5th July 1883
The Co-Operative Movement In West Cumberland
As a prelude to the opening of the Maryport Co-operative Society's new premises in Curzon Street, yesterday (Wednesday) a conference was held in the afternoon, in the hall, when a paper on the above subject was read by Mr. W. S. Harper, Whitehaven, a
member of the Northern Section of the Central Co-operative Board. A report of the proceedings at the opening will be found in another page.
Mr. Harper began his paper by stating the circumstances under which he had been requested to prepare it for the present conference, when they were met to congratulate the Maryport Society on the opening of the fine premises in which they were assembled.
It was considered that the particular subject chosen would be suitable for the occasion; that it would be appropriate to pass in review the history and vicissitudes of various Co-operative ventures in the county. He thought they would be encouraged by
the great measure of success that had attended them; while they might take heed and profit by the blundering and mismanagement that had led one or two on to ruin. The writer proceeded: "The first society in West Cumberland of which I have any
account is the old Whitehaven Co-operative Society. In his ‘History of Co-operation,' Mr. Holyoake gives the date of its formation as 1829; but I can find no trace of it previous to 1831. Co-operative societies existed at the same period in Carlisle
and Cockermouth. As to Carlisle I have no information, nor does it come within the scope of this paper; nor can I learn much as to Cockermouth. At the time the Whitehaven society was founded, a strong socialistic wave, so to speak, was passing over the
country. Mr. Holyoake speaks of it as ‘the enthusiastic period' and very enthusiastic it must have been, I am convinced, when its influence was felt so strongly as it was in Whitehaven. What the social condition of the country was then, what the hopes
and aspirations of the working man of the period, poorly paid, badly housed, and worse fed, you will find very fully and ably set out in Mr. Holyoake's most instructive and valuable work, and in ‘The Life and Times of Robert Owen,' contributed by Mr.
Lloyd Jones to the Co-operative News. I need not, therefore, deal with that phase of the movement here. There is very little doubt that the establishment of the Whitehaven Society was due to the agitation which Robert Owen set on foot. There was then
in Whitehaven a large working class population, made up in great part of weavers, ship carpenters, ropemakers, riggers, and sailors. The ropemakers deserve the credit of founding this old society. There were four roperies in the town, three of which
were situated at Corkickle; and here, during the dinner hour, it was customary to have meetings in the roadway, at which the new order of things looming up for the benefit of the everyday toiler was discussed and ventilated in all its bearings. The
principal speaker at these postprandial gatherings was a man named John Dawson, a ropemaker in Mr. Hartley's employ. Dawson was a good talker and thoroughly permeated with the Co-operative idea, he spent many hours in expounding it and labouring to show
his fellows how they might save a certain proportion of their scanty wages by doing their own trading. Dawson, I may say here, emigrated to America shortly after the store which he was mainly instrumental in founding was launched. The result of this
propaganda was that a few working men took up £1 shares and a warehouse was rented in Carter lane for the sale of grocery and provisions to the members and the general public. This was in 1831. At all events, the same warehouse (now occupied by
Messrs. W. Steele & Co.) is for the first time shown in the rate book to be in the occupation of ‘The Co-operative Society' in that year, and rated to the poor in the sum of £4 10s; and I know that this was the first place tenanted by the
society when it began business. At first the warehouse was only open for the sale of goods at nights, one or more of the members acting as countermen; but as trade improved and members increased, the services of a tailor named Isaac Thompson, who had
been a travelling Primitive Methodist or ‘Ranter' preacher, were permanently engaged. I regret that I have been unable to obtain a copy of the society's rules. A personal friend, whose father was a member of the store, told me he had a copy some years
