29th November 1883
An Egremont Mining Case
In the Queen's Bench Division of the Royal Courts of Justice, London, on Monday, the case of the Ehen Mining Company and another v. James Bain & Company came before Mr. Baron Pollock, sitting without a jury. — This case was originally entered
in the Chancery Division, and involved the ownerships of certain mineral land and the right to work minerals in the county of Cumberland. The plaintiffs are the Ehen Mining Company and Mr. Thomas Hartley, by whom they were granted a mineral lease, and
the defendants are a firm engaged in iron working in the county of Cumberland. — Mr. Cohen, Q.C., M.P., and Mr. Beale appeared for the plaintiffs, and the Solicitor-General, Mr. Crompton, Q.C., and Mr. J. Cutler represented the defendants. —
Mr. Cohen, in opening the case for the plaintiffs, stated that the two questions for his Lordship's consideration were, firstly, the question of title, and, secondly, the amount of damages for the minerals which, as the plaintiffs alleged, the defendants
had taken away. The defendants were entitled to some estate or interest in minerals under land near Egremont, and the plaintiffs were the lesses of Thomas Hartley of certain portions of his minerals, as also under Lord Lonsdale. For some considerable
time they had been and were still working this property, and the contention of the plaintiffs was that they had trespassed upon the plaintiffs minerals and carried away quantities of ore. The defendants denied the trespass and that the plaintiffs had
any interest in the minerals, and also set up a counter claim alleging trespass on the part of the plaintiffs. The case involving the question of title necessitated the tracing of the ownership from the year 1812, and raised the point whether a certain
portion of the property was freehold with the right of working minerals, or whether it was enfranchised copyhold with no such right. His Lordship, after reading the documents and hearing the arguments, gave judgment for the plaintiffs, and ordered the
amount of damages to be assessed.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bain, James | | Mine Owner | |
| Beale, Phipson | | Solicitor | |
| Cohen, — | | Q.C., M.P. | |
| Crompton, — | | Solicitor-General | |
| Cutler, John | | Solicitor | |
| Hartley, Thomas | | | |
| Lonsdale, Earl of | | Land Owner | |
| Pollock, Barron | | Justice | |