28th February 1884
The Ennerdale Railway Bill
In the House of Commons, on Thursday, on the order for the second reading of this Bill, Mr. E. S. HOWARD moved that it be read a second time that day six months. There might have been something unusual in the course taken in regard to this Bill last
year, but the opposition the Bill then met with received a great amount of justification from the fact that the Select Committee, to whom the Bill was referred, rejected it on its merits. A similar objection therefore, could not be taken this year when
he moved the rejection, the Bill showing no material alternation from that of last session. The reasons for and against remained the same, and he could not understand why the Bill was revived. It had been alleged that opposition to the Bill was
promoted by a few sentimental, well meaning, but foolish individuals, whose ideas however, should not be allowed to stand in the way of practical parties, who propose to open a new access to and develop the mineral wealth of the district and to promote
great engineering works to the advantage of the neighbourhood. But shortly and clearly he would state the grounds upon which the Lake District Defence Association, and those who would adopted their views, opposed the Bill and would oppose all such
Bills. In passing, he remarked that those who belonged to the association he had mentioned were not a small knot of obscure individuals: they included many influential members of Parliament, many gentlemen well known in the literary world, and hundreds
of thousands of inhabitants of our great cities who annually resort to the lake district for recreation and enjoyment and that relaxation which every year becomes more necessary for health. The preservation of the natural features and characteristics of
the lake district was essential, if it was to continue to afford that pleasure and enjoyment which is so necessary, and under the circumstances it was the intention of those who desired to preserve the Lake District to oppose every bill of this kind
until it is proved that such is in the public interest, and had advantages outweighing those consideration he had referred to. With that object he last year moved instructions to the committee to whom the bill was sent that they have power to hear
evidence as to injury to scenery and natural features in the district which the railway might cause, and should the second reading be now carried he would again move those instructions. But considering the result of last year's committee, that a
committee of impartial men not given to sentimental views threw out the bill, he was justified in asking the House now to reject it on the second reading stage. It was not necessary to add to what had already been said against the bill, and he moved
that it be read a second time six months hence.
Mr. CAVENDISH BENTINCK hoped the House would have heard some more solid reason for the rejection of a second reading motion of a private Bill than that given by the hon. member who had just spoken. He (Mr. Bentinck) represented a district near to
Ennerdale Lake, and knowing the local feeling in favour of the Bill should give it his support. The opposition in the statement of the case alleged that, with the exception of a slight variation in the line, the Bill was the same as the Ennerdale
Railway Bill rejected on its merits by a committee last year, but his answer to that was simply that it was not the same Bill as was brought in last year. He did not know precisely what guided the committee in their rejection of the Bill last year, but
he was given to understand there was a deficiency in the financial arrangements — not funds enough to carry out the undertaking. It was on financial grounds the Bill was rejected, not on the sentimental ground of interference with the scenery, as
any gentlemen who was familiar with the subject would know. Never in his experience as a member had so bold a proposal been made in reference to a private Bill. It was a principle well understood that no private Bill ought to be rejected on the second
reading unless it inflicted some injustice on public or private interests, and this could only be determined after the examination, a committee would give the bill. To be rejected because it interfered with the scenery, why, a more absurd objection he
never heard. This was altogether a matter to be dealt with by a committee, and if that committee chose to let the bill stand or fall on such grounds, very well; but it was unreasonable to cut the bill short at the second reading without any evidence.