ago; but he had lost it. I, therefore, know little authentic about the constitution of the society. But I think it likely that the profits were divided entirely on capital. A venerable friend of mine, who in a few weeks will enter on his 90th year,
was a member of the committee of management for a short time; and it is his impression that profit went to purchases as well. But I fancy this is a misapprehension on his part; though, of course, it is claimed that some of the old societies formed at
this period paid on purchases, thereby anticipating the principal feature of the modern or Rochdale system of Co-operation. That Robert Owen's views were looked upon with favour by the founders of the Carter lane store is shown by the fact that his
‘five fundamental facts' and his ‘twenty laws of human nature' were conspicuously hung up in the shop for the edification of the customers. The society dealt on the ready money system, and did a comparatively large trade outside its own members, its
goods being of the best quality obtainable, and sold at a fair price. The store remained in Carter lane till 1833, when I find that it removed to a shop (now Nos. 26 and 27) in New street, which must have been of much humbler pretensions, as it was only
rated at 30s a year. ‘R Whitlock' was then the occupier and manager. The fact is, the society had fallen on evil days. On a certain night, prior to removal, one of the old Charlies of the period who watched over slumbering Whitehaven, saw three men
running out of the Carter lane warehouse, as if they had been disturbed in the business of burglary. He reported what he had seen to the society and a general meeting of the members was called to consider the matter. It was obvious that the store had
been entered for the purpose of robbery and this strengthened a suspicion that had prevailed for some time that the goods were being systematically stolen at nights. No trace of the three thieves was left, save a high crowned hat, dropped in the hurry
of flight, and obviously made for a pretty big head. Such a head had a weaver named Henry Gallagher, living in Peter street; and at the meeting in question, when the hat had been passed round a number of the members, and found to be several sizes too
large for them, it was dropped on Gallagher's cranium, and fitting exactly, with one accord it was said, or at least thought, ‘Thou art the man.' Another weaver, named Daniel Downes, recognised the hat as being actually Gallagher's and boldly said ‘It's
thy hat, Harry.' But nothing could be done to Gallagher Canmore or Gallagher Bighead, even had the proof been much clearer than it was; and he shortly afterwards left the town scatheless. As Mr. Holyoake explains, the law at that time regarded a member
of a store as a partner, who might, as such, appropriate the funds or the goods to his own use. It enabled a thief to plead that, being a member of the society, he only robbed himself, although he stole the property of every member as well. Had the
fellow been prosecuted, all might have been well. But as it was the members grew distrustful of each other and withdrew both their capital and their custom; and after languishing for a while in the New street premises, the society went spark out, in
1835 or 1836, under the management of a working shoemaker named Daniel Gray. I believe all the members received their capital back and that every account was paid — a satisfactory wind up, due to the healthy ready money system which the society
adopted from the first". The writer described the persecution and outrage to which the followers of Owen were subject at that date in Whitehaven, and their inability to obtain redress at law, as exemplified on one occasion by the wrecking of their
meeting and reading room in Michael street by a gang of religious fanatics. Mr. Holyoake, in his work alluded to above, had much the same thing to tell. He says:— "In some towns a desolate theatre was the only place that could be obtained,
and it was sometimes necessary, as in Whitehaven when the present writer lectured there, to fortify it the day before the lecture, and to select as a sort of bodyguard to the lecturer, those converts to the new views who had the thickest heads (there
were said to be a good many of them), in the event of bludgeons being employed, and, as an audience would threaten to assemble with stones in their pockets. I left my friends in the wings, and presented myself on the platform alone, judging that only
good marksmen would be able to hit a single target."
