Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th July 1884

Meeting Of Miners At Whitehaven

Mr. A. Sharp On The Franchise Bill

On Saturday evening last a meeting of miners employed at the Whitehaven Collieries, was called by bellman to be held on the Embankment, but subsequently it was decided to hold the meeting in the Protestant Hall. There was a very large attendance. Mr. S. Dunn occupied the chair, supported on the platform by Mr. A. Sharp, Maryport; Mr. G. Elliott, Distington, and the members of the committee of the newly formed union.

The CHAIRMAN, at the outset, referred to the last meeting over which he presided, and the remarks of the Parquet thereon. It was stated in the Parquet that he (Mr. Dunn) requested someone to propose him to the chair. That was not true. He had been appointed chairman at a meeting of the committee, prior to the public meeting held on the Embankment, and the request he made was for his proposer to put the contrary to see if anyone was opposed to his acting as chairman. He then explained under what circumstances the meeting had been called, stating that Mr. Cowood, of the South Yorkshire Provision Company, had kindly permitted the meeting to be held there. It appeared that the existing slide scale agreement had expired, and the workmen were desirous to have it continued, and that meeting was called to see if anything could be done to induce the Whitehaven masters to join with the other employers in maintaining the scale. As to the miners themselves, he was glad to know that their efforts in the way of organisation had so far been successful, and he knew that they had the support and sympathy of at least three-fourths of the townspeople. The public was in their favour, and it only remained for them to be true to one another to gain their object. Of course, they would meet with opposition, but he advised them to pay no attention to what was said by their opponents, but, at the same time, they should see that everything they advanced in the struggle was true. What they wanted was fair play, and that they had not got in the past. If workmen had as far as 12 cwt. of coal taken off them in a day, it was only right that they should be satisfied that the quantity deducted was really bad before it was confiscated. (Applause) It had been stated in a certain paper that this movement was got up in the interests of the Liberal party, and that they wondered that he (Mr. Dunn), who professed to be a Conservative, should countenance the movement. He denied emphatically that it was a political movement, and, as far as he was concerned, he was not disposed to accept the advice of those parties, but was determined to help the miners in their struggles. (Applause) It had been very gratifying, so far to see how well the miners had supported the Union, over four-fifths of the coal-hewers having joined them, and he was really surprised to see the way the contributions had been paid up. No previous efforts of the kind in Whitehaven had ever been so well supported — there had never been so much money paid in, nor so many members. The members at the outset had taken a judicious step in balloting as to whether they should employ check-weighmen at the pit top, and in all their movements he exhorted them to act fairly, honestly, and uprightly. Referring again to the charge of the movement being instigated by political considerations, the Chairman stoutly denied the charge, pointing out that their platform was distinctly a trades' union one, and that amongst trades' unionists there were many good Conservatives as well as Liberals. Their object was neither to return Mr. Bentinck nor Mr. Gully to Parliament, but to defend the rights of labour. (Applause)

Mr. ELLIOTT congratulated the Whitehaven miners on having placed themselves in the Union. It was evident that they felt the iron hand under which they had been, and were now aroused. They must combine with one another to protect their labour, because a miner's labour was his capital; he was not like the capitalist with plenty of money in his pocket. There were grievances in the Whitehaven collieries which had existed for years, and they must not expect them to be removed in a day. It would take a long time to remove the whole lot of them. He understood there had been ballot papers handed to the men in the several collieries to test their feeling with respect to check-weighmen, and out of the whole number he was glad to here that only one man objected to have check-weighmen. But a check-weighmen could not settle their grievances if they did not give him their support. As the Chairman pointed out, the sole object of their organisation was to protect their labour. If a check-weighmen was appointed a good deal would depend on the agreement they made with the masters. A check-weighmen would be of little service to them if, like the last one they had, he was not allowed to go down on the screens and examine the coals that were confiscated. Another point that ought to be kept in mind when they drew out the agreement was the payment for small coal. He understood that at present they were not allowed to send small coal up. [A MINER: They allow it at Henry Pit.] As to the stopping off of tubs, they should insert a clause as to what should be stopped off for bad coal. It would be the duty of their check-weighmen to see that all good coal was allowed for, and not, as at present, have the whole lot deducted lock, stock, and barrel. (Laughter) If they were firm to the principles of Unionism, and stuck to one another, they would be sure to gain the day. (Applause)

