Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

9th September 1886

West Cumberland Miners Union

Demonstration At Whitehaven

On Monday last the second annual demonstration of the Whitehaven Miners' Association was celebrated by a procession, tea, public meeting, and ball. At two o'clock about 200 members formed in procession at the top of the Ginns, and headed by the Whitehaven Colliery Brass Band, together with the handsome banner of the Union, paraded the principal streets of the town, terminating their peregrinations in the Market-place. Tea was provided in the Market Hall, and upwards of 500 persons partook of the excellent meal provided by the committee. The following ladies presided at the tables:— Mrs. Christian, Mrs. J. Wilson, Mrs. Sprouston, Mrs. Snoddon, Mrs. Tubman, Mrs. Merriner, Mrs. Cooper, Mrs. Hawkins, Mrs. McCourt, Mrs. Davidson, Mrs. Cragg, Mrs. Shimmins, Mrs. McCartney, Mrs. Lynch, Miss Watson, Miss Davidson, Miss Walker, Miss Moore, and Miss Dunn.

A public meeting was held in the Market Hall in the evening. Mr. T. Bowman occupied the chair, and there were also on the platform: — Mr. A. Sharp (secretary to the West Cumberland Miners' Association, Maryport), Mr. Hugh Davey (president of the Whitehaven Lodge), Mr. J. Wilson (secretary), Mr. J. Cant, Mr. S. Dunn, Mr. J. Kelly, Mr. A. Little, and Mr. W. Cooper. The Colliery Band was in attendance, and played one or two selections in the course of the evening.

The CHAIRMAN said he must congratulate them on the success so far of the anniversary of their Union. He thought it unmistakably proved the fact that the Union was still full of vitality — (hear, hear) — and that their interest in it was as strong as ever. He must especially congratulate them on the success of their tea meeting in the afternoon. It showed by the quantity of food that was consumed that they were in a healthy condition. ("Hear, hear," and laughter.) It also showed that they did not give, and that they were not likely to give, much employment to the doctors. (Laughter.) Despite the vindictive attacks, which had been launched by certain parties against the Union, he thought it had proved its usefulness in Whitehaven — (hear, hear) — by obtaining the redress of obvious grievances. (Applause.) He need not particularize anything more than when he mentioned the fact that they had been enabled to get check-weighmen appointed at all the different pits. He thought that showed that the miner was now in a position to get full justice, and when he sent up his tub he knew that he could get full weight allowed him. (Applause.) Previously that state of things did not exist, and for their present advantages he thought they were in a large degree indebted to the Union. (Applause.) He was fully aware that this Union did not give unmixed pleasure to certain parties; but he conceived that it was extremely bad taste of certain colliery officials, who never neglected an opportunity to cast discredit upon the Union. He thought they would be much better employed attending to their duties than in trying to injure poor men struggling to obtain redress for the grievances, which, as they all know, existed in their collieries. (Applause.) He dared say many of them would have found out that there were a class of men in this who were very intolerant. If others did not see eye to eye with them in religion or in politics, they were apt to be regarded as fools or madmen. ("Hear, hear," and laughter.) Now he had very little sympathy with this class. He believed in liberality of views as well as liberality of purse. He believed that every man had been endowed by God with an intellect; and he maintained that every man had a right to act in accordance with the dictates of that intellect. (Applause.) He had that afternoon some conversation with their agent, Mr. Sharp, who assured him that wherever a union a good strong union — was in existence in any colliery district it was always opposed to strikes, and strikes were generally prevented, because the union was based upon sound and sensible principles, and the managers of the union invariably endeavoured, where grievances existed, and where differences arose, to get them settled in an amicable manner. (Applause.) Before a strike could take place in any colliery he was informed that in the first place it had to be voted upon by, he believed, two-thirds of the men; two-thirds of the men had to say that a strike should take place; and in addition to that it had to be confirmed — he believed he was right in saying it had to be confirmed by the Executive Council, at any rate it had to be confirmed in a certain manner before the men could adopt such an extreme measure as a strike, in order to obtain the redress of their grievances. (Hear, hear.) He held that strikes were antiquated and a very foolish way of seeking to set right any abuse, either in a colliery or any other concern. (Hear, hear.) They all knew far better than he could tell them, that a collier's life was a peculiarly dangerous one. He was beset with dangers the moment he descended into the bowels of the earth. Metaphorically speaking, he might be said to carry his life in his hand. Happily in this part of the country they were free from the great disasters which too often happened in South Wales, in Scotland, and in other parts of the country; but very often accidents were caused by neglecting the observance of recognised rules — too often were they caused by carelessness. He was reading the other day in a paper some statistics regarding accidents in coalmines. They were of such striking character that perhaps they would not think he was taking up their time unduly, if he drew their attention to one or two of the facts, which he there found, stated. No less than 36,000 miners, it was said had been hurried into eternity by accidents in coalmines in this country during the last 30 years; and 2,700,000 had received injuries during the same period. Every year some 12,000 men lost their lives in collieries, and between 90,000 and 100,000 — something like five times the population of this town — were injured every year by accidents, which they met with in following their dangerous occupation in the dark recesses of the earth. Now, it was obvious that if coalmining was such a dangerous occupation men who followed this work should be paid wages in some measure in accordance with the danger of their business. ("Hear, hear," and applause.) He thought it was a very reasonable contention that men who followed very dangerous employments should be paid on a higher scale than those whose occupation involved no such risk of life or limb. During the last twelve and previous to the last twelve months he regretted to say, and they regretted as well, that they had had to submit several important reductions in their wages. Now these reductions had not arisen through any fault of their employers, but had been caused by the state of trade generally. They all knew that the depression in the coal trade at the present time was very acute. Iron-ore was only selling at 9s per ton, and coal was selling at a very low price. As different qualities of coal varied so much in price he was not in a position to quote figures, but they well knew that it was selling at a very low price. Various causes were assigned for this depression in trade. Some said that it was caused by tariffs, which had a prejudicial effect upon trade. Some said it was caused by the falling off — a very grave falling off — which had been taking place for a long time in the price of silver. But he believed the real cause was to be found in over production — (applause); — and until consumption should overtake production they could not expect to see much improvement in trade. (Hear, hear.) Whatever the cause might be that operated to produce this state of trade he was glad to say, and he believed he had good grounds for stating it, that within the last few months there appeared to be a break in the clouds; and it was believed the depression which had so long prevailed in trade was at last passing away. In several important trades in this country there was a marked improvement — in the textile and in the woollen trades; and he hoped before long they would find it in the coal trade. ("Hear, hear," and applause.) He had no hesitation in saying that trade would improve, and that before long they would find a considerable revival. He hoped that before their next annual meeting they would have a return of that prosperity which in former years they so long enjoyed. He had now the greatest pleasure in calling upon their respected agent, who had done valiant work for the colliers in this part of the country — Mr. Andrew Sharp. (Applause.)