Mr. Harper proceeded:— "The next attempt at Co-operative trading in Whitehaven was in 1858. On the 20th of March in that year a store, ostensibly on the Rochdale system, was opened in Tangier street. I say ostensibly; for, so far as I have
been able to learn, the manager, a person named Tait, combined the functions also of secretary, treasurer, buyer, and shopman; and for all practical purposes, was committee to boot. He lived on the premises, and was left to manage the business exactly
as he thought fit. I remember the store very well, being a member of a reading room held in a sort of parlour behind the shop, through which members had to pass; but at that time I had not advanced sufficiently on life's journey to take much interest in
Co-operative distribution. I read in The Whitehaven News of that date that a tea meeting of the members of the store was held in the Temperance Hall, Senhouse Street (a building, by the way, now turned, oddly enough, into a bouded warehouse for
spirits), on the 3rd January 1859. From a report read at the meeting, it appeared that the society numbered 53 members, and that from its establishment (a little over nine months) the gross receipts amounted to £726 8s 9¾d — not a very
large amount, certainly. The profits were not given; but I fancy they would not amount to a great deal. The shares were stated to be £1 each, payable in fortnightly instalments of 2s 6d each, 5 per cent. per annum being given on capital. The
profits were paid on purchases every six months. There were 100 persons at tea; and I read that the Hensingham Brass Band (several of whom are members) was in attendance, and performed at intervals in a style that reflected the greatest credit on
themselves and the gentleman by whom they have been trained. This gifted trainer, I fancy, was a certain corpulent drum major of militia with whom I was acquainted. In fact, it must have been, for a tea fight, quite a jovial affair; for it is added
that the ‘meeting reluctantly separated a little after ten o'clock, with general expressions of hope that such re-unions might be often repeated'. We can't get co-operators up to this pitch of enthusiasm in Whitehaven now; they have generally had enough
of the best entertainment possible ere ten o'clock arrives. I don't think there was another re-union, however, though the society lasted a year or two after this. The members became dissatisfied with the quality of the goods sold, and with the
irresponsible mode of conducting business into which the society drifted from the outset. Credit, I believe, was given; certainly it was taken from local tradesmen. At last the crash came, and the society came down, owing £200 or £300,
principally to the class just named. These, in turn, looked to the most ‘solid' of the membership for payment; and a few writs dropped into one or two quiet households in Whitehaven created no little consternation. One old member told me he was served
with one for £200. The active buying members were not a large body at the time of the collapse; and others found to their dismay that though they had practically cut their connection with the society, they had not formally withdrawn from it, and
were liable (it was in pre — limited liability days) for the whole of the debts. A stormy meeting was held; but eventually the creditors accepted a composition and the members able to pay got matters smoothed over at the cost of a few pounds each.
The third society established in Whitehaven is doing well and is likely to do better. Its history is very much that of other societies. It was begun in 1875 by a few working men and a small shop in George street was first rented. Business increased
here rapidly and in 1879 the committee found it necessary to look out for and secure larger premises. A block of freehold property in Duke Street was bought in private, and adapted as a store at a cost of something over £1,400. At the date of the
last balance sheet (March 27) the building had been depreciated by £71. A few months ago the society made another advantageous purchase of freehold property alongside and with more members it is now in a position to do a large business in various
branches of trade. The premises are perhaps in the best part of Whitehaven for a Co-operative store; and there is a prospect of their value being enhanced rather than depreciated, as it is now and has been for a number of years back, impossible to buy
land on a freehold tenure from the Lord of the Manor. Like many other societies, that of Whitehaven has had its vicissitudes. It would not have been a legitimate Whitehaven institution if it had not. All novelties go off with a rush there, as a rule
— whether it be Good Templarism, Blue Ribbonism, Revivalism, or the opening of a new ‘tea and toys' or American ham and beef shop. But public interest dies out ere long; and unless considerable perseverance and endurance be shown, the ‘ism,'
whatever it may be, will come to grief. The Whitehaven Co-operative Society has passed through that experience, but it has gained its second wind, so to speak, and I have now no fears for the future. In one quarter the sales reached £1,565; and
two years and a half afterwards the quarterly takings were as low as £787, or little more than half. The membership in 1879 stood at 274; in 1881 it dropped to 179. The society has paid 2s 6d in the pound on purchases and the dividend has fallen
to 1s 3d. With the adoption of the leakage system, and steady purchasing from the Wholesale, it has now been found that a uniform dividend can be paid of 2s in the pound (as much as I personally think any society should pay), and yet keep a good balance
back for a variety of purposes. The present membership is close on 200, and the last quarter's sales were only £932 — a small ‘basket power,' but one, I'm glad to say, that is increasing. The share capital amounts to £632 and the loan
capital to £1,500". A small store started at Hensingham in 1865 and which lasted three years, was next briefly sketched. It was never very successful, but it paid its way, and eventually wound up honourably, that the members might join the
Cleator Moor Society, which has now a flourishing branch in the village. The next society dealt with was Egremont, which dates from 1859. The first meeting was held at the Horse and Groom Inn, when eleven members clubbed up £7, and began business
