Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

6th May 1886

The Discovery Of Human Remains At Cleator Moor

The Inquest

Yesterday (Wednesday) afternoon, Mr. H. J. Whiteside (deputy-coroner) and a jury, of which Mr. James Kitchin was foreman, held an inquiry into the identity of a person whose remains were found in No. 1, Jacktrees Pit, Cleator, and as to the cause of death. The Coroner, after stating the nature of the inquiry upon which they were sworn, said he was informed by the police that there was clear proof that the remains were those of a Matthew Simpson, of Egremont, who disappeared some thirteen years ago. He had no doubt from the kindly feeling of gentlemen who formed juries, and especially of juries in West Cumberland, that the matter would be approached in a kindly spirit, and without attempting to interfere with private feelings. He had no doubt their verdict would be one such as would clear up a good deal of mystery and would tend to take away an amount of prejudice which had been felt against a person who had been suspected, probably unjustly, of having something to do with the disappearance of this man. — Elizabeth Simpson, Egremont, said her father was missed on the 22nd April 1873, and she had neither seen nor heard anything of him since then. He was about 5ft 8in, in height. When he was missing she knew of no reason why he should commit a rash act. He went out to clerk at a sale, in the day, and she expected him back at night. Yesterday witness was shown some human remains, clothing, and other articles. She had identified the articles: the small comb, keys, spectacle case, pair of tweezers, handkerchief, and neckerchief produced. She had also recognised the clothes, which were found. He wore the old-fashioned style of trousers. She had no doubt — she was perfectly satisfied — that the remains found were those of her father. About two years before his death both shoulders were dislocated. The left shoulder got all right, but owing to the dislocation of the right shoulder he was never able to lift his right arm. Witness yesterday mentioned this to Dr. Speirs, who examined the remains and found traces of these injuries. Witness's father was 62 years of age when he disappeared. He had done nothing for many years previously. His business was that of a skinner. William Walker, overman at No. 2 Pit, belonging to the Carron Company, said that the first portion of the remains (the skull) was found on Saturday about four or five yards from the bottom of the old shaft — No. 1, Jacktrees Pit. The manager directed further search to be made. This was done, with the result that all the remains, which the jury had seen, were found, the only portions wanting to make a perfect skeleton being the feet. This old shaft had never been used since witness came into the district, and he had been here for nearly 13 years. Formerly the shaft was not closed as it is at present. At the time of the deceased's disappearance there was only a rail round it. A footpath came along from the church at Cleator, passing within three or four yards of the shaft, and coming out at Jacktrees Farm. William Graham and George Jenkinson assisted witness in searching for these remains, and in removing them from the pit. — The Coroner observed that he did not think it was necessary to call the men who had assisted witness. By dispensing with them he might materially shorten the inquiry. — By Mr. T. Bell (one of the jury): He had never known anyone else fall down the shaft. — Mr. Bell said about twenty years ago a man named William Carty fell down this shaft, and broke his thigh. — William Watson, manager at the mines, corroborated the statement of the last witness. — Dr. Speirs said he was called to see these remains on Monday. They were the remains of a male, who would have been about 5ft 9in or 5ft 10in, in height. There was no mark of violence on the skull. The collarbone was dislocated backwards on the shoulder blade, and was adherent, forming a false articulation, which would have the effect of preventing him from lifting his arm up — it was rigid. This dislocation would have taken place a year or two before the man's death, as the adhesion was partly ossified. Three ribs on the right side were fractured. The long bones were entire; there were no fractures of the limbs. There was a perfect skeleton with the exception of the feet. The hands, however, were dislocated, but they were nearly all there. By the larynx he was able to assert that the man was about sixty. The "Adam's apple" until a man was fifty years of age was cartilage, and then it began to become bone, and this was completely ossified. — John Campbell Farquharson, auctioneer, Egremont, said that on the 22nd April 1873, he had a sale up at Cleator Moor. As clerk on that occasion he had Mr. Simpson. After the sale he accounted for the money and paid it over to witness. After the sale they went into Fearon's house, the Three Tuns, at Cleator. Matthew Simpson was with witness. Just below the Infirmary they saw a young man lying in the ditch at the roadside. Witness spoke to him, and the young man said that he had come into the neighbourhood in search of employment, but witness had never been able to learn who this man was. They stayed in the public-house for about an hour. Simpson then got up and went out, leaving his coat and his stick in the public-house. He had his hat on. He did say something as he went out, but witness was engaged in conversation with Mr. Fearon, and only heard him say "I'll tell you what." Witness expected him returning very shortly. Towards closing time witness and Mr. Fearon went out on the doorstep and waited there till he was starved, and then concluding that Mr. Simpson must have gone on home, he took up the coat and walked towards home. Mr. Fearon was with him, and they stood near the forge till nearly half — past twelve. Witness then went home and Fearon turned back. Mr. Black was in the room that night. Witness could not say that Simpson was quite sober; he had two or three glasses of grog, but had witness thought that he was not perfectly capable of taking care of himself he would not have allowed him to go out alone. The pit in which the deceased was found was not in the direction of his home. Witness had seen portions of a suit, which had been found in the pit, and had been washed, but he was not in a position to say that they had been worn by Simpson. Mr. Bewlay (a juryman) asked if on that night there was not a quack doctor at the corner of the street, turning water into whiskey, and milk into wine, and if he (Mr. Farquharson) or Mr. Simpson did not stop and say, "I wish he would turn us a sup into whiskey?" — Witness said he didn't remember anything of the kind; and he had no need to ask for any, as they had plenty, and they had left plenty. — Mr. Bewlay said he only mentioned it in order to show that he (Mr. Farquharson) and Mr. Simpson were sober at that time. — Robert Black, baker, Cleator, said he remembered being in the Three Tuns at Cleator, on the night of the 22nd April 1873. William Park, miller, was in company with witness. Mr. Farquharson and Mr. Simpson afterwards came in. They all chatted together a while. Park went out first, and witness next left the room, and went down to the Brow with Park. After seeing Park home witness returned to his own house. — The Coroner: I understand Mr. Black that it has been suggested that you had something to do with the disappearance of this man? Yes. — Now, I am going to ask you a question, but before I ask it you are clearly to understand that you need not answer it unless you wish. The question is this: Do you know anything about this man's death; had you anything to do with this man's death? Nothing whatever. — Very well; I think that will be very satisfactory; and I believe you have suffered severely in your business in consequence of this suspicion? I have; if ever there was a man boycotted in this world I have been; it has ruined my trade. — And it did not die out for a long time, did it? No, sir, I think at the present time there are some would believe it, until this has happened; it has been thrown at me many a time. — After further examination of this witness and the Coroner's summing up, the jury found as follows :— "That the remains which they had viewed were those of Matthew Simpson; that he was found in No.1, Jacktrees Pit; that there was not sufficient evidence to show how he came by his death; and that he had been missing since the 27th April, 1873."

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bell, T.    Juror  
Bewlay, —    Juror  
Black, Robert    Baker  
Carty, William      
Farquharson, John Campbell    Auctioneer  
Fearon, —    Innkeeper  
Graham, William    Miner  
Jenkinson, George    Miner  
Kitchin, James    Jury Foreman  
Park, William    Miller  
Simpson, Elizabeth      
Simpson, Matthew      
Speirs, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Walker, William    Overman  
Watson, William    Manager  
Whiteside, Henry J.    Deputy Coroner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Jacktrees (Iron ore)  Jacktrees (Iron ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print