had been fired that morning in the working. — By Mr. Brown: He never heard anything before Friday morning about the place being unsafe. — Robert Kinnish, Scalegill, said he heard the deceased say that the working that the working was dangerous, two days before the accident. He had himself heard the woodwork creaking, and a day or two before one or two of the heads were broken by the weight there was on them. They were repaired by legs being put under them. — Wilson Wright, an overman at the Pallaflat mines, said it was his duty to see that the working places were properly wooded and in a safe condition. He was not at Minhennet's working place on the morning of the accident. He visited it on the previous day, and examined the working on that occasion. The roof was supported by uprights and cross-trees. There were six or seven feet of ore lying bodily on the wood, and it would be a great weight. If there was any water it would come quickly. There was a little water, and he knew that was dangerous. The wood seemed to take the weight gradually, and he thought the wood sufficiently strong to bear it. He did notice that the first crosstree and the third were bending, and that props had been put under them. None of the other headtrees were broken, and he noticed no other prop. If he had seen the two props put and the head-trees broken, he would have ordered "middle legs" to have been put in. They were a little bent. The first was the worst. — The Inspector: That bore the weight of the lot, and was the key to everyone in the place. — By the Inspector: The greatest distance between the timbers was not over three feet. When I was in I considered it was a completely safe place — A juryman asked the witness if the wooding was sufficient to bear the weight of the ore, how it was that it had come down so suddenly? — The witness said he could not say. The ore was short, crumbling stuff, and very soft. — The Coroner: And therefore requires greater precaution in working? — Witness: Yes. — Did you know it was in a dangerous condition? — No. It was not so reported to me by Minhennet or any one else. Minhennet never complained to me about it being dangerous. — Henry Fisher, overman, gave similar evidence. — The Coroner, in summing up, said he thought it was much to be regretted that no steps were taken to protect these men in a better way than was the case. Minhennet was certainly an experienced miner, and if he thought the working dangerous he could have left it. A life had been lost, and, from what the inspector had told him, the whole of the six men might have also have lost their lives. — The Foreman said he should like to have Mr. Brown's opinion as to the cause of the fall. — Mr. Brown was then sworn, and stated that the wooding, as a rule, gave some warning of a fall, but this wood could not have given any warning. The Pallaflat ore was like shot or a bag of meal, and if there was a hole it would run away; and his impression was that it got away at the face, and the weight then on the wood, which was bound to give way. — A juryman said if it ran at the face it ought to have been "spiled." — Mr. Brown said they used to do that, but they had not done it lately. — The Coroner: What strikes me as most extraordinary is that it should have come away in such a sudden manner. — The Inspector: I should advise Mr. Brown to "spile" these places. Pallaflat ore was like Furness ore, and no head-tree was put in without spiles. — The room was cleared for the jury to consider their verdict. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death," and attached blame to no one.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||