|
12th July 1883 The Late Fatal Pit Explosion At HarringtonProsecution By The Home OfficeAt the Whitehaven Petty Sessions, on Monday, before Mr. H. Watson, Esq. (in the chair), H. Jefferson, Esq., Mr. J. Dickinson, jun., Esq., John Steward Simpson, for of the owners, and David Ferguson, certificated Manager, of Sir James Bain & Company's Colliery at Harrington, were summoned at the instance of the Home Office, charged on twelve information's with Offences against the Mines Act. Mr. Stevenson, Q.C., London (instructed by Mr. E. Atter, of Whitehaven), appeared to prosecute, and Mr. Howson (Mr. Lumb and Howson) appeared for the defence. Mr. Willis, Government Inspector of Mines, and Mr. Dickinson, deputy inspector, were present, as were also some of the chief officials of the Whitehaven Collieries, they decided to take four of the information's and put them together against the two defendants, viz., That of not having locked safety lamps in a part of the mine were safety lamps ought to be used, and not having a competent person to lock or control the lamps, as used in any working where there was likely to be an accumulation of gas — Mr. Stevenson said he appeared, instructed by Mr. Atter, to prosecute the defendants. The offences were various — for not keeping proper ventilation, for not using safety lamps, not having proper safety lamps, &c.; but the charges that he wanted to go into would limit the information's to two cases against the defendants. The first was that they were guilty of a contravention of one of the general rules of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1872, by having used a lamp other than a locked safety lamp, to be seen working in their mine approaching a place where there was likely to be an accumulation of explosive gas. The other was that the defendants had neglected to have a competent person to examine every safety lamp immediately it was taken into the working of the coal mine for use, to ascertain the same to be secure and remain locked. The learned counsel quoted the section from which the proceeding were taken, and proceeded :— He proved his case, the defendants would be liable to fines not exceeding £20. Now for the facts. On the 31st March last two men named Beatty were working in No. 9 pit in a seam called the yard seam, a place which gas had been seen before, a place that any practical man (Mr. Ferguson or Mr. Simpson) ought to have seen was dangerous, owing to the gas omitted being allowed to accumulate. That it had accumulated and quickly was true, for the men Beatty were so severely burned that they died. That explosion and burning was caused by a naked light. The case was considered by the district inspector and the Home Office to be an important one, not only for the workmen themselves, but those gentlemen who had under their control large works so that they should take every possible means to prevent accidents. The only charge just now was that the owner and manager did not take reasonable means to prevent the explosion, and that men were working with unlocked lamps. He would now call his witness — James Willis, inspector of mines for the district in which the Harrington No. 9 pit is situated, said he had instituted this prosecution. — By Mr. Howson: He could not tell anything about the internal arrangements of the mine. — Joseph Davis, Distington, said he was formerly a miner at No. 9 pit, Harrington Colliery. On the 31st March last he was a deputy in the colliery. He knew the place where Thomas Batey was working. To his knowledge there had been gas in the "yard" seam. The seam had been worked for eight or nine weeks up to the 31st March. Two or three days before the 31st March he found a "blue cap," indicating gas, in his lamp when he was in the working. At the time of the accident James and Thomas Batey were in the working. Their safety lamps were not locked that morning. Witness was at the bottom of the shaft when he heard the explosion, which came out of Batey's working. He was about 15 or 20 yards off. He went straight to the Bateys, who were shouting. They were burned, and subsequently died. He noticed the safety lamp that was in the working. It was a "Davy" lamp. The gauze of the lamp was off, and it was not locked. He saw the lamp in the hand of Batey when he looked in, and the gauze was then on. Since the explosion only locked safety lamps had been used in that part of the mine, but not before. Had he been told to use only safety lamps he would have used them. He had no special instructions from Mr. Simpson or Mr. Benson as to the working of the seam. He had never seen copy of the special rules given him, and the number of the rule under which these proceedings were taken was not read to him prior to the31st March. — By Mr. Howson: He was at the colliery when the six-quarter (the yard seam) was opened. It was being opened out to get to another shaft in the pit. Previous to the 31st all the gas he had seen was when he was going round to test for gas, and then he saw