Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

30th October 1884

Mr. Sharps Reply To Bentinck, Waddington, & Co

On Saturday night last Mr. Andrew Sharp, secretary of the West Cumberland Miners Association, addressed a crowded meeting of working men, chiefly miners in the Whitehaven Colliery, in the Protestant Hall, Duke Street in reply to "Bentinck, Waddinton, & Company," as was stated upon the placards calling the meeting. Mr. Joseph Jackson, who was distinguished by Mr. Bentinck as a "child of the gutter," being present, was called upon by the meeting to preside, and Mr. Samuel Dunn, the secretary of the Whitehaven Miners Union, also occupied a seat on the platform. — Mr. SHARP, who was received with enthusiastic cheers, said it was not any desire of his that he should meet them that night for the purpose that had called them together, but he was bound to give them an explanation, and at the same time refute the most unjust statements that had been attributed to him and others. Some gross charges had been preferred against them respecting their organisation and its attitude towards the Liberal and Conservative parties. It was necessary for him to answer those statements; but he did not pick this quarrel, for he never, in all his career, mentioned the Conservative or Liberal parties — that was, so far as he was connected with any Association. So far as the Franchise Demonstration was concerned he told them that a trades union was composed of all sides and colours, and that any action they took in regard to that matter must be purely voluntary; and the meeting knew that the action they chose to take in connection with the franchise question was a spontaneous action of their own, and did not spring from any coercion or influence that he used. (Cheers.) The action he took himself he took in his private capacity as an individual. When he agreed to sell his labours to the miners of West Cumberland he reserved two or three things, one of which was that he should be of what religion he liked; and another, that he should be of what political principles he liked. During the whole ten years he had been in his present position he never to his recollection used the name of Cavendish Bentinck in any speed he ever made. But Mr. Bentinck had made what he considered a very unwarrantable attack upon himself, Mr. Burt, and Mr. Broadhurst. (Cheers.) The attack upon him was made owing to certain statements in a speech of his on Ellenborough Moor. Well, when he attended the Ellenborough moor meeting he did not attend as a representative of the Miners Association, but as a private individual and as a member of the Liberal Association at Maryport. (Cheers.) And the statement he then made were entirely connected with the House of Lords, and he never mentioned either Conservative or Liberal at that meeting. He said that the House of Lords had been great opponents of the miners, and in 1842 they opposed women and young boys being brought out of the pits. Mr. Bentinck at a meeting in Whitehaven attempted to refute that statement; but he did not refute it, because he admitted that the House of Lords opposed the measure, although he said it was only on the question whether it should be six or eight or twelve months before the women were brought out of the pits. But he (Mr. Sharp) did not say with respect to what the House of Lords opposed the thing; he simply said they opposed it. Now, he would to like ask, was it consistent of a House of Lords to oppose anything that was likely to be elevating to the female sex? (Cheers.) What person would consider, when a woman was occupied in a beastly occupation, whether it should be six, eight, or twelve months before she should be brought out, poor thing? (Cheers.) Was there any reasonable man with respect for his country or his family who would have attempted to oppose that? But he would like to know when the House of Lords ever considered the people of this country when their interests were at stake? (Cheers.) Mr. Bentinck also attempted to refute his statement that in 1860 the House of Lords opposed the education of boys in connection with the mines. Now, he repeated that he quoted actual facts. The House of Lords did oppose the education of boys in mines, and not only so, but they crippled the Bill, and he and many others here tonight owed their weak education to that action of the House of Lords. (Cheers.) According to Mr. Bentinck, the opposition of the House of Lords was only on a trivial or technical point. He said it was only a question of whether it was to be 20 or 24 hours. Now, he would quote to them the actual Act of Parliament. (Cheers.) What the House of Lords agreed to was this: "Provided that a boy above the age of ten years and under the age of twelve may be employed in a mine or colliery upon either of the following condition, that is to say, that before such boy is so employed the owner of the mine shall, after the 1st of July1861, obtain a certificate, under the hand of competent school-master, that such a boy is able to read and write — (hear, hear); — or that in the second and every subsequent lunar month during which such boy is employed in such mine or colliery, the owner shall obtain a certificate, under the hand of a competent school master, that such boy has attended school for not for not than three hours a day for each day in each week during the lunar month immediately preceding, exclusive of any attendance on Sunday." Now, he asked in all fairness, was it possible that a gentleman presuming to represent the working classes of Whitehaven could stand upon a platform and deliberately utter such statements as to say there was a difference as between 20 and 24 hours? It was utterly scandalous to the working people of Whitehaven to try and thrust such doctrine down their throats. What the House