Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

14th July 1885

Letters to the Editor

Colliery Explosions

Sir,

In the letter from me which you inserted in The Times of the 26th ult., and which furnished the subject of your leading article on the following day, I endeavoured to show how disastrous and how opposed to every principle of humanity and economy is the fatal practice of shot-firing in coal mines. At the same time I intimated that, with your permission, I should have something to say with regard to so-called "safety" lamps.

That this question of lamps is one of great difficulty cannot be denied, and I should not be surprised to learn that the delay which has occurred in issuing the official report of the Royal Commission on Accidents in Mines is largely due to the anxiety of the Commissioners to effect an adequate and satisfactory settlement of the matter. Wherein the difficulty consists I will endeavour to point out in this letter.

I have before me a pamphlet by Sir Humphry Davy, presented by the author to Mr. John Buddle, the eminent north-country mining engineer, and containing Sir Humphry's autograph notes in the margin, entitled "An Account of an Invention for Lighting the Mines and Consuming the Fire-damp without Danger to the Miner." This pamphlet was published in 1816, and gives a full description of the "Davy" lamp, the use of which, to quote the inventor's words, "will enable the miner to work with perfect security in parts of the mines most liable to fire-damp, and will not only preserve him from, but will enable him to combat and subdue his most dangerous enemy." The "Davy" lamp was tried and approved by Mr. Buddle and the principal mining engineers of the Newcastle district. But there were rivals in the field, and the lamps invented respectively by Dr. W. Reid Clanny, of Sunderland, and George Stephenson, then a workman employed at the Killingworth Colliery, Newcastle, were the chief of these.

The claims of the various lamps were settled, after careful examination, at a meeting of the coal-owners on the 11th of October, 1816, when it was decided "that the merit of discovering a real safety lamp belonged to Davy." This decision was followed by the presentation to Sir Humphry by the coal-owners of Newcastle of a service of plate "as a testimony of their gratitude for the services he had rendered to them and to humanity."

There is something grimly ironical in this sundering of "coal-owners" and "humanity ;" but at the same time the action of the coal-owners in 1816 is in marked contrast to the attitude adopted by many colliery proprietors at the present day with regard to safety lamps and other devices for the saving of human life.

For 70 years the three lamps which I have mentioned have been in use. That they have afforded some protection — and for a lengthy period of their history a very great measure of protection — to the miners it is impossible to doubt ; but new diseases cannot by cured by old remedies, and the lamp which in Davy's time formed a moderately efficient safeguard is of little or no use in the changed conditions under which coal is now won — viz., the greater depth and area of the mines, and the increased ventilation and its effect on the coal and in the mines. Indeed, a "safety" lamp that is unsafe under conditions which are nowadays of constant recurrence is a delusion and a snare. The recognition of this fact has led to the invention of many new types of lamps, some of them good, some of them very bad ; but, good or bad, there is no law to prohibit the use of any of them. Government inspectors, who know the "Davy" and other lamps to be defective, have no power to forbid their introduction into the mines, and there are in consequence more than a hundred kinds of lamps in use. Many of these, especially where the masters compel men to provide their own lamps, are purchased simply because they are low priced, without regard to their value for the purpose for which they are intended. But even if the men were prepared to give a good price for their lamps, how could they be expected to select the best lamp, when so high an authority on mining matters as Mr. A. L. Steavenson, of Durham, manager of Sir Isaac Lowthian Bell's collieries, was fain to declare, at a recent meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining Engineers, that "he was very much bewildered at the present time as to which was the best lamp, as there were so many lamps by various makers, and it was difficult to say where the best was to be found ?"

During the last few years much has been said on this subject, and many efforts have been made to obtain a better system of lighting. After the explosion at the Abram Colliery in 1881 — by which 40 miners lost their lives — I offered through the Central Association for dealing with the distress caused by mining accidents a premium of £500 for the lighting of a colliery by means of electricity, but that association would do nothing, preferring to reverse the adage and to continue what must be at best but a very inadequate "cure" rather than to make any effort in the direction of "prevention." At the time of the Seaham explosion, and on many subsequent occasions, I have called attention to the necessity of safer and better lights in mines.

