|
2nd October 1884 The Dynamite Outrage At Cleator MoorAt the Whitehaven Petty Sessions on Monday, before H. H. Watson, Esq., J. R. Bain, Esq., and R. Jefferson, Esq., Patrick France, alias French an iron-ore miner, residing at Cleator Moor, was brought up on remand, charged with having attempted to murder Mr. John Moffat, of Montreal House, Cleator Moor, by an explosion of dynamite, or other explosive substance. — Mr. W. W. Lumb appeared on behalf of the Public Prosecutor and Mr. Atter appeared for the prisoner. The Clerk (Mr. Brockbank) asked if the charge was really one of attempting to murder, because if it was it could not be under the Explosives Act, on which he understood Mr. Lumb was proceeding. If the prosecution went on section 2 of the Explosives Act they were required the consent of the Attorney-General: but from what he (Mr. Brockbank) had seen of the evidence from the first, it was impossible to maintain an indictment for attempting to murder, whatever they might do with regard to the offence alleged to have been committed under section 2, for causing an explosion calculated to destroy life or property. — Mr. Lumb said he would take the case under section 2 of the Act. He admitted that it was for the prosecution to make out their case, and he observed that the evidence he had to lay before the Bench was wholly circumstantial; but notwithstanding he thought they would find the evidence of such a nature that it would be their duty to commit the prisoner for trial. If that should be their opinion he should ask the Bench to remand the prisoner for another week, in order that he (Mr. Lumb) might obtain the action of the Attorney-General to this prosecution under section 7 of the Explosives Act. The depositions of the witnesses examined last Monday were taken as read, by consent, on the understanding that if there should be a prima facie case against the prisoner Mr. Atter might further cross-examine Mr. Moffat and Supt. Sempil. George Bell deposed: I live at No. 15, Schoolhouse-Lane, Whitehaven. I am storekeeper and messenger for Mr. Stirling. As such I have charge of the dynamite purchased at his pits. I know the prisoner. I did not know him by name before, but I knew him by sight. He has been a good while in the employment of Mr. Stirling — I don't know how long. He could not say prisoner had access to the dynamite. He had the privilege, like the rest, of coming to the store to obtain dynamite for the purposes of his work, and for all I know he might help himself in going out. The store was kept securely locked, and dynamite was not kept elsewhere. — Cross-examined: Mr. Stirling employs 300 or 400 men; it may be 200 or 300 more for all I know. Dynamite is given out to the workmen in 5lb. packages. A great number of the workmen daily receive it. — By the Chairman: There are about 36 charges in a 5lb; package. — Cross-examination continued: We keep a record of the slate of the company to which the dynamite is taken out, and that is transferred to a store-book. I do not produce the store-book. The men have a store-book their own also. I cannot recollect ever having given prisoner dynamite. There are several other mines in the immediate neighbourhood where a large number of men are employed, and where they give out dynamite in the same way. Ralph Kearton deposed: I live at Galemire. I am an overman in Mr. Stirling's employ. I know the prisoner. He was formerly in Mr. Stirling's employ. The workmen in that employ had ample means of getting dynamite. — Cross-examined: So have the workmen in other mines in the neighbourhood. James Walker Montgomery deposed: I live at Whitehaven, and I am the public analyst for the county of Cumberland. After the explosion on the 30th August, I received instructions to go to Mr. Moffat's house. I went on the 2nd Sept., in company with the Chief Constable. I examined the debris to see whether there were any remains of a fuse among it. I believe the explosion was due to some compound of nitro-glycerine, most likely dynamite. — The Chairman: Is it from the product produced or from any residue that you come to that conclusion? — Witness: Yes, from the effect; we could not find any residue. John Shylock deposed; I live at High-street, Cleator Moor, and am an engineman at Crossfield Pit. I remember Saturday, the 30th August; I was on Cocklety Bridge that night, at 25 minutes to eleven. This bridge is beside the goods railway station at Cleator Moor, I was going home. I was facing the town's clock and thus was aware of the time. I heard an explosion. I did not know at the time from what direction the explosion came. I thought it was from the Iron furnaces. I went straight to Montreal-street corner. I stood there about five minutes. I saw Patrick France. He was going up the Moor in, the direction of Duke-street. He was coming in the same direction as I had come myself, from Cocklety Bridge. There is a road from Mr. Moffat's, Montreal House, to Cocklety Bridge. — By the Chairman: Perhaps it might be ten minutes, it would not be more, after the explosion, that I saw France. — Cross-examined: Cocklety Bridge will be about 150 yards from the corner of Montreal-street. When I say stood five minutes at the corner bf the street I am only having a guess. I have spoken to the police, and I was requested to come here first by the prisoner's wife. When I heard prisoner was arrested, I said I did not think