the "blue top." It was a rise working, and the gas showed a tendency to gather in such a place. The only spot where he got the "cup" was at the forehead. He could detect it a foot back from the face. It was not a place but the "nicking corner." The working was 12 feet wide, and the coal seam was about a yard wide. The "blue cap" did not explode, and therefore they did not consider it dangerous. A canvas brattice was used for ventilation, and there was plenty air to take away the gas that produced the "cap." Up to the time the place had been regularly worked with open lights — naked lights. It was the regulation there to work with naked lights. He was regularly there in the morning from six to two o'clock. The place had always been worked for sixteen out of the twenty four hours with naked lights. Whilst there he had never seen any occasion to work with anything but open lights, and he had never called the attention of the manager or owner to the fact. Had he seen any gas he would have reported it for his own sake. It was his duty as deputy to examine the workings before they went in, and he did it. The men looked to him for the safety of their workings from gas. In the six-quarter coal there were about 16 men working, some of them had ever complained to him that the six-quarters was making gas. Some of the men found their safety lamps, some did not. On examining the flame he used the safety lamp, as was done in collieries. Having seen the "cap" he did not think it worth reporting. — The Chairman: Why not. Witness: Because it did not explode. — By Mr. Howson: The brattice was kept up and the air going on the 31st. Naked lights were being carried in the bottom of a safety lamp. The men worked out about two feet of the coal when the explosion occurred. They had been out of their working getting their breakfast for half an hour, and they returned to the work when the explosion took. The explosion was not a violent one. No they were removed and the canvas was not knocked out. The man who was stripped and working died first. He could not account for the explosion, but there was a mark of "little trouble" close to it — sufficient to ignite gas if pierced. There was not much smoke in the working after the explosion. The "blue cap" was there the day after the explosion. He believed that the men had left a lighted open lamp in the working. He saw one of the men had the gauze of the lamp in his pocket, and the other man's lamp was hung on the brattice. He could not say how the gas exploded. — By Mr. Stevenson: He was the man appointed by Mr. Ferguson as deputy. He did not know how the mine was and if anything went wrong with the ventilation he would have reported it to John Moore, and if John Moore was absent he would let the place stand. Bratticing was for ventilation, and the drift had been bratticed right up to where the men were working to keep the place clean. It was set up because of the "blue cap" being found. — Mr. Stevenson: And you found it often? — Witness: Yes. And you say it was not a dangerous place? — Witness made no reply. — Mr. Stevenson: Very well. — Witness in reply to further questions, said he could tell that Kelly and Davis were singed. He under stood what "bleeding" was. This place made a little gas and a little water. He never said before the inquest it was his opinion that naked lights should not be been used. He would not swear he did not say so before the coroner. The lamp was more convenient with the gauze is off because it is handier. As a miner he liked the naked light better, because he could see to a lot better. The safety lamps were there, so that if there was anything" he could lock them. When he saw the "blue cap" he used to tell the men to keep the tops of their lamps on. Perhaps he had told them some times. He reported that to John Moore. John Moore, overman in the colliery, stated that on the 31st March he was working in the two-foot main seam, after the accident he went to the men, and about an hour and a half or two hours afterwards he went into the working and put down his flame, and then put it up found nothing that was dangerous. — The Chairman :— What did you find? — Witness: A small "blue cap." — Examination continued: Before the 31st of March Crone told him there was "blue cap." Witness had also seen it very small in Batey's working. — The Chairman :— Does not the smallness of the flame in your lamp take the smallness of the "blue cap?" Yes. — And if you raise the flame won't it be greater? No, it would not be seen at all. — Mr. Stevenson: And if there is gas, what then? It puts the light down altogether — Cross-examination continued: He had told the men on one occasion to bring the tops of their lamps. The men were not to screw the tops on the lamps. That would have been done by the deputy. — By Mr. Howson: He had been a coalminer 24 or 25 years, and had seen a bit of gas in his time. If there was only a small "blue cap" and it was not dangerous, it was not necessary for men to have safety