|
25th September 1884 The Dynamite Outrage At Cleator MoorFurther Magisterial ProceedingsAt the Whitehaven Petty Sessions, on Monday (before H. H. Watson, Esq., H. Jefferson, Esq., R. Jefferson, Esq., and J. R. Bain, Esq.), Patrick France, alias French, miner, Cleator Moor, was brought up on remand, charged with having attempted to murder Mr. Thomas Moffat, mining engineer to Mr. John Stirling, by blowing up his residence with dynamite or other explosive. The court was crowded. Mr. Dunne, Chief Constable, occupied a seat at the rear part of the magistrates' bench. — Mr. W. W. Lumb prosecuted, and Mr. Atter defended the prisoner. — Mr. Lumb said that in this case he was instructed by the Public Prosecutor to appear in support of this charge, which was preferred against Patrick France for attempting to murder Thomas Moffat by means of an explosion of dynamite or other explosive substance on the 30th August last. France was taken into custody on the 12th September. He was brought before the Bench last Monday, and was remanded until to day. The charge was a serious charge, and was one that took great care and time in getting up; and he was not prepared to go fully into the evidence to-day, but would simply call before the magistrates such evidence as he thought necessary to enable them to grant a further remand until this day week, when he hoped that he would be able to go fully into the case. — Thomas Moffat, examined by Mr. Lumb, deposed: I live at Montreal House, Cleator Moor, and am a mining engineer. I remember Saturday night, the 30th of August last. I was at Montreal House that night, between ten and eleven, living there with my family. An explosion of dynamite or some other explosive substance took place there, at somewhere about twenty minutes to eleven. — Mr. Lumb: Will you describe the nature of the explosion, shortly? — Mr. Moffat: "Well the charge was placed on the kitchen window. — Mr. Atter: You did not see this, and I must object to it. If you saw the person place it you may so; but do not say what you suppose. — Mr. Brockbank: Describe the effect of the explosion. — Mr. Moffat: The effect of the explosion was to totally shatter all the glass in all the windows facing Crossfield-road, with the exception of the attic window which was uninjured, and the staircase window which was partially blown out. The glass of the lower sash of that part of the drawing-room window looking towards Crossfield-road was smashed. The fan light above the kitchen door was very much shattered and blown out. The kitchen wall facing the window where the explosion took place was pitted all over and studded with particles of glass, from the force of the explosion. The door leading into the back kitchen and another door leading into a pantry were burst open. The table standing in front of the window in the kitchen was blown to the other side of the room, and completely smashed. The other furniture in the kitchen was more or less damaged. — Have you any knowledge of dynamite, Mr. Moffat? Yes. — Do you believe that this explosion was caused by dynamite? Yes. — Mr. Brockbank: How long have you had a knowledge of dynamite? — Witness: Well, I may say since it was first introduced. — Mr. Lumb: Do you know the prisoner, Mr. Moffat? Yes. — Prisoner: Yes, and I know Tom an' all. — Mr. Atter (to the prisoner): Please keep quiet, and leave your case with me. — Witness continued: I have known the prisoner for a considerable time: I cannot say how long. He was in Mr. Stirling's employ some little time ago. I am manager of Mr. Stirling's iron-ore mines, and I gave prisoner notice to leave the employ some time ago — in the beginning of August. Some other men received notice to leave at the same time. After he had worked his notice up he came to me and asked why he had received his notice. I said I declined to say what he had got his notice for. He had got his notice in the usual way, and I did not consider I was bound to give him any reason. He asked if I thought I was acting wisely in what I was doing. — Mr. Lumb: In what kind of way did he say that? Well, he said that in rather a threatening manner — in rather a malicious sort of way he said it. — Did he say anything else to you? He asked me, "What about the pistol shooters? I said those were matters I did not intend to discuss, and I declined to say anything further in the matter. — Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: Did not give any intimation to the police of prisoner threatening or appearing to be malicious until the day after, the explosion, nor did I ever mention it to any other person. I have given to the police the names of other men who have been discharged. — You mentioned to the police the manner of other people who you thought insulted or threatened you at all after they had been discharged? No. — You say so? Yes. — What number of persons did you discharge at the same time as you discharged the prisoner? Somewhere about seven or eight. I am speaking from memory, and I can't say exactly. I have not discharged 100, nor 20, but I will not swear that I did not discharge ten within a week or a fortnight. — From the 12th July to the happening of the explosion, can you tell the magistrates any number of men who have been discharged by you from the pit? That is a question I must decline to answer. — On what grounds do you decline to answer? Because I don't see that it is necessary to go into all the private matters of the works simply to prove why that man was discharged. — Then these are private matters: that is your opinion. Then I will have an answer? I decline to answer. — Mr. Brockbank: Oh, yes — I see the force of the question, if you don't — I think you must answer. — Witness: Well, of course I am only speaking from memory, and I can't give you the exact number: there