of Lords agreed to do was to let them have six hours schooling, and even then they made the mistake of not saying whether it should be a day school or a night school, the consequence of which was that many of them, poor things, got their six hours sleeping over a farthing candle in a night school. This was the fair treatment they got. This was the schooling passed by the House of Lords. And he asked them could any body of gentlemen sit upon the people of this country, and dictate whether a poor child should have six or eight hours of schooling? Where was their sympathy? What was the fear and danger? The fear and danger was "Educate the people, and we lose all our power." (Loud cheers. A VOICE: Good lad. Gaa into them) Mr. Bentinck said that he had looked carefully through Hannard's reports previous to making that speech, but whether he did or not he deliberately made that statement to put before the people that were listening to him. Because in no part of Hannard's reports would he find that the House of Lords argued upon 20 or 24 hours. Mr. Bentinck presumed to have knowledge of political matters, and he had no doubt that on some things he was well and ably posted. But generally he had spent his time in trying to ascertain foreign matters; and he had always a smell of war. (Laughter.) He didn't think there would be any difficulty in any workingman contending with Mr. Bentinck upon home affairs, especially in connection with the working classes. (Cheers.) Because he didn't think Mr. Bentinck ever gave the question of the workingmen of England one moment's consideration. (Cheers.) Going on to refer to Mr. Bentinck's Parton meeting, Mr. Sharp was making use of the well-known quotation from Burns, "Facts are chiels that winna ding," etc., when a well-known customer bearing the sobriquet of "Scottie," who had previously interpolated here and there a mild interruption, in a tone indicative of some disgust, said, "Speak Scotch, man!" There were immediately cries of "Put him out," and some of the audience in his immediate vicinity collared "Scottie" for this purpose. The obnoxious one, however, was not so easily dealt with; he struck out right and left, and created considerable commotion, but he was soon bundled out of the hall amid great cheering. — Mr. Sharp, referring to Mr. Bentinck's statement at Parton that he should be taken and have his nose rubbed in moral mud, said if it suited Mr. Bentinck to come forward as a pugilistic professional he had a right to do so. But no one whose unfortunate lot it was to come in collision with Mr. Bentinck could help coming in contact with mud if they perused the speeches that Mr. Bentinck delivered. He considered Mr. Bentinck a sort of dredge-hopper. (Great laughter.) Every time he opened his mouth it was a matter of mud or something of that sort that was going to be heaped upon the head of some opponent. (Cheers.) Mr. Bentinck charged him with coming down to Whitehaven in 1880 to hold a meeting in behalf of Mr. Gully. Now, he (Mr. Sharp) said that was a deliberate lie. (A VOICE: We aw know that). He never knew, and never saw Mr. Gully until he saw him at that meeting in the iron-ore yard; and Mr. Gully never knew him. He did not deny that he came to Whitehaven in 1880 to hold a meeting, but it was not to support Mr. Gully. Before the election of 1880 the trades unionists of this country held a conference, and they resolved to adopt a programme of labour questions as a test for Parliamentary candidates and he came to Whitehaven to ask the miners, and to ask the working people of Whitehaven generally, to put these questions to Mr. Gully and to Mr. Bentinck, and whichever agreed to support them let him have there vote. (Hear, hear.) That programme consisted of the Compensation Bill, the Bankruptcy Bill, County Franchise, and additional inspectors for factories and mines. The newspapers of that day would show that he never mentioned either Mr. Gully's name or Mr. Bentinck's. But he might say this. He being, he believed, the only recognised head of the trades union in Cumberland, it had been his duty at various different times to write to the members of Parliament in Cumberland, asking them to support certain measures that were brought forward in the interests of the working classes. He wrote to Mr. Bentinck, asking him if he would support the Compensation Bill and he wrote to the Hon. Percy Wyndham, Sir Wilfred Lawson — (cheers) — Mr. Ferguson, and Mr. David Ainsworth. (cheers.) Now, every one of these had the courtesy to reply and say, "We will support it," except Mr. Bentinck. (Hooting.) That gentleman never replied. Of the conservative member for West Cumberland he (Mr. Sharp) never spoke except with the greatest of reverence. He never wrote to the Hon. Percy Wyndham to ask him to do anything in connection with the miners, but he acted the part of a gentleman and replied. Their Association made no distinction between Conservatives and Liberals, but wrote to them all. When the Bankruptcy Bill was in Parliament there was a strong apposition to it, which might have advantaged as much from Liberals as from Conservatives. But the point was simply this. Under the old law, when a gentleman became bankrupt he was allowed £99 worth of bedding, tools and other things, but if a poor working man got into debt, the very bed was taken from under his wife and family; and the trade unionists wanted to put the working man on the same footing as the rich man. Well, he wrote to every Member of Parliament in this country upon the question, and even got of the eight sent him word that they would support the course that the trades unions advocated. The question was who was the eighth. The eighth member was Mr. Bentinck. (Hooting.) Now, although for years and years Mr. Bentinck had treated the Miners Association with all the