he could have been at it, as I had seen him about ten minutes after the explosion. Cocklety Bridge is in the main street of Cleator Moor. It is lighted with lamps. Where I saw prisoner was quite convenient to the Market-place. I was on the parapet close to the Conservative Rooms. There was a lamp there. There is a public-house on the opposite side called "Ward's corner," where some-times persons congregate in large numbers. There was nothing unusual about prisoner's appearance or style of movement that drew my attention. — Did a police-man of the name of Hamilton lodge with you? I decline to answer that question. — Mr. Brockbank: Go ahead please. — Witness (replying to the question): Yes. Had they left the night before the explosion? I don't know were he was on the night of the explosion. I have now two policemen lodging with me. I am not aware whether they came before or after the reward was offered Hamilton has not come back to me. — By Mr. Lumb: A person would take about a Quarter of an hour to come from Montreal House to Cocklety Bridge, if he walked nicely. John Moffat, re-examined, deposed: I have tried some experiments with dynamite and fuse since the explosion. I tried various lengths of fuse, from 10ft. to 24ft. It took 10ft. of fuse about five minutes to burn, and 24ft took 12 minutes. If fuse be wrapped up in clay, it will burn without showing a light. The fuse which I tried the experiments was the kind used in the pits. In an explosion from fuse wrapped up in clay there was nothing to be seen of the fuse during the explosion — neither fuse nor clay. It took about the same time to burn. It showed no light. I would say it would take considerably over a pound of dynamite to produce the damage done at my house. The prisoner had means of getting dynamite in Mr. Stirling's employ — Mr. Atter said he did not propose cross-examining Mr. Moffat unless there was be a prima facie case, considering his former experience of him. Daniel Anderson, deposed: I am an inspector of Police at Cleator Moor. I apprehended him on the 12th September. I charged him with being concerned in the blowing up of Mr. Moffat's house, on Saturday night, 30th August, with the intention of murdering Mr. Moffat. I cautioned him, told him any reply he might give might be taken down in writing and used against him at his trial. He said: "I knew nothing about it till the next morning at eight o'clock, when my wife shouted upstairs to say that Mr. Moffat's house had been blown up." I was at Mr. Moffat's house all night after the explosion. When the explosion took place I was between Bowthorn-road and Leconfield-street. It was about twenty minutes-five minutes to eleven. I walked down to Mr. Moffat's house from that place in about five minutes walking at a good pace. Early next morning I examined the premises. I found one clog mark on the wall and a slight mark of a clog on the grass. The wall was the boundary wall between the highway and the shrubbery in front of the house — a stone wall between three an four feet high, with iron rails on the top. The coping stone of the wall is of dressed sand stone. There were two marks of clogs on the dressed stone, both inside of the rail. One was a mark of a left clog — that was right in front of the kitchen window were the explosion took place. That appeared to have been made by a man wearing clogs standing in the shrubbery. A distinct mark of a clog was left on the stone. There was a slight mark on the grass near. There was a clog mark inside the rails, close to the pillar at the far end of the standing, about five or six yards away from the first mark. That was a mark of a right foot clog, pointing forwards from the shrubbery to the road. The first clog mark I have mentioned, on the wall, was very distinct it was an outline from the wide part of the foot to the toe. The other mark was longer, but not so distinct on one side. — The Chairman: Were they not such marks as could have been made by the caulkers on shoes? — Witness: Oh, no; no similarity at all. They were distinctly the marks of clog caulkers. I was with Mr. Black, surveyor, who has made tracings of the clog marks. On Thursday, the 25th September, I went to the place with Sergeant Hope, Mr. Superintendent Thornburrow, and Mr. Sempill. I took with me a pair of clogs that I obtained from France's wife at his house on the Tuesday night, the 16th September. Sergeant Hope put on the left foot clog and made a mark alongside the mark I named first. The impression was similar to the one originally on the stone. Sergeant Hope then put on the right foot clog, and made a mark on the wall close to the footprint near the pillar. It corresponded as near as could be to the mark already there. Mr. Black afterwards made a tracing of the whole of the four marks. The clogs produced were exactly in the same state now as when received from the prisoner's wife, except that the sole of one was now split in going over the wall. The right-hand clog looks to be a size larger than the left-hand clog; and the mark on the wall of the left-hand clog is smaller than the right. I have not ascertained where the clogs were obtained. — Cross-examined: France lives within 300 yards of the police-station at Cleator Moor. He never attempted to decamp. Other two persons were taken to the police-station the same night as the prisoner — Cochan and Edward Ennis. In addition to them, John