Of the hundreds and thousands of individuals who gave support to the opposition he believed not one in a hundred had ever seen Ennerdale Water. Not a single petition had been lodged against the bill either from landowner or Railway Company. Local
authorities were all in favour of the bill, and so were the inhabitants. What were the reasons put forward by the opposition led by two gentlemen living at Windermere and Ambleside? He would go through them and would undertake to knock them all to
pieces. First, it was said that except for a slight variation the railway was the same as that proposed last year. That was not so; it was considerably altered and was planned to run through a 25 feet cutting for a considerable distance, where last
year it was proposed to run along the shore; and he was advised the financial difficulty had been over come, and there was sufficient support to warrant the passage of the bill. Next it was said the railway was not for the convenience of the inhabitants
of Ennerdale, and certainly it was not, for there was no population. Then it was not to serve public but private interests. But was not the developing of the resources of the country and the employing of labour matters of public interest? Would any
sentimental Radical say that? The line would develop the mineral wealth of the district, and would give an access to the lake for visitors. He did not know whether the member for East Cumberland had been there. It was nine miles from Whitehaven; to
get there requires the hiring of a conveyance: and therefore to the humbler class of tourists the lake, if worth seeing at all, is a sealed exhibition. The statement that visitors can reach a railway station within a mile and a half of Ennerdale Bridge
seemed to show that the compiler of these reasons had never been in the district. Ennerdale Bridge is 1#189; miles from the lake, and the nearest railway station is four miles away, and then it is only a station on a mineral line. The fifth reason was
that Whitehaven drew its water supply from the lake, and lead workings in the neighbourhood would render the lake water impure. Whatever professors of sentimentalism might say, the inhabitants of Whitehaven knew best about this, and they almost to a man
were in favour of the bill. All the district was in favour of it, as no one knew better than the hon. member for West Cumberland. That hon. member now withdrew from the opposition, any why? Because at every meeting he attended the rejection of the
Ennerdale Bill was dinned in his ears, and he found it was calculated to make a considerable hole in his political coat, and he retired from the front of the battle, leaving it to be fought out by the professors of sentimentalism. On general grounds,
there must be two opinions as to whether a railway partly in cutting injured scenery. He considered that a railway train was an advantage in a picturesque way. (Laughter) Well it was matter of opinion. Why did not the hon. gentlemen opposite and their
friends make friendly representations to foreign powers not to allow railways on the Italian, Swiss and Savoy lakes? He had seen an opponent of the Bill at Aix lers-Bains: would he say that the railway train there coasting along the lake and through
tunnels spoiled the lake? Then again why not go in for pitching the St. Gothard railway over the precipices? What an outrage, too, to cross the Righi in a railway train or visit Como, Maggiore, or the lake of Geneva in a train! In truth, the objection
of sentimentalists could only be met with a reluctio ad absurdum. On general grounds he claimed for the promoters of the bill a fair hearing when anything that could be alleged against the scheme could be examined.
Mr. BRYCE pointed out that the house was not asked to decide on points of detail. It was a large and general question in which interests were concerned that could have no locus standi before a Committee. The house was the only tribunal were the case
could be heard, and the House did sometimes step in to defend public interests; witness the rejection of the Epping Forest Bill. The Bill was really not needed on public grounds, and it would serve private ends, and was promoted by speculators.
Mr. J. LOWTHER, as the trustee of property largely affected the Bill, desired to make a few observations. Mr. Bryce was entirely in error in the statement that the mineral resources of the country were not worth developing. He (Mr. Lowther) was advised
on competent authority that as regarded the particular estate with which he was connected the importance would be by no means inconsiderable if the district were developed in the manner proposed. The House was now engaged in considering the merits or
demerits of the Bill. They had thought it inexpedient to withdraw the House as a whole from the consideration of details in private legislation, and he considered the House would now act unwisely if it were to go back upon its history and resumed itself
the consideration of intricate details. A statement was made by Mr. Howard, which he must with all respect flatly contradict. The hon. gentleman stated that the Bill was rejected last year by a committee of the House upon the grounds on which he
opposed it now. The Chairman of the committee would, however, bear him (Mr. Lowther) out when he said that the Bill of last year, differing as it did in some important respects from the scheme now before the House, was rejected on grounds of finance
which had nothing to do with the question of the scenery. He had every reason to believe that the person in the neighbourhood, to whom the preservation of objects of interest was far more precious than to any hon. gentleman in that House, had arrived at
the conclusion that great benefit would accrue to the general public as well as to themselves if the proposed railway were constructed. The British tourist, on behalf of whom so much had been said, was absolutely unable to get nearer the lake by railway
than 4#189; miles, and that fact alone practically withdrew Ennerdale out of the ordinary tourists route. He trusted the House would not be led away on any of the grounds put forward to resume consideration of intricate details, but would refer the Bill
to a select Committee.
Mr. FORSTER supported the motion for the rejection of the Bill. He observed that the measure seemed to be promoted with the object of developing one estate — for developing some iron or lead mine, which would even more than the railway spoil the
scenery in the district of Ennerdale. It was a question of public policy whether the House would assent to a possible speculative development at the great risk or marring a very beautiful part of the country.
Mr. AINSWORTH said he had been asked why he did not oppose the Bill as he did last year. As a matter of fact, although he moved the rejection of the Bill last year, he did not vote against it because that railway affected his property, and therefore he
might be considered an interested party. He did not intend to vote to night, and he trusted the same reason, which prompted him, would cause the right hon. gentleman (Mr. J. Lowther) to refrain from taking part in the division.
Mr. LOWTHER said he was quite willing to pair with Mr. Ainsworth.
