|
18th September 1884 The Recent Explosion At Moresby CollieryProsecution Of WorkmenAt the Whitehaven Police-court, on Monday, before H. H. Watson, Esq., and R. Jefferson. Esq., James Cowler, Terence O'Neal, John Barry, and John McKew, miners, were charged on two information's, one for infringing the special rules and the other for a breach of the general rules of the Moresby Coal Company, on the 23rd of June. Barry and McKew did not appear, and their cases were not gone into. — Mr. Atter appeared for the prosecution, and Mr. Paisley, of Workington, was for Cowler and Barry. — Mr. A. Sharp, of Maryport, agent for the miners, was also present with Mr. Paisley. — At the request of Mr. Paisley, the witnesses on both sides were ordered out of court. Mr. Atter stated that in these cases he appeared to prosecute on behalf of the Moresby Coal Company. The men were charged with two separate offences, one under the special rules, and the other under the local Mines Regulation Act, 1872. The offences were stated to be that on the 23rd June, at Moresby, being employed in a certain coalmine, Walk Mill Colliery, they did unlawfully contravene one of the special rules established for, and then in force in the said mine, to wit — by then and there passing beyond a certain station appointed in the said name, before such mine, or part of such mine, beyond the said station, had been inspected, and stated to be safe; and, 2nd, that on the 23rd June, at the said mine, they did contravene a special rule, by then and there proceeding to a certain travelling road or working place in the said mine, before such travelling road or working place had been reported upon by the fireman or other person appointed for the purpose that the same was safe to be entered. On the date named the defendants went into the pit. They got to the fireman's station, where some other persons were assembled, and they were told that the fireman had not come back and reported. The defendants went into the working, and the result was an explosion. The men had injured themselves and brought on themselves suffering, and further injury might have been done to the property, and the directors felt bound to take notice of this case. The penalty in each case was not to exceed 40s, but the Company did not press for a conviction in both cases. They would be satisfied with one conviction. — Mr. A. Johnstone, C.E. (of the firm if Messrs. Strongitham & Johnstone), produced a plan of the workings of the Walk Mill Pit, in which the accident occurred, and pointed out the fireman's station and the working where the explosion took place. — Cross examined by Mr. Paisley: There was no notice up to intimate that the place he indicated on the plan was a fireman's station. He visited the pit four months ago, and again on the 5th September, when this was pointed out to him as a fireman's station by the overman (Mr. Miller). — Mr. James Ramsay, certificated manager for the Colliery Company stated that these proceedings were taken at the instance of the directors of the Company. He produced a copy of the special rules in force on the 23rd June, when the accident occurred. They were duly posted on the pit top. — Mr. Paisley objected to the rules being received in evidence, as they did not bear the signature of the Government Inspector of Mines. — Mr. Atter pointed out that the signature and certificate of the Inspector were appended to the rules. — The Clerk, on reading the certificate, pointed out that the date of the signature of the Government Inspector was only the 5th of September last, and that if that was the only signature they had there would be no special rules in force at the time of the accident. — Witness said they sent two copies of the rules to the Home Secretary five years ago, but had never had them returned. — The Clerk: Government officials want rubbing up a bit. If you sent up the special rules and they were never signed, then there would be no rules at all. — Mr. Atter contended that according to the Act, if they were exhibited for forty days and no one objected, they then became law. — Mr. Paisley: But those at the mine required to be signed. — The Clerk said he did not see how Mr. Atter could get over the fact that the rules were not signed. — Mr. Atter: They are signed. — The Clerk: They would be right if the offence had been committed after the signing of the rules, but they were not signed until September. I am against you on the special rules on the ground that the rules were not signed. — It was then agreed to proceed on one information under the general act. — Witness continued: He said that on the 23rd of June they had a fireman employed under the Act, and they had had a fireman's station appointed for the last five years. At this station workmen were required to see the fireman before they proceeded to their work. The two defendants passed this station on the date named without leave or authority. The pit was not working on the day of the explosion. Witness was not in the pit at the time of the occurrence; but the place where the lamp was found was pointed out to him on the following day. The lamp was found in the working. — The witness was cross-examined at great length by Mr. Paisley. — In the course of his cross-examination, he said that the force of the explosion might blow the lamp a considerable distance. He was aware that alterations were daily made in the pit. The men never worked in the place where they were injured, but it was necessary for them to travel up the working to get to their place. He did not know what took the men there. He knew that the two defendants were discharged on the 21st of June. The only reason they would have for being in the pit would be for to bring out their gear. He did not discharge the men himself, but he left word with the banksmen to tell them that they were to have no more work, as they filled nothing but dirt. When the accident occurred he reported the affair to Mr. W. Fletcher, chairman of the Company. After the explosion he assisted Mr. Cowler's wife, as being in need. The money was not given as payment. He might assist her for two or three weeks. The money was stopped when it was seen that the woman was not thankful. — Mr. Paisley: Was it not stopped after you received this notice under the Employment Liability Act? — Witness admitted that that was the cause. — Mr. Paisley closely questioned the witness as to the monetary aid given to this man who was alleged to have infringed their rules, and as to the time when the prosecution was decided on. — Witness, in reply, said the money was paid out of kindness, and he thought all honour was due to him for helping the woman. As to the time when the prosecution was decided upon, he was recommended to prosecute the same week that the accident occurred, by the Deputy inspector of Mines, who visited the mines. He could not say whether there was anything on the minutes of the