15th May 1884
The Ennerdale Railway Bill
[By Telegraph, From Our London Correspondent]
House Of Commons, Wednesday
In the House of Commons, to-day, this Bill came before a Select Committee, consisting of Lord Eustace Cecil (Chairman), Mr. McLagan, Mr. Gabbett, and Mr. Harris. — Mr. O'Hara and Mr. Erskine Pollock appeared for the promoters; the petitioners, Mr.
David Ainsworth, M.P. and Mr. John Sterling Ainsworth, being represented by Mr. J. W. Batten. — Mr. O'HARA, in opening the case for the promoters, said there was something in this Bill which was peculiar to the case, viz., an instruction from the
House of Commons in relation to certain matters which took it out of the category of ordinary private Bills. It was a measure really of the most innocent character. It was promoted for the purpose of making a line of railway, six miles, seven furlongs,
and 38 chains in length, commencing at Frizington, by a junction with the Whitehaven, Cleator, and Egremont extension railway, now vested in the London and North-Western and Furness Railway Companys, and terminating in the township of Ennerdale and
(parish of St. Bees) at a certain beck known as Gillerthwaite Beck, at a point 20 chains or thereabouts from the junction of the said beck, with the river Liza opposite "Moss Dub." The line was one, which from an engineering point of view was
entirely free from defects, for its worst gradient was 1 in 180, and its sharpest curve had a radius of two furlongs. In fact, throughout its entire length it presented no engineering difficulty. Moreover, it did not interfere with the level of any
existing route, neither did it touch a single building. For 4½ miles it passed through land of a purely agricultural character, and the remainder was through land at the foot of a mountain. For one mile it ran alongside the Ennerdale Lake, but it
was hidden in a cutting 15 feet deep, and at a minimum distance of three hundred yards from the shores of the lake. One of the objects of the Bill was to open up the mineral district to the north and east of Ennerdale Lake, in which there was very
valuable iron-ore. At present the circumstances of the district were such that although that iron-ore was there, and although a good deal of it had been let to persons who were financially capable of working it; still, owing to the want of railway
accommodation, it could not be obtained with advantage. To the north of the lake there was a large tract of land which had been let by Lord Lonsdale to a Glasgow firm, iron-ore having been proved to exist there; whilst at the eastern end of the lake
rich ferns had been discovered, and more than two miles of which had been partially developed, and would be in active work if there was any railway accommodation. Ennerdale was in the immediate neighbourhood of Whitehaven, Workington, Cockermouth,
Egremont, and Cleator, and it was a spot to which tourists and the citizens of those towns would repair in large numbers if railway facilities existed. The proposed railway would put them down on the very shores of the lake. The population of these
towns was about 100,000, to the great majority of whom the expense of vehicular traffic was quite prohibitory. With the exception of Mr. Ainsworth and his brother, who were joint owners of a small field, through which the line would pass for about 300
yards, there was not a single landowner opposed to the scheme. In fact, he might take it that the owners of land in the district were entirely in favour of the line being made. But for the instruction to the Committee from the House of Commons, he
would say he could not understand how the committee could be delayed for many minutes in coming to the conclusion that the preamble ought to be passed. The Whitehaven District Highway Board, the Cleator Moor Local Board, and others, had petitioned in
favour of the Bill, and he thought the committee would agree with him that the inhabitants of those districts were very proper persons to follow, because they knew exactly the value of the beautiful features of the district, and they knew, further, that
the business of the district would suffer materially if the tourist traffic which went there was at all interfered with.
They knew perfectly well their friends and neighbours in the summer or autumn depended very much upon the visitors for the sale of those things which they produced, and they knew the desirability of the beauty of the district being preserved. The
instruction to which he had referred ran as follows: "The hon. member for the Tower Hamlets (Mr. Richie) moved as to the Ennerdale Railway Bill that it be an instruction to the committee to inquire and report to the House whether the proposed
railway will interfere with the enjoyment of the public by injuriously affecting the scenery or otherwise, and that they have power to call witnesses and receive evidence on the subject." If this resolution was looked at critically, it would admit
of criticism, which, perhaps, would strike every member of the committee. It was not for him to say, what right the public had to this district, but he would say that they had not nearly so much right to it as the people living there. He admitted that
the scheme projected last year was not laid out with that due care for the amenities of the place, or the beauty of the district, which was desirable in a measure of this kind, and he recognised that by the efforts of the gentlemen who threw out that
Bill the promoters had been taught a lesson, which was a very salutary one; but when he told the committee that the distance was to be traversed in a cutting 15 feet deep, and at a minimum distance of 3,000 feet from the lake, and that between the line
and the lake there would be an occupation road, he could not suppose that there would be any difficulty in returning a satisfactory answer to the instruction of the House, in saying that it did not interfere with their approval of the preamble, for the
passing of the second reading of the Bill was an admission that the necessity existed for the accommodation proposed. Last year the railway was laid out on a high embankment, and consequently it stood prominently forward as an ugly and disfiguring
feature of the district, but with the present scheme there would only be a whistle from the train, and perhaps a little steam, and how that could spoil a district of this sort he could not possibly conceive. He pointed to the existing line from
Cockermouth along the Bassenthwaite Lake as a precedent for the construction of the line. In that case the railway ran through a cutting 30 feet deep, and at a minimum distance of 80 yards from the shores of the lake. The CHAIRMAN inquired if
Bassenthwaite was visited largely by tourists. He put the question because he wanted to know if the two cases were parallel in all respects.
Mr. O'HARA said the cases were perfectly parallel, except that at Bassenthwaite they ran between the road and a high road, whereas at Ennerdale the railway was divided from the shore by an occupation road. When the committee had heard the engineers'
evidence they would, he believed, be quite satisfied that the line would add greatly to he value of the district from a mineral and commercial point of view, and that it would give great facilities for the tourists and over-worked populations of the
large towns in the neighbourhood, and he thought they would not find it necessary to call witnesses. As authorised by the order of the House of Commons, the capital proposed was £70,000, with the usual borrowing powers. The estimates for the
line, works, and land was £60,994, allowing the usual 10 per cent. for contingencies, and was therefore within £9,000 of the share capital, leaving a fair margin for contingencies; whereas the borrowed capital would be used for the
equipment of the line. Mr. Renton, one of the original promoters of the line, was unfortunately suffering from grievous affliction, and his name had to be replaced by that of Mr. Smallpeace, whilst the name of Mr. Bowen had been added to the original
list. The learned counsel then proceeded to discuss in detail the petitioners' objections to the line. He said Mr. Ainsworth's chief grievance appeared to be that a small field at the end of his property would be injured by the line. But the promoters
were perfectly willing wither to pay Mr. Ainsworth a fair compensation, or to buy the field from him altogether.
Mr. BATTEN said Mr. O'HARA was endeavouring to draw a herring across the trail. The petitioners did not come there simply because the line was going across a single field, or to get the money value of the field. They came in the interest of the public.
Mr. O'HARA said the petitioners had no right to represent the public there. The interests of the public had been confined to the House of Commons, and the committee was competent to call any evidence on the subject they thought fit.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ainsworth, David | | M.P. | |
| Ainsworth, John Stirling | | | |
| Batten, J. W. | | | |
| Bowen, — | | | |
| Cecil, Eustace, Lord | | | |
| Gabbett, — | | | |
| Harris, — | | | |
| McLagan, — | | | |
| O'Hara, — | | | |
| Pollock, Erskine | | | |
| Renton, — | | | |
| Richie, — | | M.P. | |
| Smallpeace, — | | | |