12th March 1885
An Important Mining Case
Action Against Lord Mancaster
In the High Court of Justice, Chancery Division on Friday last, before Vice Chancellor Sir James Bacon, Mills v Lord Mancaster came on. — Mr. Miller, Q.C., moved to defer the trial of the action of Mills v Lord Muncaster until the Easter Sittings
in April. He said the action related to the customs of the Manor of Pennington, and those customs would have to be proved on one side or both by reference to documentary evidence which went at least as far back at the Doomsday Book, and far and beyond
legal memory. The action was of this nature. The defendant, Lord Muncaster, was Lord of the manor of Pennington, and the Askam Iron Company had a licence from him to dig iron ore under a close of land in the manor. That close of land the plaintiffs
claimed to be in possession of. The question in the action would be the right of Lord Mancaster to grant licences to the second defendants, the Askam Iron Company, to dig under the land of the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs said that there was no special
custom as to the mines and minerals, but that the tenant by custom had the possession of the minerals, that the Lord of the Manor could not demise and that he could not give possession without the consent of the tenant, and that consent, it was alleged,
had not been given. Lord Muncaster had given a licence to the Iron Company to enter and dig for ore on land in the plaintiff's possession, and he pleaded a special custom authorising that to be done. — Mr. Elton, for the plaintiff, Mr. Mills,
opposed the motion, stating that if the trial were thrown over the ling vacation, the licence granted by Lord Muncaster would come to an end, and they would be obliged to dismiss the whole of their 600 workmen. No doubt the idea was that if the
plaintiffs could be driven to the end of the year, they should be forced into a kind of compromise. — Mr. S. Hall, on behalf of the Askam Iron Company, supported the motion. — The Vice Chancellor, on the ground that it was impossible for the
defendants to be prepared with their case before the Easter sittings, acceded to the motion, and the hearing of the action accordingly stands over until that period
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bacon, James, Sir | | Vice Chancellor | |
| Elton, — | | Q.C. | |
| Hall, S. | | Q.C. | |
| Miller, — | | Q.C. | |
| Mills, — | | | |
| Muncaster, Lord | | | |