|
31st July 1885 Letters to the EditorColliery ExplosionsSir, I read with great interest Mr. Ellis Lever's letter to you in The Times of June 26 last, and I should have asked you to favour me by the insertion of a few remarks upon this question had I not considered that your powerful leader of the following day expressed all that could well be said for the present. But Mr. Lever's reference in The Times of the 14th to a letter of mine which you published on November 14, 1883, after the Accrington explosion, has induced me to ask for a short space to enable me to say a few more words. The attention which is now being given by mining men and scientists to the subject of "earth tremors" and earthquakes, and their possible, and I believe probable, relation to the sudden issues of fire-damp, which are so much to be dreaded in coal mines, renders it to my mind doubly and trebly important — first, that all naked lights, including underground furnace fires for ventilating purposes, should be banished from fiery mines ; secondly, that the safety lamps to be used should not include three kinds which are "safe" only in name ; and thirdly, that in fiery mines blasting should be entirely dispensed with. When the article upon "earth tremors" appeared in The Times on November 12, 1881, followed by another article on September 14, 1882, and by a letter by Professor Milne of Tokio, Japan, on October 11, 1882, it was probably little dreamt of that such occurences might have to be seriously considered and investigated in their bearing upon the irregular and violent issues of fire-damp in coal mines. Since then, however, sufficient attention has been given to the matter by papers and discussions by the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers, and by recent letters in your columns as to earthquakes and explosions, to warrant that institute appointing a committee to investigate the question, as announced in The Times of the 6th inst. by Mr. T. W. Bunning, the secretary of the institute. I know that there will be outcries as to these theories being far-fetched and only promoted, or at least circulated, for the purpose of finding possible excuses for the occurrence of colliery explosions, but I hope, as I believe, that no persons will be guilty of such almost criminal weakness. At all events I only mention these theories now as being probably correct, with the view of suggesting increased vigilance for the prevention of accidents. Surely, if we discover that there is good ground for the belief, if not positive knowledge, that underground movements do occasion unexpected discharges of fire-damp, no one will fold his hands in despair, or in apathy, and say that an explosion where there has been the presence of naked lights, or the use of imperfect safety lamps ; or the adoption of blasting at the time of a discharge of fire-damp, can be deemed accidental and unavoidable. First, as to the abolition of naked lights, including underground ventilating furnaces in fiery mines. The necessity for this appears to be so self-evident that I do not purpose to occupy space by enlarging upon it further than saying that powerful ventilating fans are now so well-known, and can be so readily obtained that there need be no excuse for their absence, excepting the possibility of a ventilating furnace being more efficient — as regards quantity of air produced — in very deep mines than a fan ; but even if this be so, which I am disposed myself to believe, the safety question so far outvies any other that I am fully of opinion that where mines are liable to large and sudden issues of fire-damp a furnace, even with the well-known appliance of a "dumb-drift," is quite inadmissible. Colonel Shakespear, in The Times of the 4th inst, advocates the introduction of air by pressure instead of by exhaustion. This is a matter of detail, and, at present, he has but few supporters among experienced mining men as to the desirability of ventilating the whole of an extensive coal mine by pressure. Secondly, as to the employment of efficient safety lamps. I know how difficult and even impossible it would be to have legislative enactments as to the use, or disuse, of various appliances for coal mining, without inflicting hardships or unequal pressure somewhere or other ; but if there be one subject that loudly calls for the immediate interference of the Legislature as regards coal mines it certainly is the abolition or prevention of the use of lamps which are well-known to be unsafe even under very ordinary circumstances ; and yet for one reason or another are in daily use. The most unsafe of all in strong currents of air highly charged with fire-damp being the "Davy" which I most strongly denounced in my letter in The Times of November 14, 1883. There are now well-known lamps which, so far as proved, are not unsafe unless in most exceptional cases, such as the movement of the air, or of the lamp and the air, at velocities which can hardly ever be expected to arise in a mine. I do not say that we should at present insist upon the use of any kind of lamp, but I do say, most emphatically, let us clear the way so far by insisting upon the disuse of those lamps which are known by the merest tyro in mining to be thoroughly unreliable. Thirdly, as to blasting. After spending 40 years in the earnest endeavour to render coal mining as safe as can be reasonably and practically expected, I am, of course, fully aware of the numerous obstacles that stand in the way of a total abolition of blasting in coal mines without inflicting hardships somewhere in the present state of our knowledge ; and that if on the one hand there appears to be vantage ground gained at times, on the other hand we are sometimes disappointed by meeting with unforeseen and even greater difficulties than we had anticipated ; and I am strongly disposed to believe that it is these continually recurring difficulties, and the presenting of new phases in the various branches of coal mining, which have prevented the Accidents in Mines Commission from issuing that report which we are all so impatiently awaiting, in the hope that we shall have very valuable advice and suggestions as to the safer working of coal mines in the future. The researches into the nature and effects of coal dust, even in an atmosphere containing an almost infinitesimal proportion of fire-damp, show that its disturbance by the effect of a shot fired for blasting purposes may prove most disastrous by originating or frightfully extending an explosion in a mine. Mr. Galloway, of Cardiff, formerly an inspector of coal mines, and who was one of the first, if not the very first, person in this country to loudly call — I may say even to demand — attention to the risk of blasting in very dry and dusty mines, has at numerous intervals for some years, and even quite recently in the columns of Nature and elsewhere, pointed out what is known of this great risk in Germany and France as well as at home. It is true that Professor Faraday and Sir Charles Lyell, who were instructed by the Home Secretary to investigate the cause of the Haswell explosion in 1844, mentioned the effect of coal dust in spreading an explosion, but really nothing was practically known of it until at least 30 years after. Until blasting be absolutely abolished in dusty mines, watering the roads in the vicinity of the spot where shots are fired must be absolutely insisted upon. But we require an entirely efficient substitute for blasting by gunpowder or any other explosive that will incur the risk of generating flame. At present, and I write advisedly and, I believe, with the knowledge of all the present inventions, we have no such a force at command, either as a chemical or mechanical agent, for the safe and economic breaking down of coal and the overlying stone, so that we can say that we care no more for the power of gunpowder in mines. I come now to one of the main objects I have had in writing this letter — viz., calling attention to what I frequently hear spoken of as the great anomaly of our House of Commons voting, almost without stint or grudge, enormous sums annually for all kinds of devices for destroying life, but not one shilling to promote discoveries for the safety of life in coal mines. I should be one of the very last to begrudge or cavil at any outlay necessary for the maintenance of Britain's proud position among the nations of the world, but I do think that while providing for the arts of war we ought not to be unmindful of the arts of peace, and that a few crumbs might be scattered from the nation's resources, small as compared with those resources but ample for the purpose in question, to induce the discovery and the perfecting of inventions to provide for the safe lighting of coal mines and the efficient detection at the same time of fire-damp, and for a safe and adequate substitute for flame-giving explosives, and not leaving the inducement for such discoveries to private munificence alone, great though that may be as emanating from individuals. I maintain that, given the two requirements of safe lighting and safe blasting, accompanied with the entire absence of naked lights in fiery mines, colliery explosions must, as a matter of course, be reduced to a minimum ; and the annals of coal mining would not be then disfigured by such dark pages as are now of too frequent occurrence. I conclude by invoking your powerful aid to bring about this difficult, but by no means impossible, task, if a nation's resources, followed by a nation's gratitude, can be systematically brought to bear to realize such a happy result. I am, Sir, your obedient servant, John Brown, M.Inst.C.E., late Honorary Professor of Coal Mining, Mason College. Birmingham.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||