|
26th June 1884 The Alleged Evictions Of Colliers At WhitehavenThere has been a good deal of talk, and much newspaper writing and correspondence, during the past week, as to what has been termed "Colliery Office terrorism," and "Colliers' evictions." One notorious sheet has seized upon the subject as presenting just what is wanted at a crisis to abuse Mr. James Lowther, Mr. Bentinck, and the Colliery Office authorities in one comprehensive whole. About sixty notices have been served upon colliers in Lord Lonsdale's employ to vacate the free houses they tenant; and, upon this simple fact has been raised a superstructure which, for audacity, misstatement, and pure invention, has probably never before been paralleled in local annals. In the print to which we allude it was stated that "On Thursday last the Colliery Office policeman was actually despatched to serve every man who had joined, or was suspected to have joined, the Union, with a fortnight's notice to quit the tenement he holds under the trustees of the Lowther estates." And, having got this far, the writer in question adds, "This means that about one hundred and fifty families are to be driven from their houses and robbed of their bread for taking a step that, under the circumstances, is more praiseworthy than otherwise." So it will be seen, first that, on the principle of the three black crows' story, the sixty have grown to one hundred and fifty; secondly, that the men had notice to quit for joining the Union; and thirdly, that in addition to being "driven from their houses," they were "robbed of their bread." In the few remarks we purpose making by way of putting the public in possession of the facts as they actually are in this particular matter, we shall begin by saying that the above statements are absolutely without foundation. Not a single man in Lord Lonsdale's employ has had, or ever had notice to quit his house or work because he joined a Union; nor is there, so far as we can gather, the slightest objection on the part of the Colliery authorities to the men joining any Union they may feel disposed to patronise. What particular step they may take when they do join is, of course, another matter. Questions as to prices, output, &c., may arise, on which the employer has, at least, as much right to be heard as his workmen, and wherein he may by no means take the same view of the position. And this brings us at once to the dispute that has arisen between a small body of workmen in the William Pit and the manager, Mr. Liddell. We are informed, by the newspaper authority above alluded to, that close on one hundred and fifty colliers have joined the Union, under Mr. Andrew Sharp's guidance. If it were the Union, therefore, the Colliery authorities wished to crush, one hundred and fifty men would not only have been evicted from their houses, but would have been discharged from the Colliery. As it is, only sixty have received notice to quit their houses, and not one of them has been, nor will be (so far as this particular agitation is concerned) deprived of his work. The facts are simply these. In face of the depressed state of the coal trade in general, and the severe competition in the Irish and local markets, it became necessary a month or so ago for the Colliery authorities to make heavy reductions in the selling prices of Whitehaven coal. During the spring months and up to the time of the said reductions, the Whitehaven Colliery, in common with most others, suffered greatly from the general depression, and the pits here were only working half time — a loss of 50 per cent to the employees and their employer. Consequent upon the reduction of prices another of wages ensued. On the 12th May last a reduction in that respect was made, and was with good grace accepted by the men, with the exception of the hewers (100 in number) who work in what is known as the Countess district in William Pit. Since that date the pits have worked nearly full time; and thus the men, by submitting to a diminution of their wages by five per cent. have improved their position in spring by forty-five per cent. These hundred discontented hewers from Countess district, instead of sending, according to wont and use, a deputation to headquarters, adopted a policy of their own regardless of the rest, the large majority, of their fellow-workmen. They evidently acted upon some sinister advice — whose we cannot definitely say — and began voluntarily to reduce their own wages by sending one tub or 12 cwt. of coal less per man per day to bank than they had hitherto been accustomed to send. That was done no doubt with the object to posing as martyrs, embarrassing the Colliery authorities, and of forcing an advance in the rate of wages. On the 29th of May, more than a fortnight after the five per cent reduction had come into operation, a deputation of the Countess district hewers waited upon Mr. Liddell, and asked for an increase in their hewing price. In answer to Mr. Liddell, the deputation freely admitted that the small wages of the Countess district men were due, in a great measure, to the policy of output