might be 20, but I can t say precisely to one or two. — Mr. Atter: May there be 50? No; there are not 50. — Have all the persons that have been discharged, so far as your knowledge goes, been of the one religious persuasion? No. — You say no? Yes. — Can you mention out of the 20 to your knowledge the probable number of persons who were not Roman Catholic? I don't know of my own knowledge their religious persuasion. — Were they not discharged in consequence of what took place on the 12th at Cleator Moor? I decline to answer. — Then I press it. — Witness persisted in declining to answer. — Mr. Brockbank said the questions were very simple and proper, and the witness must answer them — whether the men discharged were all of one religious persuasion, and whether they were discharged in consequence of what took place on the 12th at Cleator Moor. — Witness: I decline to give reasons here for the discharge of men. — Mr. Brockbank: Well, but Mr. Moffat, I think it is a proper question; because you are endeavouring to make out that it was in consequence of discharging this particular man that something was done to you, and if you discharged a number of men on the same ground there may be the same motive for any of them. — Witness: I have not given any reason for discharging the men. — Mr. Atter: No, you haven't; and I want you to say now. What the Clerk has stated is exactly the reason why I will have an answer. — Mr. Brockbank: Of course it goes to the gist of the whole offence. — Witness: Well, there were some discharged for one thing and some for another. — Mr. Atter: Well, I put the question to you, were any of the men discharged from your works in consequence of what took place on the 12th July? — Witness: I decline to answer. — Mr. Atter: Then you will answer, sir, that is all. — Mr. Brockbank (after consultation with the Bench): The Bench are of opinion that you must answer that question. — Witness: Well, the principal reason — . — Mr. Atter: That isn't my question. Were any of the men discharged from your works in consequence of what took place on the 12th July? There were no men discharged solely on that account. — Tell me the reason the prisoner was discharged? I decline. — Mr. Brockbank said the witness must answer the question. — Witness: Well, if you will have the answer, I discharged him because I considered him a dangerous character to have about the place. — When did you first consider him a dangerous character? I appeal to the magistrates whether I am bound to answer. — Mr. Brockbank said he thought all these questions lead up to a material point. It might be pleasanter not to answer; but there was a grave charge against the prisoner, of which he might be guilty or he might be entirely innocent; and Mr. Moffat having stated that he considered him a dangerous character must state now the grounds of his belief. — Mr. Atter: When did you first consider him a dangerous character to have about the place? I can't say precisely, just now; but I had a reason for not having him about the place before the time of his discharge. — About when, then? It might be about two or three months ago. — What was it made you consider him a dangerous character? Those are questions I decline to answer. — Then you shall answer. You have come here to state the truth, and the whole truth, haven't you? Yes. — Then having made the statement that you considered him a dangerous man if it is the truth you will have no difficulty in answering the question on what grounds you consider him a dangerous man? [Witness remained silent.] — Mr. Brockbank: If you have no reason, say so. You know. Mr. Moffat, it does not do to state you consider a man a dangerous man without stating your grounds for so doing. — Witness: I found him interfering with things about the works that he had no business to interfere with. — Mr. Atter: What were the matters he was interfering with? I must decline to answer. — Mr. Atter: But you will be obliged to answer. You have said that before, you know, and you have answered. You have stated something about this man's character; we will have something about your character before we are done. — Mr. Lumb (to witness): Say what it was. — Witness: He made statements and reports about the works that were not true, to begin with. — Mr. Atter: To whom did he make those statements? In Cleator Moor. — Yes, I dare say; but to whom? — Mr. Brockbank: You see, Mr. Moffat, you have made a very grave statement against the prisoner. — Witness: I would not have made the statement if I was not pressed. — Mr. Atter: But you are pressed now, and you will have to give a reason for it. To whom did he make those statements? Well, he made the statement to our workmen. — Name the workman? Milburn is the name. — Christian name? George. — What was the statement? He said he had taken certain weights of the output and certain weights of the despatches, and he showed that there was a great discrepancy, and consequently that there was an injury being done to somebody. — Was there any other reason beyond that for your statement that you considered him a dangerous man? I considered a man who would go and do these things about the works was a dangerous man to have about the works. — Had you any other reason than that? Well, there were other reasons, of course. — We will have them, then? Well, there is my general opinion of his character, from that and other remarks he had been making about the place. — Give me anything else he had been stating, and the person he had been stating it to? Well, I don't remember anything just now. — Can you remember any other reason than that you have given for the conclusion you say you have formed about him? I decline to give any other reason at present. — Mr. Brockbank: Oh, do! Don't keep the Court all day, Mr. Moffat. — Witness: