Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

21st December 1882

Employers' Liability Act

Casson v. Bain

This was an action brought under the Employers' Liability Act by a widow of a miner in the employ of Messrs. Bain, for £184, as compensation for the death of her husband occasioned by an accident while he was at work. — Mr. Whiteside appeared for the plaintiff and Mr. T. Brockbank for the defence. — Mr. Brockbank urged as a preliminary objection that as the amount was above £50 it was beyond the jurisdiction of the Court, basing the objection on the interpretation put upon the Employers' Liability Act by another judge of County Courts in a recently published work. — His Honour made a note of the objection, but said he was confident there was nothing in it. — The plaintiff, Phillis Casson, said she was a widow, and resided at Egremont. Her husband, who worked in Woodend Pit, the property of the defendants, was a sober man and was aged 31years, and his average earnings per week were 24s, and she was entirely dependent on him for support. — Mr. John Dixon, C.E., Whitehaven, was then called and from his evidence and from the tenor of his examination it appeared that at the defendants iron ore pit where the accident occurred there was a working shaft and a disused shaft, and over the disused shaft was a pulley on which a chain was suspended, one end of the chain having a 27lb iron weight attached to it, and the other a wire which passed down the centre of the disused shaft and so to the "sump," where a float on the water completed the arrangement so as to indicate by the position of the weight at the pit top what was the height of water at the bottom. This was for the information of the engineman, so that he might not be pumping when it was not required, and on the other hand might not allow water to accumulate and let down the cage with men in it into the water. The accident by which the deceased met his death occurred through the chain which ran on the pulley at the pit top breaking and the weight falling to the bottom of the working shaft (having hit the boarding of the disused shaft and rebounded) and smashing plaintiff's skull. The material part of the witness's evidence was that the pulley and chain was exposed to the influence of the weather, and that they were not in a proper position as regards the safety of the men. The weight should have been carried over another pulley into the engine-house, and should not have been hanging over the shaft at all. It would have served its purpose in the engine-house equally well. He did not consider it was for the information of the men themselves, but for the engineman — it was to keep the pump man right, so that he might not be working on air. — Mr. T. Brockbank commenced a cross-examination with a view to establishing a theory that that the deceased was taking a long piece of timber out of the cage at the bottom into an "eye," and that this timber had been thrust against the wire in the disused shaft and had caused the weight at the pit top to be jerked and so snapped the chain; and further that it was not necessary nor proper, but against the rules, for deceased to have got on to the cage when he was discharging timber, and that he did this and so incurred the loss of his life, which would not have happened had he kept in the "eye" and done his work. — His Honour: And the chain was not strong enough to bear the jerk? — Mr. Whiteside: That is it, your Honour. If they are able to establish that it was, I am out of court. — Mr. Dixon examined the chain produced in court, and showed to His Honour that the links were very much rusted. — His Honour: They are actually so much rusted that they are, some of them, fast together. — Mr. Dixon said he did not think that chain was a sufficiently strong chain to have hanging over a shaft, exposed to the weather. — James Garnet said he was working at the pit top at the time of the accident. Deceased was at the bottom, and some wood had gone down in the cage, which he was to take out. The timber was nine or ten feet long. He saw the weights at the pit top fall shortly after the timber went down. It went suddenly up to the pulley and then fell. There was a piece of chain attached to the weight when it fell. It struck a portion of the shaft that was boarded, and then bounced off and went down the shaft. He considered that the weight should be in the position it was, so that every man could see it. He, himself, looked at it every day, to see if it was working right, but he never examined the chain closely, as it was high above his head. He thought it was quite safe, and would have worked underneath it if nobody touched it. — Edward Tyson was the last witness, and gave similar evidence. — Michael Flinn was with the deceased working at the bottom of the shaft. Deceased was shoving a piece of timber out of the cage when the weight fell and struck him. He had got the timber partly out of the cage when he was struck by the weight. Casson was in the cage at the time, and as the top of the cage had to be taken off when timber was being taken down, there was no protection. He could have got the timber out without coming out of the "eye" of the pit, and without getting on to the cage. — Isaac Pattinson, underground manager, said he inquired what had caused the accident and learnt from the people at the top that something had caught the wire. It was part of his duty to see to the security of the machinery so far as regarded the safety of the workmen at the bottom. This pulley and chain to the best of his knowledge was put up between three and four years ago. Every time he went down the pit he examined to see that the chain was in working order, but could not say that he had ever since the chain was put up examined it link by link. The links were not rusted through. He could easily have examined a few of these links. The chain had never been off the wheel since it was