Mr. A. SHARP, who was well received, spoke of the pleasure he felt in addressing such a large gathering of Whitehaven miners. Had the meeting been held on the Embankment, he had intended to have spoken on some matters that might have interested the public, but as it was their meeting was one solely for miners? He was glad to see the success they already made in regard to unionism. He had had many attempts with Whitehaven, and he would not be disheartened, even if their present attempt should fall through. (Applause) He had seen the darkest clouds surrounding their movement, but disaster never affected him in the least. In all matters relating to organisation and the rights of working men he set out determined to win. (Applause) Neither Mr. Liddell nor any other manager could at all affect the ultimate issue, for there would always be plenty of men willing to defend the rights of the working classes. The rights of the working classes had been won step by step. By combination the working classes might obtain a fair share of the wealth of this country, and in order to secure it they ought to put forth all reasonable, social, and moral efforts. There was no lack of intelligence amongst the Whitehaven men, for in Durham and Northumberland their ability was recognised, and they were appointed as check-weighmen, lodge secretaries, and to other posts, which showed what they were able to do as soon as they were free. Here in Whitehaven they ought to make their organisation a great success. In conversation with Mr. Crawford and Mr. Burt, M.P., these men had expressed their astonishment that the Whitehaven men could never be got to organise, while as soon as ever they got to Durham or Northumberland, they were the leaders of the movement, and were the best union men to be found. He (Mr. Sharp) would venture to say that great numbers of the lodge secretaries in Durham were Whitehaven men. There was no lack of intelligence amongst the Whitehaven miners, for not only in Durham and Northumberland were they recognised, but in Scotland and Lancashire, and at present he believed they had in their midst as good men as in any other mining district in Great Britain. Referring to the recent examination of the weighing machine at Wellington Pit, by Messrs. Ramsay, the speaker said he was not going to say that deficiency in weight given to the men was known to the officials of the colliery. The men he blamed were the police, who were the state-appointed officials to attend to the adjustment of the weighing machines. It was as much the duty of the police to look after the weighing machines, as it was for them to get hold of a poor man for setting a snare in a gentleman's grounds, or to watch a fish poacher. When the Mines' Regulation Act was passed, the leaders of the men pressed this subject on the attention of the Home Secretary, and the clause empowering the police to examine the weighing machines was inserted. But the way the matter was neglected led many to believe that there was truth in the old saying that there was one law for the rich and another for the poor. He had written dozens of letters to Mr. Dunne, chief constable, respecting the necessity of having colliery weighing machines periodically tested, but what had been the result? Mr. Dunne replied that the weigh-beams were in good order and yet he ventured to say that none of them ever saw a policeman examining the weighing machine. That was the kind of treatment they received from these men. Capitalists could get justice, but when it came to the working men there was no justice on their behalf. They wanted no new Acts of Parliament to enable them to inspect weighing machines for it was already specially provided for. So long as they contributed to the rates they had a right to expect the police to bestow upon them a fair share of attention. The police were public servants, and as such ought to act fairly. The outlook in the coal trade in Lancashire was not now very promising, the attitude of the masters towards their men being very stupid. The South Wales coal proprietors met with their men and discussed their differences, and the result was that the men were getting good wages, and the proprietors were getting good prices. It would be a good time when the working men of this country showed their independence and their manhood, and not be afraid to speak to their masters who were only men like themselves. What could be more ridiculous than to see a man bowing, pulling his hair, and scraping his feet when in the presence of his employer? Let them speak to each other as man to man. Another instance that would show them the benefit of combination could be seen near home. The top men, who were not organised, were asked to submit to a reduction of 5 per cent in their wages, while the coal-hewers were only asked to have their wages reduced by 1.25 per cent. (Applause) Mr. Sharp then proceeded to speak of the sliding scale agreement, which he contended had been of great