Mr. ANDREW SHARP said he had very great pleasure in being amongst them on the occasion of their second annual demonstration. He need not tell them the objects of union. They were well known amongst the working class. Unionism had made great headway, and though the headway that had been made had perhaps not always been maintained, still, however they might have been driven back, they had always had sufficient strength and vitality left them to recover their forces and resume their onward march in the direction of justice and equity. (Applause.) They had been told that their organisation was solely used for the purpose of promoting strikes; but he might say that their Union was opposed to the principle of strikes, and it sought only to defend the rights of working men. Of course, when they were attacked and compelled to fight they did not shrink from the contest. He remembered on one occasion being at a meeting where the coal proprietors acknowledged that in trying to crush the spirit of unionism they had lost more than £70,000. But they had not succeeded; and now when disagreements arose, proprietors were ready to submit them to arbitration — a system which the Union always sought to employ. They had been told, too, over and over again — though there was nobody told them except at Whitehaven — that they were a political party and that their organization was used solely for a certain political purpose. ("No, its not.") They all knew, however, that every man in the Union might belong to whatever political party he liked; he might profess any religion he chose. They only banded themselves together for the purpose of protecting their own interests and remedying abuses; and in this direction they had done much. (Applause.) He dared say many of them would have been rather shocked at reading an article, which appeared last week in the Whitehaven papers respecting the treatment of miners in Belgium; but they were no worse in Belgium than they were in England fifty years since. And in Belgium they were adopting the principle, which had worked so well in this country in bringing about a better state of things — the principle of trades unionism. (Applause.) Mr. Sharp went on to deal with the market price of coal, comparing it with the amount of wages paid to the miners in Whitehaven and other parts of the country. In Whitehaven, he said, the men were fined when they sent up small coal, although this was in no way their own fault. They might load a tub with large pieces, and by the time it had travelled over a bad road, and got to the top it might be converted, to a very large extent, into dust. The Whitehaven collieries were the only ones in the country where this fine was imposed; and a County Court Judge in Wales had ruled that the men had no rights to be fined for such a thing, as they had no responsibility over the tub. What would be thought if large coal loaded in a vessel got so knocked about in the course of a stormy passage that it was broken up into slack and the consignee claimed damages from the colliery proprietors? What was fair for the men was fair for the proprietors. (Applause.) What they wanted was simply justice and nothing more; and until they got justice the labour organisation would never cease its operations, or abate its activity. They had to contend with the employers in some instances; but there were certain influences, which operated against them more prejudicially than the opposition of the capitalist, and that was when they had dissenters in their own ranks. (Applause.) A man might be bought — Dan O'Connell used to say that any many could be bought if you could find his price. He was sorry to say the price of a man in their own ranks was in some cases very low. (Laughter and applause.) But when a man allowed himself to be bought over he was not only selling himself but he was selling his fellow men. And when a man had done all he could to injure his brother-workmen could he ask a medal of honour from anybody for it? Could he look upon his action as anything like an honourable one? ("No, no," and applause.) Let every man who left the ranks leave them honourably, and not sell the secrets of those whom he had left. There were men now occupying prominent positions who had sprung from amongst the ordinary miners; but they were honourable men, and they did not turn round upon the workmen immediately that they were raised above them. In either the Whitehaven collieries or anywhere else men who disagreed with the Union had a right to leave it; but he hoped such men would show them that respect to which they were entitled. They (the Unionists) always treated them with every kindness; and he trusted that so far as Whitehaven was concerned they might look upon it in future as one of the leading organisations of this county. (Applause.)