Gribbon, William Doran, and Michael Welsh were taken to the police-station in connection with this charge. Thomas Ennis is not at Cleator Moor. I can't say that he has been charged; I never heard it. I have not heard of Stephen Doran or Philip Waters; I saw it in the newspapers, that is all. I did not take any means to preserve or cover the marks either on the wall or on the grass. I searched about to see if I could find other marks. There was another mark on the outside wall, that I have not mentioned. It was below the clog mark, as if of a man putting his foot up and slipping. The mark on the grass was not worth covering, and the one on the wall was distinct, and is now. I cannot swear that the marks on the wall were not made before the explosion, for they are as distinct now as they were when I first saw them. I took the clogs on the 17th September and compared them myself with the marks on the wall. No one was with me then. I have attended the Court both days on which the prisoner was examined, but I was not called. I took a little bit of a branch, and measured the marks and measured the clogs. I did nothing more till the 25th. I never asked the prisoner for the boots he was wearing that night. I asked Mrs. France for France's clogs. France has never been shown those clogs. They are not what he was wearing when he was taken into custody. I have seen him wearing clogs. I have seen him wearing clogs since the explosion. They are not the sort of clog that is generally worn at the pits; they are what are worn by the men at nights when they are off work. Many a hundred people wear clogs. These are just the ordinary kind that is worn. I would not be surprised if the clogs produced are not prisoner's. — Re-examined: I got the clogs produced from prisoner's wife as his clogs, and I believe them to be such. Since the explosion the premises of Mr. Moffat have been watched to see that neither the footmarks nor anything else were disturbed. John Hope deposed: I live at Whitehaven, and am a sergeant of county police. On the night of the 30th August I went to Mr. Moffat's house, and remained there till daybreak. I then made an inspection of the premises, and was assisted in so doing by Inspector Anderson. I found marks of clogs on the wall spoken to by Inspector Anderson. On Thursday last I went with Inspector Anderson and Mr. Sempill to examine the marks. Inspector Anderson handed me a pair of clogs. I put on the left one, and got over the wall into the shrubbery, leaving a mark alongside the mark of the left foot clog mark already there; and then I put on the right clog and came over again into the road, again leaving a mark to compare with the other original mark. The marks I made, and those that were already on the coping-stone, were similar in appearance and identical in measurement. — Cross-examined: Witness could tell nothing about a man acting the part of a police-detective having been put into prisoner's cell. Had not heard the prisoner make a statement respecting it. Did not know of a man from Workington being locked up at Whitehaven on arrears of bastardy. Had not charge of the lock-up at Whitehaven. A man from Workington might properly be locked up at Whitehaven on such a charge, if the complainant lived at Whitehaven; but he knew of no such case. Had no reason to suppose that the prisoner's feet were at all different in size, except the clogs. Had never asked prisoner whether the clogs produced belonged to him. William Black deposed: I live at Hensingham, and am a mining engineer. I know Montreal House. I have been shown by Inspector Anderson four clog marks on the coping-stone of the wall between the house and the road. I have made very careful tracings of those marks, which I now produce. The marks made by Sergeant Hope and the original marks appear to have been made by the same clog, or a clog of the same size. The widths of the sole of the foot agree. The print near the pillar is a little larger than the one opposite the window. I have been shown the clogs produced, which are right and left clogs. I have measured those clogs across the "ball." The right foot is 3 inches and 5-eights, and the smaller one is 3 inches and a half. I have not compared the measurement of the clogs with the measurement of the marks on the wall. — Cross-examined: I have not had much experience of boots or clogs. The fact that one of the clogs was split by Sergeant Hope would not make the one mark larger than the other, if Sergeant Hope's foot was larger; because the split clog was the one that left the narrower mark. I do not say of the tracings that the marks are exactly similar, but the measurements are the same. There is a slight difference between the original marks and those left by Sergeant Hope; they do not entirely correspond. There is nothing peculiar about the boots or about the marks. — Re-examined: The general outline of the mark made by Sergeant Hope corresponds with that originally made. The slight difference in the marks would be accounted for by the tooling of the stone and the different pressure with which the foot might be put down. Superintendent Sempill, recalled, deposed: I have heard the evidence of Inspector Anderson and Sergt. Hope with reference to the footprints on the coping of the wall. The marks made by Sergeant Hope correspond with the original marks. I have carefully examined the clogs, and I believe that both the marks