restriction that was being pursued by them; whereupon Mr. Liddell replied that so long as they persisted in lowering their own wages of their own accord, he declined to consider their application. Notwithstanding Mr. Liddell's reply, and several warnings from the manager and overmen that notices to quit the free houses they occupied would be issued, the Countess district men have continued up to the present time to limit their work for the purpose of lessening their pay. The result of this conduct has been that the Colliery authorities have issued those that occupy free houses notice to leave them. At the same time it must be understood that the men continue at work. In truth, therefore, it cannot be said that these hundred discontented men are being "robbed of their bread." After their deputation's interview with Mr. Liddell, the men either put themselves into communication with Mr. Andrew Sharp, miners' agent, Maryport, or vice versa; and the result was that Mr. Sharp visited the town on several occasions, and gave the men what he no doubt considered good advice. He is credited with having advised them to restrict the output still. Whether he did so or not, it is certain that the discontented are continuing the same old game. Now, in the Whitehaven Colliery, which employs 1,500 men, women, and lads, this restriction is a serious matter. Should the example of the Countess district men spread throughout the colliery, there is no telling the amount of mischief that may ensue. The large steamers coming to Whitehaven for coal may be delayed at least a tide; and rather than encounter such a serious loss again, it is not only possible, but highly probable, that they will go elsewhere for cargoes, to the serious disarrangement and loss, if not permanently, at least temporarily, of the Whitehaven coal trade. As it is, there has been much inconvenience, and several sailing vessels in the South Harbour have been delayed owing to the fact that an extra quantity of coal had to be sent from the south side pits to the steamers in the dock, to make up for the deficiency occasioned by the restriction of the output, by the Countess district men in William Pit. Leaving on one side Lord Lonsdale's interests in the matter, we might soberly ask the tradesmen and residents of Whitehaven wherein the town is to be advantaged by restricting the output of coal when there is a market for it to be had? Surely it is their interest, as it ought to be that of the colliers themselves, that as much coal should be raised and wages earned as possible. Not less than £3,000 is paid in wages every fortnight at the Colliery Office; and there is not an inhabitant of Whitehaven who ought not to desire that the amount should be increased rather than diminished. We are satisfied that men who prefer to idle their time at the pit bottom, who will not send coal to bank when coal is wanted, and will not earn money for their families and themselves when the opportunity is given them, will not command much public sympathy. We hear now and again from candid friends that the coal trade is leaving Whitehaven, regrets that colliers are badly paid, have so little working time, and so forth; and yet the commiseration of the public is looked for when a policy is advocated, the direct result, if not aim, of which is to accentuate and perpetuate these very evils. Having now disposed of the facts touching the present dispute in William Pit and "the evictions," we may glance for a moment at the average rate of wages paid in the Whitehaven Colliery. There is a current impression that the collier is much better paid elsewhere than he is here, and that the best thing he can do is to migrate to the Northumberland, Durham, Lancashire, Yorkshire, or other coal fields. In practice, however, we find that he does so to a very limited extent, and often having gone, his next care is invariably to make his way back again. Work and wages, in fact, are no better in other pars of the country than they are here. In one of the largest collieries in Durham the hewers are at the present time only working half time, for little more than 20s. a week. And generally throughout the Northumberland and Durham districts work at the collieries has been very slack for a long time, and is so at present, in contradistinction to the Whitehaven pits, which are now on full time. In an article on the Warwickshire coalfield, written by Mr. E. M. Melly, M.E., in the June Transactions of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers, it is stated that fillers and getters (coal hewers) only make 3s. 6d. a day of eight and nine hours. We will contrast with this the pay sheet of the Whitehaven Colliery for the various pits, taking the figures for the fortnight ending June, 7th, being the last pay. — In William Pit, the hewers average (in the Bannock Band) 4s. 11d. per day; in the Delaval district, 5s. 3d.; in the Countess district, (where the dispute is, and owing to the voluntary restricted output), 3s. 9d. The average daily wages in the same pit during the eleven working days was 4s. 2d. per man, and the lost time stood at 