lamps. It was necessary with the bratticing for ventilation whether there was any gas in the working or not. Crone and he had conversations about the "blue cap," and had he saw anything dangerous he would have reported to Mr. Ferguson. He had never had a complaint from any of the men that they had got their whiskers singed. He had never thought the place dangerous, and never reported to his superiors, to his knowledge any of its becoming dangerous. He accounted for the place becoming dangerous by a small fall of metal, but it could not be seen on the 31st as it might have been cut in a moment. He thought the men might bring the gas down on account of the air when they recommenced working. — Mr. Atkinson, assistant Government Inspector of Mines, said that after the explosion he went down the mine, and testing for gas found it. In his opinion it was safe to work the place without safety lamps. It was safe, and a very bad practice to allow the men into the working and to allow them to screw on tops of their lamps. The coal was "bleeding," and you could hear the gas hissing through the water. He went with the lamp, and then found the "blue cap." By the Chairman: He found the cap near the top of the Bateys had been working. The place was checked and his lamp filled with the gas. A slight rise in the mixture of the air and gas would have caused an explosion. — By Mr. Howson: Examining as you did the 13th of April the state of things, such as the atmosphere, might be different on the 31st March. But could not find gas except at the forehead and in the heading against the face. The gas exploded in the lamp on the 11th of April there was not sufficient ventilation for the gas. Naked lights should not have been in. the working. — By Mr. Stephenson: It was his opinion that the place having been newly opened out, with a rise of 4in. to the yard, and having seen this light, coupled with the "bleeding," all showed there should be safety lamps. There had been occasions at Moresby Colliery also where naked lights were used, and the manager had been burned. — John Davis, miner, Parton, said he formerly worked at No. 9 Pit. About three weeks or a month before the explosion he had a slight singe of his whiskers by a "blower" in the working. — By Mr. Howson: He had previously been out for his breakfast, and was coming into the working when the "blower" was lighted. He did not think it was worth mentioning. He was not alarmed, and worked his shift out. He had been a collier about 12 years. There was no fault to find with the ventilation. — John Kelly, who formerly six-quarter worked in No. 9 Pit, said that a day or two before the accident to the Bateys he was slightly burned about his ear. — By Mr. Howson: There was an overman at the pit at the time, but he did not think it worth reporting. The flash occurred some time after he commenced working. He had worked a few shifts after he was burned. He considered the place safe so long as there was efficient ventilation. The explosion when he was burned was owing to an accident to the brattice. — This was the case for the prosecution. — Mr. Howson, for the defence, said it had never become necessary to use safety lamps in this particular place except for the purpose of examining the working. The rule since February last had been to work with open lights; and there was no indication of danger until the 31st of March, when the explosion occurred. The blue cap was not a sufficient indicate of danger to put upon the manager or owner of the colliery (even had they known it, which they did not) the duty of working a place with locked lamps. Up to that time they believed that the place was free from danger, and that the working of it with naked lights was a thing of regular course. Had there been any regulation to carry safety lamps they would have seen it carried out, but with the state of things that existed from the time the working was opened out, no such necessity arose. Of course, since the accident they had more information on the subject, and safety lamps had been used; but that must not be taken as an admission on their part that there existed on the 31st March, or previously, a danger that they ought to have foreseen. The question was whether his clients were aware, directly or indirectly, that there was likely to be an accumulation of explosive gas in the working. There was nothing of the kind to be anticipated. The theory was that just before the men Batey went to their breakfast they had come upon a fissure, which discharged into the working a quantity of gas, which exploded when they returned. No reasonable foresight could have anticipated that state of things. He submitted with great confidence that the facts brought out proved that all reasonable means had been used by the owner and agent to avoid accident. — The Clerk: The onus of proving that you have used all reasonable means is thrown upon you. — The question is whether the evidence does not point to some extent to the fact that there was