were made by those clogs. The right clog was considerably larger than the left in length, breadth, and altogether. There is a correspondence in the marks on the wall to the difference in size of the clogs. The general outlines agree. The tooling of the stone decidedly affects the spots left on the stone, although not the size or measurements. On the Sunday morning after the outrage Sergt. Hope pointed out on one of the footmarks the appearance of dust along the grooves; and that conveyed to my mind the idea that the marks had been made quite recently. — Cross-examined: I did not think it was prudent to take the tracings of the marks before I did. I decline to give you the reason why I thought it was not prudent. — On appeal to the Bench, the Chairman said they thought Mr. Atter should not press the question, and Mr. Atter in deference to them, accordingly abandoned it. This was the case against the prisoner. Mr. Atter, on behalf of the prisoner, said there was no evidence, either circumstantial or direct, to incriminate the prisoner on this charge. As Mr. Lumb said the charge was a serious one, but there was all the more reason why there should be direct evidence against the prisoner. It was not fair that a man's liberty should be at stake on so serious a charge unless there was evidence to support the charge; and he said that today there had not been one tittle of evidence which in any way brought home the charge against the prisoner. Bell and Kearton strongly proved the prisoner's case, because hundreds of persons, they showed, had the same opportunity of getting dynamite as the prisoner. There was no question as to Mr. Montgomery's evidence, for he was not there to deny that an explosion did take place, and probably of dynamite. The testimony of Shylock was strongly in favour of the prisoner; for the remark that he made there and then, on hearing that the prisoner was apprehended, was that he could not have been the man. The evidence of the police and their conduct in this case had been highly unsatisfactory. Inspector Anderson said he made an examination of the footprints the day after he got the clogs, but so little was thought of his testimony that he was never called before now. That was on the 17th September, and nothing further was done until Thursday last, when Sergeant Hope took these clogs, and what he did he (Mr. Atter) did not know, for nobody was there on behalf of the prisoner, and all that the police did was best known to themselves. But if all that they did and said was straightforward and proper it did not bring the charge in any way nearer to the prisoner. Those boots, even if they were the prisoners (and he said nothing about that), were only like hundreds of others that were worn at Cleator Moor, and there was nothing peculiar about the marks which in any way brought the charge home to the prisoner. The prisoner was one of those who were prepared to prove that the policeman Hamilton, on the 12th July, told the Orangemen to fire, thus causing the riot that took place that day. Remarks had been made independent of himself on the conduct of Hamilton; and he (Mr. Atter) said that it was on account of the prisoner making that charge that he had been taken into custody by the police out of spite. There was not a tittle of evidence which in any way justified the conduct of the police in taking prisoner into custody. It was not very easy for the prisoner, a man leading a life nearly every day of which had the same experience, to say at the police-station, in the presence of a number of policemen, when called on suddenly in the middle of the night, where he happened to be at a certain time on some night a fortnight before. And because he did not give them that information they came into the witness-box and said they had sufficient evidence against him. He submitted that the prisoner should not be sent for trial, but should be discharged. The magistrates retired with Mr. Brockbank to consider their decision. On their return, after a short absence, the Chairman said: From the evidence to-day there seems to be a prima facie case against the prisoner, and we don't consider we shall be doing right to discharge him; but we remand him till next Monday, so that the Attorney-General can be communicated with in the usual way. In answer to Mr. Atter, Mr. Brockbank said if there were any witnesses for the defence their depositions had better be taken now, so that all the facts of the case might be laid before the Attorney-General. The magistrates would be guided by his decision. If the Attorney-General said there was not a case to prosecute, the magistrates would discharge the prisoner. Of course, Mr. Atter would have the right to call his witnesses for the defence afterwards, and have their depositions taken, if he did not do so now: but it was desirable that the Attorney-General should have all the facts before him. Mr. Atter said if the Attorney-General decided that there was no case his witnesses for the defence would not be necessary; and if he had the right to call them afterwards, in the event of a prosecution being decided on, he would run the risk of that and defer calling any just now. He again applied for bail on behalf of the prisoner. Mr. Lumb opposed the application. The Chairman: It is no use asking for bail to-day. Prisoner was then removed in custody.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||