in a public house stable, with a bag of flour. The writer proceeded:— "One of the members carefully took the society's stock-in trade up the ladder on his back, and set it down quite as carefully, he thought, on the loft. But the flooring
couldn't stand such a sudden accession of wealth and weight; it collapsed, bringing the sack down with a run into the premises below, and wasting one half of its contents. Clearly this wouldn't do; so the rickety loft was abandoned, and the society
migrated with what was left of the flour to an old smiddy belonging to a third public house, and which was popularly supposed to have been a smiddy since the days of Tubal Cain. The disused smith's hearth was fitted up as a counter, the beam and scales
being attached by a rope to a rafter overhead. As much as what was left of the £7 would allow was laid out in groceries. A box of oranges was added; the fruit was taken out, and the box utilised as a seat by the committee, who lovingly took turn
about in sitting and standing. After staying here a year or two the society shifted its quarters again, finding a resting place this time in a small shop in the Main street, also public house property. Things went badly with the society here. They got
into debt to two millers to the tune of £80, and being in debt and under an obligation; things were made worse by the inferior character of the flour supplied. There was naturally much grumbling at this. Members lost confidence, and left the
society; there was a general run upon the capital; and the certain ruin of the concern was confidently predicted. But there were one or two of the right sort in the society who were determined it should not go to the wall if they could help it; and
manfully they stuck to the ship. One of this limited number who had the root of the matter in him, performed a feat one Saturday afternoon, which savoured of the skilful contrivances of old Caleb Balderston, in ‘The Bride of Lammermoor,' to keep up the
honour and dignity of his master's house. A travelling grocer landed from Whitehaven with a claim against the society of £6 for good supplied. The chairman and treasurer were in a state of perturbation. There was nothing in the bank, of course,
and the merest glance at the store till sufficed to show that only 10s was available to meet the wholesale man's claim of £6. In despair the chairman rushed to the door, when lo! Coming deliberately up the street, he beheld a member — what a
pearl of great price he must have been to the early Egremont co-operators! — who was in the habit of spending no less than £3 a week in the store — the only man, by the way, who had that honourable distinction. He was then bearing down
on the store with his £3.
To collar him, to drag him into the King's Arms and administer a friendly pint of ale on the spot (they are an older body at Egremont than the Blue Ribandists are the ale drinkers), to hurriedly explain the crisis that had arisen in the society's
affairs, and to urge that not only that particular £3, but £3 more, was necessary to save the society's credit, was the excited work of a few moments. The big purchaser on whom the society's hopes depended lent an attentive ear, approved of
the spirited foreign policy recommended, finished his pint and going off in a bee-line to the store, tabled £6 for groceries past and prospective. The treasurer at once impounded the money, and sallying back to the King's Arms, where the traveller
was located, he paid over the amount of the bill with the nonchalance of a man to whom such settlements were an every day occurrence, at the same time inquiring with a business air if the traveller had any further claims against the society. The grocer
said he hadn't. He had heard, he said, that the society was bankrupt, but it was obvious, on the contrary, they were doing well; and as they were thus promptly meeting their payments, he would be glad to supply them with all they wanted. So that little
difficulty was tided over. After two or three years' stay, the society removed again to bigger premises on the other side of the street, still struggling and fighting for existence. Once over it was £140 in debt, with all its share capital sunk.
The members, at a noisy meeting, demanded their money back; but no money could be had, and it was taken out in abuse. Then it was proposed to break up the society, as it stood; but one old and staunch supporter declaimed earnestly against this. If it
were done, he said, so long as he and those who were associated with him lived in Egremont, they would have the finger of scorn pointed at them, with the remark, ‘There go the shopkeepers!' So they stuck to the society and by dint of perseverance and
unremitting exertion, such is the force of enthusiasm and honesty of purpose, they persuaded a considerable number to join a concern that was, and was known to be, practically insolvent. The next trouble was the doubling of the rent of the shop —
from 17 to 34 guineas — on its becoming known that the society purposed building premises of its own. This extortion they submitted to for a year and a half. Sir Robert Brisco, Bart, of Crofton Hall, was then a large employer of labour and an
active public man in Egremont, and indeed in West Cumberland; and the early co-operators speak gratefully of the encouragement he and his son gave them. Both bought largely at the store, though they were never, I believe, members; and Sir Robert sold
the society five cottages in the Main street at a comparatively low figure. But for that action, the society could not have obtained a shop in Egremont. On the site the present premises are built; and now, its troubles over, the society is flourishing,
and likely to flourish. It has 766 members, a share capital of nearly £7,000; and the cash sales for the past quarter were £5,745." The writer made a few remarks on the credit system, which prevailed at Egremont, and which he thought
might be modified somewhat, in accordance with suggestions made at a previous conference. The origin and progress of the Aspatria Society was next briefly sketched. It was founded in 1865 mainly by quarrymen employed in the district, a room in a
thatched cottage being the first scene of operations, with a young woman as shopkeeper. The net result of the first years' business was as follows:— Membership, 43; Capital, £30 1s 1½ d; Receipts, £358 14s 2#189; d; Profit,
£3 10¾d.
