26th June 1885
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
The disastrous colliery explosions last week at Pendlebury and Newcastle-under-Lyme, by which close upon 200 miners were hurried into eternity, leaving behind them nearly 100 widows and 400 fatherless children besides aged and dependent relatives, have
caused a feeling of consternation throughout the whole country. With regard to the first-named explosion — that at Clifton-hall Colliery — we are told the same old story ; that it was well-conducted and considered safe — so safe,
indeed, that naked lights and shot-firing were freely permitted. It may appear singular that this colliery — declared to be the safest in the neighbourhood — should be the scene of such an appalling catastrophe. But the late Mr.
Knowles, M.P., of Wigan, a large colliery owner, who had begun life as a working miner, speaking in the House of Commons on the 21st June, 1878, said :—
"Unfortunately, if an explosion should occur in a well ventilated mine the consequences would be much more serious than in an ill-ventilated mine. As an instance of this (he said) they had an accident near Bolton some time ago in a mine which was
considered to be perfectly safe. The men worked with naked lights and they blasted coal, but every one of them was killed. Since they had had heavy ventilation the explosions had been of a much worse character than formerly. Bitter as the pill might be
to swallow, they would have to consider the question of doing away with blasting altogether and also with the use of naked lights."
In the course of the same debate Sir George Elliot, M.P., another well-known colliery proprietor, who has also been a working miner said :—
"The use of gunpowder (for blasting or shot-firing) simply meant the application of a naked light, which was of itself a great source of danger. The abolition of blasting in fiery mines would probably increase the cost to the consumer ; but he
agreed with the hon. member for Morpeth (Mr. Burt) that there was no other remedy than the prohibition of gunpowder."
Sir Richard A. Cross, M.P., the then Home Secretary, speaking on the same occasion, said :—
"In several cases which had come under his notice he had pressed on the owners of collieries — for he had no power to interfere further — that they should give up blasting by gunpowder in fiery mines. But he had known in many instances
that the objection to the discontinuance of blasting came not so much from the masters and colliery owners as from the men themselves, because where blasting was employed a much greater quantity of coal could be obtained in a shorter time. So long as
blasting was carried on in the fiery mines it was obvious that the danger must be greatly increased. Why was it that in those dangerous mines the men were compelled to have safety lamps ? Because it was not thought right that a candle or naked light
should be used. But if a wretched farthing candle could not be trusted, why could a great stream of light from blasting be allowed ? It was inconsistent to prohibit the farthing candle and permit the blast."
Is it not equally inconsistent to permit the use of naked lights and systematic blasting by gunpowder in mines which have the reputation of being safe — a kind of reputation which is frequently possessed by mines of the most dangerous character
— viz., those where the outbursts of gas are intermittent ? The very quality which has gained for these mines their safe reputation — the partial immunity from explosive gas — constitutes their main element of danger, because it
promotes a feeling of security which sad experience has proved to be altogether baseless, and leads to the relaxation of those stringent prohibitions which are quite as necessary in mines comparatively free from gas as in the most fiery mines.
Notwithstanding the denunciations of shot-firing by mining engineers, colliery proprietors, representatives of the miners — like the late Alexander Macdonald, M.P., Mr. Burt, M.P., and Mr. W. Pickard, J.P. — this most
reprehensible practice is allowed to continue. The explosions in South Wales, Lancashire, Durham, and Staffordshire are surely sufficient to induce Parliament to act at once, and to stop this wholesale slaughter.
I had many interviews with Mr. Macdonald, and on the day before he died he wrote to me — his last words being, "I am worried to death on this powder question. It will be sad beyond measure if the work of half a century be reversed.
Every man should be at work — I cannot."
It is a national disgrace that, during the last 30 years, nearly 40,000 miners have been killed in the mines of this country, and close upon 1,000,000 injured or disabled by accidents many of which were preventable. Unless immediate steps are taken by
the Legislature — without waiting longer for the report of the Royal Commission on Accidents in Mines, which, to the eternal discredit of Royal Commissions, has been sitting for seven years without visible result — we may daily expect other
so-called "accidents," which Mr. Macdonald designated "crimes." Shot-firing must be done away with, and our miners' lives protected even against themselves, otherwise as the, mines are worked at greater depth we shall have
greater slaughter than hitherto.
I might say something about the lamps in use in coal-mines, but I will leave this for another occasion, if you are kind enough to allow me space in The Times.
Yours faithfully,
Ellis Lever.
Bowdon, Manchester, June 24.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Burt, — | | | |
| Cross, Richard A., Sir | | | |
| Elliot, George, Sir | | | |
| Knowles, — | | | |
| Lever, Ellis | | | |
| MacDonald, Alexander | | | |
| Pickard, W. | | | |