Company or not. He only received verbal instructions. He sent a written report to Mr. Willis the Government Inspector, but he did not charge the defendants with negligence in that report. When the Deputy inspector visited the pit on the following Friday he did not make any special recommendations. He had a caution board put up after the accident. He put it up on the following day. It had since been removed, as the workings had gone further in. There was no notice to indicate that the station was for the fireman, but every workmen understood that it was such, and that no one was allowed to go in by without seeing the fireman. He himself saw that that was carried out. It was an offence to pass the place without leave on the 23rd of June. It had been observed as a rule ever since the pit opened that the men were to meet the fireman at this station. He had never seen any one man pass the station without the leave of the fireman. On the Friday before the accident he turned a man named Lamb out of the working, and caused the men to use closed lamps. He had since taken back O'Neal, one of the defendants, to work for the Company. Since the pits were opened there had been about three gas explosions in the mine, at which five men had been injured. — Mr. Atter objected to this style of cross-examination. It was not material to this case, and was only fishing for another court. — Mr. Paisley denied that he was fishing for another court. — In re-examination, Mr. Ramsay said that the men had no right to pass the station. Witness consulted Mr. Atter as to taking proceedings against the men the same week that the accident occurred, and long before Cowler left the Infirmary. — Mr. Paisley said he had an objection to take to the proceedings, and he thought he might as well take it at that stage. They had it in evidence that at the time of the explosion the men had been discharged by the Company, and were not then in their employ, and would no therefore come under the provisions of the Act. He quoted a case which he contended uphold this view. — The Clerk pointed out that if the objection was to succeed it would be fatal to the notice which had been given under the Employer's Liability Act. — Mr. Paisley said he would have something to say as to that at the proper time. The magistrate would not have that point to decide. — The Clerk: Sufficient for the day is the evil thereof. (Laughter.) — Mr. Paisley: Quite so. — Mr. Atter contended that as the men had not returned their gear to bank they had not completed their bargain, and to prove this he re-called Mr. Ramsay, who said that the men were never paid their wages when leaving until they returned their gear to the office at the pit-top. — The Clerk said the objection would narrow very much the object of the Act, and his opinion was that the men at the time of the explosion must be considered as workmen. — William Rundle, fireman at the pit, said they examined no working places except on working days. On the 23rd of June he saw neither Cowler nor O'Neal, and he examined no working places that day. At half past six on the morning of the explosion he was on the engine way. The station was well know to the men in the employ. He also saw the two men Barry and McKew, who had passed the station without witness's permission. — In cross-examination, witness said that on ordinary working days the men never descended the pit until he gave the signal. On this morning he met others past the station as well as Barry and McKew. They were about ten yards apart. Their names were Joseph Kirkbride, John Kirkbride, Henry Haig, and Joseph Osborne. It was an invariable rule for men to wait at this station until they met the fireman. He could not account for these men passing the station the morning of the explosion. — Henry Haig stated that on the 23rd of June he was in the pit. The fireman's station was quite well known. He and two men waited at the station for the fireman. He saw Cowler and the other men at the pit, and when a light was seen there were shouts of "He's coming," and the defendants and others went away into the mine. — Cross-examined: When the report was given that the fireman was coming it turned out to be the wrong man. — Joseph Kirkbride, William Miller, deputy overman, and Joseph Osborne, also gave evidence. — Mr. Atter said he had four more witnesses, but in order to save the time of the court he would not call them. — Mr. Paisley addressed the court for the defendants, stating that it was a matter of importance that this case should be fully investigated. He need scarcely remind the Bench that the two defendants had already suffered considerable hardships in connection with the explosion, and he thought it was most unfortunate that any such proceedings should have been taken after the delay, especially when they remembered they were only instituted after a notice had been served upon them under the Employers' Liability Act. According to Mr. Ramsay, as soon as it was discovered that the woman was "not thankful" the money was stopped, but if they had received the 15s for another week, without comment, they would have been unable to have taken any proceedings under the Employer's Liability Act. The fact was that the case had been brought to patch up the negligence of the manager, and they would hear from his witness that no one even knew that there was any such station as was contended for the prosecution. — James Cowler, one of the defendants, said that after he had been discharged on the 21st of June, he went down the pit for his gear on the 23rd. He went down with the men, and after a short rest at the cabin they went into the pit and met the fireman on the road, who said nothing to them. The ordinary road to their working was blocked, and as they were going in by the other road the explosion occurred. The custom was not to wait for the fireman, but to go right in, except when they were waiting for a working. He never heard of any prosecution until the notice was served for compensation. There were several other refuge holes in the pit. — Cross examined by Mr. Atter: He had only been eight days in the colliery on this occasion, but he had been there before. — O'Neal (who was still in the employ of the Company) gave similar evidence, contending that men never waited for the fireman. — John Clark, who up to Saturday week was employed at the pit, said during his three years experience of the mine he never knew men wait for the fireman. They invariably walked straight in. At one time he worked in a portion of the pit where he could not pass this station. — The Chairman said he did not think it was necessary to hear anything further, as they had agreed to dismiss the cases. — The case occupied about four hours in hearing. — Mr. Atter applied that warrants might be granted against the two defendants Barry and McKew, and they were granted.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||