Well, he made some remark to the banker as well, which I don't remember at present. — Surely that, it you don't remember what it was, would not help you to come to that conclusion? Yes, it did. — What is the banker's name? Graham. — In answer to further questions, with a continuation of the same hesitation to give replies, witness said he heard from Milburn what prisoner had been saying respecting the weights before giving him notice. Never spoke to prisoner about what Milburn told him. He had heard of complaints being made about the weights, but no complaint had ever been made to him. Perhaps he had heard of half a dozen who so complained. He did not dismiss any of them or consider them dangerous characters. He had not yet said what he discharged France for. He did not discharge him because he complained about the weights. He declined to say why he discharged France. He had told part of the reason. Pressed to tell the whole reason, he said from what he learned of France before, and from what he learned of the way in which he conducted himself on the 12th, he thought he was not a character to be about the place. The conversation with France after his discharge took place in his office. No one else was present. Gave no directions to stop payment of France's money. Took no proceedings against France by summons for threatening him. Did not consider it unreasonable that he should ask why he had been discharged, but considered he was not bound to answer him. When a man left the place he gave his notice in and left of his own accord, and when he gave the men notice he did not consider he was bound to give them any other reason than that their services were not required. It would be somewhere about twenty minutes to eleven when the explosion took place. He looked at the clock or his watch — he could not be sure which, or whether he might not have consulted both — a few minutes after the explosion, and it was then about a quarter to eleven. After the 12th July he did not ask for any police protection, nor make any complaint of being in fear. Had no reason at the time of the explosion to fear any injury to himself or damage to his property, and had never expressed any fear to any one. — Re-examined by Mr. Lumb: Gave prisoner the customary week's notice. Prisoner had threatened men in the employment of Mr. Stirling, he was informed. That was the reason he thought him a dangerous character. — Mr. Atter objected that the words had been put into the witness's mouth by leading questions. Why did the witness not mention this before? — Witness: It escaped my memory at the moment. — Mr. Lumb: Who did he threaten? — Witness: He threatened that man Milburn. — John Douglas Sempill deposed that he was the deputy chief constable of the county, and, as such, had charge of this case. He knew the prisoner previous to his being taken into custody. On Thursday night, the 11th September, he was at Cleator Moor, and on that night, at half-past twelve o'clock, prisoner was brought to the police-station there by his directions. Witness told him that he had sent for him on suspicion of his being connected with that dynamite outrage at the house of Mr. Moffat which occurred about 20 minutes to 11 on the night of the 30th August. He (witness) explained to him that if he had any explanation to give as to his whereabouts, and whom he had been talking to between 10 and 11 o'clock, about the time of the explosion, the police might be able to inquire into the truth of what he said. He waited a considerable time for a reply, but prisoner made none. Witness then directed Inspector Anderson to charge the prisoner. He was cautioned immediately after being charged, and he then said, "I knew nothing about the explosion until my wife shouted to me at eight o'clock next morning." Got a cab, and half-an-hour afterwards conveyed him to Whitehaven. On the way to Whitehaven he entered into conversation with witness. He said he had heard that Cochan and Ennis had been to the police-station, and he wanted to know what had become of them. Witness did not satisfy him then as to what had become of them. He then said, "I suppose somebody had to be apprehended, and I have to suffer for the lot." Witness said, "You must not say that, France. I must tell you that both Cochan and Ennis explained to me where they were, and who they were talking to when the explosion was heard. I found their statements to be true, and you had the same opportunity." He said, "I was about the market, but saw nobody — not that I knowed," and added that he did not keep company or go about public-houses. Witness considered it would not be prudent in the interests of justice to give further evidence to-day, and asked for a remand for a week. — Mr. Brockbank (to Mr. Lumb): Do you represent the Public Prosecutor? — Mr. Lumb: Yes, I am acting on his instructions. — Mr. Brockbank: Is there anything at present with reference to the authority of the Attorney-General, under Section 7? — Mr. Lumb: No, sir; not yet. — Mr. Brockbank: It is not necessary for the purpose of remand. — Mr. Lumb: When the case is complete then I think is the time to apply for the Attorney-General's fiat. — Mr. Atter, for the defence, contended that it was most unreasonable, when there was not a tittle of evidence forthcoming, to again ask for a remand. If the prisoner was set at liberty he would be accessible at any time if anything was found out against him. He opposed the application for a remand. — The Chairman said they had decided to remand the prisoner till next Monday, and they hoped that by that time something more definite would be brought before them in the way of evidence. — Mr. Atter applied for bail, which was refused on the ground that it would not be prudent.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||