Mr. HUGH DAVEY said he had a very pleasing duty to perform, and that was to present Mr. Dunn with a purse of gold. (Applause.) He need not explain to them the services Mr. Dunn had rendered to their Union. What he had done for them would be fresh in their memories. He had great pleasure, on behalf of the Union, in presenting Mr. Dunn with this money, and he hoped he would render the same services in the future as he had done previously. (Applause.)

The CHAIRMAN said he was very glad to have the opportunity of supporting Mr. Dunn in what he had just done. He believed Mr. Dunn fully deserved what had been given him. He had done good work for the Union in the past, and he (the chairman) was sorry to say that he had been cruelly and vindictively persecuted. But his character had been triumphantly vindicated by a jury of his countrymen; and Mr. Dunn deserved their support.

Mr. A. LITTLE next addressed the meeting. He said M. Dunn had been persecuted, and that there was an arrangement made by a solicitor in Whitehaven about two years ago, to ruin him; and the object of all this was to wreck the Union. But they might as well try to pluck the man from the moon, if there was one there. (Laughter and applause.) There was no power on earth to crush Unionism in England. (Applause.)

Mr. SAMUEL DUNN said he scarcely knew how to thank them for the present they had made him that evening. He could assure them that when he first came to their assistance he had no idea whatever of being re-paid. For his first quarter's services, remuneration was offered him, he refused it. ("You did.") Again and again it was offered him, but he always refused it. ("True.") And he might say this evening that, whatever he might have done in the past, in the future he was still their servant. (Applause.) M. Dunn went on to speak of the manner in which Mr. Little had said he (Mr. Dunn) had been persecuted, and also referred to letters which appeared in local papers with regard to the banner of the Union, in which latter connection he denied that the flag was ever out of his house, except on the night of their demonstration a year ago. With respect to the Union, he said it had done many things for Whitehaven men. What had it done for the girls? Instead of working twelve hours a day, as they used to do, they only worked eight; and now there were, as a consequence, twenty or thirty more girls employed; and they earned the same money in eight hours as they formerly did in twelve. (Applause.) It was said that the Union was driving their daughters to earn their living by the street corners. But had it not resulted in something better — something to benefit both mothers and daughters. Referring to arbitration as opposed to strikes, he said that James Lowther, when he was addressing meetings in Darlington and elsewhere, recommended arbitration as the best means of settling agricultural differences, and therefore he (Mr. Dunn) thought arbitration could not be bad for the miners at Whitehaven. (Applause.) There were those who were desirous of breaking up the Union — those who tried to induce them to go in for separation. But the Union was their cause — the cause of the miners — and he felt sue that it would never be broken up. (Applause.)

Mr. JOHN WILSON, in moving a vote of thanks to the ladies who presided at the tables, denied the statements made by "A Whitehaven Collier" in a letter addressed to a local paper, and referring to a "hole and corner" meeting to have been held in the Ginns.