The society progressed rapidly, however, a good patron being the late Sir Wilfred Lawson. This society, unlike many others, does well in the butcher meat department; last year the receipts for meat alone were £2,247 15s. The society has 534
members, and a share capital of £4,396; and the buildings, for which the members found all the money, are valued at £1,483. The total receipts on all accounts for the year ending March last were £10,901; and the average dividend since
the society began has been 2s 2d in the pound. The Aspatria Agricultural Co-operative Society was also reviewed. It has been founded 13 years; and with a share capital of only £1,633, the total sales last year amounted to £15,599 — a
very large turn over for so small a capital. The society supplies its members with manures, feeding stuffs, seeds, implements, &c. It was noted as a remarkable fact that in a small township of under 1,900 of a population, two co-operative societies
had in a year sold over £26,500 worth of goods. Mr. William Lawson's experiment in farming at Blennerbasset from 1860 to 1870 was also noticed. The Workington Society, founded in 1865, had a few remarks devoted to it. The writer thought,
however, it was not exerting itself as it might to take a better hold of the town, as was evinced by the huge array of shops that were being run up, especially at the low end of the town. A few statistics bearing on the society's progress were given;
and the writer suggested one or two little matters, which it would be to the interests of the members to attend to. The following sketch was next given of the Cleator Moor Society:— "The Cleator Moor Society is by far the largest we have in
either Cumberland or Westmorland, Carlisle standing next. It was begun in 1858 and may be said to have been founded at the bottom of a pit — the Cleator Iron Ore Company's No. 2. The first meeting was held, not in a public house, as at Egremont,
but behind a dyke; and the society started with 20 members and a share capital of £28. There was some difficulty in procuring the conventional cottage to begin business. Cleator Moor was then little more than its name denotes, as I very well
remember; cottages were few and far between; and their owners had small faith in a squad of ‘red men' successfully keeping shop. One land and mine owner, a doubting Thomas, on being applied to, refused to let the co-operators have one of his workmen's
dwellings, which was then empty; but luckily another local magnate, Mr. John Stirling, who is and always has been very popular on the Moor from his liberality and consideration, came to the rescue and let them a cottage. At first and for two years
afterwards, business was conducted on the old and exploded system of paying dividend on share capital only. To the Cleator Moor co-operator of that particular school, the capitalist was everybody, and the mere purchaser must keep to the outer court of
the synagogue. As a matter of fact, however, there was no dividend to pay; and whether owing to this circumstances or not, it is certain that two years after the society was started, the accepted Rochdale system of co-operation was adopted. The society
then went forward. Cleator Moor was rapidly growing in population; and the store and its business grew steadily with it. It is always easier for a store to make progress in a rising village than in an old established town, where a large percentage of
the tradesmen almost inherit their respective businesses. Capital increased, land was bought for a large store, and after five or six years' life in a cottage, the society entered on its own property. The first branch store was opened at Frizington in
1867 or 1868; and now the society has no less than 15 of these branches scattered over a large district, and is now doing a quarterly business of well on to £35,000. In 1873 it opened a large and handsome drapery store and hall nearly opposite the
central premises. In 1871 the society rented a flourmill, driven by water, at Wath, with 20 acres of land attached. The mill turned out between 150 and 160 bags per week, working day and night. In October last, the society opened a large, well-fitted
steam flourmill of its own on the Moor, which had been built at a cost of about £8,000. Taking last quarter's business as a guide, this mill is paying about 10 per cent per annum; and after being charged with rent, depreciation, &c., it is
expected it will clear itself in about twelve years. The flour is giving every satisfaction to the membership; and it is claimed for it that it is equal to anything turned out at the same figure by any mill in the county. The Cleator Moor Society's
members manage to consume 300 bags of flour per week, and the mill is capable of turning out between 500 and 600. Last year the society successfully tendered for a farm of 60 acres close to their central store. The land is used for grazing and dairy