explosive gas in the working, and that it was the duty of some one to see that safety lamps were used. — Mr. Howson: That's the question. I submit that there is an entire want of evidence on the point. The only persons to say anything about it are the two workmen, who thought the circumstance so trivial that they never mentioned it. — The Clerk: You have Mr. Atkinson's evidence to the effect that a blue cap indicates danger, and that the working should be worked by safety lamps. — Mr. Howson said that in the Stella mine naked lights were used. — Mr. Stevenson: There are several shafts there. You need not go into the circumstances of that case. — Mr. Howson: And there would have been two shafts here shortly. As to the evidence of Mr. Atkinson respecting the danger indicated by the blue cap, the latter was not known to the owner or manager. It was not reported to either of them. — Mr. Stevenson: You don't keep a report. You shut your ears and eyes, and then say that you know nothing about it. — Mr. Howson: There is a report kept. — Mr. Stevenson: There are no reports according to the Act. — The Clerk: If a certain state of things existed, it is for the manager to find out, or to show that he used reasonable precautions to find it out. — Mr. Howson then called his witnesses, as follows :— Archibald Frazer, coal-hewer, living at Lowca, said he had worked at No. 9 Pit since it was opened up. He saw no gas in the working referred to in the case, or he would not have been there. Heard no complaint of gas. — By Mr. Stevenson: I always worked with a naked light. I never used a safety lamp there. I heard talk of Davis and Kelly having their whiskers burned. — Ed. McCluskey, coal hewer, Distington, said he worked in the place where the accident took place. He never saw any gas, nor did he hear any one complain. On the 31st March the explosion did not make a great noise, and there was not much smoke of afterdamp. The men Beatty walked out. — By Mr. Stevenson: The deputy never told him of the blue cap. He never tried for gas. — Mr. Peile, mining engineer, Whitehaven, said he knew the seam in question. Having explained the object of the workings, he said the coal made very little gas. He tested it on Thursday morning last. — By the Bench: If I saw a small blue cap on the flame I should not consider it necessary to use safety lamps. I attribute the accident on the 31st March to the absence of the men from the forehead. The men may have worked a foot or two of coal, and have come upon a fissure which collected and ignited on their return from breakfast. — By the Bench: The accident could not have occurred with safety lamps. — By Mr. Howson: There were naked lights in many collieries. He would not have enforced the use of safety lamps in this case had he been the owner or manager of the mine. The ventilation of the pit was by air admitted by one shaft and let out by another, and was sufficient to render naked lights safe. — The Chairman asked if that was so how did the accident happen? — Witness explained that an accumulation might have taken place during the absence of the men. — By Mr. Howson: If the men had been working the gas would have been dissipated and an accident probably averted. — By Mr. Stevenson: When gas is heard that is a signal to provide safety lamps. Working in a new place would make him more cautious; and if in a rise he would be more cautious still. If on three occasions a blue cap were found in the current of the air he should have thought about it; but if it was close in to the coal he should not regard it as dangerous. If reports had been made to him that the cap had been seen, that explosions had taken place, and that the place was a new working, he would have been cautious. The gas would be more likely to accumulate when the men were away. He attributed the explosion to an accumulation of gas being ignited. — By the Chairman: Had there been safety lamps there would have been no danger. It was not reasonably practicable to have foreseen the danger. — The Chairman: There was a general responsibility. — Mr. Howson: But we are not bound to do except what was reasonable practicable. — Henry Woolcock, mining engineer, Whitehaven, said that No. 9 pit, which he examined on Thursday last, was properly ventilated. There was no appearance of gas; and they were not even to get a blue cap. The coal is not by any means fiery. There was nothing in the seam to necessitate safety lamps, or to lead the manager to think it was dangerous. The place was sufficiently ventilated to allow of naked lights being used without danger. — By Mr. Stephenson: If gas was only found in the corner of the working he would not consider it a necessity to use safety lamps. If deputies reported gas in quantities, he should say that safety lamps ought to be used, but if just seen in the "nicking" he should not do so. There were no means of telling when then they were coming to gas in quantity. — John Stewart Simpson, managing partner of Bain & Company, gave