Mr. W. COOPER, in seconding the vote of thanks, said he would like to address his remarks to the young ladies, and he would point out to them the dangers of a miner's life. As the ball proceeded to night, and on "the light fantastic toe they danced," the miner was at his work. He went at all hours. They would meet him at midnight with a glimmering light — at one, two, and three o'clock in the morning. While they were sleeping the miner was at his work; and he went to the mine with his life in his hand. A simple accident might result in a hundred or two men being killed. Some of these girls would get married some day, but he advised them never to marry a miner. (Laughter.) Let them remember that — never marry a miner. Get some tradesman, or somebody that could lie in bed till six in the morning, go to work at seven, and get his breakfast when he came home, perhaps, at eight, and have two or three pints of ale before he went back to work; but if a miner did that he was a drunken miner. (Laughter and applause.)

Mr. CANT said that he had a resolution to submit to them, but before doing so he would claim their indulgence whilst he made one or two remarks that were not strictly applicable to the proposition he would shortly submit. He said it was a pleasure for him to appear on that platform in order that he might assert that freedom and independence he at all times professed, a freedom and independence which he trusted animated every one present. (Applause.) The chairman, and no doubt many others who were present to-night, were aware that he had been asked to preside at this meeting, but he found that the reasons he gave for not occupying that position had been misinterpreted, and he regretted this all the more because he had only that day learned that the object and desire the committee had in view (in his opinion a very proper desire) was to show that their demonstration or gathering had no political significance, but unfortunately the deputation that waited upon him omitted to so inform him, otherwise he unhesitatingly said that had he known this he would undoubtedly have occupied the chair; however, he trusted that his presence on that platform would amply demonstrate to them the sincerity and truthfulness of his remarks. (Cheers.) The reason he objected to preside was that he thought it would be much better for them to have some older man — he was only a youth and a mere stripling — (laughter) — someone who had resided longer amongst them, and had grater local influence than he had to preside, but it was certainly out of no fear or disrespect for the Whitehaven collier that he declined. (Cheers.) He remarked that he had upon more than one occasion addressed the colliers of Whitehaven, and at times he had had to argue subjects on which he knew they did not all agree with him, but to their credit, be it said, they had upon every occasion accorded him a fair and impartial hearing, and any man who had not the courage or was ashamed of coming amongst the colliers, or any other working men, was not worthy of the name of a man. (Loud applause.) He then remarked that they could not expect him to dwell at any length upon the objects of their Society — that had been fully dealt with in a simple and homely, but eloquent and expressive, way by their representative, Mr. A. Sharp, but he took it that the primary and principle object they had in view was a legitimate object, viz, to protect themselves, but not to be aggressive, and so long as they stuck to the very natural law of protecting themselves, without being aggressive no reasonable being could find fault with them. He then went on to remark that he hoped they would have no greater grievances to rectify in the future than they had had in the past. Strikes were always to be deprecated; and, happily at Whitehaven they had not had occasion to resort to such extreme measures. Capital and labour here had worked hand in hand; master and man had pulled together amicably, and he trusted this very proper feeling would long continue. He advised the men to always act in a conciliatory and moderate way, and remarked that in his opinion they had at the head of affairs in Whitehaven a man and a gentleman in every sense of the word, who would always receive them courteously and listen to anything they had to say — he referred to Mr. Alleyne Robinson — (loud cheers) — and he was certain that if they should have any fresh or legitimate grievances to bring before this gentleman, they might rest assured that any appeal to him would not be in vain. He had listened to the men before, and redressed their grievance; and he felt confident he would so again. (Applause.) Mr. Cant then proposed a vote of thanks to the chairman.

Mr. JOSEPH KELLY seconded the vote of thanks, which was carried, and duly acknowledged. — The room was then cleared for dancing, which was kept up with spirit until the early hours of the morning.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bowman, T.      
Cant, J.      
Christian, —, Mrs.      
Cooper, —, Mrs.      
Cooper, W.      
Cragg, —, Mrs.      
Davey, Hugh      
Davey, Hugh      
Davidson, —, Miss      
Davidson, —, Mrs.      
Dunn, —, Miss      
Dunn, Samuel      
Hawkins, —, Mrs.      
Kelly, Joseph      
Little, A.      
Lynch, —, Mrs.      
McCartney, —, Mrs.      
McCourt, —, Mrs.      
Merriner, —, Mrs.      
Moore, —, Miss      
Sharp, Andrew    Miners' Agent  
Shimmins, —, Mrs.      
Sprouston, —, Mrs.      
Tubman, —, Mrs.      
Walker, —, Miss      
Watson, —, Miss      
Wilson, J., Mrs.      
Wilson, John      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print