|
22nd February 1883 Claim For Wages Against the Maryport Hematite Iron Ore CompanyAt the Whitehaven Petty Sessions on Monday (before H. Jefferson and J. R. Bain, Esqs.), the Maryport Hematite Iron Company were summoned on five information's by workmen for wages due. The first case called was that of Richard Burns, Thomas Burns, and Edward Barrett against the company. -Mr. Atter appeared for the complaints, and said the summons was taken out under the Master and workman's Act, to recover wages in lieu of notice. It would be a very simple case indeed it were not that company had had a great number of these claims and had refused to pay the workmen. There were a great number of cases, therefore, that would in a great measure have to depend upon the decision of their worships. In this case the men were workmen employed for the Maryport Hematite Company, at their mine at Moor Row. Under the rules of which contracts made with underground workmen (which they were) were stated to be "from fortnight to fortnight." The plaintiffs worked up to the 27th January, and upon that day notice was posted:— "All men working in Robin Ben and Fletcher Pits are quit of the company's employment 14 days from this date, 27th January. W. Brown." The W. Brown was the overman or manager for the company at the Moor Row Works. On the Monday Following, the plantiffs in this case, along with others; went to the works and was instructed that they were not allowed to work, and had not been allowed since. This case differed from the others. The company kept a week's "lying-on money," and in this case the men had been paid for the metal they had in the pit, after they had consulted him, and he had sent a letter with respect to it. In the other cases the men sued for the metal they had in the pit. The complainants in this case calmed two weeks wages in lieu of notice — for Richard Burns, 20s a week £2; the like for Thomas Burns, £2. They also clamed 15s a week for Edward Barrett, but that he believes Edward Barrett did not intend to support, and that would be struck out. — P.C Booth was called to prove the service of the summons, and Mr. Webster thereupon made the objection that this company ceased to exist after the first meeting at Carlisle, on the 16th January, when the creditors agreed to liquidate the affairs of the company, and a trustee was appointed. That he submitted was an end of the matter. — Mr. Atter sought to show no dissolution of a contract took place through bankruptcy, and this point was argued, but Mr. Brockbank (the justices clerk) was against Mr. Atter, although he thought there was a right of claim against the trustees. — Mr. Atter said the trustees were carrying on the business under the head of the Maryport Hematite Iron Company, and he would ask the magistrates to add the name of the trustee to the summons. — Mr.Webster said there was no such power to amend — Mr. Brockbank said the power to amend was in case of misnomer, which meant that if they summoned John Smith and he turned out to be named Thomas Smith, but was the same person. That was merely to prevent a mistake in a man's name. They could not add the name of the trustee, because he would have a right to be here and defend the case. — Mr. Atter said he must then call upon Mr. Webster to prove that the company had been in bankruptcy. — Mr. Webster: It is within the knowledge of the Court: — Mr. Atter: No it is not. — Mr. Webster: I shall call Mr. Bain, to answer any question. — Mr. Brockbank asked whether it would not be better for Mr. Atter to ask for an adjournment, and see if he could not get something out of the trustee. Supposing he got an order against the present defendants, what would be the use of it against the Maryport Company, who had not anything? — Mr. Atter said he would be satisfied with the order. — Mr. Webster: You cant take the property in the trustee's hands. — Mr. Atter: I shall run the risk of that of that. I want the magistrates now to hear my case for these men. — Mr. Webster then, to save the time of the Court, objected that the particulars gave no dates to show whether this claim was before the bankruptcy or after. He presumed it was after the bankruptcy, and, therefore, they were not entitled to claim. — Mr. Brockbank said the particulars were certainly very vague, because this might have occurred ten years ago for anything that appeared upon the particulars. But evidence would be given as to the time. — Mr. Atter: If Mr. Webster: will communicate with the trustee I will agree to adjourn for a fortnight. — Mr. Webster: I have no instructions in the matter; you must take your own course. — Mr. Brockbank: I am very strongly myself of that opinion — that the trustee should be approached, and I think (to Mr. Atter) you are the person to do it that. — Mr. Atter: I don't know, as a legal matter, that they are in liquidation. -The Chairman: It is a notorious fact. — Mr. Atter: Yes: but we don't accept facts unless they are proved. — Mr. Webster: I have only had instructions this morning. If you have a mind to communicate with me I will forward your letter to the proper quarter. I believe that these proceedings are proceedings that are taken for the recovery of money that may be due from some other person, but cannot be due from the Maryport Hematite Iron Company. That is what will be my connection eventually. — Mr. Atter pressed the magistrates to hear his case, and called evidence. — Richard Burns said he had worked for the Maryport Company for five years as a miner. He worked with his son and Edward Barrett. He could not dismiss them, nor could they dismiss him: the undergaffer had to do it. He worked up to the 27th January. He then left metal in the pit. Was not allowed to start on Monday, the 29th; he was stopped by Mathew Barlow. He had not any received notice. Should have received 14 days' notice. Received some money for the metal left in the pit, after Mr. Atter had written to the company. — Thomas Burns produced the rules showing that contracts with underground workmen shall be from fortnight to fortnight and the notice posted by Mr. Brown dismissing the workmen. They received no money in lieu of notice. — Mr. Webster renewed his objection as to the date at which the alleged breach of contract took place. If it took place after the 16th January, then he submitted that the proceedings should have been taken against the trustees of the estate; if before, they should be as against the bankrupts. As regarded the trustees he had to state that they had not taken possession of this particular pit in which these persons worked. Shortly after the appointment as trustees, before they got any notice from the owners of the pit, they declared their intention not to take over those pits. Whether they might be responsible in consequence of permitting these to work after they became trustees was another question, which would have to be determined in some other way than this. Supposing the magistrates came to the conclusion that these proceedings had been rightly taken as against the Maryport Hematite Iron Company, what would be the affect of their order? The only persons they had a remedy against were the partners, and who they might be would have to be found out. The complainants could not come against the trustees, inasmuch as they had no notice of these proceedings. If strict proof of the bankruptcy was required they would have some one from London to produce the file. — Mr. Brockbank said the view he took of the law was assuming there was a bankruptcy, ant the bankruptcy would date from the appointment of a trustee, then these proceedings as against the present defendants could not be well founded; because supposing it was a mere breach of contract, the 31st section of the new Act would meet the point, and the claim was a debt which must be proved before the trustee. A debit claimed as against the bankrupt's estate, he took it, the present defendants could not be responsible for. No proceedings should be taken against the bankrupts for any claim subsequent to the bankruptcy for which they might have been liable before the bankruptcy. He would advise the magistrates that in the present proceedings there was no claim against the bankrupts. The complainants had a claim, and it ought to be paid, but the question was by whom and he thought it should be met by the estate. — Mr. Atter then pressed for strict proof of the bankruptcy, and after some further legal parrying, the case was adjourned for a fortnight that Mr. Webster might prove the bankruptcy.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||