purposes; and butter, eggs, milk, and bacon are produced on a comparatively small scale and find a ready market amongst the members. This question of farming is one that is destined ere long to have more consideration from co-operative societies than it
has yet received. There is a good deal of nonsense talked about ‘the land for the people'; but, on the other hand, I believe it is quite practicable for a co-operative society of say 500 members to dabble a little in farming, with profit. So far as I
know, the Cleator Moor Society is the only one in the two northern counties that has tried the experiment; and with it it has been a success, as it was almost a necessity. A year or two ago the Aspatria Society made a bold bid for an adjacent farm; it
was not taken, but from what I know of co-operators in that village, I am perfectly satisfied that if their tender had been accepted, they would have made the land pay them. Why, indeed, should it not pay co-operators as well as it does farmers? For
that it does pay farmers is evident from what we see around us, and the brisk competition that ensues whenever a farm comes into the market. This society at Cleator Moor, started at the bottom of an ore pit, now owns fully £20,000 worth of
property, and a share capital of over £50,000. It is not, however, a model institution, from the co-operative point of view. It jogs along with no attempt to tone down a credit system that shows at the end of each quarter that members owe over
£7,000 to the society. The society belongs neither to the Central Board nor yet to the Co-operative Wholesale; and therefore is not the power for influencing this district in the movement that it ought to be and should be. Last quarter, of a sum
of over £30,000, only £2,117 17s 4d was spent with the Wholesale. It is incredible; it is more, it is incomprehensible. However, it is just to state that of late signs have not been wanting that the ‘Moor,' as we call it in our part of the
world, is beginning to see the error of its ways". Two failures, those of Parton and Cockermouth, were alluded to. The Parton Society was started about 20 years ago, with some help from Cleator Moor; and ten years or so afterwards a large store
and hall were built in the village. Two years subsequent to this, however, dissensions cropped up amongst the members, share capital was demanded back, and as it could not be had, a run was made on the store for goods; and the society drifted from bad
to worse. Finally the bank foreclosed a mortgage it had on the buildings; and they were put up for sale. The last balance sheet issued, to the close of 1879, showed that the members were in debt to the store to the tune of £123 odd. The share
capital was given at £902, the goods on hand at £159, the buildings and fixtures were valued at £1,546 and £745 10s 1d was owing to the bank. In August of last year, Mr. J. Baird, of the Lonsdale Ironworks (a large shareholder in
the society, and a good friend to the co-operative movement), in his capacity of liquidator, advertised that he was open to receive offers for the society's book debts, amounting to £92 13s. As to Cockermouth, the writer stated that he had little
or no information to give. There seemed to be an indisposition on the part of those who had been officially connected with it to say much about it, and to treat its affairs as only privately affecting the members. The writer contended that this was a
mistake; that tactics of this kind had no place in the co-operative movement, which courted and gloried in publicity; and that wisdom was to be learnt by failure. An ex-official of the Cockermouth Society had told him that a co-operative society was
like a family circle, and that what took place in the family circle concerned only the family. He (the writer) didn't know whether a co-operative society would ever again be started at Cockermouth, but if so, he hoped it would take in not only as much
of the town as possible, but the Central Board, the big Wholesale, the Co-operative News and the noble army of co-operators all over the world. Let it be one of the biggest things in family circles on record. He only knew that the Cockermouth society
went on the rocks, as others had done before and since, owing to bad management and credit. "It went out from amongst us because it was not of us."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Baird, J. | | | |
| Brisco, Robert, Sir | | | |
| Dawson, John | | Ropemaker | |
| Downes, Daniel | | | |
| Gallagher, Henry | | | |
| Gray, Daniel | | Shoemaker | |
| Harper, W. S. | | | |
| Hartley, — | | | |
| Holyoake, — | | | |
| Jones, Lloyd | | | |
| Lawson, Wilfred, Sir | | | |
| Owen, Robert | | | |
| Steele, W. | | | |
| Stirling, John | | | |
| Whitlock, R. | | | |