|
25th September 1884 The Recent Fatal Mining Accident At FrizingtonThe Adjourned InquestOn Saturday afternoon last the adjourned inquest touching the death of the lad named Andrew Cain, who was killed on Friday, the 12th inst., in No. 5 Iron-ore Pit, Frizington, the property of Messrs. Fletcher, by a fall of the roof, was resumed at the "Fleecy Ram," Wath Brow, Cleator, before Mr. H. J. Whiteside, deputy coroner, and the following jury:— Messrs. D. Bell (foreman), R. Crone, G. Bell, N. Vipond, T. White, M. Hope, J. Bawden, E. Oates, W. Graham, G. McRenney, J. Moore, W. Fisher, and W. Russell. — Mr. Lewis T. Helder (of the firm Messrs. Brockbank, Helder, & Brockbank) was present on behalf of the owners of the mine. — Messrs. Fletcher; and Mr. E. Atter was also in attendance, on behalf of the relatives of the deceased. — The first witness, Patrick Falloon, said he was a miner, and worked for Messers. Fletcher. The accident occurred about half-past nine in the morning. He was told of it, and went at once to the spot. The place turned off the main "eye," and rose up till they got to the metal, when it was level ground. They at once organised a gang to get the deceased out, as he was quite buried in the stuff that had fallen. They didn't know exactly where he was, and it was about midnight before they got the body out. The body was lying about six or eight feet from the fore-breast, and four or five feet from the side of the working. The roof had come down in a solid mass, commencing near the fore-breast, and covering the ground with about six or seven feet in depth of limestone. The lad was quite dead when they got him out. There were no large stones on him. — By Mr. Helder: He did not work in this particular place, but he had been in it. It seemed a solid stone roof, and looked as though it would stand for a generation. There was no parting on either side, and he would have had no fear to work in it himself. It was what was considered a safe roof. — By the Coroner: He never knew any stone come down. — By the Foreman: He had been working at the place for three years, and he considered the managers were particularly attentive. They came round every day to inspect the roofs. — John Cain said he was the father of the deceased. He did not work in the same pit as his son, but he was in the same employ. He was sure that if the roof had been a good stone one, as it was said to be, it never could have come down. There were no props under it. If there had been, the roof would have given warning before it came down. The place would be about 15 or 16 feet high, and the same in breadth. When he saw it, it extended about five or six fathoms, but had since been worked further. The lad told his mother that sill was dropping time after time from the roof. He mentioned it about a week before he was killed. — By the Foreman: He did not report it to the overman; it was not his duty to do so. According to the Act of Parliament the place was much larger that it ought to be. The lad was not employed by the company. He was engaged by the overman, Edward Rowe, and paid by the men as a labourer. — Falloon, recalled for cross-examination by Mr. Atter, said as far as he understood the overman Edward Rowe made an inspection of the roof the morning previous to the day on which the accident occurred. He did no know that anyone had been to inspect it on the day of the accident, the 12th September. — By the Foreman: There might have been someone round, without him knowing it, as he didn't work in the spot. — By Mr. Atter: It was the duty of some one to go around every day to inspect it, but when you went to your work you had no guarantee that anyone had been round to inspect it. They generally went round about eight or nine o'clock. Mr. Rowe came down as soon as he heard of the accident. — Josiah Collins, a miner, belonging to the same gang as Cain, said he went to work about six o'clock on the morning of the 12th September. Two men named William Warren and John Whitford were in the same working with him. No one to his knowledge had inspected the roof from the time witness went to work to the time of the accident. Witness himself examined part of it near the hollow where Cain was working, and found it up to the fore-breast as sound as a bell. — By the Coroner: A bell without a crack in it. Witness was lightly injured by the fall; having his legs buried. He had not been to work since. — By Mr. Helder: He had worked about 12 months at that work, and he always had considered it a firm roof. — By Mr. Atter: He sounded the roof of his own free will. The overman was down the day before to examine it. He looked at it, but he didn't sound it with the hammer. He (witness) made a report to the overman on the Thursday when he was down, and told him it was a good sound roof. He had always told him so. — By the Foreman: It was the duty of every workman for his own safety to examine the roof. — By Mr. Atter: It was not part of Andrew Cain's duty