17 per cent. In Henry Pit, over twelve days, the average was 4s. 7½d. per man per day, the lost time being 15 per cent. In Wellington Pit, for ten days, the average per man per day throughout the pit was 5s. 2½d., the lost time being only eight per cent. In Croft Pit, for eleven days, the daily average per man was 4s. 10½d., the lost time being 20 per cent. As average wages, these will compare favourably with those paid at any other colliery. Then, exaggerated statements are made as to the deductions in the coal sent to bank. The authority alluded to above in his "Stray Notes" (they might with much more propriety be termed "Astray Notes") committed himself to the assertion recently that the men lost 4s. 7d. per man per fortnight from this cause. Nothing more utterly absurd and ridiculous ever appeared even in the "Astray Notes." Taking last pay-sheet as a basis again (and all pays are much alike as far as the average goes) the coal hewers in William Pit lost 9d. per man during the fortnight for "off-takes;" those in Henry Pit, about 7d.; and those in Wellington Pit, 6d.; and those in Croft Pit, 4d. Information acquired in a public-house, for the consideration in "pints," is apt to be very highly coloured; and it is much better to look for it in a less equivocal quarter. The off-takers are not only customary, but strictly legal. It is the only check coal owners have on dishonest or careless colliers. In the Whitehaven Colliery the men have every consideration. They are instructed to cast back coarse or bad coal, unfit for sale; and both for this, and for difficulties in their working caused by "faults," "hitches," or "rolls," they are allowed reasonable compensation. Closely connected with this question of "off-takes" is that of appointing a check-weighman, as to which Mr. Sharp made so strong a point in a recent address to the colliers here. There is nothing whatever to hinder the men appointing a check-weighman at each pit to-morrow, if they are so minded. "The law allows it, and the Court awards it." The Colliery authorities have no power to prevent the appointment, even if they had the disposition. Mr. Maskell Peace, Wigan, in his summary of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1872, says: "Miners paid by weight may, at their own cost, station a person, called in the Act a check-weighman, at the place appointed for the weighing of the mineral, to take account of the weight on their behalf." But, with one exception, the Whitehaven colliers have never taken advantage of this clause in the Act. Perhaps the fact that the wages of the check-weighman so appointment have to be made up by a levy on the men has had something to do with it; and we believe a further reason is to be found in this, that the colliers are satisfied with the men appointed and paid by the Colliery authorities. The exception to which we allude occurred at William Pit in 1873, when the men appointment their own check-weighman, being dissatisfied with the weight. At the end of the first fortnight, however, they found that the average weight per tub was even less that previously, and they promptly discharged the man of their choice. We are not sure whether he was even paid his fortnight's wages. Such, so far, has been the experience of check-weighmen at Whitehaven. He may be a necessary institution here. All we can say is that as yet he is not appreciated. We have dwelt so long upon the facts of the present dispute, and one or two points connected with the working of the Whitehaven Colliery, because we know they comprise a subject in which the public of the town and district are very much interested. And naturally so, too. The coal trade is the one staple, stable industry of the town. It has been so for two centuries, and remains so yet. Everything connected with it has an interest for those resident in Whitehaven, and more especially for tradesmen. Where so large a body of men is employed, under diversified rules and regulations, disputes will at times crop up. But it is not in the interest of the public and of "the town and trade of Whitehaven" as the toast goes, that these should be left open to rankle and fester, and furnish capital for those who are only anxious to set employer and employed by the ears for their individual, or for purely party benefit. They have an axe to grind, as Abraham Lincoln phrased it. We have, as we know, journalists of this stamp in Whitehaven; and it is unfortunate for the town that it is so. The public could very well dispense with them, and the best interests of Whitehaven and the coal trade would gain by their disappearance. Lord Lonsdale and the Colliery Office, from their position here, present a broad front to attack, from which other employers and employees are altogether free; and to attack is easy. To many minds it is also pleasant. There is only reason to complain when the attack is based upon misstatement, upon declamation and abuse, instead of argument and fact, and upon assertions that are, designedly or un-designedly, absolutely false in every particular.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||