Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th July 1884

Local Law Case

The Egremont Mining Dispute

In the Chancery Division of the High Court of Justice, on Saturday, the case of Ponsonby v. Hartley came before Mr. Justice Kay. This was a summons taken out by the plaintiffs in the action asking that the defendants be ordered to produce a certain deed dated October 13th, 1815, and that the plaintiffs, their solicitors or agents be at liberty to inspect the deed and copy extracts therefrom; or further, that the time for delivering the notice of reply be extended. A second summons asked that the defendants be ordered to unseal certain portions of the deed that had been sealed up by direction of the Court. Mr. Robinson, Q.C., with whom was Mr. Druce, appeared for the plaintiffs, and Mr. Pearson, Q.C., with whom was Mr. Phipson Beale, appeared for the defendants. — Mr. Robinson, in opening the summons, said his lordship would gather from it that it was an application by the plaintiffs for liberty to inspect a certain deed, and this question of inspection was one of very vital importance to the action. The question had already been before the Court three times for the purpose of making the defendants produce other deeds, and Mr. Justice Pearson, sitting for his lordship, made an order upon the defendants to produce certain deeds, but giving them liberty to seal up certain portions. The defendants, feeling how very vital the production was, took the matter to the Court of Appeal, but the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal with costs. The deed that they now asked for the production of by the defendants had never been inserted in any affidavit or documents made by the defendants until the plaintiffs obtained leave to administer a second set of interrogatories. — Mr. Justice Kay: What is the nature of your action? — Mr. Robinson said he was going to inform his lordship, but he was endeavouring to point out how reticent the defendants had been or were over this deed. The first plaintiff was Myles Ponsonby, who was the lord of the manor of a certain manor called Howbank, situated in the parish of Egremont, in the county of Cumberland, and the other plaintiffs were tenants with him. The defendants were the owners in fee simple of the surface of the soil, but by the enfranchisement deed dated the 22nd of January, 1879, the mines and minerals were excepted and reserved to the landlord, and by the deed a peppercorn rent was imposed which preserved the relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties. The first deed stated that the lands of Howbank were divided, and consisted of four separate tenements and lands, three of the separate tenements being held by a lady of the name of Catherine Grayson, and the rest of the land and one tenement being held by Isaac Scott, who was admitted as tenant on the 17th June, 1875. The first enfranchisement was made in 1879, when in consideration of £129 the three tenements were conveyed to Catherine Grayson at a peppercorn rent, but there was nothing in the deed about the acreage. — Mr. Justice Kay: That will appear in the Court roll. — Mr. Robinson replied that it was not forthcoming. The next deed of enfranchisement to Isaac Scott did mention the acreage as 12 acres or thereabouts. That was the case made by the plaintiffs. The defendants on the other hand did not admit that Myles Ponsonby was lord of the manor, they made no admissions as to the lands of Howbank, but they had made certain admissions as to preventing the plaintiffs' workmen trespassing on the land to commence mining operations. Those being the pleadings the first summons taken out for the production of deeds led to the defendants making an affidavit of documents by which it was admitted they had certain deeds and documents which they objected to produce on the ground that this was an action for the recovery of land in their possession, and the documents related solely to their own property, and did not contain anything proving or supporting the plaintiffs' alleged title to the land called Howbank. Upon this the matter came before Mr. Justice Pearson, who ordered the deeds referred to be produced, but giving the defendant the right to seal up everything but the names of the parties and the parcels relating to Howbank. Interrogatories were then filed for the examination of the defendants, when in the first answers they admitted they were in possession of the surface of the land contained in the deed. In the second answer it was admitted there was a deed, dated October 13th, 1815, in the possession of the defendant Thomas Hartley, but they declined to answer any questions as to the contents of the deed. He submitted he was entitled to have inspection of the deed as it had been shown that it conveyed the surface of Howbank. — Mr. Justice Kay intimated that he would like to hear the other side. — Mr. Pearson, Q.C., said this action related to 30 odd acres of land called Howbank, and nothing more, and the plaintiffs claimed the mines and minerals under Howbank. The old deed of 1815, of which inspection