4th June 1885
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
"Prevention is better than cure."
In the autumn of 1880, especially, I called attention to our system of colliery ventilation being more favourable to explosions than to their prevention, since, whether carried out by fan or furnace in the up-cast shaft, it is by suction through the
workings, which, tending to lessen atmospheric pressure in the mine, eases the flow of gas out of the coal strata.
In illustration of what I say, imagine a check or stoppage in the air supplied by the down-cast shaft ; then the action in the up-cast is causing a vacuum then and there through the mine, which nature feeds with gas from the coal and strata.
Each one-tenth of an inch fall in the barometer lightens pressure 7lb. on the square foot. Now, explosions are always preceded by a fall of the barometer, often of half an inch, which corresponds to 35lb. less pressure on the square foot, in a few hours.
Is it wisdom or folly to still further aid the escape of gas by artificial appliances which suck gas out of the coal into the mine ?
But, again, ventilation by suction is mischievous in another way, as the current travels in lines from point to point like a running stream, omitting bays, sides, crevices, and the like, which harbour accumulations of gas as creeks do water. Now, the
real and true check to colliery explosions is by delivering air under pressure at the face of the coal, which would expand, and, penetrating all parts of the mine, make its escape up both or either of the shafts. This I persistently urged five years ago,
and I must say it met with wide support in print from correspondents. The general style of objection will be understood by a quotation from a letter thus :—
"Although ventilation by suction — i.e., exhaustion, is a more economical method of ventilating mines than by compression, yet there is no question it is much less safe."
The pressure of air in excess of nature, of course, gives safety ; but instead of acting on that principle we weaken nature and so hurt ourselves.
I need not trouble you with figures as to the first cost in the mechanical engineering of such a change of system as I advocate, but the additional cost was admitted to be — price of piping at per yard, according to size ; in other respects the
"give and take" would balance.
Now, suppose, for instance, £5,000 capital saved 200 lives ? Would the money be ill or well spent ?
Others must answer the question.
As to electric lighting, my previous ideas in its possible use for good received a severe check on finding that when breaking the glass of a 5-candle power incandescent lamp, the gas in which I had placed it for experiment fired in the instant of the
fracture. As the electric light is not extinguished until after the fracture, I fear that ever must be so.
Yours obediently,
J. D. Shakespear.
Institute of Civil Engineers, 25, Great George-street, S.W.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Shakespear, J. D. | | | |