up, to witness's knowledge; and they had never tarred the chain or oiled it. This weight would have to travel 35 fathoms before it hit deceased. The link that gave way was not discovered, so far as witness knew. When witness got the weight there was no chain on it. — By His Honour: Did not know that there had ever been any preparation applied to the chain to keep it from rusting, such as tar, since it was first put up. — His Honour called witness's attention to two or three links fastened together with rust and said they would not work so well as if they were loose. — Witness: Well, I would consider that was t' strongest part of t' chain. — His Honour: Should you! — By Mr. Brockbank: We had 17 stone on each end of the chain the other day when we tested it. His Honour recalled Mr. Dixon to ask him, would the working of iron ore aid rusting more than the working of coal. — Mr. Dixon said he did not think so, but rather that iron ore would to some extent act on the chain as oil. — John Borrowman searched and found the weight after the accident. There was a crook attached to the weight, but no chain. The chain might have slipped off the crook. If there had been a piece of chain in the sump it could not have been recovered until the sump was cleaned out, and the sump was not cleaned out. Witness put the chain up and it was black painted or Japanned. There was not so much rust as iron ore on the chain now produced. Had never since the chain was put up examined it thoroughly — that was nearer three years than four. Had since the accident tested the chain, and it bore a strain of 33 stones. — John Saunders found Casson, the deceased, on the cage quite dead. He had been struck on the back of the head, and a portion of the skull was knocked clean off. — By Mr. T. Brockbank: Deceased was lying on the cage. The cage had no cover on it. Men are not supposed to go into the cage when there is no cover on. The cover could not be on, in consequence of the cage having timber in it; and the timber ought to be taken off by workmen in the "eye" of the pit, clear of the shaft. Deceased need not have gone on to the cage to get the timber off; it was not easier to get it off by going on to the cage. — Mr. T. Brockbank said he would call witnesses to speak to the strength of the chain, but he would rely upon each of the jurymen exercising his own judgment when they examined the chain and considered whether it was sufficient to bear a weight of 27lbs. There was a mechanical contrivance on the cage, placed there for the express purpose of enabling the miner to draw the timber from the cage without exposing himself as the deceased exposed himself. But he got on to the cage and was struggling there with a beam of wood some nine or ten feet long, with the result that the end of the beam struck the wire attached to the float, and thus caused the weight at the top to be jerked so as to break the chain by which it was suspended. The weight could not have fallen down the working shaft had it not been thrown by such a jerk out of the perpendicular; and there was only one man either at the top or the bottom who could have touched the wire at all, and that was deceased himself. — George Scoular, managing partner of the Parkside Mining Company, said the indicator by means of a weight and chain was a necessary contrivance, and one that they had in operation at another mine in Lindal. The chain produced he considered amply sufficient for the weight, even rusted as it was. The men ought to keep clear of the shaft in unloading wood. — Henry Woodcock, C.E., Whitehaven, said he had been down the shaft. It was possible and was the duty of the miner to unload wood without getting on to the cage. He explained the plan to the jury. He thought the chain was amply sufficient. This chain was rusted, certainly, but still it was a very fair chain. It only carried 27 lbs. in working, and in testing it bore a strain of over 4 cwt. By the striking of the wire, the chain would be run over the pulley rapidly, and there would be the strain of the jerk, and also the cutting strain of the sharp edge of the pulley on the links. — George Ross, mechanical engineer, of Whitehaven, who makes machinery, assisted to test the chain produced, and gradually applied 4cwt. to it. Considered it amply sufficient. The breaking-weight of that chain as it was now was 11 cwt. — Mr. Brockbank then put it to the jury whether it had been brought home to the defendants that they had been negligent and not taken proper precautions, and asked them to carefully avoid any feeling of sentiment in this case. As far as he could see, the only question for them was whether the chain was sufficient, and they could examine the chain for themselves. — Mr. Whiteside pointed out to the jury that all the evidence for the defence as to the strength of the chain was worthless, inasmuch as the chain was only as strong as its weakest link, and that link was the link that was broken, and which had not been found. He asked the jury, however, to look at the part of the chain that was produced and say whether it was strong enough, and for the sake of example in this district, he asked them to give the greatest amount of damages to this woman for the loss she had sustained. (Slight applause, which was at once stopped by the bailiffs.) — His Honour, addressing the jury, said that in this case he was very glad indeed to have the assistance of five intelligent gentlemen like them. The first observation was that they would perceive that this case had been out — mainly made out by witnesses who were servants of the defendants; and he said that because he was very glad indeed to find that as it seemed to him they gave their evidence in a very fair, straightforward way, and made out a considerable case as at present on the part of the plaintiff. This poor man was killed; there was no doubt about that — if this chain had not broken the accident would not have