|
29th April 1886 Fatal Mining AccidentPropping In MinesYesterday (Wednesday) afternoon an adjourned inquest was held before Mr. W. W. Lumb, coroner, at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary, touching the death of George Eilbeck, aged 55 years. Deceased was a miner in the employment of the Ehen Mining Company. On Monday, the 22nd March, he was putting up some prop wood in Ehen Pit, when a piece of shale about two or three stones in weight fell upon his leg, fracturing the ankle. He was immediately conveyed to the Whitehaven Infirmary, where he expired on the 19th inst. Mr. T. Brown attended to watch the proceedings on behalf of the Company; and one of the Government inspectors was present. — John Maley deposed that he lived at Cleator Moor, and was an iron-ore miner, working at Ehen Pit, near to Gillfoot. He knew Eilbeck, who so far as witness knew was an experienced miner, having worked in the mines a good many years. On the 22nd March Eilbeck and witness were working together in what was called the "shale drift," in the Ehen Pit. Between nine and ten o'clock in the forenoon they were putting in a set of wood, when a lump of "sill" fell out, part from the roof and part from the side, as near as he could judge, between two and three stones in weight. The lump fell on Eilbeck's leg and put his light out. Witness went to him and lifted him, and he said, "John, the foot's off me." Eilbeck was afterwards conveyed to the Infirmary at Whitehaven. There was plenty of props to secure the place. The place had been examined that morning by Mr. Kitchin and Mr. Glover, two gaffers. No man in the world could have anticipated any accident. — By Mr. Brown: The working was only five feet in height. The wood was notched ready to put in, and there was plenty of it whenever we liked to go for it. — James Kitchin, Moor Row, manager for the Ehen Mining Company, deposed that he knew the deceased. At nine o'clock on Monday, 22nd March, he was working in the "shale drift." He had the contract of that working. Witness went into the working with John Glover to examine it. It was all right so far as witness could see. It was seven feet high, outside of timber. Witness examined the place only by eye. He had a light, but no pick or hammer. He could make a proper examination of a place like that by eye alone. He scolded Eilbeck for not having put in the timber on the Saturday. What occurred could scarcely be considered a "fall." It was a lump that slided off the side from a height of about six feet. Shale was apt to burst when exposed to the air. The timber was squared and notched on the surface by witness himself, and was lying ready to the hand of the men to put it in whenever they liked. Mr. Glover told them on the previous Saturday to put in their timber, but they did not do so. If the timber had been put in witness believed the accident would not have happened. — By the Inspector: When men disobeyed orders like that the only thing to do with them was to dismiss them. — The Inspector: Is that sufficient, do you think? — Witness: There is nothing else can be done that I am aware of, under existing rules — By a juryman: If there is any reason to be given for the deceased not having put in the props sooner, I would say it was because he was a little anxious. He would be wishing to push forward. He had been knocked about a good deal lately, and no doubt he wanted to make a little money. — John Glover, another of the pit "gaffers," gave corroborative evidence. Witness saw Eilbeck the first Sunday after the accident, and he said the occurrence was a pure accident and could not have been avoided. — In answer to the Inspector, witness said he did not consider it necessary to sound shale, in a place like that. — The Inspector said he examined the place with the witness that morning, and if he had not been directed to do so witness would not have examined the drift by sounding. He (the Inspector) did not think it was good enough to go into a place with a candle, without examining by sounding. It was greatly practised in the iron ore districts, and it was wrong. It was quite impossible to say whether a place was or was not safe without sounding. — An Infirmary nurse deposed that Eilbeck was admitted to the Infirmary suffering from compound dislocation of the ankle. He died from his injuries. — The jury returned a verdict of accidental death. — There were two practical miners of many year's experience, and a builder upon the jury, and the witnesses were closely examined at considerable length. — One of the jury, referred to, said he regarded it as absurd to think that in an iron ore working perhaps forty feet high, an overman should be required to tale a ladder and a hammer to examine the roof. If he was working in such a place he would consider it an insult. If the men did not know themselves, as well as it was possible to know, whether the place was safe or not, they were not fit to be there.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||