was asked, was the settlement deed of a very large property in Cumberland, to which the Hartleys were entitled. — Mr, Justice Kay: But you have not filed an affidavit stating that it relates to your own title and to nothing else. You have not made an affidavit protecting the parts of this deed as you did the others; and it might, for anything I know, contain complete admission of the plaintiffs' title. — Mr. Pearson admitted that the deed had not been protected in that way, and if his lordship thought it necessary he would ask to be allowed to make another formal affidavit to the effect that it related to large estates belonging to the defendants, and had nothing to do with Howbank. — Mr. Justice Kay: Then I will hear why you did not make that affidavit. — Mr. Robinson said if his learned friend made the affidavit he would take it without scruple. — Mr. Justice Kay: I am sorry to hear you say that, as it imputes to those who will make the affidavit less accuracy than there should be. — Mr. Robinson said he only imputed mere ignorance. If they could arrive at what parts assisted the plaintiffs' case he was willing the affidavits should be made; but he should not consider an affidavit reliable that was made by a gentleman who was not conversant with law. — Mr. Justice Kay: That is an argument against affidavits of the documents altogether. — Mr. Robinson said that if his learned friend would not make the affidavit then he would ask his lordship to look at the deed and say what parts should be left open for inspection. — Mr. Justice Kay: If I did that the Court would be asked every day to look into deeds, and I therefore decline to exercise any such jurisdiction. — Mr. Robinson: This is in an exceptional case, and it is one in which it is absolutely impossible for a layman to make a perfect affidavit. — Mr. Justice Kay: Then the Legislature should alter the practice. Your action is practically an ejectment action. — Mr. Robinson said it was an action for an injunction to restrain the defendant from obstructing or interfering with the working and getting of the mines under Howbank; and secondly, to have the boundaries of the lands ascertained. He submitted that no further affidavit should be made, or if it was one that should be made as precise and as clear as could be, pointing to the fact that there was no statement in the deed that assisted the plaintiffs' case, and that none of the other parcels in the deed tended to show what the boundaries of Howbank were at the time the deed was made. — Mr. Justice Kay, in giving judgement, said as he understood the facts they appeared to be these: The plaintiffs had instituted an action claiming to be the owners of mines and minerals under certain land called Howbank, and asking for an injunction to restrain the defendants obstructing the working of those minerals. The defendants made an affidavit of documents in which they sought to protect certain of them by swearing in a manner that seemed to him quite formal and accurate, that the action being to recover land in their possession certain documents they object to produce relate solely to land in their own possession, and not to matters in dispute in the action. The question whether the documents were sufficiently protected came before Mr. Justice Pearson, and the Court of Appeal, and looking at the nature of some of the documents an order was made for liberty to inspect all the documents and plans, but previous to such inspection defendants to seal up, on oath, all except the names of parties, parcels, and plans relating to the property called Howbank. It seemed that another document was afterwards discovered, dated in the early part of 1815, which was referred to in an answer of certain interrogatories. Two affidavits had been sworn in relation to this deed, and the second one omitted by an oversight to state that he had sealed up all such parts of the deed which did not relate to Howbank, and only such parts. That being so, he was now asked not to allow any further affidavit, because it was almost certain that the gentleman who would swear the affidavit would not swear it rightly. He could not accept the statement, or he should therefore give the defendants liberty to make a further affidavit before he ordered inspection of the deed, but he would restrict them to a week's time, when the matter could be considered on the further, affidavit. Another matter he ought to refer to was this: He was asked to take the deed in his hand to say what part should be sealed up. That, of course, he could not accede to, because, if he did, in any case of dispute as to documents he would be asked to do the same thing. — His Lordship accordingly directed a further affidavit to be made by the defendants, the costs to be costs in the action.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Beale, Phipson      
Druce, —      
Grayson, Catherine      
Hartley, Thomas      
Kay, —    Justice  
Pearson, —    Justice  
Pearson, —    Q.C.  
Ponsonby, Myles      
Robinson, —    Q.C.  
Scott, Isaac      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print