happened; and what they had to inquire was how far the defendants were liable for the breaking of this chain. No doubt the chain ordinarily used, quietly suspended, and going up and down as it was wanted, would have small weight to bear — only 27lbs., and therefore there was little doubt that this chain broke in consequence of what the witnesses called a "jump" — what the jury would call a jerk — and that the weight it had to bear in an ordinary way would not have broken it without this jerk. Now they came to the question whether the company had taken sufficient caution — whether they were not bound to contemplate such a thing as this jerk. If they were, they ought to have provided a chain they would have borne the jerk. It was clear it had not borne the jerk; it was not intended it should receive a jerk and it was not competent to do so. But it had received a jerk, and when the jury had examined it they would have to consider whether the exposure of the wire in the shaft was not — he would not call it an act of negligence exactly, but it would seem more cautious that that wire should have had some protection round that pit. He supposed it was possible to put the wire in a tube, and if it had been in a tube it would not have got a jerk and this would not have happened. This wire was part of a the machinery of the company, and he was bound to tell the jury that all employers of labour were bound to have their chains and contrivances in good working order to meet any occurrence that may be fairly contemplated; they were bound to do that, no doubt. The jury saw exactly how this accident had happened, and they would have to say — now they were coming to a very important part of the question, whether there was what was part of the defence, what was called contributory negligence. That was more a legal term than anything else. No doubt it would be very hard if employers of labour were to be responsible for the carelessness of servants, and therefore contributory negligence was this — that if a man was careless about his work, and was doing something against the rules of the pit, or the mill, or whatever it might be, and an accident happened in consequence of his so transgressing, that was what they called contributory negligence, and he would not be able to recover, because he had brought in a great measure upon himself. Well, there had been no proof, but he supposed it was so, that there was an iron top to this cage, which was not put on when timber was going down, because the cage was not high enough for the timber — six feet of timber would not go into a cage four or five feet high — and therefore this cage went down on this particular occasion without the top. Then came the question which had been asserted — and he did not see that the plaintiffs had attempted to rebut that part of the evidence — that there was a provision for men unloading timber without going into the cage at all. He did not understand it, but there was some piece of timber on the cage which was moved sideways, and enabled a man to draw the timber out without himself going into the cage at all; and it also seemed to be admitted that if this man had not been on the cage he would not have been killed at all. When he was struck he was in the cage, and if he had been at the side of the cage he would not been struck at all. If that was so it was for the jury to consider whether there was not some amount of contributory negligence by the man venturing into the cage. It was clearly proved by the boy Flinn that he did not make use of the provision of safety for the unloading of timber — that was for standing and taking the timber off without getting into the cage at all. That he had neglected to do. Instead of moving this bar of wood on the cage to get the timber out, he himself keeping off the cage, and out of danger, he never moved this bar at all, and got into the cage, exposing himself to what happened. Then as to the jerk. It was quite clear, upon the evidence, that there was a jerk; no one for a moment could doubt that; and if it had not been for the jerk, in all human probability this weight would never had fallen at all. Well, if they came to the conclusion that deceased touched this wire, and caused this jerk, he did so when he was acting improperly, contrary to a rule: he was in the cage, instead of being where he ought to have been when he caused the jerk; and he could not help saying that if this was true — and it was not contradicted — there appeared to him to be considerable contributory negligence. He refused to obey an ordinary rule — he refused to adopt a provision for safety made by the company, and put himself in a place where, if he had not wrongfully been this weight would never have fallen upon him. If he was guilty of contributory negligence he put himself beyond the pale of the law. There could be no question about the amount of damages if they found plaintiff was entitled to recover at all. Deceased was a young man in the prime of life, and his widow claimed the amount of his earnings for three years, which there was every probability she would have received but for this accident. — The jury retired and after a considerable lapse of time returned a verdict for the plaintiff for the amount claimed. — His Honour gave judgment accordingly. — Mr. Brockbank gave notice that next month he will move that the case was beyond the jurisdiction of the Court.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bain, —    Mine Owner  
Borrowman, John      
Brockbank, T.    Solicitor  
Casson, Phillis      
Dixon, John    Engineer  
Flinn, Michael      
Garnet, James      
Pattinson, Isaac    Underground Manager  
Saunders, John      
Scoular, George    Managing Partner  
Tyson, Edward      
Whiteside, —    Solicitor  
Wodcock, Henry    Engineer  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Woodend (Iron Ore)  Woodend (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print