Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th November 1883

Local Law Case

Ehen Mining Company And Another v. Sir James Bain And Co

This case was heard on Monday last before Mr. Baron Pollock, sitting without a jury, at the Royal Courts of Justice, London. A shorter account of this case appears in another page, but since it went to press we have been favoured with the following full report of the case:— Mr. Cohen, Q.C., M.P., and Mr. Phipson Beal, instructed by Mr. Thomas Brown, Whitehaven, were counsel for the plaintiffs; and the Solicitor-General, Mr. Crompton, Q.C., and Mr. John Cutler, instructed by Messrs. Brockbank, Helder and Brockbank, Whitehaven, were counsel for the defendants. — Mr. Cohen, Q.C., said there were two questions in this case for his Lordship's decision. The first was as to the ownership of the minerals in a small segment shaped piece of land which laid between the mines of the plaintiffs and of the defendants, and which was shown upon a plan annexed to the pleadings with pink and barred pink colours, and was described as the "pink minerals" and what was the amount of damages payable for the abstraction of such minerals. The second question was as to the amount of damages to be paid the defendants, who claimed by way of counter claim damages for minerals abstracted by the plaintiff from Lord Leconfield's royalty which had been let to the defendants, and which was called the "blue minerals. "The plaintiffs admitted working the blue minerals, but they contended they had done so under a mistaken title, and not wilfully, and the only question which was before the Court with reference to the blue mineral was as to the value of the ore abstracted, and the amount to be allowed the plaintiffs for bringing it to the bank, and any consequential damages which the defendants might have sustained if it were found that the plaintiffs had worked the blue minerals improperly. He said that about the year 1812 one Thomas Benson was the owner of certain lands adjoining and to the south of the pink and barred pink lands, and one Bell was the owner of certain land adjoining Benson's on the north, called Candlings Meadow. These Candlings Meadows comprised the pink and barred pink land. That in February, 1812, Bell sold the Canning Meadows to one William Brown, who was the owner of the Woodend Estate, which abutted on the north of Candlings Meadows. Some time between 1812 and 1827 the boundary fence of Candlings Meadow and Benson's land was straightened, the result being that the pink and barred pink land came into the possession of Benson, and Benson gave Brown in exchange an equivalent portion of land to the west of the pink and barred pink. In July, 1828, Robert Benson and others sold the pink and barred pink, along with other lands, to one Thomas Hartley, who by his will, gave all his lands to his oldest son, Thomas Hartley, and the latter in turn by his will gave all his land to his eldest son, Thomas Hartley, who lives at Armathwaite Hall, but who lately resided at Gillfoot, Egremont. The present Mr. Hartley sold his interest in the pink minerals to the plaintiff company on the 22nd September 1878. William Brown, who before the straightening of the fence was the owner of the pink minerals, died in July 1828. By his will he devised all his real estate to trustees upon trust for sale. His trustees about the year 1862 obtained the sanction of the court of Chancery to sell the surface of his estate separately from the minerals. In 1863 they sold the surface of the Woodend Estate and the Candlings Meadows to Messrs. Lindow, and in 1867 they sold the minerals to the defendant for £30,500. Messrs. Lindow never took possession of the pink and barred pink land, but under their deed they took possession of the land given in exchange on the straightening of the fence. The defendants never worked the pink minerals until 1878. It will be seen that the plaintiffs had been in uninterrupted possession of the surface of pink and barred pink land for at least 50 years, and being in possession of the surface they were prima facie in possession of the minerals, and unless his learned friend Mr. Crompton could show either by deed or other document that on the exchange of land when the fence was straightened the minerals in the pink and barred pink were reserved to Brown he contended that the minerals belonged to the plaintiffs. Now, as the defendants admitted that they had worked in the pink and barred pink, if his Lordship decided that the pink minerals belonged to the plaintiffs, he would ask that his Lordship should state what was the measure of damages to be paid by the defendants for the pink minerals they had abstracted. If his learned friend would admit that the plaintiff's trespasses in the blue mineral were made under a mistaken title, he on the other hand would admit that the defendant's trespasses in the pink mineral were also