On the 14th of November, 1883, Mr. John Brown, Professor of Mining at the Mason Science College, in a letter to The Times, referred to the defective character of the "Davy" and other lamps, and spoke emphatically on the urgent necessity for improvement.

In giving evidence at the inquest as to the cause of the death of 67 miners killed by the Accrington Colliery explosion in November, 1883, Mr. John Higson said "he looked for increased safety in a better lamp. He considered that the ‘Davy' lamp contained great elements of danger. A miner when at work had not his eye constantly upon his lamp ; in fact, if a man had his daily bread to earn, he did not bother so much about it, and it was possible for a ‘Davy' lamp to be full of an explosive atmosphere for a considerable time and the miner not to notice it." At this colliery "Davy" lamps were used and shot firing practiced.

I fearlessly repeat to-day the words which, upon hearing the usual stereotyped verdict of the Accrington jury to the effect that "the explosion was caused by a sudden outburst of gas, but there is not sufficient evidence to show how the same exploded," I telegraphed to the Manchester papers on the 23d of November, 1883 — viz., "Another unsatisfactory verdict. No condemnation of ‘Davy' and other bad lamps. No denunciation of blasting by gunpowder or of furnace ventilation. No recommendation by the jury. The ‘Davy' safety lamp, so-called, I know to be nothing less than a death-dealing man-trap."

In the same year I offered through the council of the National Miners' Union which represents some 400,000 colliers a premium of £500 for a perfect, portable electric, or other miners' lamp which should afford a good light and be safe. The following adjudicators were appointed — viz., Mr. Thomas Burt, M.P., nominated by the Miners' Union ; Professor Sir Frederick Abel, F.R.S., nominated by the Society of Arts (both these gentlemen are members of the Royal Commission on Accidents in Mines) ; Professor W. Grylls Adams, F.R.S., nominated by the Royal Society ; and Professor Sylvanus P. Thompson, of the Bristol University, nominated by myself. The Coal Owners' Association of Great Britain were invited by the council of the Miners' Union to nominate a fifth adjudicator, but, through their secretary, Mr. Maskell Peace, they declined. Nearly a hundred lamps were sent in, and tested at the Royal Laboratory, Woolwich, with the result that no competing lamp was found to fulfil the conditions which had been prepared by the National Miners' Union, and the award was consequently withheld. Many improved lamps have, however, been introduced, some of which were first sent to compete for the premium, e.g., the "Marsant" and the "Morgan" lamps, and much good has thus been effected. There are also the "Meuseler," the "Tin Can Davy," the "Protector," the "Routledge," and the "Linethurst" lamps, which claim a greater degree of safety and afford a better light than the old lamps. But in the words of M. Marsant, the inventor of one of the lamps just named, and an authority on the question, "we have yet to find a perfect safety lamp."

Until we can have our mines lighted by electricity — and I am glad to say there are unmistakable evidences that this is coming quickly — I would suggest that candles and naked lights, together with antiquated and worthless lamps should be absolutely prohibited in all coal mines ; that no safety lamp (whether found by master or man) should be allowed to be used that it did not bear the stamp of the Government inspector or some other competent and properly authorized official (weights and measures and gas meters have to be officially stamped, why not safety lamps ?) ; and that smoking and shot firing should be altogether forbidden.

There are many other important questions affecting the safety of coal mines — notably that of coal dust floating in the atmosphere of the mine, which is not a new but a very old question. However, I must not now trespass further upon your space.

Yours faithfully,

Bowden, Cheshire.

Ellis Lever.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Abel, Frederick, Sir      
Adams, W. Grylls, Professor      
Bell, Isaac Lowthian, Sir      Whos Who Page
Brown, John      
Buddle, John      Whos Who Page
Burt, Thomas      
Clanny, William Reid, Dr.      Whos Who Page
Davy, Humphry, Sir      
Higson, John      
Lever, Ellis      
Marsant, M.      
Peace, Maskell      
Steavenson, Addison Langhorne      Whos Who Page
Stephenson, George      
Thompson, Sylvanus P., Professor      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print