18th October 1883
The Cleator Moor Barber and His Apprentice
Another Charge Of Ill-Treatment
At the Cleator Moor Police court on Friday last James Bell, barber, opposite the Market-square, was charged with assaulting an apprentice barber named William Ferguson, son of Mr. William Ferguson, builder, Hensingham. — Defendant, it will be
remembered, was fined for a similar offence some time ago, at the instance of the Whitehaven Guardians. — Mr. W. H. Chapman appeared for complainant, and Mr. E. Atter represented the defendant. — Mr. Chapman briefly sketched the circumstances
of the assault, and was proceeding to say that it was only one of a long series of assaults, as defendant had treated the lad badly by pinching, striking, and kicking him, when Mr. Atter objected to anything but the particular assault complained of being
gone into. — Complainant, an intelligent looking lad, said he was 15 years of age. At the end of last year he was bound as an apprentice barber with the defendant, and entered on his duties on the 1st of January last. The conditions were that he
was to have his board, lodgings, and washing, but that he was to receive no wages. He was bound for five years. On Saturday the 29th ulto, between three and four o'clock, he had been "lathering" two or three men, preparatory to Mr. Bell
shaving them, and after he had "lathered" one of the men he went near to his master, who thereupon kicked him four or five times on the shin, from the effects of which he suffered great pain. While kicking him defendant asked him why he was
keeping the man waiting. As a result of the kicks there were marks on his legs. On the Sunday he went home to his parents at Hensingham, and informed them of what had taken place. On the Monday his father and stepmother went with him to Mr. Bell's,
and his father asked defendant if ever he nipped witness. Bell replied that he nipped people who did not do as he wanted them to do. His father asked Bell if he ever kicked him (witness). He replied that he always kicked people who would not get out
of his road. When shown the bruised condition of witness's leg defendant denied that he had been the cause of it, but alleged that it must have been caused by him falling down the cellar steps. While his father was present the indentures were burned.
At this interview defendant shoved him back to keep him in the shop. He acknowledged that he was disobedient sometimes. — Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: He had been in a draper's shop before he went to Mr. Bell's, but he liked the barbering
business better.
A man named Briggs, living at Frizington, but employed at the Co-operative Store, was in the shop at the time of the assault. His father and stepmother called on Briggs before they went to Bell's shop, but Briggs said that while he heard Bell repeat the
words about keeping the man waiting, yet he did not see the kicks given. At the time referred to Briggs was holding his head back, and consequently could not see what was done. He did not call out when he was kicked. — Re-examined: The reason
why he did not shout out when he was kicked was because he had got used to it. (Laughter.) — Mr. William Ferguson, father of the complainant, said he was a builder at Hensingham. On Sunday the 30th of September his son came home and complained of
Bell's ill-treatment. Along with his wife he examined the lad's right leg, which was quite swollen and black. He also examined one of his arms, and found on the back of his arm four finger marks, and at the front one thumb mark, which were all very
black. On the next day (Monday) they went to see Mr. Bell. Witness gave corroborative evidence as to the conversation that passed between the parties at this interview. Defendant wanted to have the lad left with him again, but he (witness) refused to
allow him to stay there any longer. Some talk took place about the indentures, which were ultimately thrown into the grate and burned. Defendant on a former occasion had promised to give witness the indentures on condition that he let his son go back
to him after he had been ill-used. Bell had admitted to the Hensingham policeman that he had ill-treated the lad before this. — Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: Bell denied that he made the marks on his son's legs.
The lad was willing at the time to have his legs examined by a doctor, but it would not be fair to examine them now, a fortnight after the occurrence. He saw the marks were still on the lad's legs last Saturday. — Mrs. Louisa Ferguson, step-mother
of the complainant, gave similar evidence. — For the defence, Mr. Atter pointed out the difficulty that his client was placed in this case, as he could neither give evidence himself nor call his wife. The whole of the case rested upon the
unsupported evidence of the complainant, and he (Mr. Atter) was instructed to give an emphatic denial to the charge of assault. The lad's story was trumped up simply that he might get clear of his trade, as he liked the drapery trade better. The lad
had admitted that he did not always obey orders. It was a curious thing, if the assault was committed, that none of the customers who were in the shop saw it. The lad's legs had not been examined by a medical man and his parents had now declined to
have that done. It seemed very probable that if the legs were marked the marks had been caused by his falling down the steep cellar steps. — The Bench having decided to convict, Mr. Chapman called Inspector Smith, who proved that defendant had
been previously fined 40s and bound over to keep the peace for a similar offence. — Defendant was now fined £3, including costs, with the alternative of one month's imprisonment. — The result of the case was received with slight
applause in the court, but it was immediately suppressed.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Atter, Edward | | Solicitor | |
| Bell, James | | Barber | |
| Chapman, W. H. | | Solicitor | |
| Ferguson, Louisa | | | |
| Ferguson, William | | Builder | |
| Ferguson, William | 15 | Apprentice | |
| Smith, — | | Police Inspector | |