to do so. — By the Jury: One side of the roof was of metal and the other side of stone and between these there was a layer of sill. — William Warren said he was one of the party working with the last witness. He saw Collins sound the place, and heard him say that it was all right. Witness had examined it himself before, and found it all right. Witness was close to the fore-breast when the fall came. The fall came down all in a lump, and there would be about 600 tons of stuff. It was their duty to look after the place. It was only Rowe's duty to ask them if everything was right, and not to examine it himself. The roof had seemed all right and there was no hallow place above it. — By Mr. Helder: It was customary to sound the roof every day. He had no fear in working under the roof; if he had any he would have left. — By Mr. Atter: If they had wanted to timber the place they (the men) would have had to do it in their own time. Rowe told them if they wanted wood they had to get it, but they had no need of it. If the place had been wooded the weight of the stuff that came down would have broken the props. There had been props put in other workings by Rowe's orders since this roofing came down. — John Whitford said he had examined the roof the day before the accident, and he could detect no flaw in it. Cain never said anything about sill falling. — Witness in further cross-examination by Mr. Atter, corroborated the previous statements. He said that if they had timbered the place, the company would have supplied the wood, but they (the men) would have lost time in doing it. The place was not examined that morning, but it was examined the morning before. They sometimes started work before examining the roof. If Rowe came in and found they had done so, he always told them that they ought to examine it every morning. It was the fault of himself and his mates that it had not been examined on the day of the accident. Collins was up the ladder on the Friday examining the place. Props of wood would have made it safer, now that they knew it had fallen in, but it was a solid stone roof, and when it was struck with the hammer, the hammer would bound back again. — Edward Rowe, the overman, was next called, and said he was an underground steward. He knew the working were Cain was killed well. He examined it the morning before the accident. He didn't make a practical examination of it, but he asked the men, and they replied that it was as sound as the bell of brass. The roof seemed to be of solid limestone. He had no idea of the cause of the accident unless there had been a joint in one of the sides that they knew nothing about, and the air had got into it. It was quite customary to have a place of such breadth without props. The men would have lost nothing by timbering it, as they would have been paid four shillings a day for that work. Witness had been 28 years in the pit, and 18 years underground manager. — By Mr. Helder: It was not customary for any overman to examine the roof unless there was some complaint, and then it was their duty to do so. — By Mr. Atter: He could not say that it would have been safer to have the place wooded. He had wooded several places. He never asked the men whether the place should be wooded, as it was quite new. He had talked over with Collins and Warren about the place, but not since the accident happened. He didn't know of anything been given to them. He didn't believe sounding was any good as a test. There were blocks of limestone in the roof five feet thick, and he didn't think sounding would have any effect upon them. If the place had not been inspected, the blame would he should think come on the miners. It was not part of the deceased's duty to examine it. It was the duty of the men in the gang — Collins, Whitford, and Warren. It was also their duty to see that it was wooded if it required it. — He threw all blame off himself, knowing that they were practical men. The deceased was paid by these men, but was allowed by witness to go down the pit, and he had to obey his (witness's) orders. By the Foreman: In similar cases it was his custom to talk about wood and tell them to get it if they wanted any, but he didn't remember saying so on the day before the accident. He might have done so. — Warren, re-called, said Rowe did not say to him on Thursday, "If you want wood get it." He asked at different times if the place wanted wooding, and they told him it didn't. — Whitford, re-called, said that on the day before the accident he believed Mr. Rowe said to him, "If you want wood, lads, you can get anything you want." It was a regular thing to say, if you want anything you can get it. — This concluded the evidence, and the Coroner briefly summed up. — The room was then cleared, and after a half and hour's deliberation the jury returned a verdict of "Accident death," and they also recommended that props be used more freely in the mine.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||