service to the coal trade of this district. The agreement had now run out, owing to several owners declining to recognise the Masters Association, and join with them. The masters who were parties to the sliding scale were willing to continue it on condition that the other employers would join with them, and he hoped the men of Whitehaven would try to induce their masters to join with the other employers in the sliding scale agreement, and so keep up both wages and the selling price of coal. Colliery managers were continually crying out for the men to increase the output, but nothing could be more unwise. An increase of output necessarily meant a reduction of price and a corresponding reduction of wages. He actually knew one coal proprietor who paid his manager a commission upon the increased quantity of coal that was raised, and who was thereby paying a commission to bring about his own ruin. If managers were to set about securing better prices, and let the output alone, it would be more to the advantage of the proprietors and also keep up the wages of the miners. The speaker then referred to a report published in the paper, charging him with advocating restriction of output. It was not a fact, for the men at Whitehaven restricted the output before they consulted him. With reference to the charge of this movement being a political one, he denied such was the case. Party politics were never discussed in their lodges, and they never asked as to a man's creed or colour. At the same time it should be pointed out that men were not bound to sell their principles. What they sold to the employers was their labour, and their labour only, and as regards politics they had a right to what politics they thought proper. (Applause) One writer to the Pacquet had stated that the object of the movement was to get somebody to be M.P. If that referred to him, he could assure them that he had no ambitions in that way. He could tell them that he had not fallen sufficient in morals to accept a position like that. (Laughter) It was true that he addressed a meeting in Whitehaven in 1880, but in that speech he dealt only with labour questions. Both political parties had passed measures that had been beneficial to workingmen, and these measures had been advocated irrespective of politics by trade union leaders. He had advocated the Shipping Act because he found that of every 72 men that left the harbours one of them went to the bottom. In the mines it used to be about one in every 200, but since the passing of the Mines Regulation Act it had been reduced to one in 452. The trades' unionists had waited upon Mr. Gladstone as to the Franchise Bill, but they would quite as readily have waited upon Sir Stafford Northcote. He advocated the Franchise Bill, because he contended, that one man had as much right to vote as another. Last Monday, at their delegate meeting, there were 23 present, and only six of them had votes, and when they looked at these six they could see no reason why they should have votes in preference to their fellow workmen. The Franchise Bill was a labour question, and it would have been all the same to him whoever had promoted the Bill. The House of Lords in rejecting the measure were not only fighting the Liberal party, but they were fighting the British people. (Cheers) He had no doubt; however, that when the Lords saw the millions of people arrayed against them they would soon turn about. (Laughter and applause) Referring to the miners in the Cleator Moor district, Mr. Sharp said that at a meeting held on Thursday week he was informed that about 1,200 of them had joined the union in a comparatively short space of time, and they had accumulated a large sum of money. Their grievances in Whitehaven had been accumulating for the last forty or fifty years, and they could not expect to have them removed at once, but if they remained true to their principles he had no hesitation in saying that the Whitehaven miners had a great future before them. (Cheers.)

Mr. SHARP said that before they separated he had a resolution to read which had been placed in his hand. The resolution was: -

That this meeting request the Earl of Lonsdale to include his collieries along with the other collieries of West Cumberland in the proposed sliding scale agreement for the adjustment of wages for the whole of the county.

The resolution was carried unanimously.

The reporters then withdrew, and the meeting proceeded to appoint a deputation of workmen to wait upon Lord Lonsdale's managers, to press upon them to join in the sliding scale agreement.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Burt, Thomas    M.P.  Whos Who Page
Cowood, —      
Crawford, —      
Dunn, S.      
Dunne, —    Chief Constable  
Elliott, G.      
Gladstone, —      
Liddell, —    Manager  
Lonsdale, Earl of    Mine Owner  
Northcote, Stafford, Sir      
Ramsay, —      
Sharpe, Andrew    Miners' Agent  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print