After some words from Mr. MACIVER in favour of the Bill, the House divided
| For the second-reading | 164 |
| Against | 148 |
| Majority | 16 |
Mr. STAFFORD HOWARD then gave notice that he would move the same instruction to the Select Committee as was passed by the House last year.
In the House of Commons on Monday, Mr. BRYCE moved that it be an instruction to the committee as the Ennerdale Railway Bill to inquire and report to the House whether the proposed railway would interfere with the enjoyment of the public who annually
visit the Lake District, by injuriously affecting the scenery or otherwise, and that they have power to call witnesses and receive evidence upon the subject. He reminded the House that the same instruction had been moved last year, and had been carried
by a large majority. Without this instruction, those who wished to preserve the scenery of the district would have no locus standi before the Committee. He was informed that there was a strong feeling in the district against the Bill — (Mr.
CAVENDISH BENTINCK: "No, no.") The right hon. member said "No, no" but he (Mr. Bryce) said, "Yes, yes." The Bill was not promoted in the public interest, but was promoted entirely by certain private speculators, and it was
only fair that they should be asked to meet the case which he was informed would be laid against them. — Mr. CAVENDISH BENTINCK opposed the instruction. He said the opposition to the Bill was promoted by men who had never been in the district.
— Mr. BRYCE: I have. — Mr. BENTINCK: Than the hon. gentleman is the exception to the rule. He proceeded to complain of attacks, which had been made upon himself and the member for Lincolnshire (Mr. James Lowther), in the Echo. — Mr.
BRYCE: I have not written anything in any newspapers. — Mr. BENTINCK said he had stated that the hon. member did so, but the hon. member might have taken steps to prevent his friends doing so. The paper he referred to spoke of " the
pertinacious Lowthers " who came to the House with shameful and selfish proposals for the purpose of putting money into the pockets of particular families. There was another newspaper of the same date, lately under the control of the hon. member
for Newcastle. — Mr. JOHN MORLEY disclaimed responsibility for the article. — Mr. BENTINCK was understood to say that the article was probably written by somebody the hon. member knew all about. (Laughter.) He denied that in supporting the
Bill he was actuated by selfish motives or by private greed. He was actuated by regard for the public interest. It was the pretended friends of the people who were able to pay for carriages and horses, and desired to keep the beauties of the Ennerdale
scenery to themselves who were actuated by selfish motives. At present the district was inaccessible. The railway would open it up to Sunday school excursions, and to people who could only afford to spend a few shillings. That was what the opponents
of the Bill wished to prevent. He pointed out that the Bill was supported by both newspapers in Whitehaven, in the interests of the people of Whitehaven to whom the railway would prove an admirable outlet. The line as laid out this year was entirely
altered from what it was last year. It was now carried upon an embankment alongside the lake, but was shielded from view in a cutting 25ft deep. — Mr. BUSZARD hoped the instructions would be sent to he Committee. The Ennerdale valley was twelve
miles long, and was almost unique as an example of solemn and impressive rock scenery. The railway would occupy several miles of the valley, and in his opinion would entirely destroy its character. The railway was not required by the inhabitants of the
district, who were only 75 in number. The neighbourhood was essentially a pedestrian neighbourhood, and no one without the full use of his legs must go there to enjoy it. — Mr. PEMBERTON opposed the instruction to the Committee on the ground that
it would deprive the owners of property of the right to develop the resources of the district because somebody else happened to admire it. (Laughter) Mr. ROBERTS also opposed the instruction as asserting the rights of private individuals unconnected
with a district to set up an opposition to its development. He asked the House to consider what would have been the effect on the development of Wales if opposition of this kind had been allowed to the railway through the Vale of Lllangollen and by the
Lake of Bala or to the opening up of the Conway Valley to Lianrwst. It appeared to him that this bill was promoted by a quixotic association, which ought not to receive any encouragement from the House of Commons. The bill ought to be inquired into and
decided upon its own merits. The House divided, when there voted — For the instruction, 121: against, 101; majority, 20. The announcement of the figures was received with cheers.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ainsworth, — | | M.P. | |
| Bentinck, Cavendish | | M.P. | |
| Bryce, — | | M.P. | |
| Buszard, — | | M.P. | |
| Forster, — | | M.P. | |
| Howard, E. S. | | M.P. | |
| Howard, Stafford | | M.P. | |
| Lowther, J. | | M.P. | |
| MacIver, — | | M.P. | |
| Morley, John | | M.P. | |
| Pemberton, — | | M.P. | |
| Roberts, — | | M.P. | |