|
14th December 1882 The West Cumberland Mining DisputeJudgment For The DefendantsIn the Chancery Division of the High Court of Justice, on Thursday, before Mr. Justice Pearson, the case of Dixon v Wood came on. — This was an action brought by the plaintiff, Mr. Dixon, the owner of the surface of a farm called Birks Farm, near Whitehaven, in Cumberland, against the defendants, the present owners of the iron ore and minerals under the farm, for an injunction to restrain the defendants from so working or winning the iron ore and coal as to let down the surface of the plaintiff's farm, and for damages. — Mr. Barber, Q.C., and Mr. Archibald Osborne appeared for the plaintiff, and Mr. W. W. Karslake, Q.C., and Mr. Northmore Lawrence represented the defendants. — His Lordship, in giving his reserved judgment, said the original plaintiff in this action was the owner of the surface of the land of a farm called Birks Farm, and Mr. Crosthwaite was his tenant. The defendant, Mr. Johnstone, was the owner of the mines and minerals under the farm, and Mr. Wood was his tenant. The plaintiff, Mr. Dixon, had died in the course of the litigation, and his representatives had been made plaintiff's, but during the whole of the arguments Mr. Dixon had been spoken of as if he was still alive, and his lordship, therefore, in the remarks he had to make, would adopt the same course. The real question in dispute was as to the mode in which Mr. Johnstone, in whom the mines and minerals were vested, should mine and win the ores, and whether he should be allowed to do so in such a way as to interfere with the plaintiff's surface rights. The entire case might be stated very shortly. The Baroness Steinburg was originally the owner of both the surface and the minerals of the estate of which Birks Farm forms a part. In 1842 she granted a lease of the mines and minerals to a Mr. Attwood for 21 years. The baroness died in 1859, having executed certain instruments. By her will she vested the property in the mines and minerals on her estate in certain trustees, of whom Mr. Johnstone was the survivor. These trustees in 1860 sold and conveyed to Mr. Dixon the surface of a portion of the estate, reserving to themselves the mines and minerals, and the question which had to be decided was what were the different rights of Mr. Dixon and the survivor of the trustees under the Baroness Steinburg's will. There was not much dispute between the parties as to what was the law as to the rights of persons where the owners of the surface and of the minerals were separate. The law, prima facie, was that a person who was possessed of the surface of the land which was liable to be worked for minerals, as this estate had been, was entitled to support from underneath. The deed which conveyed the surface of the land to Mr. Dixon was dated the 20th April, 1860, and it conveyed all that surface, but contained a reservation, to the effect that all the mines, minerals, veins, and seams of coal and iron ore and other ore than opened, or to be opened, were the property of the trustees. This conveyance also gave the trustees power to search for, dig, and to win, take, and carry away all the minerals, but provided that in case the lands taken and used for mining purposes are injured, or injuries were done to the surface, all such compensations as were to be paid by the lessor or grantor by agreement under which the grantor of the conveyance of the 20th April, 1860, held should be payable to Mr. Dixon. It was obvious, therefore, that there was a reservation of the minerals to the trustees, and that they had power to search for, dig, and work the mines, but that a reservation was made in favour of paying compensation for any injury to Mr. Dixon by reason of letting down the surface. The clause which related to compensation stated that the lessor should pay to the lessee an amount in damages to the extent of £80 per acre for damage done to the surface by working the mines. The questions that had been raised before him were two. The first was whether or not Mr. Johnstone in working the mines had a right to work them in such a manner as to let down the surface of the land; and the second was, it having been agreed upon by both sides, that he was to pay £80 an acre as compensation for any damage he did; such compensation of £80 per acre was a compensation in perpetuity — that was to say, for as long as he should work the mines, or whether the compensation was simply paid for a period of 21 years, and was to be renewed every 21 years after, so long as the mines were worked. The first of these was the most important question, and he must say that, having considered all the facts, he had come to the conclusion that Mr. Johnstone had a right to work the soil so as to let down the surface, he paying a compensation of £80 an acre for that privilege of so doing. The second question was whether the compensation was for 21 years only, or was compensation for as long as the mines were worked, or until the minerals were exhausted, and he had come to the conclusion that the £80 per acre was to be paid by Mr. Johnstone once only, and that as he had paid that amount once already he was not bound to pay it again, and was entitled to work the ore and occupy the land in the manner he had done. As to the question which had been raised at the bar, and which was not in the pleadings, as to the ownership of some cottages that had been erected by Mr. Johnstone for the purposes of his mine, he must decide, at present, that they belonged to the defendants, and not to the plaintiffs, because it was quite possible that before giving up the land, which was at present used for mining, to the surface owner, the defendants might pull them down or remove them. The plaintiff must pay the costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||