Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

22nd March 1883

The Claim By the Maryport Hematite Iron Company's Miners

At the Whitehaven Police Court, on Thursday, before H. H. Watson, Esq. (in the chair), and a bench of magistrates, the wages claims brought by a number of miners formerly in the employ of the Maryport Hematite Iron Company, were again gone into. — Mr. Atter was for complainants, and Mr. Webster for defendants. — Mr. Webster, when the case was called, said he took it that what was now wanted was the production of proof that the company had liquidated; and he produced and read a document from the London Bankruptcy Court to show that this had been done. — Mr. Atter said this was put in as a defence. The first cases had been before the Bench, and he would now take their ruling as to whether the company was liable or not. — Mr. Brockbank said that had been discussed pretty fully before, and the magistrates had decided that nothing more was required beyond the production of the document just read. The company were not liable for the claims made. — Mr. Atter: In that case we will take the cases against the trustees. — The following are the names of the miners who brought the claims against the trustees, "W. B. Peat and another," as they stood on the charge sheet:- Richard Burns, Thomas Burns, Edward Barratt, Robert Brown, Patrick Morgan, Richard Lowery, John Merrigan, Patrick Curran, Richard Daley, Edward Moran, Patrick Gunn, Patrick Maloy, John Berry, and William Williamson. — The test cases taken were those of John Merrigan, and Patrick Curran. — Mr. Atter, in stating the case, said the two complainants sought to recover £4 16s, for a fortnight's wages in lieu of notice. The men were engaged by the Maryport Hematite Company, and one of the rules of the company, which was posted up at the pit, was to the effect that miners and other underground workmen were employed from fortnight to fortnight, and subject to a fortnight's notice. The men were paid on the 27th January. On the 25th of that month trustees in bankruptcy were appointed. On the 27th of January, a notice, which, he contended was a trustee's notice, was posted, signed by "W. Brown," who acted for the company at the works, to the effect that all men working at Robin Benn and Fletcher pits were clear of the company's employ fourteen days from date. On the 29th, on the Monday, the men went to their work as usual; but they were prevented from working, they had not been allowed to work since the 27th of January. It was in respect of this that the men now sued under the special rule of the company, viz., that all contracts made with the company were from fortnight to fortnight. He (Mr. Atter) thought there could be no question that if the men had left their work without notice they would have been liable to have been brought before the Court under the same rule. On the other hand, the men being willing to work, and not being allowed to work, they were entitled to come here and claim a fortnight's wages in lieu of notice. — Peter Curran then gave evidence in support of Mr. Atter's statement as to the wages claimed, and the posting of the notice signed by the manager; and he stated that on Monday, the 29th, he was lowered down the pit by the engineman, and was about to begin working when he was told that the pit had stopped. He worked on the 26th, and up to Saturday, the 27th. — Cross-examined by Mr. Webster, Curran said that the wages they earned depended upon the quantity of ore they got, and it varied every fortnight. Nothing was kept off them on the 27th of January except the metal that was in the pit, and which had been paid for since. — The other complainant also gave evidence. — Mr. Atter put in the appointment of the trustees on the 25th of January. There was, he said, work for two days afterwards, up to the 27th. No notice was given by a proper authority; and he considered the trustees adopted the contract of the company — Mr. Webster said he would now raise the objection on the 31st section of the Bankruptcy Act, 1869, which provides with respect to certain unliquidated damages, that they can only be dealt with in a certain way. The Bench had held that the bankrupts were not responsible, and now it was brought as a debt against the trustees. But he (Mr. Webster) held that they were not responsible either, for if it was a sum of unliquidated demand from the bankrupt's estate, that would have to be dealt with under another section, which he read. It was entirely problematic whether the men where entitled to anything at all under the circumstances. He did not know what position the trustees of the estate might be in, but it was quite possible they would not have anything to pay the men. He was instructed that the whole of the estate of the company was under mortgage to some person, and it might be that the trustees had not means to pay the men; but they ought to have had the means of ascertaining the amount of this debt or liability before proceedings had been taken in court. He submitted that Mr. Atter was premature, and not entitled to take these proceedings. It was an unliquidated demand, and they had not put in their proof. The file of proceedings did not show that the men had proved as against the estate. Whether the trustees might think that the men were entitled to something or not was another matter; but he must submit that the trustees were the persons to consider the point, and not this Court. — Mr. Atter said the men were not bound to go under the Bankruptcy Act. The claim was not made under bankruptcy, but under the Employers' and Workmen Act, which provided that in a dispute the men could come before their Worships, who could adjudicate. It was as if there had been no bankruptcy. — Mr. Webster said he was prepared to recommend the trustees to further consider the case of the men. They had done so already, and they had paid them all the money they had earned in respect of ore lying in the pit. He (Mr. Webster) would also advise the trustees that they should give the men something in respect of this loss. — Mr. Atter objected to such a settlement of the question; and Mr. Webster remarked that if Mr. Atter was putting it legally, he would withdraw what he had said. — Mr. Brockbank said it was a case of extreme difficulty. It was a question whether Mr. Brown, having paid the men after the appointment of trustees on the 25th of January, and having put up his notice on the 27th of January, did not really make a new contract for the next 14 days by putting up a notice stating that the men would be clear of the company at the end of that time. After that, to put it the other way, supposing they had wished to carry on the pit, and these men had chosen to absent themselves without notice, would they not have been liable to be brought up here for breach of their contract? — The Chairman: And possibly they would have been brought up. — Mr. Webster: But my clients did not make the new contract. — Mr. Brockbank: If their agents did that is the same. — After further discussion, Mr. Brockbank said if Mr. Brown had not stuck up this notice the men might have had no remedy. He thought it was a case for a compromise. — Mr. Webster renewed his offer as to advising the trustees to consider the men's claim in an equitable spirit. — Mr. J. R. Bain wished to know who authorised Mr. Brown to put up this notice; but the question was not specifically answered, Mr. Webster stating that the trustees never entered into any bargain with the men to give them a fortnight's notice. — Mr. Brockbank (to the solicitors): You two gentlemen should put your heads together. It is essentially a case for a compromise. — Mr. Webster said the trustees would treat the men in a proper manner. He would undertake to put himself in consultation with them, and let Mr. Atter know, and if what was decided upon was not satisfactory, then he (Mr. Atter) could take their worships' decision. — Mr. Brockbank: Pay a week's wages and the costs. — Mr. Webster: What are the costs? — Mr. Brockbank: They are only small. — Mr. Webster: I will certainly advise them to do that. But I must get their authority. — Mr. Atter said that without seeing his clients he would agree to that. — After some further conversation it was agreed that Mr. Brockbank's suggestion should be accepted, the wages to be paid on an average of the two fortnight's preceeding the closing of the pit.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, —    Solicitor  
Bain, J. R.      
Barrat, Edward    Miner  
Berry, John    Miner  
Brockbank, —    Clerk  
Brown, Robert    Miner  
Brown, W.      
Burns, Richard    Miner  
Burns, Thomas    Miner  
Curran, Patrick    Miner  
Daley, Richard    Miner  
Gunn, Patrick    Miner  
Lowery, Richard    Miner  
Maloy, Patrick    Miner  
Merrigan, John    Miner  
Moran, Edward    Miner  
Morgan, Patrick    Miner  
Peat, William Barclay    Trustee  
Watson, H. H.    Magistrate  
Webster, —    Solicitor  
Williamson, William    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Fletcher Pit (Iron Ore)  Fletcher Pit (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print