mistaken trespasses. — Mr. Compton said he could not admit that the trespasses in the blue minerals were made under a mistaken title. The plaintiffs had actually worked after they received notice from Lord Leconfield that the blue minerals belonged to him. — Mr. Cohen said, as his learned friend would not admit that the plaintiff's trespasses in the blue minerals were made under a mistaken title, he could not then admit that the defendants trespasses in the pink minerals were made under a mistaken title. The fact was, the present Mr. Hartley let the blue minerals to the plaintiffs on the 28th September 1878. Lord Leconfield, who contested Mr. Hartley's title to these minerals, also let them to the defendants about the same time. Mr. Hartley and Lord Leconfield referred their dispute to arbitration, and the award was made in December 1881. By this award the blue minerals were given to Lord Leconfield. Whilst the preliminary proceedings in the arbitration were going on, both the plaintiffs and defendants had been working the blue minerals, and by arrangement they agreed to stop working simultaneously until the ownership of these minerals was settled, and they accordingly stopped their mining operations on the 8th September 1879. Since then the plaintiffs have not worked any of the blue minerals. — Mr. Crompton said that, as the plaintiffs admitted abstracting the blue minerals, it was, with regard to that portion of the case, simply a question of what was the amount of damages the defendants were entitled to be paid, and if his Lordship found for either the plaintiffs or defendants with regard to the ownership of the pink minerals, the amount of the damages to be paid by either of the parties for the abstraction of the pink minerals would likewise have to be settled. He thought it would be better the question of damages in both cases should be left to a referee. — Mr. Cohen concurred with Mr. Crompton as to settling the amount of damages before a referee, but he thought the basis should be settled by his Lordship. — Mr. Crompton contended that as the land taken in exchange for the pink and barred pink land when the fence was straightened did not carry with it the minerals because they had been reserved to Lord Leconfield by a dead of enfranchisement, it had been the intention of the parties making the exchange that only the surface should be exchanged and not that the one should take the surface only, and the other take both surface and minerals, and he had no doubt there was some deed or document between the parties to the exchange carrying out an arrangement of this kind, and although they had no copy or evidence of such a document yet that his Lordship, sitting as a jury, was entitled to presume if he thought as from the facts put before him that such a document had been in existence. — Mr. Hartley, examined by Mr. Cohen, said the pink and barred pink land was purchased by his grandfather, Thomas Hartley, in 1828, along with other lands. He produced a plan dated 1827, showing that the fence was straight at the time, and he also produced the deed of 1828, conveying the property to his grandfather. — Mr. Crompton said they did not dispute the devolution of Mr. Hartley's title. — Mr. Crompton cross-examined Mr. Hartley to show that he was not aware until very recently that he had any claim to the "pink minerals," and that he had never treated them as belonging to him until about five or six years ago. — His Lordship, in giving judgement, said if Mr. Crompton could have shown him by any evidence that there were any reasonable grounds for his presuming that there had been some deed or document affecting the arrangement for straightening the fence by which the "pink minerals" were reserved to the defendant's predecessors in title he would have been inclined to presume the existence of such a deed or document, but in the absence of any such evidence he must find in favour of the plaintiffs. The question of the amount of damages for the abstraction of the "pink minerals" by the defendants, and of the abstraction of the "blue minerals" by the plaintiffs must be left to a referee, who would have to report to the Court the circumstance attending each trespass, so that he (the judge) might decide whether the trespasses were mistaken or wilful trespasses to settle the measure of damages. Costs to funds he extrudes.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bain, James    Mine Owner  
Beale, Phipson    Solicitor  
Bell, —    Land Owner  
Benson, Thomas    Land Owner  
Brockbank, —    Solicitor  
Brown, Thomas    Solicitor  
Brown, William    Land Owner  
Cohen, —    Q.C., M.P.  
Crompton, —    Solicitor-General  
Cutler, John    Solicitor  
Hartley, Thomas    Land Owner  
Helder, —    Solicitor  
Leconfield, Lord    Land Owner  
Lindow, —    Land Owner  
Pollock, Barron    Justice  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print