contempt that he could, this was the first time that he (Mr. Sharp) had ever spoken about him upon a public platform. (Hear hear.) And he would not have done so now if it had not been for the challenge that had been thrown down. (A VOICE: Go for him.) Mr. Bentinck had taken pains to stamp the union as a body of Liberals, but he never made a greater mistake in his life; for at their delegate meetings they had men on both sides, and never such a thing as Liberal or Conservatives was mentioned. (Hear hear.) When first he became a miners agent, the Secretary to the Conservatives sent him a letter and a free ticket to go to a good luncheon — (laughter) — he did not wish to be personal and mention the gentleman's name: — but he told that gentleman in reply that from the earliest age his tendencies always laid with the Radical party. (Cheers and laughter.) He had never had any further invitation from either party, but had been left at liberty to suit himself; and he had done so. (Hear, hear.) He thought in this matter Mr. Bentinck had been made a cat's paw. (Laughter.) The Colliery Office officials had run the thing so hardly against the men that the men had organized. Mr. Bentinck, being one of the Trustees for the Earl of Lonsdale, would probably inquire the cause, and to avert his wrath he had been told, "Oh those men have combined with the Liberal party to oust you." (Laughter.) He had been buttered up by the Colliery Office officials, and there seemed to have been a sort of contract — that Mr. Bentinck would denounce trades unionism, and stamp it out, and that the Colliery Office officials would do all they could in return to send him to Parliament. (Laughter.) But, between them, they had got into a muddle; because there was a miners organisation, and Mr. Bentinck had no guarantee that he would go to Parliament. (Cheers and laughter, and a VOICE: "But Gully has.) Mr. Sharp then proceeded to deal with "Mr. Waddington, of Barrow." The challenge Mr. Waddington had thrown down for a discussion he was quite willing to accept, although he did not wish to stop the more able opponent who had already taken the challenge up. (Cheers.) But he could not very well discuss whether the Liberals or the Conservatives had done the most for the working classes of this country; because he considered Mr. Waddington and he would be like two lambs discussing whether the fox or the wolf had been their greatest friend. (Hear hear.) Everything the trade's unionists and the working classes had obtained either party had been by their own efforts. (Hear, hear.) But there was this to be said, that the Liberal party had very often turned over to their side. There were plenty of men in the Liberal ranks held as strong notions against them as Mr. Bentinck or other did. But it was not one or two they had to deal with, but the general body. The question for them was, what party is the likeliest to do for us the most good? (Cheers.) He had no objection to discuss that with Mr. Waddington at any time, if he preferred him to Mr. Dixon. (Cheers.) He could not for the life of him understand how a trade's unionist and the Colliery Office and Mr. Bentinck came to be in harmony. (Laughter.) Every effort of the Colliery officials had been to disestablish unionism; and Mr. Bentinck had treated unionism with silent contempt. But at the last moment these honourable gentlemen had to submit to the humiliation of employing a gentleman like Mr. Waddington! (Laughter.) At the election of 1876, when the Judge Advocate Generalship was given to Mr. Bentinck because his seat was considered the safest to contest at that time — (cheers and laughter) — he (Mr. Sharp) was in Whitehaven, and saw and heard a policeman go up to a group of colliers, and tell them, "You live in No. so and so, Newhouses or Ginns " Yes." "Well, you vote so and so;" and the men were led to believe that it would be known how they voted. This was one of the means resorted to to return Mr. Bentinck. Here was a man who had drawn more money in one year than he (Mr. Sharp) had drawn from the miners all the days of his life, who had actually the audacity to rise up and impute dishonest motives. (Cheers and laughter.) Mr. Waddington seemed to consider Mr. Bentinck superior to him. But he would scorn the notion! He never considered Mr. Bentinck on his level — the thing was too insulting. (Cheers and laughter.) Would ever he have attempted to attack Mr. Bentinck? Never. What, he did not attempt to attack every chimney sweep that ran through the town. (Laughter.) That gentleman attacked him, and of course he had to defend himself, that was all. He did not think he was fighting with Mr. Bentinck. When he caught hold of a boy he simply gave him a lashing and let him go. (Cheers and laughter.) — On the conclusion of Mr. Sharps address, Mr. S. DUNN moved a vote of thanks to him. In doing so Mr. Dunn told his audience that some one had sent a parcel to Mr. R. Moore, in which was a weasel minus its tail. Mr. R. Moore had written to him demanding to know whether he had sent it, and threatening to "take proceedings" against him. (Laughter.) — Mr. DIXON seconded the motion. — The CHAIRMAN, in putting the motion, said he would not act as they did at the Tory meetings, but would give them an opportunity of showing their disapproval of the motion. (Cheers.) — The motion was carried unanimously: — Mr. SHARP responded, and a vote of thanks to the Chairman concluded the meeting.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ainsworth, David    M.P.  
Bentinck, —      
Broadhurst, —      
Burt, —      
Dixon, —      
Dunn, Samuel      
Ferguson, —      
Gully, —      
Lawson, Wilfred, Sir      
Moore, R.      
Sharpe, Andrew    Miners' Agent  
Waddington, —      
Wyndham, Percy, Hon.      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print