Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

10th April 1884

The West Cumberland Iron Mines and the Proposed Ennerdale Railway

The following is extracted from The Colliery Guardian of last week, in which it forms part of a paper by Mr. W. W. Barnes, M.E., or Ireby, who has paid considerable attention to the subject upon which he writes:— As in West Cumberland, so in Furness and North Lancashire, the ores — haematites — that have been successfully worked — proved continuous deposits — have been, with one exception only, Knockmurton — not truly veinous formations and situated in the carboniferous series, not in the primitive rocks. The veins in the primitive rocks indicating haematite iron ores over an area of many miles square, along the Ennerdale, Eskdale, Mitredale, and Buttermere mountains and valleys, though well known to the West Cumberland mine owners and ironmasters for nearly half a century, have remained unheeded by them, or comparatively so, although so far as surface indications go there is a greater demonstration, a more "visible presence" of haematite ore than is to be found in the limestone of West Cumberland, Furness, and North Lancashire districts. Even during the greatest speculative periods — when the desire seemed to be to the mine for haematite iron ores — the county's mineowners, engineers, and others intimately acquainted with every likely ore bearing district of the counties named still allowed the mountainous ranges in the Lake District to remain unwrought and neglected, and preferred to re-open abandoned mines, and bid high rental and tonnage dues for mines or royalties in the known and acknowledged centres of deposits of haematite in the Cleator, Frizington, Moor Row, and surrounding centres, rather than attempt what they considered a most risky undertaking to mine for haematite iron ores in the vein formations of Ennerdale, Mitredale, or Eskdale ranges. The Whitehaven Iron Mines Company, Limited, that had a "take" of about 6,000 acres at a rental of £20 per annum and tonnage dues of 7d per ton for one section, and £50 per annum and 1s per ton for another portion, have shown by their varied trials over an extended area the uncertainty of the true vein or lode formations, so far as their haematite iron-ore bearing qualities go. Again, the South Cumberland Company, Eskdale Mining Company, Wilton Fells and Lowther Park Common mining trials — all have and the same results, unprofitable working, no deposits of any material extent, silicious and poor ores unfit for the blast furnaces. The above named companies have worked recently. Years ago, about from 1810 to 1830, and even prior to the first given date, working for haematite upon the mountainous ranges of the lakes were made — continuing for a limited time only — always, without exception, proving that the broken and irregular soppy deposits were the rule. That the indications are taking or attractive, and calculated to impress a casual observer — especially if he be unacquainted with the general character of the rocks — cannot be denied. Vein after vein can be seen — outcrop after outcrop; the many gullies or ravines are coloured red with the "washes" and nodules of ore. Immense detached blocks showing "strings" of ore, are scattered about, and other demonstrative indications, all going to impress an enthusiast that ore is here to be wrought in thousands of tons without that expense of sinking and other heavy charges of rents, tonnages, &c., that are made by the royalty owners in the Cleator and Egremont mining districts. So far as the writer has observed there is not any single vein in the granite and other kindred rocks that has not "nipped out," "broken up," or been thrown by "faults" or other coincident geological changes. Consequently, the want of irregularity in bearing or direction and other adverse features are prohibitory, of even fairly good deposits. The most flattering and most demonstrative veins have frequently been the most disappointing. No matter how experienced the miner, he has little or no idea how soon or how suddenly the vein may be barren, may be "thrown," or completely broken up. Is it not, then, likely — indeed probable, may it not be asked, that these very irregularities — these frequent disturbing forces exhibited over, not only a narrowed limit, but over many miles square are the chief and direct means of such prodigality of "indications?"

The immense detached portions of vein-stone, outcrops, washes — hundreds in number — are the very outcome of the irregularity of the veins. Had the lodes or veins been less disturbed — kept their course more directly — not been broken up, thrown by faults, &c., then the same profuse and innumerable indications would not and could not have been observable. The very profusion of such outcrops, &c., combined with the character of the rock, caused the writer to conclude that continuous deposits of haematite iron-ore are unlikely — nearly impossible — to have existence over the whole area embraced by the mountainous ranges and valleys of the Ennerdale, Eskdale, Buttermere, and Mitredale. At the time when haematite iron-ores were selling from 30s to 40s per ton, some little likelihood of a limited liability company keeping pace with their expenditure might have been expected. Failure, however, resulted. Now, when even the high-class West Cumberland ores of Cleator raising of best all round analysis command only about 11s per ton at mines, and difficult to dispose in quantity even at this figure, how can it reasonably be expected that profit can be obtained for silicious ore of the vein formations? An analysis may give as far as 60 per cent. metallic iron. This, however, is not enough to satisfy the consumer. He is greatly interested, indeed anxious to know — bound in fact. With many advantages there are at present many mines showing only nominal profits. Some will be, and have for some time back been, raising at a loss. What probability, then, it may be reasonably asked has the proposed Ennerdale Mine and Railway Co. to be a concern of profit to anyone connected with it, other perhaps than the promoters? Considering the Ennerdale Railway Bill in its entirety — its primary object — the accessory to mine flotation, the unlikelihood in the face of the present depression of an material benefit, and the improbability that even the capital expended would ever be recoverable, low prices of best known ores the rapidly extending and increased consumption of Spanish and other ferro-manganese ores — consequently greater competition and lessening in price of superior local raised ores, it seems unnecessary, that such a Bill as the Ennerdale Railway Bill should at the time present be brought forward, and somewhat remarkable that the questionable undertaking has the support of several gentlemen who have given evidence in its favour. The remarks of the chairman of the Cleator and Workington Junction Railway Company at the last half-yearly meeting may be taken as strongly indicating the general state of the county. When, there-fore, such an authority strongly deprecates the construction and extension of his own railway where the object was to benefit mineowners, colliery proprietors, the coke, iron and steel industries, and trades generally — not to be a foster parent of a mine worked on the limited liability principle — the construction of the Ennerdale Railway must even to thoroughly disinterested parties be regarded as a most voluntary and speculative scheme with little probability at even the capital expended being realisable, much less the cent. per cent., profits that are stated in prospectus as being certain of attainment. Mr. J. D. Kendall, of Whitehaven, the well known mining engineer, probably the greatest authority upon haematite iron-ore mining and geological conditions of haematite, has along with other locally connected engineers in every case advised the ironmasters and mineowners of the west coast to shun the Ennerdale and adjoining mountainous ranges, so far as a searching for haematite ore is concerned. Such opinions adverse to the likelihood of deposits in the vein formations are, however, for varied reasons, not shared by London and south country mining engineers, and who have reported that "immense deposits," "thousands upon thousands of tons, are simply awaiting for the advent of a railway to be removed." When recognised authorities for years having made haematite mining and its conditions of deposit their study agree that the mountainous vein forms are unlikely — indeed, it is not natural for them to be stored with iron-ore, on account of the general character of geological condition — and the ironmakers along the coast do not prosecute a search, it is singular that there are founders of a limited mining company and promoters of a railway where support from the public is requested — both mine and railway expenditure having to be and stated capable of being supported by the mines produce alone. Even should the varied veins largely yield ore, the silicious element would in all probability prohibit utility by the blast furnaces of the west coast and other centres of manufacture?

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Barnes, W. W.    Mining Engineer  
Kendall, John Dixon    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print