evidence on behalf of Ferguson. He said he did not attend personally to the colliery; he acted on the information received from his manager. Having explained the method in which the pit had been worked, he said they were connecting two shafts of the mine together. No reports had been made to him that there was any symptom of gas. Repeatedly he had spoken with the manager on the mine. He had been surprised to hear the evidence of Mr. Atkinson on the subject of the "blue cap." He would have attached little importance to the "blue cap" at the heading of the working. It only signified the want of more ventilation, but they had a fan capable of spreading 50,000 cubic feet of air, and they could pass 100,000 feet of air in the working on the morning of the accident. There was nothing to necessitate the use of locked lamps. He considered that the accident had occurred through something that could not have been foreseen before the accident occurred. — By Mr. Stevenson: He had not given Mr. Willis, the Government Inspector, notice that this place was going to be sunk. He considered it would be better that workmen should report the appearance of "blue cap." — Mr. David Ferguson, certificated manager of the Harrington Colliery (called on behalf of Mr. Simpson), stated that the colliery was principally worked with naked lights. It was the duty of the overman who inspected the mine to report in a book, and witness had examined the book daily. He daily examined the mine. Until the 31st March it had never occurred to him that it was necessary or devisable to use safety lamps. It was never suggested to him by an inspector or workman that it was necessary to use safety lamps. It was an agreement that they should work with naked lights. That seam had never made much gas from the commencement, and he did not think it ever would make much. He examined the mines with a safety lamp, using pure colza oil; but they generally mixed a little paraffin with the colza oil for the use of the workmen, and that made a little "cap" of itself. He never observed any gas, except that he knew it was bleeding a little. He did not consider a "cap" almost touching the coal at all dangerous. If there was a larger quantity of gas in the working there was an explosion. It took very little gas to a "blue cap." Neither the check-weigher nor any of the men had ever made complaints to him. He considered the ventilation quite ample for the mine. Since the accident they worked with safety lamps. — By Mr. Stevenson: Could not remember whether he had noticed the "blue cap" before the 31st of March. Incidentally Crone might have reported the "blue cap." He had a competent person to make a report every eight hours. The man was Crone. He could not read, but the rules were explained. The man did not know the mine was ventilated by a fan. Would swear that the report-book was kept before the accident. It was commenced on the 28th March — three days before. Mr. Stevenson: Can you account for these dates having been altered. — Witness: No, I can't. — Mr. Stevenson said it was a most remarkable thing. The book had only been commenced three days before, and he found that those three dates had been altered. — Crone and Moore were re-called, both stating that they knew nothing of the alterations made in the figures. — Mr. Stevenson then addressed the Court, speaking strongly on the alterations that had been made in the report book with regard to dates and times, and argued that the reason why the reports commenced on the 28th March was that warnings had been given. He severely criticised the evidence of the witness Ferguson, who considered that the "blue cap" was no sign of danger, and that the indication of the barometer was of no importance. He pointed out that every warning had been given of there being gas in the mine, that it was the duty of the manager to see his regulations were enforced, and that no reasonable means had been adopted for enforcing the carrying out of the rules. Then, as to the employing of a competent person, was Crone a competent person to make a true report? A man who could neither read nor write, and who had to trust to another to write his reports, and who knew nothing whatever about the ventilation of the mine. He might be a good hewer; no doubt he was, but was he competent for this duty? The explosion which had occurred had been described by a witness as a small affair. It was sufficiently small to burn to death two unfortunate men. It was sufficiently great that his duty was to lay the facts before the Bench, and to ask them to say there was no doubt in this case that the manager and owner had not taken all reasonable means of publishing and enforcing the rules and regulations. — The Bench then retired, and on their return into Court, the Chairman said they found the defendants guilty of a slight breach of the Act, and inflicted a penalty of 25s. in each of the four cases. — The Clerk said that would be £5.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||